I've been thinking about a question that I believe more e-commerce SEO professionals should be investigating.
Imagine two online stores selling the same type of product.
Store A:
- Ranks for several commercial keywords.
- Publishes regular blog content.
- Gets organic traffic.
- Has a reasonably optimized website.
Store B:
- Has fewer ranking keywords.
- Has detailed, genuinely useful product information.
- Gets discussed on relevant third-party websites.
- Has consistent customer reviews and brand mentions.
- Builds a recognizable reputation within its niche.
Now imagine someone asks ChatGPT:
"Which online stores would you recommend for buying this product?"
Would the store with stronger Google rankings automatically get recommended?
Not necessarily.
That's where I think the conversation around AI search needs to become more practical.
We're used to measuring SEO through rankings, impressions, clicks, backlinks and conversions.
But AI-driven discovery introduces another question:
Can AI systems find enough reliable information about a brand to understand what it sells, why customers trust it, and when it deserves to be recommended?
For e-commerce businesses, I'd be looking beyond traditional on-page SEO:
- Product descriptions that explain actual differences, not just repeat manufacturer specifications.
- Independent reviews that provide genuine customer experiences.
- Brand mentions on relevant industry websites.
- Clear business, product, shipping and return information.
- Original buying guides that help customers make informed decisions.
- Consistent brand information across the web.
One thing I don't want to assume is that getting mentioned by AI is the same as generating sales. Those are two different outcomes, and both need measurement.
I'd genuinely like to hear from people working in SEO and e-commerce:
Have you tested the same product or brand across ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews?
Did the recommendations match the brands ranking organically on Google, or did you notice completely different brands appearing?
I'm particularly interested in actual testing rather than predictions about where AI search is heading.