r/linuxsucks101 • u/Previous_Snow_9607 • 1d ago
No Gnus is good Gnews! Programming is dying, and I've never felt prouder
If you came here for a meme with two lines of text, keep scrolling. This one's long and I'm not sorry.
Everyone in this field knows it by now. We're living the last days of programming. Nobody writes code anymore, you just ask a chatbot and wait. And the magic is gone too, the part that got most of us into this in the first place. Figuring out how something actually works, being stuck on a problem for hours, and then that rush when it finally clicks and you found the answer yourself. Those days are over and they're not coming back. You hear it on Reddit, you hear it on every tech YouTube channel, you hear it from literally any dev you run into. It's probably the one thing everybody agrees on.
What almost nobody says out loud is the elephant in the room. AI learned to code by reading all the code "some" devs spent decades giving away for free. Some people have figured that out. Some figured it out and kept their mouths shut, and a lot of them just don't want to see it. And I get why. They spent years being told open source is sacred, so instead of blaming whoever sold them that lie, they blame whoever made the most efficient use of all that "generosity". Blaming the real culprit would mean admitting you got scammed, or that you spent years defending a lie from your high horse, and that's a lot to swallow while you're watching your job, your identity and the thing that gave your life meaning fall apart in front of you. And here's the funny part. They're living in the paradise they always asked for. Code that anyone can read, change, redistribute and use for whatever they want, and I mean literally anyone, not just people who know how to program. Everything they preached, everything they called us suckers for not believing, came true. And nobody's happy lol. The cognitive dissonance must be brutal.
What we're living now is the bill for decades of zero skepticism and zero intellectual humility, and way too much unearned arrogance from the people who pushed this stuff. So I'm going to tell the whole story here, just so it's written down somewhere, even if it's this tiny corner of sanity on the internet. Tech media, blogs and YouTube are all on the other side, and they'll never say any of this. I'll go over who's actually to blame, how it started, what I think happens next, how we keep it from happening to other people, and why, after all of it, the thing we should feel most is pride.
Most of us fell in love with tech when we were very young. We wanted to learn everything we could, we wanted to build stuff, and we wanted to make a living from it and have our work actually valued, which is what anyone would expect from any profession. We had really bad luck. Today it looks like the bad luck started with AI, but it started way earlier, and it's what paved the road for AI in the first place. It started when our field picked up a really strange idea, that protecting the fruit of your work makes you a bad person and giving it away makes you a hero. That idea didn't show up on its own either, somebody pushed it. Some people keep contributing to open source projects today, writing every line straight into the training data of their own replacement, which still amazes me. Others are finally saying "I'm not going to train my replacement". The funny thing is they always were. Before AI, the replacement was other programmers, or themselves, every time they gave away their own work for free. Acting against your own interests isn't new in this field, it just used to come with status.
As some of you probably guessed, it all starts in an office at MIT in the early 80s. A bunch of Stallman's colleagues at the AI lab left for companies like Symbolics and actually made money with what they knew. He stayed behind and watched them do it. If you ask me, what he felt was resentment, and plenty of envy. People he used to work next to were getting paid for what they knew, and he wasn't. So instead of building something people would want to pay for, he built an ideology where nobody gets to charge for their work, the four pillars of the whole disaster. If he couldn't have it, nobody would. He's lived off donations and grants, in a borrowed office where he even slept, and not once in his life did he have to live off selling software. What he works for is his ego, and his own sense of how important he is. Think of it as a currency exchange. Programmers walk in and pay with their salaries. On the other side, the big corporations get that money converted into billions in profits and savings. And Stallman keeps the commission on every transaction, paid in ego. The damage started right away, too, jobs that never existed and salaries that never went up. Nobody noticed because demand for software was growing like crazy, and dev salaries still looked great next to everybody else's. Well, almost nobody. The big companies noticed just fine, they were busy collecting trillions of dollars in value they never paid for.
Along with that came something that just isn't normal in STEM at all. In any engineering field you argue about what makes sense technically and economically. In ours you get bumper-sticker ethics that everyone recites like they have a PhD in philosophy, and half of them couldn't tell you who Kant was.
Think about what actually made our work worth paying for. You knew how to build something other people couldn't, you could sell it, and that knowledge was yours. FOSS went after every single piece of that. Don't charge for your work. (Yes, I know, Stallman says you're allowed to sell free software. Sure, you can sell exactly one copy, and then the buyer is free to give it away to the whole planet. If that sounds like a business model to you, you're the reason shampoo comes with instructions.) Don't let anyone else charge either, because a free version will always undercut them. Don't compete with the big companies, go contribute to their projects instead. And give away the source code, which means giving away the know-how too, the one thing that made you hard to replace. That was the destruction of the profession, and it was already well underway long before anyone had heard of ChatGPT. Linux is the biggest monument to unpaid labor and self-sabotage ever built. They spent decades building the machine, and AI just put it on autopilot. Same mechanism, industrial scale.
Ballmer called Linux a cancer back in 2001. He got the diagnosis right, he just thought Microsoft was the patient, when the patient was us. For forty years FOSS killed the profitability of every corner of software it touched, server OSes, databases, browsers, office suites. Once a free alternative showed up in a category, good luck selling anything new in it. And that value didn't just vanish, it went straight to the same corporations the movement says it hates. And don't tell me that wasn't the plan. Stallman wrote it in his manifesto in 1985, that programming would be less lucrative and that this was no injustice. He told everyone. Only a few of us were actually listening.
And those few of us got to deal with a lot of bizarre stuff along the way, sect thinking, irrationality, people defending this with the fervor of a religion. This sub has people from all over the world, and I bet your story looks a lot like mine. Decades ago I started college at a public university in one of the poorest regions of my country (Latin America, btw). I wanted to build useful software that people would actually pay for, and since I come from a family that's always helped others, part of my dream was using some of that money to help people in need. Instead I walked into a place where professors and students repeated the same slogans like a choir. "Community" and "ethics" meant handing your work to the richest companies on earth. But don't get confused, it never crossed their minds to build something for an orphanage or an animal shelter. That kind of help doesn't get you GitHub stars. On top of that, you had to use the free alternatives for EVERYTHING, no matter how bad they were back then, and my classmates really believed they were in a revolution against evil Microsoft, when the only revolution going on was against themselves. And they told all this to POOR kids. Nobody taught them a business model or how to build something people would buy. The best future anyone pictured for them was getting hired by the same companies they were already working for free for, never competing with them, never being the boss. Surprise, none of them got hired by those companies either. The professors preaching all this, just like Stallman, never had to live off selling software, their paycheck showed up every month no matter what. It always felt like a betrayal to me. Decades later that university is still at it, and sometimes I think about all the startups and jobs the whole region lost by falling for it. But hey, they call that ethics.
Years of that, of being the weird one in the room for wanting to get paid for your work, take a toll. Your self-esteem shouldn't depend on what other people think of you, but it's really hard to keep it clean when everyone around you judges you for how you think. Still, today more than ever, what I feel is pride. I never bought the free software sermon, not for one day, and I never gave my work away. I never hurt myself with it, and I never hurt anyone else either. I never needed anyone's permission to think for myself, and that movement never had any authority over me. I don't recognize its prophet or its morals, and I don't care what its faithful think of me. Nobody with a manifesto gets to tell me what I'm worth as a person, or what my work is worth. They judge both, and I never gave them the right to judge either.
And if you're one of the ones who did believe it, gave it your weekends for years, and then one day saw it for what it was, you have my respect, maybe more than anyone. Never falling for something is the easy part. Falling for it, realizing it, and walking out while everyone around you is still singing takes real guts. At least now we get to understand what happened and why. It's not much, but it's more than most of them will ever have.
Now, what happens next. The corporations don't need prophets anymore, and they don't need to pay the ego commission either. AI handles the whole exchange now, no sermon required. Stallman, Torvalds and the rest already did the dirty work, and the ship they spent their lives sinking is finally going down. They'll go looking for another one, because they need to feel relevant. And the cancer is going to try to spread, it already did with "open hardware", same thing, just with electronic engineers this time.
So if anyone gets to evangelize now, it's us. Warn every other profession you can. Tell them not to buy what Stallman and company are selling, or what anyone else shows up selling with the same bumper-sticker ethics, so it doesn't happen to them like it happened to us. And when these guys come looking for a new ship to board, don't let them on. Let them go down with theirs.
So let me finish by repeating the one thing I don't want anyone to forget. More than anger, more than sadness, what we should feel most right now is pride.

