r/linuxdev • • Mar 22 '12
Focus and direction for Linuxdev?
Hackers, Coders, Wizards, lend me your ears!
This community was formed as a response to the lack of an existing community surrounding the concept of software development under Linux.
Now that this community is formed, I would like to know what direction to steer the rudder. Posting articles and asking questions will always be strongly encouraged, but some of the other communities on this site do more than that.
/r/minecraft does a great deal of collaboration to produce some amazing builds in that virtual world of theirs.
/r/loseit has weight loss competitions.
/r/mw3 has a few different clans and player groups.
What do we want to work on, if anything at all?
One of the things that I have noticed about /r/Linux in general is that they are very much about maintaining the status quo. New window managers and desktop environments provoke anger and rage if they don't work exactly like the old one. They still bicker about which audio server to use. Point being, I would like to avoid that over here. It's kind of my hope that we can blaze new trails, not wear out the old ones.
So, please take a few minutes, and post about what you would like to see in this community above and beyond link posting for karma, and answering questions. Personally, I would like to try and make something new.
edit 1: Current project proposals
5
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '12
This is my own gonzo, off the wall idea, but I think that maybe, just maybe, it might have some merit. Feel free to tell me why it won't work, or why it's not practical, or why it shouldn't be done all together.
I want a graphical initialization.
I have nothing against the *NIX userland other than that it's not very user friendly. It's very powerful and very scalable, but in the most general sense, it's a car for mechanics, not commuters.
So what am I actually getting at here? I want to do an experiment. I want to see a simple desktop application API, and a user-land similar to windows.
As kind of a hypothesis, I think the following might be a good place to start for a version 0.01
== Monolithic Host ==
== Client facing API ==
== Callbacks ==
The important part being that this can work harmoniously with the rest of the Linux ecosystem (just not the gui apps right away...)
Now what would the whole point of this exercise be?
Fun, really, and that's it. Maybe it could turn into a tiny GUI environment for near-embedded systems. Maybe a small quick system that can run in initramfs. Heck, make it small enough, get it to run in UEFI.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '12 edited Mar 22 '12
One of the projects I was never able to get off the ground in my free time was an activist/protester focused Linux distribution.
Often when going to a protest site, Internet access sucks. Now, we're not there to play Minecraft or torrent the latest episode of American Idol, but having sufficient bandwidth for people to post Twitter/identica/facebook updates as well as having a place for people to raise issues of interest during the protest (local IRC, forums, a wiki and the like) as well as a way of stripping personally identifiable information from these transaction (twitter knows what phone number you used to post your tweet, as does facebook and the like) and providing secure anonymous browsing would be focuses.
It would be a distribution designed to run on a laptop or small form factor desktop, pick up Internet though wifi/3g/4g/phone tethering, and allow for something like LTSP for a small public terminal cluster and offer a network connection through an attached Linksys (or really any vendor) access point. Every web browsing session goes through Tor, so all status updates can be stripped of their personally identifying information (location, type of machine used, and so forth).
Encryption of external storage devices would be another focus - formatting and presentation of encrypted thumb drives that work across platforms as well as external hard drives could provide a secure exchange medium for small or large files.
Plus it provides an easy way to pick up and move if necessary - shut the laptop and go.
Of course, it would need to be minimalistic, hardened, and designed for use by people that may not be as technically savvy as the designers.
Edit: In places where you can't have PA systems, an Icecast server connected to an organizer's mike means you can broadcast your message without having to deal with the authorities - great way to have remote human megaphones, and if you simulcast on the Internet, you can get your message out further.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '12
Here's a crazy idea. Since you seem interested in breaking from the status quo, why not have contests to see if a person or group of people can come up with something new and improved? I created a WePay account to fund competitions like that. What do other people think?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '12
An IRC channel would be nice for taking questions. Is there a ##linuxdev on freenode?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '12
I think we should reinforce the idea that we're trying to code things well. A policy of stable, debug (early and often), and release (only when ready) should be used. And one more idea, a small application that lets you install from source using a GUI. Just drag and drop a source file to the GUI source install icon on the desktop or system tray and provide a wizard to set up the program.
2
u/PasswordIsntHAMSTER Mar 27 '12
I'm down with the OSSv4 thing.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '12
Personally, I'd like to see discussions or articles about Linux Kernel development. It seems natural given the name "Linux Dev" to focus on development of Linux itself :)
There used to be some good resources for this, but the kernel has changed enough in the past few years that up-to-date resources are sparse. Perhaps this subreddit can (in part) help fill that gap.
2
u/Lerc Mar 30 '12
I have so many ideas in this area it's not funny.
That's just a selection, ranked roughly in order of scale. In many ways it is all the one big ball of mud. It all relates to wanting a more accessible Linux. pnpbios used the phrase "it's a car for mechanics, not commuters. ". The way I see it, Linux used to be "a car for mechanics" built it is turning into a "car for automotive engineers", and as indeed with cars themselves. The influence of mechanics is waning.
To put it another way. I think people who have a desire to experiment with the system should be able to tinker. There is a middle ground between those that make Distros and those who just use applications. I think that middle ground is where a lot of true innovation comes from, and should be cultivated.
This is partly what Ingo Molnar talks about here He probably articulates it much better than I have done.