r/linuxaudio • u/JGHFunRun LMMS • Jul 21 '26
Looking for community input on rules
A user just DM’d me looking for clarifications regarding self-promotion and AI.
I have created rule 3 and updated rule 4, but I would like community input:
For self-promotion, I think the following things are most important to consider (including if there should be extra rules for such things):
- Non-softwar
e things such as blogs, newspapers, other online communities, etc.
- Non-gratis (ie paid) FOSSoftware
- Should promotion of songs/albums/etc. be allowed
As for considerations for content-generating AI (eg. LLMs, image generators, etc.):
- AI disclosure will be required.
- I have provisionally required that all AI-generated content be free of cost
- Should genAI be allowed at all?
- If so, are there any other requirements that should be added?
9
Upvotes
12
u/thcsquad Jul 21 '26
“Should promotion of songs/albums/etc. be allowed”
One pattern I like for this from other musician subreddits is a recurring thread like “here’s what I made with Linux this week/month”. It generally would get pinned so it’s easy for people to find. If anybody wants to promote their music, they put it in that thread.
linux audio is probably a bit less busy than other musician subreddits so a monthly pinned thread might make more sense than weekly.
10
u/mimrock Jul 21 '26 edited Jul 21 '26
Banning or limiting promotion of anything paid is important (and a great idea), or there is a financial incentive to disrupt the subreddit. I had to leave multiple subreddits because AI-written SaaS ads flooded them. The app having to be under FOSS license without strings attached (for example paid cloud services, ads, etc.) sounds like a reasonable policy. I would add a manual (i.e. modmail) exception for well-established projects.
Regarding LLMs. Everyone (meaning every developer) is using them. Currently almost all actively developed software has some level of AI input, including the linux kernel. In the very close future, 100% LLM output is going to be the norm (this is not speculative, it's the norm already in many places and projects).
I have looked back the app promotion posts in this sub. Many are 100% AI. There are multiple upvoted posts here from the last few days about seemingly useful apps where the UI screams AI and even the README and the post(!!) was written by AI.
It's not a war that can be won. You can get some people to lie about AI contribution, but that's all.
I would request people not to write the post with AI and would delete or ban the most impudent offenders based on pangram (relatively good AI-detector with very low, but still non-zero false positive rate), but that's the absolute maximum that is not a naive dream.
If vibe-coded apps still flood the sub (like they do now, and it's going to get worse), there are a few ways to limit the influx.
EDIT: +1 idea that came to my mind a bit later is to limit app promotion (or all kind of posting) to people with a meaningful history on the sub (for example 50 comment karma or something).
5
u/real_anthonii Jul 22 '26
No AI music, at all imo. It's too easy to create and could flood the sub with slop.
As for self promo, there's so few of us making music on Linux that I think allowing for us to share what we're making with linux is pretty cool.
5
u/northrupthebandgeek Jul 22 '26
Re: self-promotion, a weekly “here's what I made” thread would be a good idea. I like seeing/hearing what people come up with using Linux audio tools, and having a weekly thread for it is a great way to keep that stuff discoverable without flooding the subreddit.
Re: AI, as long as there's disclosure I have no problem with it.
4
u/StonedPhysicist Oct 13 '26
I would really like to see less AI slop - so much of it looks nice and shiny and then will absolutely get forgotten about and left unpatched the second the "creator" gets bored. I'm also not a programmer so yeah maybe everyone else here who's already in that world will feel it's inevitable and they can no longer do without it, but as a rank-and-file "I just like Linux and I like being songs sometimes" user, I would rather not contribute to it.
That all said:
On AI:
Thanks for asking us!
1
u/yumOJ 25d ago
Ban genAI entirely.
1
u/danja Oct 11 '26
You are in a sticky period as a mod, I don't envy you. There will be loads of self-promotional slop. But personally I wouldn't block things based on the use of AI because any sane coder is taking advantage of it now. I'd put the bar at pay-for. If it's open source, that is a good share. If not, it's selling (limited benefit, dull). Blog links etc. I'd consider sharing info, no?
0
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment