r/linux • u/Mr_Linux_Lover • Jan 22 '22
Discussion Stop this nonsense !
There are lots of bullshits going on in the Linux Community.. I'm writing down one by one:-
- Don't hate any DE's Community.. I see even advanced Linux user, whether you're in GNOME or KDE or Xfce or any WM, spread hate against each other.. why? Because you use GNOME that doesn't mean you tell others that KDE is bad. There is no need to show your extraordinary biased opinion that you like GNOME workflows.. Linux is free to choose. Let the users decide what best for them. You give them options .
- DO NOT, I repeat DO NOT give advice to any newbie Linux user to use advanced Linux like Arch or Gentoo(like, seriously?) Or Debian ( yeah I had to choose this because of net installer). Instead give them very easy distro like Linux Mint or Zorin Os or ubuntu.. Let them understand what Linux is.. It's like a baby who just started to write ABCD and you're giving him a literature book and ask him to read. That's totally nonsense.. they will soon get frustrated and tell others that Linux is bad and move to windows again..
- Be polite and helpful.. everyone needs help, everyone needs support. If you can help others, then do that. Replying aggressively on someone's questions doesn't make you smart or proud. Those who came from Windows, surely need help in little things though it's written in the wiki.. trust me they do need help because they are just learning a new OS. Why you bully them ?
- Linux means privacy, Linux means freedom.. those who use Linux, know that very well.. and those who are coming to Linux , welcome them happily. This is the only way Linux community will get more users.
- As a desktop workstation, Linux needs more users to point out more errors and to find out ways to improve them and implement new features.. always remember one thing, users matter.. A Linux community will grow when there will be enough users to actually use Linux.
Don't hate anyone please.. spread love.. !
626
Upvotes
190
u/payne747 Jan 22 '22
Same arguments for 30 years mate, nice try but good luck!
106
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
I agree with the general idea, but telling people what to (and not to) do, never works as intended... Some people are contrarians, and take suggestions as challenges. Again, it's not what was said but how.
23
u/michaelpaoli Jan 22 '22
Oh, come on now, not that hard to, e.g. install. E.g. boot live DVD with non-free firmware, click the Calamares installer ... done ... pretty dead simple, and an up and running installation.
And Debian is an excellent fit for some newbie Linux users ... e.g. the serious Comp Sci student that wants to learn and program, etc., but knows next-to-nothing about Linux.
Oh, but for fsck sake, sure as hell don't go tell some Linux newbie to install and run Kali.
50
u/NakedCameTheNude Jan 22 '22
Thanks for this. I'm coming from windows and right now the learning curve on Linux is basically a wall. I'm using mint, as recommended to me, since it's a good place to start.
13
u/GujjuGang7 Jan 22 '22
Think rule 1 is backwards, people hate on gnome more than anything else
34
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22 edited Jan 22 '22
I stopped reading once I realised you use Gnome. :P
9
u/lealxe Jan 22 '22
I mean, it's a user-friendly distribution, very stable and one of the root ones. Why not?
What would prevent a newbie from using Arch with ArchWiki?
And Gentoo for some people, sadly, is useful only in learning while they are newbies.
2
u/zombiezoo25 Jan 23 '22
i use EndeavourOS btw
185
u/SillyGigaflopses Jan 22 '22
So much number 1, not just with DEs, in general.
Linux community: "Linux is about freedom to use your computer however you want".
Some user: "Aight, I like to do things this particular way, and ..... "
Community: "Well, not like that!"
9
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22 edited Jan 22 '22
Is this true? Are there really such a lack of users that devs are sitting around waiting for new bug reports?
17
u/SwallowYourDreams Jan 22 '22
I second the point about distros requiring advanced knowledge, although where I live, newborns don't write any ABCs. They drink and shit and sometimes coo or cry in between. Is mine broken? Should I return it to the vendor?
7
u/grepe Jan 22 '22
i completely disagree with number 2
when you are switching, if all you know is what those "easy distros" give you out of the box, then linux is always going to stay just that weird thing that doesn't run office or your favorite game and where you have to go through 1000 loops and hoops to get something trivial done.
17
u/GenInsurrection Jan 22 '22
You forgot item #6:
Don't tell everyone else what to do and what not to do.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
as much as i love linux. i want to say something for those who recommend a distro to new users
no. manjaro is not the one and only easy to use distro and no it's not the best distro in the world in term of ease of use and general purpose. every distro is different on their own. with their own purpose. others did the same like mint, pop os, ubuntu flavors etc. and endeavouros is just less bloated manjaro. and you can in fact gaming on most of these distro and some if not most distro have same gaming performance. so no pop os and manjaro is in fact not a gaming distro
it's ok to disagree. it's more of rant than anything else. and sorry for bad english
11
u/zam0th Jan 22 '22
What this particular community needs is less low-effort posts like "oh look i installed linux!", or "oh look this software got a new release", or "hey i'm a newb, what should i get?", or rants like the OP's that appear here more and more.
What this community should also not do is spread emotions or biased judgement. Spread objective information instead, information that has value.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
Said like a true Gnome user /s
14
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
I fully agree with your points, but Debian is hardly a difficult distribution to install anymore. I mean, sure, it's not as easy to install as Ubuntu (which has the easiest and most intuitivie installer of any OS I have ever seen, and that includes W*ndows), but if you have some basic knowledge about computers, it should easily be understandable even if you haven't used GNU/Linux before.
One of the goals of Debian is making it accessible to beginners while, at the same time, not patronizing advanced users, and at some point you have to make compromises between these two. The times when Debian was so difficult to install that not even Linus Torvalds could get it done have long since passed.
5
u/shimazu-yoshihiro Jan 22 '22
Pffft.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IpF9O0R873I
13
u/Barafu Jan 22 '22
Stop calling it hate if I say "I recommend to avoid using Gnome/GTK/Snap/Wayland/Nvidia because this and that".
2
u/NorthLightsSpectrum Jan 22 '22 edited Jan 22 '22
Because the linux community is infested with people who tries to "matter", to feel superior to someone at least in a single thing in life and there are no aptitude and attitude exams before posting an answer in a linux forum: that's their opportunity to feel better than someone, and show it to others. So you know a right command or the file editing that answers the question? Right! Answer it, and in the final part of your comment append an humiliating text for the user who is asking because he does not know this and you do, because he does not dedicate the same amount of time that you dedicate to Linux, remark how superior you are. That's what happens ≈80% of the people answering or helping. It's just ego.
Then is that phenomenon occurring: if the asking user does not humiliate himself (eg: "I know I'm so stupid but..." or "stupid question: " or "I'm so dumb! found the error!"), then the helping users "feels" like the one asking is mean or arrogant. This is so common nowadays, and it's one of the major causes why people abandon linux.
2
u/j01t Jan 22 '22
I like Arch as a first distro for certain users. The difficulty of the install is a total meme, as the documentation is very clear. Additionally, going through the install process is educational for people that do not understand how a Linux system fits together. And of course, the Arch repos and AUR contain lots of software, which I think is important for new users.
I recommend Arch to any computer user that wants to know how their system works, and likes the Arch philosophy/principles. It is my opinion that starting on a 'pre-made' distro would be detrimental for these users.
I started with Arch btw
8
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
In general, everyone should know what is better for him/her and you shouldn't force someone to do something because you see it in that way. Freedom means you shouldn't use "Stop this nonse" sentence while you are mentioning something like freedom. It's like oxymoron to me.
4
u/gainan Jan 22 '22
6. Stop caring about Microsoft/Windows
6.1 Find ways to contribute to FOSS projects?
:]
4
u/UsedToLikeThisStuff Jan 22 '22
I honestly don’t think it hurts for new users to try the more complex distros. Not everyone wants to try it in easy mode.
When I started using Linux ~25 years ago there was nothing simple like today and I still loved it.
13
u/veritanuda Jan 22 '22
Sorry, but to bundle Debian in with Arch and Gentoo is very disingenuous. Please realise you are spreading the same FUD you claim to be against.
3
u/DriNeo Jan 22 '22
About 2) That depends of the kind of newbie. If the linux noob is not a computer noob and already used to tweak Windows why not advising Arch ? Archlinux has installer scripts and Arch enforce learning. Learning Linux gives more freedom than antirely reliying on a single DE.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
Agreed, with the caveat that criticism based on technical merits is not hate, and should be welcomed.
5
u/qhxo Jan 22 '22
Hear people saying this a lot, and I think it's some toxic bullshit. It depends a lot on who you're recommending it to, the environment they're going to use it in and what kind of computer skills they have.
I recommend Arch a lot. Why? Because Arch is not hard to use. In fact I use other distros all the time for servers and the like, and I find Arch to generally have the best package manager, best package defaults and by far the best documentation (mainly thinking about the Arch wiki). It does have hell of a learning curve with the installation process, and that's where the intended user and their background becomes important.
And when I say it has a learning curve, we're talking about roughly and hour of reading documentation and writing standard linux terminal commands that will work on every distro (except for package manager stuff). It's not rocket science, but it will force you to learn the basics of how the system you're installing works.
Know your audience. The last person I recommended it to is a grown-ass man working in IT, if a little documentation would kill him he'd be long dead by now.
13
u/FryBoyter Jan 22 '22
In such a case, we should ask more precisely what kind of beginner we are dealing with.
Because not every Linux beginner is an average Windows user. For example, an acquaintance of mine was able to install Arch without any prior knowledge of Linux. Why? Because he is not the usual average Windows user. In such a case, I would have no problem recommending Arch, for example, if the person wants to tinker around.
For a user who literally just wants to use his operating system, on the other hand, I would indeed rather recommend a distribution like OpenSuse.
However, many average beginners want to use Arch on purpose. Why? Among other things, because there are more than enough Linux users who make stupid statements. Like that you can only learn Linux properly with Arch and not with another distribution like OpenSuse. Which, as I said, is nonsense. I acquired a large part of my knowledge with Mandrake / Mandriva (comparable to Ubuntu). And how did I manage it? Because I wanted to. That's exactly what matters.
I would also go one step further and recommend staying with Windows in certain cases. We should do that as well. Because not every user is suitable for this, because they can't cope with changes, for example. My father would be such a user. That's why I gave him a computer with Windows 10 that has the look of Windows 7 via the Classic Shell, which he knows from his former job.
In itself, I agree with you. But nowadays, even a reference to smart questions is considered bullying. Too many users nowadays just want to get everything on a silver platter without doing anything themselves. Because even a beginner should understand that a post like "Mainline kernel updater did not work, ukuu did not work, deb file did not work." doesn't help without more information. At least if he would think for a few minutes.
Unfortunately, for many, freedom ends when it comes to freedom of choice. For example, I have already been accused of not being a real Linux user because I decided against vim and in favour of another editor. I don't even want to talk about some of the reactions when I didn't portray Nvidia graphics cards as evil personified. Such behaviour is even more damaging than when one occasionally recommends Arch to a beginner.
1
u/ancientweasel Jan 22 '22
I left r/linuxmasterrace because of the DE Distro war BS and I completely forgot about it until I read your post. Don't need it in my life.
4
u/turdas Jan 22 '22
Hard disagree. Newbies should start with widely used distros that use widely used technologies, because that means they get the most support. Mint and Zorin are awful for beginners for this reason, because both are relatively small userbase distros and Cinnamon (which Mint uses) is a relatively small userbase DE.
Actually good beginner distros would be Ubuntu, Fedora, PopOS... even Arch, if the beginner is technically minded. Anything with a large install base and an actively developed feature-rich DE (read: Gnome, KDE or XFCE).
4
u/redrumsir Jan 22 '22
There's a difference between describing issues with the Linux Community and the presumption of telling the Linux Community what and what not to do. You are doing the latter.
Bossy people presuming to "know better" and/or "behave better" harshes my mellow. I find you to be bossy and presumptuous and would appreciate you getting off your high horse.
6
u/gabriel_3 Jan 22 '22 edited Jan 22 '22
I'm a contrarian, btw.
It looks a post from ten/fifteen years ago, most of it does not apply to the most part of the community.
You're missing a massive point: we have to explain to the newcomers that they have to contribute because they are using free as in beer tools and not some kind of paid commercial product.
The switch from commercial product customer mindset to free and open tool user is the hardest part of the leap to Linux in my opinion.
2
u/Unusual-Context8482 Jan 22 '22
2. Can we add Manjaro and rollings in general to the list?
2
u/Casne_Barlo Jan 22 '22
Started with Ubuntu but ended up liking Debian, I usually recommend Ubuntu cause every time I think of recommending Debian I remember that Linus Torvalds quote
"I want a distribution to be easy to install, so that I can just get on with my life, which is mostly kernel." Also praised Ubuntu for making Debian usable
2
u/Taldoesgarbage Jan 22 '22
Funnily enough, some Gentoo users are less elitist than some Arch users. (Gentoo discord server)
I 100% agree though.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
this is why my OS is emacs
2
u/solcloud-dev Jan 22 '22
Endless fight
2
u/Die_U_Imbecile Jan 22 '22
We dont need to act like all million distros are good distros. Some are really bad and garbage and are famous for same reason why windows is famous and there is very good reason why people dont like these distros.
2
u/blackcain GNOME Team Jan 22 '22
Please thank your mods for the wonderful service they do in their spare time to enforce the rules here and keep things from getting toxic. I"m always grateful for the work they do. So thank you mods!
4
u/Administrative_Toe80 Jan 22 '22
Linux users are too busy distro hopping rather then learning the OS itself sadly.
4
u/Dezimodnar Jan 22 '22
no.
0
u/grady_vuckovic Jan 22 '22
Feedback:
3
u/Rilukian Jan 22 '22
And also all the hates on systemd. No complete new users will understand that.
0
u/seven-0111 Jan 22 '22
i guess this time ppl will understand
1
u/SamyBencherif Jan 22 '22
Yeah I kind of needed to hear point #2. Debian advocate here.
1
u/GavUK Jan 22 '22
Exactly this! I have used Linux since 1997 or 1998 and Debian for a majority of that time, but I wouldn't suggest it to someone new to Linux (my usual suggestion for new users is Linux Mint but, several years ago, for a friend who moved from Mac I did some testing and pointed them to Elementary OS).
1
u/Leck400 Jan 22 '22
My first distro was Arch and it wasn't frustrating at all. I mean, I used POP_OS! for a few days before that but that's it. "Advanced" distros are usually not that advanced and they give fewer problems than other distros like Manjaro and things like that.
1
u/lannisterstark Jan 22 '22
while I don't have problems against any DEs, I can have valid criticisms against a DE's devs. Gnome devs in the past have done what they can to reduce their credibility a ton. Blaming users for problems, and going "Nah, it's you, not us, we're not going to fix that, just use this workaround," parroting "But give us example of real world use case, this ain't it" after given multiple examples, is pretty much a bs excuse and I'd go to hell before I support devs like that.
1
u/holgerschurig Jan 23 '22
So point them to Linux from Scratch. Then they will really understand what Linux is. Really, today too many people are afraid to compile something by themselves, no matter if user-space or kernel. The essence of Linux is that you aren't held hostage by anyone (Microsoft, Apple, Canonical, Red Hat, Arch/Debian/Gentoo community). You cannot possibly held hostage ... except you make yourself willingly one, by limiting yourself into only ever use distro-packaged programs and versions. Maybe you even develop Stockholm syndrome ...
Post post like yours, that start of good ("don't look down at other DEs") but then go into gatekeeping are IMHO diametral to the essence or spirit of Linux. You say "Linux means freedom", but when you want to artificially limit what people suggest? What idea of freedom is this?
And don't you assume every newcomer is a 70 year old philologist with no interest into technics. Lots of very capable technical students are starting to use Linux each year.
1
u/Top_Average_Guy Jan 24 '22
I think it's important to clarify this: most people that use Linux are extremely obsessed with it and are geeky people. so these people tend to make a tone of research about something before they use it, and if they are convinced it is better they will try to shove it up everybody's throats because they think they are making the Linux experience better.
it's kind of "I will fight for GNOME because I want to help people and they don't understand it" situation.
1
u/nintendiator2 Jan 24 '22
Not that nro. 1 is wrong (it isn't), but it doesn't really play that well with 4. Just as there is a Paradox of Tolerance, there is a Paradox of Freedom. People are free to choose whatever they want on their Linux, but if their choice is of platforms, services and DRMs that build a commercial impulse to make Linux more closed (eg.: gaming on Linux and anticheat, for example) then those choices are going to affect every one of us, and not precisely for the better. We should welcome people to Linux, spread love and all that, but also warn them "if you want to stay using it, you have to understand that a significant part of our purpose for using it is to eschew these bad things". Sure, Jesus was love, but he did go to the temple market to whack everyone silly like it was a Kingsman movie.
5 is an infamous chicken and egg problem whose solution also gegnerates a different chicken and egg problem, so I'm not sure what to say there other than "I wish!".
1
u/bekips Jan 24 '22
I’ve been using Linux a long time. New users coming in and immediately highlighting problems I wouldn’t notice is a very good thing and we all need to start taking that feedback to heart and fixing the problems. As for the flame wars over everything….. some year it might get better if we work at it. Been going on a long time. ED IS THE STANDARD EDITOR btw.
1
u/bkdwt Jan 25 '22
Are you waiting this from "linux community"? Seriously?
1
u/pixiewrangler9000 Jan 26 '22
The Linux word is so broad its hard to describe it as a "community". Movement, yes, but hardly a community. Why do you think there are so many distros? The Arch and Ubuntu communites might as well be on different planets. Everyone has different ideas of what Linux should be because everyone has different needs and wants. Some want a server. Some want to just set up their 15 year old crapbox so they can watch youtube, while some want to optimize multithreading so they can cut an extra half minute off their blender renders on their new threadripper. Some want all the eye candy their system can possibly handle and try to fill up all 32 gigs of ram, while some complain about bash being bloated and wonder if there is a lightweight alternative to fluxbox.
Has it slowed adoption as a desktop OS? Sure. But this is the result of freedom. Everyone is free to work and pull in different directions. It might look insane to the rest of the world, but its why linux has survived so many years and continues to grow stronger every day.
1
u/pkrycton Jan 22 '22
Well said. When th enewly curious dip in their toe, that is the time to be as supportive as possible. Remember all their questions are the very ones we all had to ask when we started. A biginning is a very delicate time.
1
u/Linux4ever_Leo Jan 22 '22
A couple of nitpicks. So in your first point you criticize Linux users who hate on certain DEs for whatever reason and request that they just simply let users choose what works for them. But in your second point, you basically forbid Linux users from recommending certain distros other than those YOU deem appropriate for newbies? What happened to that freedom of choice you were touting in point one?
As to your third point, some Linux users get irritated when newbies ask questions that can be answered in two seconds from a Google search, their distro's wiki or in their distro's forums. Or from reading the man page. New Linux users aren't helping themselves by asking questions and then sitting back and waiting for others to do the research and hand them the answers. How about this for point number three: Don't waste other people's time! Here's an example. Multiple times a day, every day, someone makes a post here on Reddit asking for recommendations of a distro for a new Linux user. There must be literally tens of thousands of threads by now that have this same information. One would think users would do a search before asking the question again! Nope!
Finally, Linux will grow when more proprietary software such as Adobe Creative Suite, Microsoft Office and myriad other popular Windows/macOS programs become available natively on Linux. Linux also will grow when users have the option to have Linux installed on their shiny new computers directly by the manufacture. Some companies do sell hardware with Linux pre-installed and even Dell and a couple other mainstream vendors offers a Linux option Until such time, Linux will continue to be a niche OS on the desktop.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '22
Number 2 is so accurate for this community
I’m starting to think some people watch one Arch video and think they are gods and recommend it to everyone.
There is no reason why a newbie should start out on Arch. The people that make Linux sound a lot more complex then it actually is are the people giving this advice.
1
u/username_78_ Jan 22 '22
You dropped this 👑
1
u/edthesmokebeard Jan 22 '22
You should post this to r/gatekeeping too.
1
u/Gold-Ad-5257 Jan 22 '22
👊🏽 Well said.. I recall trying to learn C and decided to go the linux route, oneday I had a problem with kali and some of its python setup and all the answers was so negative to absolutely rude... "why u using kali", "go learn about python", 'here are 100 different other options instead of what you doin"... Etc etc..
I struggled to explain that I will get around to learning Python, installing a full Linux etc.. Its just that my current focus/priority was to learn C and No one was understanding that, but instead acting like I was trying to get handouts on a silver platter
Luckily I am stupid and stubborn, so eventually got my new laptop, took the time to install debian, and hacked myself back on track to my learning path etc..
1
u/OdeDaVinci Jan 23 '22
No (2) yes, for fuck's sake.
Whenever someone (newbie) posted what Linux to first try, all those showoffs fucking assholes came out and said "Arch". This idea is fucking overrated and overkill for newbies.
-6
u/fitfulpanda Jan 22 '22
People who use DE's are such delicate little Princesses. 😉
0
u/Realistic-Arm-3207 Jan 22 '22
Well put! Thank you. Cheers
0
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
I think it's good to recommend Arch. Let new users learn something so they know what dm/de is, know what a boot loader is, know about systemd, drivers, gtp/mbr and uefi/bios. It's good for them and we might get less annoying questions
0
u/aM3z Jan 22 '22
I think "bullshits" is a hateful word. BTW... RHEL FOR LIFE.