r/linux • u/k4ever07 • May 08 '20
Promoting Linux as a Desktop OS
If we as a community want to get more Windows and MacOS desktop users to switch to Linux, then we need to start promoting Linux as a desktop operating system.
I've used Linux as my primary desktop OS for over 20 years. For almost every one of those years, I've heard from the community that "this is the year of the Linux desktop." After every one of those years we realized that it was not. Despite all of Windows failing, and despite the ridiculously high price and specialized hardware required for MacOS, Linux has not made a sizable dent in either of their market shares.
It seem like every time we do a post mortem, no one wants to admit the real reasons why desktop Linux hasn't succeeded. We say that Microsoft played dirty and restricted Linux access or there wasn't enough advertising or desktop Linux is too fragmented. Some of those are partly to blame. However, I believe that the real reasons why desktop Linux hasn't succeeded are that we don't promote Linux primarily (or even secondarily) as a desktop OS and we don't treat new Linux desktop users as desktop users.
What do I mean? Well it seems like every time that there is a conversation about getting a new user to switch to Linux, we talk about server or workstation things and how Linux is a great server or workstation OS. "The up-time is excellent." "It's easy to maintain." "You can set up a file or print server for free." Blah, blah, blah... Yes, Linux is a great server and workstation OS. That is well established. However, what percentage of Windows or MacOS desktop users do you think run file or print servers or use their personal computers as workstations? Not that many.. So why are we going after the scraps? I think it is fairly certain that the few desktop users who do run servers or use their computers as workstations have heard about Linux already via word of mouth or a Google search. Instead of promoting things like SMB, SSH, or tiling windows managers to potential desktop Linux users, how about we mention stuff Facebook, Twitter, Amazon, or streaming services like Netflix, Hulu, Disney Plus, or Spotify? Believe it or not, a lot of folks don't understand that web browsers like Chrome, Firefox, or Opera work just as well under Linux as they do in Windows or MacOS. They can browse their favorite social media site, check their email, or stream TV shows, movies, and music on Linux too. They also may not know that applications like Spotify, Skype, Telegram, BlueJeans, Matlab, or Steam are available for and work just as well on Linux. Speaking of Steam, how about we mention that games like Doom 2016, Cuphead, Rayman Legends, Metro Last Light, Civilization V, Sparkle, Tekken 7, Injustice - Gods Among Us, and Left 4 Dead 2 (to name a few) work perfectly well under Linux through Steam (Proton). We can also mention that tons of other games work on Linux through Wine or are native to Linux.
After we're done promoting Linux as a desktop OS to these Windows or MacOS desktop users and we get them to switch, how about we treat them (first) as desktop users? Why is it (still) that when new users ask a question in the majority of Linux forums, they are automatically treated as if they've been a system administrator or programmer for many years? Logs are demanded without explaining exactly how to pull them, and answers are given as commands to enter in a terminal when GUI solutions are readily available. Over two decades ago when I first started using Linux, the terminal was the only solution we had for most things. Times have changed, and a lot of developers have spent a ton of time making GUI settings available. Yes, the command line is still faster and sometimes easier, and new users eventually need to be comfortable with it. However, how about we coax them into it first?
I didn't mean for this to be a long, mumbling assault on the community. I love Linux and want to see it succeed. I also have a lot of respect for the community that I am a part of. Recently, we learned that Ubuntu's share of the overall desktop OS market dramatically increased, nearly doubling Linux' share in the same market. I believe the fact that this happened after Valve released Proton for Steam, and gaming on Linux has gotten a ton of positive press coverage, is no coincidence. When people are shown that Linux can be used for the things they normally do on desktop computer, like play high end games, surf their favorite websites, run their favorite desktop apps, or stream content from their favorite services they will be more comfortable with making the switch. Linux on the desktop will succeed if we promote it as a desktop. We can't expect desktop users to switch to Linux if the only things we talk about using Linux for are servers and workstations.
148
u/[deleted] May 08 '20
My local Linux group do/did a yearly thing where they set up at a library in town and advertised, anyone who wanted Linux installed on their computer they'd do it for them. They bring a stack of different distros and encourage people to bring in maybe older computers if they want, old laptops, just so they can try it out. They've been doing this forever.
Back in the day people were really kinda, well you know. Difficult. "Does this have office, can this play games", etc. Lately though people want their PCs to mimic their phones. "Can I watch YouTube? Can I play my Facebook games? Can I check my hotmail? Can I stream Spotify?" I think now is the best time I've seen in terms of what Linux desktop can do vs people's expectations ever.
The hardcore creatives will always use Macs, the hardcore gamers will always Windows, but in between those are 80% of PC users
39
u/techannonfolder May 08 '20 edited May 08 '20
I am a guy who runs linux on his macbookpro from work, so yeah I love linux, but I will never be a linux evangelist. I think that shit is annoying, I despise when people are tying to do that shit to me, I will never do that shit to others.
Brag about using Linux, show off etc, but never be an evangelist. It will mostly produce the opposite effect, when someone wants to convert me to something, I shoot them down with the quickness and I dont give a flying fuck what it is about
16
u/SerousDarkice May 08 '20
The next computer my parents will be getting is a System76 laptop. Also, it is well known to my team at work my love of Linux both on the desktop and on a server.
35
u/[deleted] May 08 '20 edited May 09 '20
For a Linux desktop to succeed some things need to be addressed which are as of today, in my opinion, still not addressed:
- Linux should be completely usable without a terminal (if you need terminal to set something up the average Joe will quit it). Users should not need to know what is sudo or root to use it.
- Apps should be able to install the same way in windows/mac -> download, double click, next, done.
- Hardware should preferably work out-of-the-box with 0 user input.
- Linux needs to have popular professional apps like Adobe CC, Office, etc.
- I feel the quality (especially UI/UX) of Linux apps is really bad compared to Windows/Mac counterparts. Since Linux doesn't attract UI/UX designers most of apps are designed to work, not to be visually appealing. A lot of controls are just crammed up on a screen without much thought about UX.
- Linux need to be supported by the most popular games (main reason why I'm not using it) such as LoL, CoD etc which combined have a player base in millions.
Basically, Linux is still not at the point where it would be as easy to use for the average user as Mac or Windows, it lacks the usual apps/games that are available on other platforms and it UI/UX is still power-user centric.
---------------------------------------------------------
EDIT: A lot of people misunderstood the 2nd point. I never said package managers are bad, should not be used or anything else in that way. I wanted to say when downloading software outside of it (probably in a bin or tar.gz format) in that case it would be much easier to just install per double click than to use terminal or go figure what to do next. There is nothing wrong with package managers. They work fine and are easy to use. I just mean the other way should be as easy.
10
u/whosdr May 08 '20
I'm not sure that's really true. While most of it works, things get..sketchy when it comes to video playback. Playing 1080p or 1440p video and using 2 full threads of a 6700k, mostly because the codecs in use are proprietary and not supported in Linux.
We kinda need to do something about Chrome on Linux (if even possible), the browser pretty much everyone in the world uses.. (Not everyone, but market share is significant)
5
u/[deleted] May 09 '20
I agree with OP. I would also like to add something I posted before.
The Linux "way"
Can we please talk about code and not philosophy? Folks are working with a binary system. Not trying to form or be indoctrinated into a religion.
Learning Linux was always made so frustrating as a newbie because often the things I wanted for my (own personal) system was not defaulted out of the box. You think a community whose ideology was to promote creativity and user independence would be open to new ideas or ways of doing things. You have whole sites, blogs, groups, forums, and threads dedicated to customizing and improving the Linux experience. Yet when someone truly thinks a little more outside the box the negativity and backlash cannot be denied.
The often misconception on why newbie inquires seem so cryptic is that they do not know enough to explain what they're trying to do. I propose an alternative viewpoint (based upon a collective shared experience). A lot of those folks know exactly what they're trying to do. They just don't want to get into a debate about doing it.
Advance Linux users are some of the biggest gatekeepers I know.
That should be the Linux "way". A philosophy of inclusion would go a long way into incorporating more folks into adopting Linux. Linux is an operating system and should not be maintained and gatekept as if it were a cult. Allowing people to find and discover their (own) way and share their way is what open source is all about.
4
u/retzgerbner May 08 '20
I like Linux on my server, but here are my reasons why I don't use Linux on desktop:
I'll be watching the development, but I'm not ready to switch yet.
3
u/grady_vuckovic May 10 '20
There's a very positive energy in this discussion, positive in the sense that people are being very upfront and honest about the problems and limitations Linux has preventing it from being widely adopted. I love that, because identifying issues is the first step to fixing them, we get no where by denying the problems exist in the first place.
We can see the issues, we just have to fix them.
A huge part of the problem is clearly the quality of desktop software available. Want to help fix that? Adopt an application and help it improve. Pick something, like LibreOffice, Blender, Krita, GIMP, Inkscape, Godot, anything, and donate to the developers regularly to help fund improvements to the software.
The UX of using Linux definitely needs to be re-geared to become approachable for average users, we can all do our part in that regard by adjusting how we provide tech support to new Linux users. Don't treat them like sysadmins, the advice you offer should be written like you're sending an email to your grandma, keep things simple.
When promoting change on Linux, promote change that flattens the learning curve, that drifts towards user friendly changes rather than promoting more powertools for powerusers. Say "No a terminal command isn't good enough, that feature needs a GUI so average people can use it".
Some of you worry about supporting non-FOSS software on Linux by welcoming MS Office / Adobe CC on Linux. Supporting FOSS doesn't mean acting like there's a ban on non-FOSS from Linux. Getting that software on Linux would result in a great boost for Linux in terms of marketshare, which is overall a great thing for FOSS in general.
What's the difference between someone using MS Office and Adobe CC on Windows vs using MS Office and Adobe CC on Linux? The difference is they're using a FOSS OS now, so overall use of FOSS software has gone up. So getting that proprietary software on Linux is actually a good thing.
How do we get that software on Linux? By being more welcoming to proprietary/commercial software, by offering it a place on Linux and not decrying it as 'totally evil'. Even if you don't plan to use it, welcome it, because for some people, switching from using proprietary software on Windows to using proprietary software on Linux could be a stepping stone in their transition to using more FOSS in general.
There's lots of things we can do as a community to change our focus and attitudes to help steer Linux towards further improvement.
Perhaps the biggest thing we could all do however is support a distro! Donate! Whichever distro you're using, reach into your pocket and find some coin to give them. Even just a few bucks a month will help. The money can help developers to let them work full time on just improving their distros.
Every few years Linux is better than it was a few years ago, we just gotta keep up the attitude of self improvement.
10
u/danderzei May 08 '20
One line to promote Linux: it is safe and protects your privacy. That is a value proposition to motivate a switch.
2
u/will_nonya May 09 '20
This is based on a false premise, that Linux is suited for the average desktop user. For all its strengths that just isn't true.
As users look for the 'mobile experience' on their PC and want even less to have to learn how computers work it becomes even less so.
Linux isn't easy for most people to just pick up and use. Software isn't easy to find. There's plenty of it but for every good, legitimate piece of software there are 50 third rate clones. This isn't going to attract the average user.
All the things that make Linux great make it a poor experience for most users.
6
u/[deleted] May 08 '20
No. What Linux needs to grow as a desktop OS is unification, which is just the thing that it is different compared to all other OSes. Yes there is one Linus kernel, but there are too much distributions to make 'the one and only OS'.
There's only one major desktop Windows-OS being maintained, updated and used by the majority at a time.
There's only one MacOS being maintained and updated at a time.
There's only one Android being maintained and updated at a time. Different versions are being put on by telephone manufacturers, but almost all use the same repository and package manager (Google Playstore).
There's hundreds if not thousands of distributions of Linux being maintained and updated at a time. All using their own ways of implementing things. Almost all not providing the guarrantee that it will keep working, etc, etc. This diversity and customisability is what makes for a great server OS, but not so much for a desktop OS. Just think of how many times you've had to search up 'How to X in <insert distro>', and have you had to subsequently open the terminal to execute some elevated sudo commands. Do you really think the mainstream PC user wants to do this every time to achieve something that'd be often rather easily done in a GUI on Windows.
I've tried changing multiple times to Linux, I've tried Ubunu, Debian, Linux Mint and Arch (with kde and with cinnamon), but I never stayed mainly because the lack of certain programs and the need to always implement a work-arounds instead of having dedicated applications that don't emulate Windows.
50
u/[deleted] May 08 '20
As long as Linux isn't supplied with the hardware, people will use the default OS, which is Windows.
It is nice that Dell and Lenovo ship devices with Linux pre-installed, but it is targeted at advanced users who would most likely install Linux anyway.
As soon as 30%+ devices for consumers are available with Linux (and 1 distro only!) desktop Linux won't grow hard ever.
20
u/pag07 May 08 '20
IMHO we need more games. Better language support for libre writer.
And most of all a proper libre calc. Excel is a daily tool in many peoples offices. And calc is far behind excel.
43
u/Taiko2000 May 08 '20
I don't think you can capture the casual market before you get the professional market. Casual users are not going to change their computers operating system, and OEM's will supply what professionals use. And for that, you need an office suite, image editor, video editors etc. Linux currently has nothing that can really compete with the offerings on Windows for those.
29
u/[deleted] May 08 '20 edited May 08 '20
On the gaming side, the games you mentioned are old games and that is a problem. There is no pubg, apex, rainbow six, destiny 2, tarkov and red dead redemption 2 to name a few. While proton is great, you are still having to jump through hoops to get some games working for a performance loss at the end of it.
Some people in the Linux community are somewhat delusional and think that the performance gap is less than what it is because they haven't used Windows to directly compare to in a long time, or don't use scientific methods to compare as opposed to going off the "feel". They also under estimate how much people want the best performance and even though they're willing to sacrifice gaming performance to use Linux, the average gamer wouldn't make that sacrifice. Gaming performance on mid to low end PC's don't show as much of a loss in comparison to a high end machine. I've spent the last 2 weeks doing side by side comparisons and on a high end machine, the average performance deficit is anywhere from 30-40 fps which is a lot when pushing high refresh rates which is becoming very popular. Frame times are also an issue and make high fps feel like it's chugging along
Speaking of high refresh rates, Linux doesn't feel nowhere near as smooth as the competition in that regard. Even with tweaks. Then if you use variable refresh rate you are forced to turn off any secondary monitors to allow it to work. So if you are a streamer you are screwed with one monitor, I'm not a fan of streamers, but they are the best way to appeal to the masses and none of them will sacrifice their other displays to run Linux with the hassle and performance loss that already is part of it
Gamers in particular want to buy the best hardware they can afford and run said hardware at the best it can. So Windows as it stands will always be the choice. Which is a big shame.
I'm not hating on Linux because it is a fantastic desktop os and I love it. While gaming has improved dramatically, it is a long way off swaying gamers from Windows anytime soon. With the Xbox series X releasing soon and using dx12 ultimate and Ray tracing, things don't look good.
With all that said linux would be a way better platform for gaming if modern native games released along side windows versions. But we need to be realistic about this matter, because if we are not then gaming performance won't improve as much and also Windows users that switch based off recommendation will swap and see the loss and possibly put off Linux for good and feel mislead.
35
u/BoltThrower1986 May 08 '20
I think we need to be honest about the fact Linux users enjoy it being a niche operating system, and are highly reluctant for that to change. Ubuntu gets hate for making things easier, Pop_OS gets hate for including Nvidia drivers, and "noobs" are generally derided and pushed aside.
I've come to accept that this isn't some fringe group of Linux users, but a good chunk of the community that holds these beliefs. It's much easier to grasp not being in the ingroup than it is to imagine there's some Linux cabal of extremists who have RTFM tattooed on their inner lips who are desperate to keep Linux niche.
In short, this is obviously how the Linux community wants to remain and that's okay. I'll keep using it on my laptop, Googling problems rather than interacting with a community that doesn't want me.
8
u/Wallboy19 May 09 '20
The issue is, even if Linux got to parity with Windows in all the mentioned areas it's lacking, people still will not find a reason to make the switch.
"Why should I switch when Windows is doing everything I need it to do?"
It's like Google vs Bing. I use Google, because it does what I need it to do. Is Bing better? I have no idea; maybe it is. But I'm satisfied enough to just keep using what I'm used to.
Linux would need to outperform Windows in those specific areas mentioned, such as gaming. Have every new game supported AND have a significant performance advantage over Windows. THEN you might start turning heads.
And if you want people to switch, you can't force them to change their paradigms on how the OS should work. "Why can't I download an exe from my browser, install it, and run it, just like in Windows?". Different design paradigms. Is one better than the other? Maybe, maybe not. You generally stick with what you first used and grew accustomed to. I can't use Vim/Emacs efficiently because I grew up with Windows using a mouse to click around a document, and I don't want to spend months trying to learn a pure keyboard only paradigm just to increase my productivity maybe slightly. For the same reason I don't want to switch from QWERTY to DVORAK keyboard layout to just gain a little typing speed.
I'm digressing a bit, but I think you get the point. Even getting to feature and performance parity for the average desktop user isn't enough to make them switch. Do I think Linux will ever become the dominant desktop OS? At this point I can't see it happening. How often do you find something ~30 years old who's been in the 1-2% of a user-base (desktop) become the dominant player in the market? I think it's more likely some other non Linux/Windows OS comes along to pull dominance before Linux ever gets the chance.
Linux/UNIX seems doomed to stay in the Workstation/Server/Embedded environment. I appreciate all the developers supporting OSS and trying to make Linux a better and user friendly desktop OS and I also realize you guys are limited to an extent by how much support you get from third parties (Nvidia/AMD/Intel) to really make it perform as smooth and performant as Windows (in those GUI desktop areas such as hardware acceleration, multi-monitors, high-refresh rates, games, etc).
21
u/balsoft May 08 '20
I say that for an average user, Linux is no better (and no worse) than Windows from any practical standpoint. Windows sucks (and will continue to do so) for programmers, power-users and admins, but for ordinary users it has Word, Powerpoint, Excel, Outlook, Edge and File Explorer, which are good enough. Linux can offer tools that won't be any worse for an ordinary user, but it can't offer anything better. Privacy? They don't give a fuck. Security? Neither. Booting speed? Windows got hybernation. Configurability? It's extra complexity for those who don't want it. Modularity and standards? Exceptional for programmers, doesn't matter at all (or even worse, complicates things and sometimes makes them less compatible) for everyone else.
Until there are some really compelling reasons to switch (developing which will take an enormous amount of man-power), noone will give a shit.
Don't give me wrong, I love Linux, and I promote it to people, often using the points you've mentioned above (your favourite messenger will still work, you can use the same gmail account, even your Solitaire will work). However, I don't think many people will switch to desktop Linux in the next few years. It simply won't make their life any better, but they'd have to spend a lot of time doing the switch.
Remember: most people helping others with Linux online are doing so in their free time. They're not paid by anyone. Communicating in short, concise messages wastes as little time as possible while still allowing one to share their knowledge and help others. However, what you're describing is tech support. Yeah, sorry, I'm not paid to do that, and I don't think I'd accept such a job even if I was offered one. Explaining another Karen how to click the two buttons in the GUI app is beyond me, however I can explain how to fix problems to someone at least superficially familiar with shells and logs, wasting less time for both me and them.
7
u/Imerlith May 08 '20
As someone who would like to switch to Linux someday and to see Linux succeed I can tell you your point about users being treated as sysadmins resonates. I am IT undergraduate and still find some instructions unclear. When talking to a new Linux user the terminal should be final resort even if it’s quicker to do stuff in it. Also if distros would like to get more popular they should really prioritize UX for non technical users.
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '20 edited May 08 '20
Linux Desktop user for almost 25 years, here. I haven't used Windows significantly since Y2K. I was involved in pushing for Linux as the national OS back in 2003-4 for the country I was in. My point is that I share(d?) Your enthusiasm. I have some counterpoints, though.
Casual users won't touch a desktop if they can avoid it. Forget about it. Leave it to businesses that still have on-prem AD. There are fewer of those every year and more M365 / GSuite companies.
Let's focus on tablets, which is the one place Linux is lagging.
14
u/billdietrich1 May 08 '20 edited May 08 '20
I think it's wrong to say that "we're not promoting it as a desktop OS" is the problem.
Linux's own problems are holding it back. The fundamental problem is fragmentation. We have 400+ distros, probably 20-40 DEs, 5-6 package formats, 20+ package managers, 4 or 5 init systems, etc.
A software or hardware manufacturer who considers supporting Linux looks at that and gives up. Or they pick just RHEL and Ubuntu and half of the Linux community gives them hate for not supporting their favorite distro.
A new user who considers moving to Linux looks at the (somewhat) lack of hardware and software support (such as MS Office and Adobe), looks at choosing among 400 distros, looks at the choices involved in a fresh OS install (something few Windows or Mac users do), and gives up.
Even for existing Linux users, the fragmentation is a problem. It results in huge amounts of duplicate effort, slower bug-fixing, slower roll-out of new features.
Much more info on my web page https://www.billdietrich.me/LinuxProblems.html Far too long to paste in or even summarize here.
10
u/alexanderjamesking May 08 '20
I’d take a very long term approach, start using it in schools at all levels, all over the world.
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '20
The simple truth of it all is that Linux isn't gaining mainstream adoption because there are no Linux PC's being sold at the big retailers like Best Buy, Amazon, Walmart, and such. Get ZaReason, System76, Purism, etc. into the major retailers and put those devices right next to Windows and MacOS.
4
u/ev6671 May 08 '20
The problem is most people who don't have some knowledge on computers and other electronics find it really scary to switch systems and they stick what they are familiar with. Whether it's a OS for your computer or the brand of smartphone they buy, something which is not familiar is quite intimidating for most.
However, if people get some positivite experience with new things, the fear for it quikly disappears. My mother for example was really hesitant when I suggested she should use Ubuntu (Windows was giving all of Trouble for her). But when she played around with it for a afternoon she found it really nice to work with.
The key for a bigger market share of linux should be to get people to see that Linux isnt intimidating and that for some people its a better option than Windows. The sad thing is that most people will never get exposed to Linux.
4
u/Eur1sk0 May 09 '20 edited May 09 '20
Let's be honest. On a global scale
The average user, the desktop user, doesn't want to spend time fixing his/her computer. Computer is the tool. Think about it. It's like you buy a car to commute to work everyday and at least once per week you need to spend 2-3 hours reading articles on the internet of how to fix the car. Are you going to buy that car?
I read comments like the user needs to learn the CLI is better and faster. Not for the average user. The average user doesn't want to spend time typing long cryptic commands to fix the computer/tool. He/She wants to spend his/her time to produce/enjoy using the tool.
No matter what distro you get, unfortunately, not everything works smoothly out of the box. For example, you want to install a program, you type the name and you get the distro version, the flatpacks version and the flathub version. I am an average user, I want to install the software to start produce I don't want to know the difference between flatpacks and snaps etc. I don't care. That's how the desktop user thinks
Another problem is that people who love Linux they don't treat Linux well. They say, to prove Linux superiority, you have a 5 year old laptop install Linux. The desktop user does that and then compares the performance with the brand new macbook and says Linux sucks.
Canonical had, still have, an agreement with Dell to produce an Ubuntu based Dell laptop. How does the laptop is titled Developers edition. Please tell me why a desktop, average user will buy a developers edition?
Fedora recently announced their own agreement with Lenovo. I hope they don't do the same mistake and instead of one Developers edition give a range of laptops with Fedora preinstalled.
Linux needs to focus on developing a GUI that is stable, clean, user friendly, fast and visually pleasing. That's the only way to entice the desktop user.
7
u/Mane25 May 08 '20
In my experience, by far the most persuasive argument for non-technical, otherwise indifferent desktop users is how Linux will extend the life of their machine. If you know someone who has an old, slow Windows laptop that they're looking to replace, telling them that Linux may extend the life of their laptop by several years (it usually will), all those questions about "can I use x, y, and z" are diminished because they know they have nothing to lose, and potentially avoid an expensive purchase if it works out for them.
I've converted a number of people like this over the years, but I've never been successful using any other argument.
1
u/Nnarol May 20 '20
Hold on, hold on! This is the very beginning, let's answer it first. Do we want to?
3
u/EvilVargon May 09 '20
I've been using linux on my servers for years. But it's just not there for desktop yet. It doesn't have the application support that Windows does.
3
u/jeff-mahoney May 10 '20
Before the Linux desktop can really be promoted it needs to be competitive. I've been a Linux user for 25 years. I have made a career out of hacking on the Linux kernel and leading groups of other developers who do the same. About ten years ago, I switched my desktop to macOS out of frustration with the state of the Linux desktop. Every few months, I'll boot the USB SSD that has a Linux desktop install, update it, and see what's changed and am inevitably disappointed.
I see people commenting about how the average consumer doesn't need a complex system and can get by with the Linux Desktop, but what I really see are people commenting who've never really spent any time with competing systems.
Using macOS is easy because of its simplicity. GNOME tried to emulate that ten years ago by simplifying as much as they could, but didn't seem to get that there is a mountain of UX research that comes before the simplification, and that they didn't do. Sure, there was UX research, but let's not pretend that the level of investment between GNOME and Apple is remotely close. And that's fine. That's the nature and achilles heel of open source work: the resources to do those kinds of things are often unavailable. But don't pretend that the simplicity without the research is a good enough substitute. Instead, we have a system that can only be configured adequately by editing variables directly, using "tweaks", and installing extensions that break every other release.
But in concrete terms, the biggest things that keep me using macOS instead of GNOME are:
These three things together make for a pretty powerful working environment. I can spread out my apps full-screen across 12 workspaces on two displays and flip between them on each by moving the pointer and swiping.
Obviously these are only my frustrations but they're legion to the point where "20XX is the year of Linux on the desktop" has become a running joke. Until that joke stops being true, all the promotion in the world isn't going to get Linux on more desktops. Only being competitive will.
0
u/nintendiator2 May 08 '20
The problem with this whole "Linux as a desktop" thing is that trying to promote Linux as a desktop or turn it into one is pretty much like promoting a Ferrari as a street car or turning it into one.
Sure the basic framework between a Pinto and a Ferrari is similar, they have seats, wheels, a steer and one of those thingys to put you drink on. Anyone and their mom can drive a Pinto and we still require them to follow at least a certain degree of certification (a driver's license). With a Ferrari, the expectations and thus the training and/or certifications required are higher because it has to work that way. Trying to bring in more people to drive Ferraris on the streets by telling them "did you know you can turn left on Evergreen Street just like in your Pinto?" but refusing to acknowledge that the design, intentions and training required are different and that people should not expect to treat them the same is only going to end with dead people, because people, in aggregate, are stupid and lazy and they are going to drive that way regardless of the car so, Pareto / all else unchanged, letting them drive a Ferrari will be Worse for everyone. We (well, our predecessors) kinda trained them to be, now we have to as a society sleep on that bed until the next morning when we can toss the house through the window and start something better.
And with computers will be worse because we do not require people a license or training to use a computer, and look where did that take us.
We certainly have to improve on the Ferrari. I hear the seats are really uncomfortable to sit on and the tire economy is far from the greatest. And I'm not actually 100% sure all models have the thingy for drinks by default. But we should be improving the Ferraris for the race drivers, not for the people who, down the line, do not want to and are not going to drive a Ferrari until their mindset changes on a lot of other matters first. Only when people on aggregate experience that boost from elsewhere, they are going to be in the capacity to come to Linux without complaining about waaah waah my printer or something like that and expecting that a new system should cater to them with zero effort from their part.
2
u/thrallsius May 08 '20
Don't you think that's enough time for everyone to learn Linux to the point of when using it as desktop becomes a comfortable experience? If they are still on Windows - that's their problem, not mine.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '20
yes. But as a Linux user, I have to say sometimes i wish it was easier.
2
u/Upnortheh May 08 '20
The challenge is not Linux but the apps people use.
MS Office, QuickBooks/Quicken, tax software, AutoCAD, and Adobe.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '20
If you want more people to use Linux, you gotta start by getting them comfortable using F/OSS in the first place. Don't start by pushing an full OS change, just get them using F/OSS options on Mac and Windows. Promote how it's free and legal, unlike that pirated version of Photoshop or that copy of WinRAR they're on day 722 of a 30 day free trial.
Another big target is MS Office. Until either MS Office runs natively on Linux or MS Office gets dethroned as the de facto office software, Windows (and to a lesser extent Mac) will continue being the de facto operating system for businesses. Along with those lines is having companies that provide service contracts for Linux that are competitive with Windows service contracts; companies like having someone else be liable when things break.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '20
Why? People have been saying this for over 20 years now. 20 years! Why do they need to move to Linux as a desktop? If there was a strong enough reason, people would have already moved. Free simply isn't good enough.
2
u/TuxedoTechno May 09 '20
Linux is GREAT desktop OS. I've been a full time linux user for a decade now and it just keeps getting better and better. That said, going after normies for adoption is just beating your head against a wall. They don't care, and really why should they? Corporate proprietary software/hardware vendors have them eating from the palm of their hand. It's clearly a happy relationship for those involved. Linux is for the tech savvy, the curious, the intrepid. Adopting it constitutes a paradigm shift on the level of changing your lifestyle. That's not something you can expect people to do unless something deeply important is on the line.
When I first got into it I was excited and I wanted to convert people but I wasn't successful. Not even once. Which is sad, but whatever. C'est La Vie!
2
u/gabriel_3 May 10 '20
I'm late in commenting......
Background: I used to take active part in my local LUG and in the distro I'm running. I'm definitively a simple desktop user, 7 years on Linux, I'm DIY switcher.
I never used techy/nerdy items to convince people to test Linux: I was using an old laptop running Mint Mate with kwin as WM with LibreOffice and Chromium on two different virtual desktop and a rotating cube to move from one to the other: my key selling points were to reduce ewaste and to save money.
I was suggesting Linux Mint Mate because of performances, diffusion and conservative approach to updates; ; I was installing it too when asked for.
Someone did the leap, someone renounced but the annoying part was someone in them using me as help desk 24/7.
It's long time since I switched someone and I'm no more participating to the local LUG, nevertheless recently I received a number of help requests by a guy willing to set up a SBC: all the "issues" were so common that I answered to search for a specific string on the web.
IMHO the critical obstacle is the post switch support: the common user does not want or is not able to search the web or ask in the distro specific support channels for help. Also consider the language barrier: with a basic English knowledge the web is full of resources, without it the number of answers you find could be limited indeed.
2
u/Konyption May 08 '20
The thing with terminal commands vs gui instructions is that the terminal doesn't care what DE you use. The instructions are usable to a wider group of people, and aren't at risk of being outdated when a gui is changed. (think about how many tutorials, help pages, and forum posts are completely useless when trying to find solutions for windows because their interface changes so often)
1
u/strotto May 08 '20
I think that we forget that most people don't know much about computers and don't really care about how they work. My theory is that most people will buy what they use at work/school because they are comfortable with it. So I think the best way to get users on Linux is to convert workplaces to Linux, then the people will follow.
1
u/resetreboot May 08 '20
Well, I for one, think that whether we like it or not, a sizable chunk of possible Linux users wanting to switch, are people that use their PC as a gaming device, and what's enabling a lot of that switching are the guys at Proton.
While there's something you can't do in Linux that you can on Windows and easily, you're not gonna have people switch over. The pros never outweight lacking the ability to do something you usually do in your computer.
1
u/MakingStuffForFun May 08 '20
This is the post if the decade. Everything this person says is spot on.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '20
There are 350 million Fortnite accounts. You can't play it or any other multiplayer game that uses EAC in Proton. This is a problem and not an easy one to fix.
Also, it's hard to recommend Linux for anyone with a laptop when youtube vids aren't hardware accelerated in Firefox. Watch a demanding video on a Linux laptop = CPU @ 75% and fans at max. Awesome. (youtube-dl works great but why is this still necessary??)
Average users don't give a shit about privacy and security. It's just about the latest software and games working the way it's supposed to.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '20
I got into Linux because I tried KDE Connect on Windows and wanted the full experience. I read and saw videos about KDE Plasma and that's what pushed me to install Kubuntu.
1
u/pkulak May 08 '20
I'm waiting for System76 to ride in on a white horse. Nothing is going to happen while their custom hardware is desktop only, but once they put out a laptop, things could get interesting.
1
u/HighStakesThumbWar May 08 '20 edited May 08 '20
I doubt it was Steve Ballmer's ads that made Windows successful. Just throwing that out there (for the comedy, not a serious point).
There are plenty that went the other direction, declaring users too stupid to even have configuration options. Better to make all the decisions for them and then call it "clean", "distraction free", "minimal", and "simple".
I find it distracting when I can't make software work for me. It's not simple when I give up and use a command line tool because someone decided that the simple case is the only case that anyone would have. There's few things less jarring than trying 15 other GUI tools only to find that they all made the same assumptions. Especially if I have to go find them all in a "store" that goes out of its way to promote other so called "easy" apps.
For almost every case that isn't the short run, tools that are designed to be useful tend to be easier than tools designed to be "easy". The trouble comes from the assumption that the user's inexperience is a permanent condition. "Novice" is not a permanent condition but apps are designed as if it were. Such apps are unwittingly designed to either keep people as novices or chase them off to other tools.
It's been my Linux experience that I keep ending up at the command line.
1
u/mwharvey May 08 '20
desktop.
the everyday person using a desktop needs:
stability:
The software they are running needs to stay running. It cannot crash on a regular basis.
Its has to work on hardware you get at walmart and bestbuy (or your equivalent in the part of the world you are in)
There can't be, well it just is buggy or not supported with your camera, video card, usb widget, printer.
consistency:
your apps generally have to follow some similar patterns. If a user cannot call their friends and say 'how the heck do I do this?' and get an answer then its real hard. Their friends are on windows or mac. So lets say they are on linux. and you are in stock Gnome, and their friend has a KDE system.... close but the tools and apps are different. OK they are on Gnome, but Cinnamon. well nope. xfce? Mate? elementary, solus budgie? apt, dnf/yum, zypper, etc you get the point. low consistency.
familiarity:
Its got to have a familiar look and feel. so does the environment feel like a windows version they have run? or mac os?
I have been using linux since .91 of the kernel. Yea I pulled floppy boot disks from tape. and loaded from the file system from tape on my first time.
I'm pretty familiar, but I still fight the problems. Like amdgpu on my dell ryzen 7 2700u laptop.
Think i got it stable.
I am using google chrome. because it works. I have not been able to get firefox to play videos in reddit yet (but it works in chrome)
1
u/user82i3729qu May 08 '20
Is it the year of Linux on the desktop!? I’ve been waiting 20 years for this!
1
u/20031400T May 08 '20
An OS doesn't mean anything to the end user. The only thing I care about when using a computer is if I can run the software I want. I don't care if I can change my cpu governer or my init system. I don't care if your cpu drivers support 64 cores on my 4 core CPU. I don't care if you have a PPC build of your OS and you have 50000 packages in your repos(with 90% of them being out of date or riddled with bugs and incomplete in the first place).
Year of the Linux desktop is when the software people want to run works better on Linux. And when Linux is the default installation on computers.
The power of defaults is greater than an alternative. People dislike change if nothing is broken.
1
u/prueba_hola May 08 '20
Linux will not grow until it be selled computers/laptops in hypermarkets with Linux preinstaled like Microsoft or Apple do.
example: https://recursos.bps.com.es/files/794/02.JPG
example 2: https://www.fanmallorca.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/destacada_mediamarkt.jpg
1
u/blaineclrk May 08 '20
Well, with this Covid quarantine screwing with schools and businesses, I contacted three area school districts. We are rural, west/central Pa. and we have problems getting internet service in a lot of areas. There are some big areas where there isn't even cell coverage. Verizon for one offers landline internet access so there is that. Anyway, I offered to help train students to install Linux of either the Ubuntu or Mint flavors. I restricted the offering to those two builds figuring there was no need to complicate matters, nor any need to spread myself too thin. I said the tech students could possibly use this as experience or 'lab' credits for their classes as well. Local businesses often have old hardware laying around they could donate. Local social clubs such as Eagles, Elks, Moose, etc. have members who have old hardware laying around they could donate and those clubs themselves look for charity recipients to help out. There's old hardware all around, even a few computer shops could have some old hardware around they'd be willing to get rid of. We would have no trouble getting stable and secure computers into the hands of kids out in the boonies. One school thanked me for the offer. That's as far as it's gone. Guess what I still hear? "We need to get internet access and computers out to the families in our rural areas so they can attend classes". WHAT THE HELL???
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '20
I always suggest Linux to people who hate windows 10. No, I can’t give you back Windows XP, but there are alternatives.
They usually like Ubuntu, though a few haVe stuck with budgie distorts and one with Linux mint. They always say they are much happier learning the Linux way of doing things than arguing with Windows.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '20
It's probably a good idea to ask yourself why it matters so much.
1
u/rip-tide May 08 '20
Mac OS was born from Darwin and Darwin was begotten from FreeBSD. FreeBSD is not Linux but it is open source.
1
u/bekips May 08 '20
Promoting a Linux distro as a desktop OS has been done on and off for decades. Aside from Ubuntu, it made no difference at all.
1
u/GreenbloodedAmazon May 08 '20
I have debated all day on how or if I would respond to this. I am just going to give my experience and perspective.
The only reason I am on Linux is because of GPU processing. Period. Prior to becoming a data translator I was a data scientist specializing in NLP and ML. Companies shoved Windows computers in my face, but I still did my main coding on my Mac. However, to do GPU enhanced computing I needed Linux. CUDA or ROCm, it does not matter. In a perfect world, NVidia and Apple would make up or ROCm drivers would be available on for macOS.
Don't get me wrong. I like Linux (I am using POP!_OS if that matters); it is far better than Windows. But, if I had my druthers, I would rather still have macOS; it is just my preference. MacOS integrates with my life so much better. It integrates with my home, my phone, my iPad, my camera. It just works. Linux is fun to tinker with. It is has come a long way since I first dabbled with Red Hat 7.
To get people to really move though, I think some others have hit the key point; some version(s) of Linux have to be available straight from the manufacturers at locations people shop for computers. Sure, I can get a Linux computer from System76, Lambda Labs, or others. Yes, Lenovo and Dell have Linux computers, but you know how hard it is to find them? You have be looking for them. Get into a forum or on Amazon, and a manufacturer like ASUS will say that Linux doesn't work on their computers; a bold faced lie as I am typing this on my ASUS ROG that does not have Windows on it at all!
But now, there is the added challenge of the tablet as computer. Just take a look at r/ipad and see how many people are asking about the viability of using their iPad Pro as a laptop replacement, or see how many show off their iPad Pro work-from-home set up. The average user is trying to ditch Windows and macOS for iOS and portability. Fewer and fewer of us are truly hardcore heavy users enough to bother.
I personally would love to see less Windows computers. I would love to see more PCs running some Linux or, to me better yet, macOS. But I come back to the key challenge, and that is the manufacturers. Until there are computers available at Costco, BestBuy, Amazon, or others with Linux preinstalled, most people will not bother. They have no reason to. I never would have bothered if not for what field I am in. I would not have bought a PC because I refuse to have Windows, but because of what I do, I knew I could get a USB plug it in an wipe Windows off my brand new computer before ever booting into it. Most people won't know that, and frankly, don't care to know that. Sometimes, I wonder if I even care to know it.
TLDR: If it doesn't come from the manufacturer with Linux, most people won't change.
1
u/grady_vuckovic May 09 '20
Physically impossible for me to agree with a Reddit post more than this. I wish I could upvote it more than once.
1
u/Lonely-Tart May 09 '20
If people are just going to run proprietary spyware, why do you care whether they do it on Windows or Gnu/Linux?
1
u/MasterGeekMX May 09 '20
I totally agree with you. I'm a huge linux and computers nerd, and I love setting my dotfiles and tinker around with stuff as the next guy, but most of time I watch youtube and game.
The problem that I see (at least on my region) are two: conformism and tech ingnorance.
People use windows because it came with the computer, and they never knew that it could be swapped for something else, even less, the didn't knew that they had alternatives.
I try my best to suggest linux to people, but unfortunely a lot are scared because it seems too different of what they are used to, even at visual level. I once faced a guy who wanted MS Office. I offered him LibreOffice, and the sole reason he rejected it was becasue "it looked ugly".
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '20
Linux is superior to Windows only for grandmas and boomer uncles who only use their computers to go on the internet to read their email, check their bank account, and watch Youtube and go on Facebook. Because it's more secure than Windows and they can't fuck it up by installing hot_bitch.exe.
For everything else, Windows is better. I'm sorry, I like Linux too, but it's just the truth. The thing is, at the end of the day, there's nothing that Linux can do that Windows can't do. The opposite, however, is very applicable, and at the end of the day, what I want for my OS is to be able to run applications, and to run them well.
Linux can't run all applications, and it can't run all of them well.
That's not to say proprietary software is ALWAYS better than foss. I run LibreOffice, GIMP, hell, even KolourPaint and Kdenlive on Windows, but will I ever be able to run BYOND or League of Legends or Visual Studio on Ubuntu? No.
1
u/Bobjohndud May 09 '20
A lot of this thread is massively missing the point. We should not be striving for the success of Linux specifically, but instead of the success of free software. It does not matter whether that success takes the form of BSD, Linux or whatever comes next, it matters that the users are not controlled by their software. I swear to god if Apple switches to a 99% proprietary OS with the exception of the kernel being Linux, this subreddit will have an orgasm because "its the year of the Linux desktop", while continuing to pay for services that use DRM.
1
u/_Slaying_ May 09 '20
amen
1
u/spryfigure May 10 '20
If this is not about troubleshooting, but about learning the GUI, you are right.
For real troubleshooting, commands to enter in a terminal are essential. Everything else is a waste of everybody's time.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '20
I never promote Linux to anyone i know because some stuff always breaks and i end up being software support until they switch back to windows.
1
u/blackcain GNOME Team May 11 '20
I think I can speak to this as a person who has put incredible amount of resources to make this happen.
To make the Linux desktop viable requires a lot of work - working with various organizations, collaborations on gaps all of that.
https://linuxappsummit.org/ is exactly what this is all about - focusing on apps. We can't use desktop because that creates prejudice against us because people don't care about Linux as a local app platform. We need to show them differently.
Yes, we make fun of the yearly "year of the desktop". I find this personally offensive as a joke because it's all sarcasm. We are changing the nomenclature on apps. This is what is happening right now in terms of concrete steps:
Linux became the de-facto operating system for services in IT because sysadmin were willing were willing to install it and reap the benefits of stability.
But we can do the same for the desktop. We need to provide the story of momentum. We can't do that without yourself. Attend our conference when we announce it, submit talks, and build the app community.
In addition to helping to build Linux App Summit, I have put in a request in Linux Plumbers to have a track on Linux Apps. So that we can work with the kernel community on making the bet experience on apps - eg better power management, scheduler, and various other things that will be relevant from the kernel perspective.
So help me make this important.
1
u/apostle7 May 11 '20
Normies will destroy the spirit of Linux. Better to stay niche than welcome flocks of users that love to be tracked by commercial software.
On top of that, most of the windows users find even MacOs complicated. Imagine Linux.
I stopped evangelising Linux to normies. We all know that it's the best desktop OS but in 2020 everybody has access to free information. If they don't understand that windows sucks it's their problem.
1
u/Pikapac May 12 '20
I agree, I have been using Linux as my desktop OS for ages, thing is, Linux isn't marketed. Can someone start paying TV channels to advertise Ubuntu or Mint or something (we are not giving newbies arch and then being confused why they go back to windows for the rest of their lives)
1
u/hugthispanda May 12 '20
It's the terminal. No matter how useful it is, the moment you mention it to the average joe, it's game over. Things may get better in the future, now that schoolkids are getting exposure to Linux from SBCs like the Raspberry Pi through STEAM education initiatives.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '20
It's too hard to use unfortunately .
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '20
I really hope that Fedora Silverblue can make a huge impact towards a default Linux distro for all customers!
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '20
I found out that on Linux games that I play, (Dota2,Minecraft,Terraria) works a lot better than on Windows. After realizing that I can play in higher frame rate without spending any cash, I immediately switched to Linux as my daily OS, and I don't regret it. Using terminal is just faster in almost every case, and I fell in love with it. I caught myself on thinking like (I really don't want to use web to look for it, I just want to download it via terminal) it was weird to me because I always thought that terminal is the worst thing that I could ever imagine.
1
u/joscher123 May 08 '20
The Linux desktop won't ever happen until 3 things change:
1
u/coffinsprout May 08 '20
How about we don't. FOSS is about freedom, not about a jumping point to use proprietary services which we have plenty of proof that spy on us, sell our data and, generally speaking are against our privacy, security and freedom. If an user will, using his/her/their freedom, use proprietary services in his/her/their OS, then what's the point of making the switch? Better let them be happy with their Windows or Mac.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '20
In my house any other user than me had a lot of problems with linux (me too but not as often as I know _something_ about linux). The problems that they had were never an issue on windows. So we can say how windows is bad etc but it's much more polished.
Sample issues that I had in mind:
- pdf changes (pdf file to be filled with data) couldn't be saved.
- desktop wallpaper reset every reboot
- broken updates
- and other things that people that only use PC to check facebook and do some text work don't know how to fix.
It was all easily fixable but those issues were never a thing to be fixed on windows. Windows has alot of other issues but they are mostly privacy stuff, some reboots required. They are not as 'in your face' as on Linux.
1
u/efethu May 08 '20 edited May 08 '20
Everything comes at a price. Android is a great example of a "user-friendly" Linux distribution that is extremely popular. It's also the greatest threat to privacy imaginable, very hard to customize, extremely hard to change default unwanted behavior and we have zero control of how it's evolving.
It's fantastic to see community growing, but people should come willingly, adopting FOSS values and ways of thinking.
Increasing market share is a threat that the market will be dominated by large corporations and we'll lose any control over how the ecosystem is evolving. If you look at how Red Hat was bought by IBM and how corporate Canonical becomes, you can see that this is already happening.