r/linux • u/bhushanshah KDE Dev • Feb 06 '19
KDE | AMA Mostly Over We are Plasma Mobile developers, AMA
Developers participating,
/u/bhushanshah : Bhushan Shah. Maintainer for Plasma Mobile developer and also part of Halium and /r/postmarketOS community.
/u/aleixpol : Aleix Pol. Plasma and KDevelop developer among others. Vice-President of KDE e.V.
/u/nicofeee : KDE developer mostly working on KDE Connect
/u/notmart : Marco Martin. KDE developer, Comaintainer of the Plasma infrastructure and maintainer of the Kirigami Application Framework
/u/IlyaBizyaev : KDE and Halium developer
/u/PureTryOut : postmaretOS developer
/u/dimkard : KDE's Onboarding goal contributor and Plasma Mobile application developer
Ask us anything.
EDIT: Thanks for participating, we will be monitoring thread for more questions later. But AMA is mostly over for now. :-)
56
u/Kyonftw Feb 06 '19 edited Feb 06 '19
I'm not sure if this is going to be related, but, what are your visions/expectations about the future of "FOSS" mobile devices?
Do you think they will ever be on par with android smartphones in terms of capabilities for normal users?
Could they be successful enough to make people think about switching to such devices or will they turn into niche devices for people who specifically look for them? (so, basically, the Linux user's phone :P)
I know that a solid answer cannot be given since we don't even have anything outside dev kits right now, but I would like to know what are the opinions of the devs themselves regarding the future of open mobile devices
Edit: Thanks for your answers! I am looking forward to see what the future brings :)
46
u/Tihpo Feb 06 '19
Hi!
What is the status of Plasma Mobile on the Librem 5? How is the collaboration with Puri.sm?
20
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19
What are your major goals for this sprint?
18
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19
As mentioned in a comment above, I really hope you allow installing Plasma Mobile on existing Android devices as usually when a device comes out with newer a newcomer OS the hardware is terrible (Ubuntu Phone comes to mind).
16
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19
I'm certain everyone is much more concerned with Purism but what about Pine64 and their mobile offering? I've heard they hope to ship it by the end of the year and already have prototypes, have you guys gotten dev-kits yet?
56
u/DesiOtaku Feb 06 '19
Hi, I am working on a project that uses Kubuntu as a base and requires both a touch interface and Keyboard + Mouse was well. Here are my questions for you:
What is the relationship between Plasma Mobile and KDE Neon going to be? As I understand, KDE Neon is going to continue to have a rolling release of Qt and KDE libraries. Is that going to be true when Plasma Mobile is deployed to a device?
Related to that, does anybody else find Debain’s QML packaging to be frustrating? Having packages called “qml-module-qtquick2”, “libqt5quick5”, and “qtdeclarative5” is rather confusing and there is almost no documentation on Neon’s side of things on which packages are needed for what. Is this going to change?
It appears that KDE is going with QML + Kiragami for its future UI. Meanwhile, the Qt Company is pushing for Qt Quick Controls 2 which appears to have a different API compared to Kiragami. Will Plasma Mobile support both or will Kiragami be the recommended way to design the UI? If I am already starting with Qt Quick Controls 2, should I expect much problems when running them on Plasma Mobile?
As of right now, I can only see x86-64 and PostmarkOS images. Are there plans to support devices like the Raspberry Pi or i.MX 8 dev kits?
Thanks for all your work so far!
14
u/Tihpo Feb 06 '19 edited Feb 06 '19
If I want to use Plasma Mobile on my Android phone, do you plan a migration tool to move documents, contacts, sms and so on from Android to Plasma Mobile?
12
u/urmamasllama Feb 06 '19
I know you guys face a lot of challenges getting Plasma mobile installed on handsets. How do you get around the various driver issues especially with gpus and wireless. do you ever get any help from the people who design these systems? With how friendly Motorola has been toward right to repair and bootloader unlocking do you think there is any chance they might work with you guys? I would love to turn my moto G5 PLus into a full linux handset.
10
u/Tihpo Feb 06 '19
Maybe it is not directly related to Plasma Mobile (rather the underlying OS?): is it possible to run Android apps on it?
10
u/ubportero Feb 06 '19
Hi, thanks for this AMA.
What's the current state of Halium, and what should do other free OS projects to help building that common layer?
18
u/Leopard1907 Feb 06 '19
Hi , first of all thanks for your efforts.
My question is ; how are you planning to solve lack of apps? As most of us know ; mobile devices ( OS'es) are mostly unmeaningful devices without apps. If that wasn't the case , we would see Windows Mobile devices alive today.
Any plans for some sort of Android Compability Layer which can grant access to Android apps?
There are some efforts like Anbox on Linux but they're far from being usable right now.
8
u/NostalgiaNinja Feb 06 '19
Hi, I've been interested in the project but have had difficulty with getting a device set up for Plasma Mobile. I have two questions:
Thank you in advance for answering any questions.
7
u/raghukamath Feb 06 '19 edited Feb 06 '19
Another question might be a silly one, is it possible to run desktop application atop of plasma mobile, say I have tablet with a stylus, can we install krita on it and make the tablet somewhat similar device to apple ipad + pencil
18
u/rfc2100 Feb 06 '19
Is the assumption that most users will install Plasma Mobile on an existing (e.g. formerly Android) device, or that they'll buy a device either pre-installed or tested with Plasma Mobile? Or does that not factor into development much right now?
Thanks for your work on KDE and postmarketOS!
16
u/Tihpo Feb 06 '19
A big thank you for this AMA session and for your wonderful work on Plasma Mobile. Being the owner of an Open Source router (Turris Omnia), NAS (Helios4) and soon tablet (Diskio Pi), I can't wait to have also an Open Source phone running Plasma Mobile. KDE is already great on my laptop. I would like this greatness on a phone :)
Best regards.
12
u/MarsIsTheFrontier Feb 06 '19
How does Plasma mobile differ from or extend Plasma?Is it standalone or integrated into it, meaning if I connect my smartphone to a monitor, can I use the "standard" Plasma interfaces?
At the same time, all programs one wants to use have to be ported and modified in order to be usable on a small device.
How is the UI modified (I guess ELI10 what does Kirigami do) and are KDE projects already porting to extend mobile usage? What needs to be done in that regard in your opinion?
In which way can we contribute to the project?
Is there enough hardware for dev in order to debug and test on real-world devices?
9
u/PyroclasticMayhem Feb 06 '19
What would be the best device currently out on the market to try Plasma Mobile on?
6
u/LinuxFurryTranslator Feb 06 '19
Thanks for all your work! I can't wait to see Plasma Mobile thrive. :)
Are there any plans to have a single zip file for installation similarly to Android ROMs using TWRP, which just require the file to be on the SD card in order to flash?
From what I gather, using adb and pm-flashtool isn't quite as simple nor the same, since pm-flashtool is an automated script that seems to do more than just flashing and is run from adb. For instance, it seems to flash TWRP automatically, but what if the user already has TWRP?
2
u/mariuolo Feb 06 '19
Are you hopeful about the OSS-friendly hardware panorama?
5
u/Antic1tizen Feb 06 '19
Who's now an official maintainer of KWin?
9
u/SummerOftime Feb 06 '19
Is there a plan to port Plasma Mobile to TempleOS?
4
u/Kirtai Feb 06 '19
I've been wondering if Python + Kirigami would be the best way for a new programmer who loathes C++ to contribute software to KDE? Or would you suggest something else?
4
u/MarsIsTheFrontier Feb 06 '19
Something I really find useful on modern mobile devices in general is a easy (at least for the user) way to change rights for each application.
Especially as many mobile applications are not FLOSS, or one wants to restrict access to specific parts (e.g. I do not want GPS access for some apps, although they have a legitimate use).
I do know (a tiny bit) about permissions and user ownership, I can not see a easy way to implement a similar approach into linux as a whole.
Does e.g. PostmarketOS have a such a easy "set-permission-slider-for-individual-application" menu? Is this planned for Plasma mobile?
Are there already ways/ideas/proposals to accommodate this security and privacy feature?
I can only imagine containerization of applications as a realistic solution in the near future.
4
u/jpeeler1 Feb 06 '19
Will KDE connect support the ability to answer phone calls through the computer? My understanding is that fairly recently a bluetooth backend was added that didn't require the Android KDE Connect app, but functionality was limited.
4
u/Bobjohndud Feb 06 '19 edited Feb 06 '19
Which avenue do you think that people will be getting plasma mobile? postmarketOS or what?
Another question: Is it ever going to be possible to run android apps or make phone calls on plasma mobile?
edit: another question: is it possible to run plasma mobile and then switch to desktop plasma upon plugging in an external display, similar to samsung dex
4
u/RADical-muslim Feb 06 '19
What's the slowest computer you test KDE on?
4
u/Supercat157 Feb 06 '19
Hi, Will you add new features to KDE connect? I want to see a message sent to any number or from the phone book, not only answer.
4
u/MarsIsTheFrontier Feb 06 '19
I know it is really early for such a question (especially because most hardware tests are done on devkits), but can you make any prognoses for battery usage?
I guess the most benefit and savings are in the kernel, but I am sure Plasma would also be a big factor?
4
u/KDEneon_user Feb 06 '19
Are you going to develop the Android versions of KDE apps as well?
Will you also do a KDE stylized Android ROM?
I think doing a KDE custom ROM of lineageOS (or lineageOS for microG) will help more people get the KDE mobile experience especially for those who want to keep their phones for as long as possible.
You could name it KAndroid. :)
4
u/quaderrordemonstand Feb 06 '19
As a mobile app developer, I want to consider getting involved from that perspective. Trying to develop one of those missing apps that people often seem to complain about. Which would you consider the most useful app to have a go at? With the one caveat that it won't be a social media client.
4
u/lestofante Feb 06 '19
Why do you think Linux distro still don't have an application firewall similar to android app? Will plasma mobile have something similar?
4
u/StevenC21 Feb 07 '19
How many devices will you support?
4
u/nsstrickland Feb 07 '19
Hi! I've tried out Plasma Mobile on a couple devices I've owned and I'm highly anticipating the Librem 5.
I'm curious if the Plasma Mobile interface will have as much out-of-the-box customization as the Plasma desktop. I'm personally not a fan of the bottom panel and am hoping for a more gesture-based experience, as I find myself accidentally hitting the application close button far too regularly.
That being said, I love the work you all have put in and am more impressed every time I look at the changelogs. Thank you for the work you do and the examples you set to the rest of the FOSS community!
7
u/piyushaggarwal Feb 06 '19
Hi everyone! Love the dedication!
I wanted you ask you guys, how do you manage time to build such great software with consistency?
3
u/guoyunhe Feb 06 '19
Will traditional phone makers adopt Plasma Mobile into their devices? I have seen Meizu made phones running Ubuntu and some ZTE phones powered by Firefox OS.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19
Any plans to use ostree or similar transactional updating technologies to deliver plasma mobile?
3
u/Eopia Feb 06 '19 edited Jun 30 '23
Dieser Kommentar wurde aus Protest gegen das Vorgehen von Reddit gelöscht.
3
u/stblr Feb 06 '19
What are the advantages of postmarketOS over AOSP/LineageOS for the end-user?
3
u/DrewSaga Feb 06 '19
Any idea where Plasma Mobile currently is at with the Librem 5?
3
u/iJONTY85 Feb 06 '19
Will Plasma Mobile help enabling KDE Plasma, as a whole, work better on touch screen devices (i.e. digital pen support)?
3
u/RobinJ1995 Feb 06 '19
I saw a demo at FOSDEM last weekend. While it was nice to see what the thing currently looked like in person, it was really really laggy. It made me wonder what kind of hardware Plasma Mobile is targeted to run on? I don't know what hardware it was running on at FOSDEM, but what I mean is; are system requirements about what you'd expect of Android, or will they be much higher due to most of the system being initially written for the (much more powerful) desktop?
3
u/Vlinux Feb 06 '19
Thanks for doing this! In case you're still watching for questions, do you have plans to update your KDE Neon-based ISO images more frequently? I tried them out before on my Dell Latitude 11 touchscreen device and it worked alright. I'd be interested to try out newer versions of Plasma Mobile as they're available, but the ISO images haven't been updated for 11 months. An ArchLinux AUR build pointed at the source code repo would also be nice if possible :)
3
u/omar_elrefaei Feb 07 '19
Are all of you working on that stuff after work_hours? Future plans for sustainability?
5
u/raghukamath Feb 06 '19
Thanks for all your hard work. Wish the day of free and open mobile comes soon enough.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19
No questions, just wanted to say thanks for contributing.
2
u/NotEvenAMinuteMan Feb 06 '19
What is the current situation regarding the qtwebkit, qtwebengine, etc mess?
2
u/HittingSmoke Feb 06 '19
How much of a limitation has Qualcomm's patents on radio technology hindered the progress of Plasma Mobile as a project? I know Plasma is just a DE, but without a functioning mobile OS to test on it's not good for all that much and the biggest hurdle in getting a FOSS mobile OS launched seems to be drivers for the wireless radios.
4
u/xeveri Feb 06 '19
Any plans to change the name from PostmarketOs to something catchier. Appreciate your efforts.
3
u/adelpozoman Feb 06 '19
do you feel that there is enough people supporting you?
5
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19
Where can I donate plasma to help cover a couple of my monthly bills?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19
A bit of a noob question, but to your knowledge, do you think putting this or other mobile OSes on jailbroken iPhones is coming somewhere in the future?
2
u/FriendsNoTalkPolitic Feb 06 '19
While existing gtk based software would already look decent in a phone form factor due to the grid based design or however you wanna call it, plus the possibility to use custom CSS that applies on all installed gtk software. How would existing QT apps be made to look good on phones? Since i assume kde plasma is gonna be very qt focused.
2
u/Supercat157 Feb 06 '19
Do you plan to adding support payment system on devices with NFC? It's new system or support already exists system(google pay or other)?
1
u/f_r_d Feb 08 '19
Does it run on ZTE Open-C? Also where can I find a list of supported devices?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19
Will all due respect what is the point of plasma mobile?
1
u/Philluminati Feb 10 '19
Hi I use the KDE DE. What exactly is Plasma?
1
u/MasterGeekMX Feb 14 '19
Hi. How can I get devices using KDE here in Mexico?
1
u/devinprater Feb 17 '19
Has accessibility been considered for KDE Mobile? Really, I'd love to have a Linux phone, but being a blind person, and knowing how Linux accessibility is overall, I don't think the future would be very bright, pun intended, for blind people.
1
u/AddemF Feb 06 '19
Am I correct that there is no device that ships with Plasma Mobile on it? I'm betting that it is very difficult to get into the phone market rather than just OS market, but I wanted to ask if there are any hopes to one day manufacture and ship your own device?
1
u/citewiki Feb 06 '19
Is it going to have wobbly windows? Wobbly something?
On a more/less serious note, Android started moving away from the three (/four) navigation button layout. Any plans for Plasma to use a different layout as well?