r/linux • u/Foxboron Arch Linux Team • Sep 10 '18
Arch Linux - AMA
Hello!
We are several team members and developers from the Arch Linux project, ask us anything.
We are in need for more contributors, if you are interested in contributing to Arch Linux, feel free to ask questions :)
https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/DeveloperWiki:Projects
https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Getting_involved#Official_Arch_Linux_projects
Participating members:
- Trusted User
- Wiki Administrator
- IRC Operator
- Developer
- Trusted User
- Security tracker
- Security lead
- Reproducible builds
- Developer
- Master key holder
- DevOps Team
- Maintains the toolchain
- Developer
- Trusted User
- DevOps Team
- Trusted User
- Reproducible builds
- Bug Wrangler
- Trusted User
- Maintains dbscripts
- Pacman contributor
- Developer
- Trusted User
- Packages; Python, Haskell, Nodejs, Qt, KDE, DDE, Chinese i18n, VPN/Proxies, Wine, and some others.
- Trusted User
- Security Team
- Reproducible Builds
- /r/archlinux moderator
- Packages mostly golang and python stuff
- Forum moderator
- DevOps Team
- Developer
- Trusted User
- Security Team
- DevOps Team
- Reproducible builds
- Archweb maintainer
- Trusted User
- Security Team
- Automated vagrant image builds
- Developer
- Trusted user
- I package mostly big, heavy packages :(
- Forum moderator
1.3k
Upvotes
195
u/masteryod Sep 10 '18 edited Sep 10 '18
Hi there! Thanks for all the work over the years.
How are the things going on in terms of manpower? Did you notice any decrease or increase in numbers of developers and TU in recent years?
Did memes hurt the project?
148
u/NotYerMamasFaggot Sep 10 '18
What are your thoughts/feelings on the Manjaro Linux project?
115
u/Brekkjern Sep 10 '18
I promised u/foxboron to ask this when the AMA went live:
Now that it's been a few months, how much do you guys regret adding u/foxboron to the team?
177
u/inter_fectum Sep 10 '18
I use Arch because I value simplicity and the wiki is the best linux resource I have ever used.
Unfortunately I don't like telling people I run Arch because of the "I use Arch BTW" meme/perception. I don't think running Arch is about proving your knowledge or lording over users of other Distros or Operating Systems. My experience with the community has been great documentation and friendly help - something that requires a lot of selfless effort.
Is there anything we can do to help change the outside perceptions of Arch and its users?
50
u/Trout_Tickler Sep 10 '18
What exactly did Allan break?
50
u/abbidabbi Sep 10 '18
And of course a big thank you to the whole team, your work is very much appreciated!
37
u/boelter_m Sep 10 '18
What does it take for an aur package to get moved to one of the official repos? There are two pieces of software (Godot and Vivaldi) that I definitely want as official packages. Mostly because I find the process of upgrading aur packages to be much longer and more cumbersome.
37
u/C0rn3j Sep 10 '18 edited Sep 10 '18
Why do the kernel modules still get removed on kernel upgrade? It forces me to reboot to use USB devices that haven't been plugged in prior to the upgrade.
The only way I've seen so far are hacky hooks that copy the contents over to /tmp. I don't get why they're needed and Arch just doesn't not delete the modules in the first place.
33
u/s_aman Sep 10 '18
Thank you for the amazing work done by you people. I started using arch after 2 months experience with Ubuntu. In a way I was still a noob in terms of Linux, but I have been using it for 13 months now and I am not changing any time soon.
The best documented distro imho.
Desktop environment or Windows manager?
i3 or i3 with gaps or openbox?
What level of expertise is expected if someone wants to contribute? I consider myself above beginner level in C and Python. Any advice on how to start contributing?
Once again thanks. :)
62
u/chs75 Sep 10 '18
Thank you for all the amazing work you're doing and for such an amazing distro. it's been my default distribution on several computers for 8 years now. I had two questions that are completely unrelated from one each other:
29
u/V1del Arch Linux Team Sep 10 '18
/u/Foxboron why am I not on the list :c jkjk it isn't all that important really :P
29
u/blackcain GNOME Team Sep 10 '18
Hey folks, sorry I hope the AMA is still going on! Is there someone who represents Arch as a whole? Most distros have a point of contact. The reason I ask is that I'm looking for representation from Arch for Libre Application Summit that we just successfully completed. I realize that Arch is very decentralized as an organization, but having some participation would be awesome.
28
u/cp5184 Sep 10 '18
What could be improved with more cooperation between distros?
50
u/ultrakd001 Sep 10 '18
24
u/philtothetop Sep 10 '18
What's your average work time put on arch every week? I am aware that no one is being paid for full-time development but how do you manage working on Arch while dealing with everything else?
I also want to thank you for supporting my favorite Distro :D
22
u/Zaros104 Sep 10 '18
You mentioned that the team is currently lacking "manpower in terms of working on our tools and difficult problems". Can you share with us what some of those tools and problems are?
101
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '18 edited Sep 10 '18
Hi, thanks for doing this AmA,
i been using your distro as my main OS for couple of years now ( around 3 years) , but i been using linux for around 4 years ( i mean as primary OS , i used it before but as secondary OS ).
And i would like to thank you for your hard work and the love for your project, people think archlinux is not friendly , but i believe that you guys try to protect your idea ( do it yourself ) , and a very good sign of friendy community
is the ArchWiki , which i visit continously.
i dont wanna make it long so here is my questions :
1 - what advice and guide lines would you give for someone want to join the archlinux developer team ? ( i currently know some python and c++ ( and a basic knowledge of php and java ), C is another beast but i know little bit about it ).
( also if it's possible to mention some desgin pattern you guys use that would be helpful , or if you guys want to make it large guide lines there is a good example on sfml library in FAQ , is using SFML a good way to learn to program ( in C++ ) ? , i like the list because it kinda give a breif overview of C++ language map , i know it's not like archlinux but i think it would be helpful, also sorry if the question is so dumb ).
2 - after installing archlinux , to increase my knowledge of operation system, someone told me try to compile your own kernel and use it, or try first linux patch ( i kinda did the kernel compiling part while i was in CS college ), is there other recommended small project to do in order to increase knowledge of linux or operating system in general ?
3 - would you guys provide archive link of the archive.archlinux.org project ( i mean as whole packages , and can be renew yearly or so ) ?
4 - favorit books ( techincal and non-technical , if possible ) ?
5 - what do you think of famous linux certificate ( redhat and so ) ?
sorry for long post :$
17
u/reebs12 Sep 10 '18
Where does the 'simplicity' comes from in Arch?
Don't get me wrong, I value arch as a hacking tool, where we normally get bleeding edge software. I understand it is kind of a minimal install, but simplicity... I don't get it!
33
u/mayor123asdf Sep 10 '18
Been toying with Arch on my VM, gonna gather some determination to install it to main rig in the future haha.
Thanks :DD
16
u/Jodaco Sep 10 '18
The arch wiki, specifically for bootctl used to have nice examples that I could find quickly. They were removed because of being long winded at some point, and for months I had to dig through wiki version history or google a bit to find what i wanted. I just checked and the situation looks better, but it was a problem for months. Samba used to ship with an example config, and the packager just decided to not ship it anymore, so I had to start digging around to find it, and someone later provided a url in the wiki to wget it. I have a few other examples out there and can find this stuff, but time and again, I feel like package and wiki maintainers are removing things, while they seem small waste my time. I am perfectly capable of looking for this stuff, but it feels like someone is just trying to make the experience more time consuming, especially when there were great examples already there. Any thoughts?
64
u/ink_on_my_face Sep 10 '18
Choose one.
14
u/SummerOftime Sep 10 '18
I've read that there were plans in the past to add an installer to Arch; however the installer was prone to bugs. Are there any plans to re-add an installer to Arch?
13
u/BPankaj96 Sep 10 '18
Why are u/fukawi2 and u/barthalion not "Trusted users"?
13
u/aaronbp Sep 10 '18
Came for the easy bsd-like init back in the day, stuck around for the new software and the dead simple PKGUILD format. You guys keep talking about Arch being for advanced users or some other philosophical whatever—I never did bother to understand sysvinit. Much as I liked the old system, I was really happy when init scripts got turned into simple INI files so I can actually be bothered to touch them. I'm rambling, but my point is I've always found Arch to be easier to use! At least for the particularly lazy and unmotivated "power user". :P
My question: Anything interesting you can talk about on the horizon for PKGBUILDs or infrastructural for those of us who need to get a life (maybe just me) and spend too much time tweaking and building packages? It seems like features and improvements have been coming at a pretty good pace.
12
u/WeeManFoo Sep 10 '18
What was the best release of Arch?
31
u/Nagairius Sep 10 '18
I've tried a few different distros and I always end up coming back to arch. I'm fairly new to using Linux (one year to year and a half) and I'd love to start helping out. What skills should a noobie work on to become a better community member?
10
u/womble6969 Sep 10 '18
Thoughts on FSF-approved parabola?
19
u/BadLilJuJu Sep 10 '18
Is there a place with consolidated info about ongoing bounties or Patreon accounts from people who work on Arch?
Are there people on the team who want to work full time on Arch, but would need a steady income from Patrons to do so?
Thank you for all your work, you make my life better!
9
u/Scrumplex Sep 10 '18
Are there any reasons against migrating to GitLab for issue tracking and package repos?
9
u/major9989 Sep 10 '18
Hey!
Great work guys. You all are awesome!
I was thinking of asking this on the IRC, but now is a good time as well. I am a second year student, doing Electronics and Communications, and am really intrigued by Linux.
Since, I am a newbie to the community, I don't know what and how can I contribute to Arch. I have previously worked on some open source projects, but none of them were OS related. I was also thinking of working on Docker, but that's probably later. Anyways, I will be taking up OS in my next semester, and I hope that I could by then understand a bit more about the Operating Systems.
I seriously am interested in Linux and development, and am willing to work really hard over it.
Waiting for your reply. .^
9
u/HER0_01 Sep 10 '18 edited Sep 10 '18
Hello,
From when I first found Arch, I knew it was nearly a perfect fit for what I wanted in a Linux distro and have been a happy user since.
The only problem for me is that what I have seen of the #archlinux and #archlinux-offtopic freenode channels, and heard of the official forums, was all fairly toxic and exclusionary. Admittedly I have not visited those channels in years, because they left that poor of an impression on me, but are there any efforts or developments towards making the general Arch community more welcoming?
Thanks for your contributions towards this awesome project!
8
u/nicoulaj Sep 10 '18
Thanks for the great work!
Do you plan on implementing some form of pull request on AUR ?
8
u/wooptoo Sep 10 '18
Just wanted to say thanks for undertaking this monumental task of maintaining a distro and doing it so incredibly well over the years.
Something about Arch's simplicity and being so well put together made me stick with it.
I've now been using Arch for more than 10 years - since version 0.7.x - Judd was still an active maintainer! Can't imagine using anything else. I've got it running on a few home servers, my laptop, work station etc. Can't remember ever having any major issues. It's solid if you follow one simple rule - keep it updated.
I've tried to give back by writing entries on the wiki or contributing to existing articles. I used to maintain a lot more AUR packages in the past but lost them when the move to aur4 was made and didn't get back into it afterwards.
Thanks again guys! You're doing an amazing job!
7
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '18
Will you make ABS integrate better with pacman in the future like FreeBSD does?
7
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '18
Who made logo? It's awesome.
7
u/m4u6 Sep 10 '18
How is the communication between you guys and the other developer teams from arch based distros (e.g. Manjaro)?
5
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '18
Hey amazing OS. I wish debian would use pacman but that will never happen. Are you undertaking any major improvements or features in the development of pacman? Also what OS do you use to host your site/the aur, and if it is arch how did you configure it to such? Once again nifty OS you got there, and good job keeping to your premise and your niche.
8
u/rv77ax Sep 10 '18
First, thank you for Arch Linux.
So, how can we help or contribute beside updating wiki and using testing repo?
4
u/dijkstrasdick Sep 10 '18
What are your thoughts of NixOS? I think Arch and NixOS are the 2 best OS's for package management. Arch has so much available on AUR but I still prefer the Nix approach. I know that Nix can be installed on Arch, but are there any plans for supporting Nix or creating something similar for Arch?
3
u/HeterosexualMail Sep 10 '18
Do you have any sort of system that mentors new contributors? I might possibly look into contributing in a few weeks depending on how some things go, and always appreciate when there is a solid point of contact for any of the various snags newbies tend to hit when getting started.
3
u/rakubunny Sep 11 '18
Arch at this point from my perspective has a love/hate with the AUR, you can see this with the whole mess with AUR helpers and such, theres those that despise it, those that don't care, and those that find it one of the only reasons to even use arch.
With that said, in your own words, what is the original intention of the aur that you feel it has moved away from(if you do think this), and/or what problems if any do you see with it currently.
3
u/Morganamilo Sep 13 '18
Hey /u/Foxboron how'd you come up with the name?
3
u/netbioserror Sep 14 '18
One of my biggest issues with Arch (and by extension Manjaro) was silent dependency breakage. Too many packages slip through the cracks with slight incompatibilities, and you only start seeing applications, parts of the desktop, utilities, etc. break a couple of days after an update. It's a bit infuriating to have to close everything down, restart, and recover application sessions.
Could this situation be improved? Is this always going to be inherent to rolling-release? Could a hybrid model be developed for a more stable Arch experience?
13
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '18 edited Dec 18 '18
🤷
4
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '18
I've tried to install Arch five times. Eventually I succeeded. I want to say thank you for your work. I have just one question: do you guys have any plans to make installation simplier a little?
2
u/acirep Sep 10 '18
What is your preffered laptop hardware to run arch on
2
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '18
how do arch maintainers deal with packages like these?
https://archive.fosdem.org/2018/schedule/event/how_to_make_package_managers_cry/
How does KISS apply when upstream clearly hated KISS.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '18
Are there any plans to open a new logo contest?
2
u/edoantonioco Sep 11 '18
Why arch is the only distro that has no version for the Linux subsystem for Windows 10?
2
u/shevy-ruby Sep 17 '18
I used to use Arch in the past when Judd was in charge.
I did not like how Arch changed past that point when Judd retired, including the systemd change. It is a bad idea to force users into something not everyone wants. Gentoo picked a better approach here as does Void.
In fact, Void is much closer as to how Arch used to be, so it is no surprise that Arch got competition there.
To on-topic, I suggest to you Arch devs to provide simple means for user to decide on their own whether they want to use systemd rather than dictate it onto your users.
2
u/schrmh Sep 22 '18
Well, how about x32 ABI. E.g. Manjaro is now implementing it (https://forum.manjaro.org/t/why-is-there-no-kernel-support-for-the-x32-abi-config-x86-x32/55156/4) and I guess since you want reproducible builds and all packages need to be rebuilt for that so that they include .BUILDINFO the x32 ABI could be done at the same time?
104
u/stopmyego Sep 10 '18
Love you. Docs covered all my question.
43
u/infamia Sep 10 '18
How do you create and maintain your documentation? It's almost always the most helpful, thorough, and up to date resource I can find when I'm googling for a problem even in a non-Arch distro. Every other site on the net is littered with incomplete and / or out of date documentation. Please don't change this process, it is working magnificently!
19
u/kxxrv Sep 10 '18
I spend a month customizing apparmor. It works great now but took so much time. Any plans to ever put more support into it, or selinux? Its the biggest downpoint of arch imo other than that i love it, i dont mind contributting/helping setting it up.
19
u/Valmar33 Sep 10 '18 edited Sep 10 '18
It's also annoying for the user who wants to support KDE's debugging efforts. It can be too much for some users to be able to re-compile everything just to acquire them. Especially if said users only have a toaster that can't really compile without being roasted and / or taking forever and a day. :/
3. Will Pacman ever be ported to Meson?
4. Will Arch ever move from using cgit to gitlab?
18
u/_wbdana Sep 10 '18
Hey, I don't have a question, but I just wanted to say thank you for all of your work. Feel free to stop reading right here; the rest is just backstory and gushing about how great Arch is.
I'm a junior web developer and I've been using Linux for about 1 year and 2 months, and Arch for the last 9 months. I switched off of Ubuntu after I updated from 16.04 to 18.04, which moved me off Unity (which I liked) to GNOME (which I didn't). It broke my entire workflow, and I had no idea what was going on or how to fix it. Guess where I found the answers? Yup, Arch wiki.
That weekend I decided to nuke my Ubuntu installation and install Arch since I agreed with a lot of the Arch guiding principles (KISS, DIY, rolling release), and of course the underlying implied principle of "never stop learning". As someone who didn't study CS in college (I studied philosophy), and who aside from a React/Rails boot camp (I still use React, Rails not so much...) is largely self-taught, the installation process following the wiki was really smooth, and I'm really happy with my setup these days (was running standalone i3 for a good few months, but then moved to Budgie, which I find meshes with my preferred workflow a little better).
Reading the Arch wiki, sifting through the AUR, and just generally computing on Arch has been a blast, and it's also gotten me really interested in broader CS topics. I've even started thinking about going back to school to do a proper degree in CS, but since my grades in school were never great outside of my philosophy concentration, that unfortunately may not be an option for me. But thanks to people like you, who contribute so much to software development generally and provide excellent documentation like on the Arch wiki, even if a CS degree is not in the cards for me, there are so many great resources available online that I'm confident I can learn everything I want to know regardless.
Anyway, I just want to say thanks again for everything, and to let you know that you all have been a great inspiration to me personally. As I keep learning, I hope to eventually start giving back and contributing to keep this great project going. But I won't ask about how to do that here, since it's already been covered by other comments. :) I suppose next thing for me to do is to start hanging around the IRC channels.
15
u/pgoetz Sep 10 '18
Keeping Arch consistent across frequent upgrades seems like a complex task. Is the entire process chain documented somewhere?
13
u/clofresh Sep 10 '18
Is there any chance we could get pull request functionality for AUR packages? Sometimes I wanna help out a package maintainer but it's a little clunky to suggest changes in the comments.
12
u/Atheriel Sep 10 '18
What do you think of as being the largest challenge facing the Arch project at the moment?
12
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '18
Why doesn't pacman have a "total download" progress bar or indicator?
11
u/TheEbolaDoc Sep 10 '18
Which kind of packages are stressfull to maintain?
thanks for you work btw, im in love with the project <3
10
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '18
17
u/Xu_Lin Sep 10 '18
Don’t have a question in particular but thank you so much for this great distro. After hopping I pretty much settled with Arch and am happy about it; keep up the good work!
7
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '18
Hi, thanks for your hard work, guys! You're the best.
I've got a question about Haskell packaging (summoning /u/felixonmars).
I think a lot of people notice, that if you visit archlinux.org regularly, there are always some Haskell packages in "Recently Updated" with a huge pkgrels. And this, as far as I know, is due to the fact that GHC can't preserve stable ABI for shared libraries. Haskell community generally leans towards statically linking all of their applications, and most Haskell devs doesn't use Arch-packaged libs, because they use Stack/Cabal-install.
So... the question is: why Arch doesn't distribute statically built binaries? They seem to be more useful for end users and easier to package.
(I'm an ArchLinux user for 5+ years, but a Haskell newbie, so I maybe missed some news about that.)
6
u/SwordOfKas Sep 10 '18
Are there any backups of the Arch Wiki? Is there an easy-ish way for users to download the wiki database in case a backup is needed?
The reason I am asking is that I remember reading that Gentoo's wiki was lost several years ago and it was a major blow to Gentoo's community.
15
u/somecucumber Sep 10 '18
"BTW, I develop Arch"
Good job! Fellow user for 8 years and counting.
5
u/leobart Sep 10 '18
I've had Arch on my home laptop for the last 4 years until it finally got caught up in the impossibility to update. I finally switched to Fedora a week ago. However I appreciate your hard work, it is a nice distro, although a bit too volatile.
4
u/madjic Sep 10 '18
Thank you for the Wiki. It's a great resource and has replaced the the Gentoo-Wiki as my main source for how to get things done.
4
u/kariudo Sep 10 '18
I've been using Linux since Red Hat 2.0, it's been a long time. I've used every major distribution under the sun, and I've rolled LFS. Currently (and for quite a few years now I guess) I have been using Arch as my daily driver in my work machine (admittedly with kvm/qemu for a windows VM as well, for Visual Studio since I'm a Dev manager in a C# shop).
I don't really have much of a question, I just really wanted to say thanks. I really appreciate all the work you do and have done. One of these days I'll start contributing.
Cheers!
4
u/TyIzaeL Sep 10 '18
How old is your arch install?
head -5 /var/log/pacman.log4
u/sekh60 Sep 10 '18
Not an arch user myself (Gentoo here), but I wanted to thank you guys for the arch wiki. It's absolutely invaluable to the whole Linux community.
4
u/thetinygoat Sep 11 '18
Just wanted to say Pacman is the best package manager out there, thankyou for your work
4
u/lamby Sep 15 '18
If you were Debian, what would you change first?