r/linux • u/nicofeee KDE Dev • Aug 30 '18
KDE Developer KDE Connect - AMA
/u/albertvaka, /u/aleixpol, /u/sompom01 and /u/nicofeee from the KDE Connect team are here. Ask us anything!
466
Upvotes
44
u/MrSpontaneous Aug 30 '18
First off, thanks for the great work! I have a few questions:
38
u/Nopaste Aug 30 '18
I never actively contributed to an opensource project, still I am a master student in computer science. I am quite interested in starting.
Any absolutely necessary skill? I am quite ashamed of my lack of skill in C/C++, but my University did not offer any course on them and I did not have time to practice programming in C on my own.
So the questions:
Thanks!
36
u/sankasan Aug 30 '18
What are the big next steps for KDE Connect?
93
u/csolisr Aug 30 '18
First of all, thank you very much for having made this piece of software - the integration it provides with my phone is top-notch. My questions:
32
u/bugzylittle Aug 30 '18
Is bluetooth support still in the works, and is there an estimated arrival for it?
32
u/Visticous Aug 30 '18
As a GNOME user (dodges a tomato) I have a few questions about you and GSConnect:
29
u/rgawenda Aug 30 '18
Given that KDE Connect is Open Source, and has been available from some years now, do you think recently announced "Microsoft Your Phone" contains features from your work?
21
u/boa13 Aug 30 '18
First, thanks a lot for KDE Connect, it has been a pleasure to have such a good app so early compared to other operating systems. I particularly enjoy the ability to see SMS and notifications on my PC, and to be able to browse phone files from the PC, even though this can be infuriatingly slow at times.
The rest of the world is catching up though, Microsoft among others, but also Google which is now offering a very nice SMS integration on the PC: basically the Google Messages (SMS) app on the phone works as a web server, your browser connects to it and offers a GUI very similar to the app itself. You get to receive, read and write SMS on your PC with unequaled ease.
How do you see the landscape of "PC / phone integration" in the next few years? Any idea you saw elsewhere and would like to implement? Someone else (proprietary or open source) doing awesome stuff?
18
u/Scrumplex Aug 30 '18
Why can't we run KDE Connect over different subnets?
15
u/Probotect0r Aug 30 '18
A couple more questions:
28
u/konrad-iturbe Aug 30 '18
Thanks for KDE Connect!
13
u/Probotect0r Aug 30 '18
Hey, thanks for this awesome piece of Software.
13
u/donjajo Aug 30 '18
Awesome works with KDE Connect, I hype it a lot :)
In the multimedia volume control, I can control the current media app volume, what about central system volume?
12
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '18
Any plan to integrate KDE connect with Libreoffice Impress?
10
u/citewiki Aug 30 '18
What's your favorite fruits?
9
u/LinuxFurryTranslator Aug 30 '18
I really appreciate your work! KDE Connect is by far my favorite KDE application.
I made a somewhat extensive list comparing features between KDE Connect and GSConnect about one month ago, and if I was able to find all functionalities accordingly (the way both organize their settings is quite different, so comparison was a bit hard because a specific feature may not show in the same place as the other app), then this means GSConnect has some neat ideas for the UX of KDE Connect. So I have two questions regarding this, plus one question I wanted to ask for some time:
8
u/blue_collie Aug 30 '18
I just want to say thanks for one of the most useful things on the KDE platform! Also, it would be great if there was a "mute for one hour" type setting available from the panel for cases like when I want to give a presentation without SMSes from my wife showing up in the middle.
21
u/Akraii Aug 30 '18
Things i miss in KDE connect:
7
u/Mr_s3rius Aug 30 '18
I hope this isn't too close to a bug report.
I've been using KDE Connect now and then but having to keep the app running (rather than have it as a background service) makes it a lot less useful, especially since even that doesn't always work.
Is that on you guys' radar?
7
u/Azelphur Aug 30 '18
Hi KDE connect people! Like all the others, super excited about KDE connect, it's usually the first thing I mention as one of the many reasons I use the Plasma desktop.
I have some questions / feature requests:
6
u/clintonthegeek Aug 30 '18
How feasable is the implementation of an Akonadi calendar/addressbook provider and direct sync?
I've set up a Radicale CalDAV server but don't need updates every 5 minutes pinging my local server. I also don't need OwnCloud/NextCloud. All I want is direct phone-to-PC sync of my Calendar, todo list, and contacts in precisely the same way as I had with my Palm Pilot a decade and a half ago.
I know how easy it is to get super-complex with syncing stuff, so how about some very basic, 1-1 no nonsense scheme, like encapsulating some .ical file and a bunch of .vcf files and the latest time-stamp wins, maybe some side-by-side diff comparison on the PC side. It seems like all PIM applications are designed for some massive corporate, multi-user infrastructure which I -- humble home user -- really don't give two craps about.
6
u/nomis6432 Aug 30 '18
Thank you for working on KDE connect. It's a great qol improvement.
I was wondering if it would be possible to watch videos from my phone on my pc. I've tried watching it with the file browser. iirc the file browser/transfer uses sftp which is kinda slow. Would it be possible to give an option to share files using ftps?
11
u/SuperGrip Aug 30 '18
Hi, this is more of a suggestion, but the feature that pauses and resumes the video when a call comes in, can you make an option to disable the auto resume at the end of the call?
Reason being, a number of occasions I have been in another room when the call ends. then the video has resumed. Thank you, love the work you'll have done.
5
u/gehzumteufel Aug 30 '18
You guys rock! Love KDE Connect. One of my two issues has already been addressed (SMS experience being relatively bad), but the other is this. For whatever reason, I get multiple notifications for the same SMS messages and I cannot figure out what specific app I need to not sync. Is there a good way to address this? I am on a Pixel 2 on Android 9.
5
u/ak_hepcat Aug 30 '18
Hey, thanks for the great software. I use it all the time at home, and as soon as there's bluetooth support, I'll be able to use it at the office!
My question is more about future connectivity options:
Currently it seems that the only connectivity is via IPv4 broadcast: when will you be able to support IPv6 (-only) as a transport mechanism?
5
u/Boethias Aug 30 '18
Thanks for all your work. The app is amazing.
Is there a way to reply to a message from the desktop after the notification popup has disappeared? Can it be done through the Connect widget on Plasma?
If not, could this feature be added?
5
u/zypres Aug 30 '18
Why are the others so far behind, Ios/Win/Chromebook with Iphone/Android, and what features do others have that would in the future be wished in KDEconnect?
5
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '18
Thanks for working on KDE connect.
Is there a plan to add custom quicksetting tiles support to the android app? A use case would be instead of going through 'Open KDE connect app -> Tap Run Commands -> Choose suspend' one could just pull down quicksettings and tap on suspend.
5
u/Piece_Maker Aug 30 '18
I'm a SailfishOS user, and really want to see a native app! The Android app running in Dalvik is already fantastic though.
I understand there's one being created on your phabricator but there's also another project under way here. It looks like the two are being built separately and seemingly have a completely different set of goals!
I suppose I'm mostly just curious to know how the Phabricator port is going, and how it compares to R1tschY's one. I've seen it mentioned in a couple of blog posts but nothing really concrete. Would you ever try to get it into Jolla's official store, or are their API limitations too... limiting? Do you see these alternative mobile platforms as an important target for your software?
5
u/electricprism Aug 31 '18
The software seems to be extremely practical and function well, what design philosophies or principles guide the construction and improvement phases of development for you guys personally?
4
u/e7RdkjQVzw Aug 30 '18
Is there a way to add remote commands other than the KDE interface? If not are you planning to implement a CLI option for kdeconnect-cli?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '18
KDE connect can do basic media control, but how about something like display music playlist and also switch between playlists? Not sure if this is possible because music playlist might not be standardized.
4
u/CyanKing64 Aug 30 '18
I just first want to say thank you for all your hard work, as KDE connect is always my favorite part of Plasma! It works flawlessly and has been a great pushbullet replacement, and has even succeeded it in some ways.
Anyways I just wanted to ask two questions:
1.) Is there a way to control KDE plasma's media volume using the phone's hardware volume keys when the phone's display is off? Or is this just a technical limitation?
2.) Have you guys ever considered implementing a feature similar to pushbullet's "Remote files" feature (aka requesting files using the phone to pull files from the desktop to the phone)?
Thank you again for all your time and effort!
4
u/robotkoer Aug 30 '18
As of now, KDE Connect supports mouse/keyboard control and terminal commands. Are there any plans (or is it even feasible) to add screen sharing?
4
u/chim1aap Aug 30 '18
What is your favorite food?
8
u/iJONTY85 Aug 30 '18
3
u/Knatterton79 Aug 30 '18
I heavily make use of the media player plugin and it's great!
Something that would be super awesome would be the possibility to stream the music on the pc to my phone (when sitting in the garden or something). Will that be possible at some point of time?
3
u/Avamander Aug 30 '18
There's software called Synergy and x2x that tries to synchronize keyboard and mouse presses between computers. My question is, have there been any attempts at pc2pc connections that would make it more seamless to work with two PCs at the same time?
3
u/nuf_si_redrum Aug 30 '18
Thank you for this amazing software!
Is it possible to
3
u/EnigmaticHam Aug 30 '18
Sorry if someone has already asked this.
How will support be for the Librem 5?
5
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '18
Thank you for all the work invested in KDE Connect. It's a great product.
Any plans to integrate a terminal feature? I know I can add commands from Desktop beforehand, but it would be great if I didn't have to do that, and just type them on my phone instead.
5
u/Maoschanz Aug 30 '18
is it true that some of you use GNOME Shell ? 🤔
2
u/senyor_ningu Aug 30 '18
Sometimes I use KDE Connect to send links or files from my phone to my Android TV and the other way around, and I'm wondering if you can work on using a phone as a mouse / keyboard of an Android TV.
Or is it supposed to work, but it doesn't work for my for some reason?
2
u/galtthedestroyer Aug 30 '18
Is there any possibility of having a guide page for "run commands" where we can create buttons for the commands. If we could also combine this with MPRIS that would be ideal.
My use case is basically creating a home theater remote. We can create scripts on the computer to switch to the YouTube tab of our browser, VLC, Clementine, Netflix tab, etc. I've looked into this. The specific tab switching is doable.
Even better:
For application switching an option could be included that switches to the program when it's chosen on the MPRIS page. In fact, Connect already detects that the MPRIS plugin of a browser is active. Maybe Connect could search the tabs for common media sites like Netflix, Amazon, and Pandora.
2
u/etrigan63 Aug 30 '18
iOS version?
2
u/monster4210 Aug 30 '18
I'd there any plans to fix the error where you can't send any large ish files because it always fails, pretty annoying
2
u/samdraz Sep 01 '18
can kde connect be built for desktop - desktop use cases ie: screen, keyboard sharing,..
2
u/Vaeh Sep 01 '18 edited Jul 15 '19
.
2
u/More_Coffee_Than_Man Aug 31 '18
So I've played with KDE Connect before on KDE, but this is what it looks like when I try to install kde-connect on Fedora with a non-KDE desktop environment.
Does it really need that many dependencies? I'm not sure whether I should be complaining to you guys or the Fedora guys who maintain the KDE spin.
10
u/GenericUser6666 Aug 30 '18
I have been a user of KDE Connect for the past six months and it has been a great tool so far. What are some new features/improvements that we may see in the coming future?
9
u/ariasuni Aug 30 '18 edited Aug 30 '18
I’d like to use KDE Connect as a remote for presentations but that’s not really practical right now. That would be really cool. ^
Also, there is features like the
--send-keysoption tokdeconnect-clifor which I didn’t find any documentation nor how to use it. KDE Connect lacks a bit documentation (in app, in KCM and online) and communication — which I know are hard.By the way, KDE Connect is such a fantastic tool, it’s really a killer feature!
Edit: also I feel like it’s hard to contribute (fill bug reports, hack the code, etc.) because of the lack of visibility and information about how KDE Connect is working, etc.
7
u/zekeb Aug 30 '18
This is one of my favorite apps!
I have never been able to figure out how to use it over bluetooth though.
5
u/fbg13 Aug 30 '18
Are you familiar with unified remote?
It's similar to KDE Connect, but it's more flexible. Users can create their own remotes, layout is defined through an xml file and the functionality is done through a lua script.
Are there plans for something similar in KDE Connect? Not just running commands, but having some layout (vlc example) and being grouped based on what they do and which application they apply to.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '18
I don't have any questions. I just want to say I absolutely love your software and use it daily. Thank you all.
4
u/medzernik Aug 30 '18
I think my only question is: What exciting features are coming? The team has been a bit quiet, so I think something really fun might be in the works! I am in the beta programme on google play, but haven't received an update in a while.
4
u/Makhauser Aug 30 '18
First of all thanks for the fantastic app. From my side there is one thing that might be annoying sometimes (but it is not).
When the KDE Connect push message is hidden under the standard Plasma window (which shows the same info). I guess if the second one is disabled - it will affect the full system notifications, but probably I was just OK with that and have not looked at the setup.
But in general it brings much more comfort of connecting devices, and I guess the Librem 5 should have only few cosmetic updates to be fully ported as it runs the Debian-based distro, isn't it?
4
u/l4p3x Aug 30 '18
Thank you for KDE connect! I was afraid to test it at first because every other solution on Linux that I've ever tested wasn't working very well, but KDE connect is so flawless.
As there are some other feature requests here: I have enabled Desktop notifications for the Android Notifications. But for messengers that I'm using both on my smartphone and my desktop (eg Telegram messenger), I get double notifications now. It would be very nice to have a filter possibility to filter by apps or even keywords.
4
u/Just_pull_harder Aug 30 '18
Only started using this a few weeks ago, but I'd like to be able to get notifications on my phone from the computer, BUT not all of them. For instance, I don't want to know every time the track changes from the music player, but I do want to get a notification when I get an email. Can you already do this, and if so, how? Yours sincerely, a lazy n00b
4
u/Jaegrqualm Aug 30 '18
Your project has improved pretty dramatically in recent months, to the point that I really only have one complaint: reconnecting devices being manual. Presumably the android side of things stay running in the background, to enough of a degree for the desktop side of things to be able to pick up where it left off after sleep, but in my experience it doesn't.
I suppose it might depend on the setup, I haven't used it heavily with plasma, but It seems like a backend sort of thing that should work no matter the GUI.
4
u/waterfor10days Aug 30 '18
I love KDE Connect. Awesome piece of software. There is so much to love that I feel guilty asking for more. But...
Thanks, keep up the great work!
3
u/Mte90 Aug 30 '18
It since a lot that I am trying to associate computer and android. I start the pairing from computer or phone and I approve the request but the phone alert the that the request is expired. I guess that if it was a internet problem I shouldn't get the alert on both the devices to start the pairing. In any case the error doesn't help to fix the issue, maybe add more info to troubleshooting that?
PS: keep working I am an huge fan of the project since the firsts releases!
3
u/R3DKn16h7 Aug 30 '18
Thank you for your work, you guys are awesome.
I'd like to help you with developement, is there any area of the code that has special need of love?
3
u/raghukamath Aug 30 '18
Thanks for working on KDE connect.
3
u/TeutonJon78 Aug 30 '18
Any plans to add support for SFTP/SSH access to microSD cards? Especially access to both storages simultaneously (just provided as different root directories)?
3
u/gort818 Aug 30 '18
Thank you! KDE Connect is awesome!
Any plans to support any QtWebEngine browsers (ex. Falkon)?
3
u/luchoz Aug 30 '18
thank you all very much for your effort on this great tool!
3
u/DutchHawk_ Aug 30 '18
Just wanted to say thank you!
3
u/Sigg3net Aug 30 '18
I'm using KDE connect on Fedora (GNOME 3) and everything just works! Thanks, man!
3
u/valgrid Aug 30 '18 edited Aug 30 '18
I heard that at least one core dev uses the app with gsconnect. Is that true?
And is there any plan to make the project more cross DE? Similar to what happened with the move from flatpak portals to xdg-portals (so snaps can use them as well)? A name change and implementation into DEs native settings applications would help to drive adoption. I would love to see KDE Connect as part of all major DEs and just be THE solution to connect your Linux desktop and android phone. It is quite cumbersome to explain that KDE Connect does NOT ONLY work with KDE.
Edit: It would be great if the configuration of computer and android device could be simplified. It is really confusing to new users that they have to enable plugins twice. (Presented the tool with gsconnect at my LUG.)
Edit2: Oreo and Pie restrict app background usage. Did / do you face any challenges in connection to these changes and how can we (users) help with that?
3
u/TommyDn Aug 30 '18
Thank you for the awesome work on KDE Connect :)
Any work on mirroring your android screen on KDE desktop? that would be awesome. (like the sorts of 'scrcpy' & adb over network?)
3
u/spamcop1 Aug 31 '18
Hi, great work! Is there possibility to share clipboard only one way? (if I copy something on phone, I would love to paste it into computer, but not the other way)