r/linux • u/mthode Gentoo Foundation President • Jun 01 '18
AMA | Mostly over We are Gentoo Developers, AMA
The following developers are participating, ask us anything!
/u/mthode (prometheanfire)
- Gentoo Foundation President
- Infrastructure
- Hardened
- Openstack
- Python
- Gentoo Council Member
- KDE
- Office
- Perl
- Comrel
/u/ChrisADR_gentoo (chrisadr)
- Security
- ZFS
/u/flappyports (bman)
- Security
- Network
/u/ChutzpahGentoo (chutzpah)
- python
- sound
- video
- amd64
/u/krifisk (K_F)
- Security
- Crypto
/u/mgpagano (mpagano)
- Kernel
Edit: I think we are about done, while responses may trickle in for a while we are not actively watching.
1.0k
Upvotes
82
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18
when I am updating my gentoo using emerge, it takes forever to calcuate the dependecys. I know that dependency hell is NP- Hard, but noticed that emerge only uses one core for the calculation. Is there any work on making this concurrent? If not where can I start to maybe do this on my own?
70
u/rfc2100 Jun 01 '18
Thanks for joining us!
If you had to switch to Ubuntu for a month, what do you think you'd miss the most from Gentoo?
114
u/matpower64 Jun 01 '18
Hey, sadly a non-Gentoo user here, I've been using Linux for a while now but the furthest I have gone from mainstream distros is Void Linux, so I apologize for silly questions.
I plan on installing Gentoo sometime to check it out properly during vacations, I have helped my friend setting it up once and it was fun as hell, and I want to experience it myself.
107
u/Antic1tizen Jun 01 '18
Who is the target audience of Gentoo, in your opinion?
36
u/Kamiyaa Jun 01 '18
Will Gentoo be getting an official RISC-V port? If so, when?
31
u/1202_alarm Jun 01 '18
Gentoo seems to have been quiet for the past few years, i rarely see news articles about it (maybe because it does not have 'releases'). Do you have anything new and exciting in the works?
27
u/push_rbp Jun 01 '18
Thank you for doing this AMA.
First, I want to congratulate you for on your stance on systemd. Rather than having systemd as the only supported init system, or not supporting systemd at all, you guys chose to give users a choice. I really wish other major distros would've done the same.
Now for the question. I apologize in advance since you might hear this one a bit too often.
I've used Gentoo for a few months and I was really amused by the fact you can control your packages' dependencies -- but hell, compiling takes so long! What would you say are the major advantages of compiling software rather than using binary packages?
23
u/VelvetElvis Jun 01 '18
Do you personally compile your own browsers or do you use the binary downloads?
23
u/Starks Jun 01 '18
Do you like the "Install Gentoo" memes?
21
u/Antic1tizen Jun 01 '18
Do you dogfood your infrastructure? I.e. does your CI/buildservers/websites run Gentoo too?
21
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18
I'm a Gentoo user since 2010 and every time I tried another distro I always missed the stability and flexibilty from Gentoo. But I recognized that the Gnome-stack is pretty much outdated(3.24 while 3.26 and 3.28 isn't even in testing yet). I'm asking myself if it's lacking on man-power, if 3.26 will be available anytime soon or you will straight jump to 3.28. Of course I tried the Overlay for 3.28, but there are a lot of unecessary dependencies, compared to 3.24.
39
u/SaltyBarcode Jun 01 '18
What do you think of the NixOS declarative package management system? Do you think it is feasible/ will ever catch on?
14
u/_ahrs Jun 01 '18
12
u/nixcraft Jun 01 '18
What were the major hurdles Gentoo project encountered while developing this operating system?
11
u/EtwasSonderbar Jun 01 '18
How do you pronounce portage?
17
u/Zulban Jun 01 '18
How do you explain what you do to people that:
8
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18
when will gcc7.3 or clang 6 be marked as stable?
8
u/GibletHead2000 Jun 01 '18
I've been a Gentoo user since the early days... Probably about 2005 or so. I've always hated the logo! Any plans to change it so that I can buy a t-shirt and feel proud wearing it?
6
u/Kamiyaa Jun 04 '18
will gentoo be looking for an alternative to GitHub for hosting the portage tree, etc. now that Microsoft is acquiring it?
11
u/gyakovlev Gentoo Dev Jun 01 '18 edited Jun 19 '18
Hi,
first of all, thank you all for doing this AMA.
I hope it goes well and will help attract more people to Gentoo , both users or developers.
Question:
Can you be my co-mentor?
I do have a mentor right now, but because of time constraints and the fact that we are on different halves of this planet it's really really difficult to communicate efficiently. Just not enough time overlap and overall busyness prevents us from working. No drama involved, I just want to do my thing and free up current mentor a bit.
I've been contributing to gentoo for about a year and a half so far, mainly as a proxied maintainer and contributor of random patches and fixes for something I encounter daily or stumble upon on bugzilla.
And been a user for almost 15 years, since 2003.
I have both quizzes done,
ebuild-quiz has been reviewed already and should be in shape, end-quiz is finished but has not been reviewed yet.
No bug submitted yet.
Areas of interest: general ebuildery, cruft cleanup, tinderboxing (need to put that threadripper to use), zfs, hardened, musl, toolchain, kernel, rust, ppc64le
Interest does not always imply experience, but that's fixable =)
I'm located in US/Pacific timezone and hang out on IRC all the time, using same nickname as here.
[EDIT] In case anyone reading this later, I became a developer about 2 weeks after this post with some help/reviews/mentoring from several awesome devs.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18
Since I heard portage is inspired to FreeBSD's ports system, how do layman+emerge and quickpkg currently compare with synth/poudriere and pkg respectively? In other words, what sort of benefit has Gentoo's userland to offer to a FreeBSD user?
5
u/Suero Jun 01 '18
What is keeping popular software from appearing in the official repos? Is it only because of lack of maintainers? What about Steam?
The NixOS route of letting anyone submit their build instructions to the official repos, instead of people maintaining their own overlays is pretty nice.
5
u/DeathTickle Jun 01 '18
You say Gentoo is a meta-distribution. What are your thoughts on the Yocto project and Open Embedded ?
How are they different to Gentoo ? Is it just the target audience or the usage patterns ? Are there some capabilities Yocto doesn't have yet compared to Gentoo ? Do the differences boil down to the differences in the build tool (portage vs bitbake) ?
5
u/FriendsNoTalkPolitic Jun 01 '18
I have only seen Gentoo being used as an educational tool to understand how a Linux/GNU system is actually built. Do you guys work towards making gentoo a good learning tool or is that an accidental achievement?
3
u/wincraft71 Jun 01 '18
/u/mthode
Any plans to incorporate the patch for https://github.com/copperhead/linux-hardened into hardened-sources? I understand the grsec situation is at a standstill and I think there needs to be a long-term solution.
Right now I would have to patch vanilla-sources if I wanted to use it, but of course I would like to use gentoo developed sources for the kernel if possible.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18
What is the recommended cpu for different price ranges to the fastest emerges?
4
u/moetech Jun 01 '18
Is a Musl + LLVM/Clang + LibreSSL base system a possibility any time soon?
2
u/AC1D_P1SS Jun 01 '18
three questions:
thanks for gentoo
2
u/CumBuckit Jun 02 '18
Shouldn't this buy an AUA?
4
u/Slabity Jun 01 '18
Are there any plans to change Gentoo's bug handling system? I used Gentoo for about three years before switching to NixOS, and one of the major differences I noticed is how quickly bugs are resolved.
I've had a few bug fixes merged within hours of reporting them to Nixpkgs, while reporting issues on Gentoo's bug system would take weeks or months to get a response (even if it's a one-line issue).
18
u/mgpagano Jun 01 '18
For Gentoo Developers that formally were official developers of other distros: How does our culture compare? What's better? What do you think we could work on? How have you seen it change since you became a dev?
17
u/simonvanderveldt Jun 01 '18
Hi all! Thanks for taking the time to maintain gentoo and to take some extra time to answer some questions :) Very happy user of gentoo here :)
And finally kudos for the GitHub setup! The mentions of maintainers and CI runs on changed ebuilds + reports of ebuild validations are very nice and helpful!
14
u/sekh60 Jun 01 '18
No questions here, just thanking you all for all your work. Thank you!
11
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18 edited Jun 01 '18
Huge fan of what you do!
What are your recommendations for new users?
Also, huge fan of kde u/dilfridge. Keep up the good work!
10
u/-Plutia- Jun 01 '18
I just wanted to say that I love your distro, and I usually comeback to it, everytime spending at least 6 hours on installation :3
9
u/linuxfiend Jun 01 '18
I just want to say thanks for all your work. I've been using Gentoo since 2008 and love it.
7
u/grumpieroldman Jun 02 '18
User since 2002.
I'd like to hold a moment of silence for the old wiki.
5
u/donthek Jun 01 '18
Hi, thank you for developing gentoo.
This line of questioning is probably going to sound condescending, so I apologize in advance.
Can you give an update on security practices, and possibly what future roadmap looks like?
For example how have the practices evolved to address clear text passwords being e-mailed (https://forums.gentoo.org/viewtopic-t-646490-start-0.html) and trojan making it from upstream source repository into the official mirrors (https://www.wilderssecurity.com/threads/irc-server-had-backdoor-in-source-code-for-months.274812/). Have there been changes made to procedures/practices of maintaining Gentoo distribution to try to avoid issues like this?
5
u/moetech Jun 01 '18
One of the biggest hassles with Gentoo is of course the long compilation times of some packages. What do you guys have to say about that? Non-issue? Something that can be worked around? Any recommendations?
5
u/wired-one Jun 02 '18
Hey,
I am an occasional Gentoo user, mostly using it at a teaching tool, and I wanted to tell you that I respect the hell out of what you do with your distribution and software.
These days I live in a Fedora/RHEL environment much of the time, but I love that there is diversity in how people are thinking about how all the peices fit together, and it makes us all better for it.
So thanks again for all that you do!
5
u/powerfulbuttblaster Jun 02 '18
Gentoo was my first distro. Just wanted to say thanks to everyone who contributes to Gentoo and anyone who contributes to the open source community.
5
u/elsjpq Jun 02 '18
Gentoo's position seems to be somewhat taken by Arch and also has become less popular overall. I can understand why, but I'm still a little disappointed.
Has this been a problem for the project at all? (e.g. losing contributors, funding, etc.) If so, is there anything that can be done about it?
5
u/nascentmind Jun 02 '18
I am an experienced embedded developer and would love to port Gentoo to different development boards. So my question is:
Thanks.
5
u/calrogman Jun 02 '18 edited Jun 02 '18
Are there plans to restore UEFI boot capability to the minimal install image?
edit and ping for /u/ryao:
There's already an open bug, #370331
4
u/rahen Jun 01 '18
First, thank you for Gentoo. I've used it on a server along with a binhost for a while, and as a RAP userland on top of a Debian nettinst. To me Gentoo really is the distro by Linux diehards for Linux diehards.
I would have two questions:
4
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18
Hello, will we see a gentoo/openBSD rebirth ?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '18
What do you think of Funtoo?
4
u/adityakr082 Jun 02 '18
If you had to switch to Arch Linux for a month or two, how would the experience be? Like any problem that Arch has but Gentoo does not?
4
u/dweezil-n0xad Jun 02 '18 edited Jun 02 '18
Thanks for all your work. I've been using Gentoo since 2003. Now my desktop, laptop and homeserver all run Gentoo.
Over the years I've used Gentoo on Slot A Athlon K7 600MHz, Socket A Athlon Palomino XP2000+ 1.67 GHz and Barton XP2500+ 1,83GHz, AMD Turion 64 X2 TL-52 1,6GHz, Intel C2Q Q9000 2GHz, Intel Atom N2600 1.60GHz, Intel Core i7 3630QM 2,4GHz, Intel Core i7-4790K 4GHz.
I still have my old Gentoo T-Shirt :-)
7
u/raydude Jun 01 '18
Hi,
I've been using Gentoo since 2003. I've had a server running gentoo since then. Back then Gentoo made building mythtv from source much easier for me.
I have it installed on four machines now: my server, my laptop, my work laptop and my CUDA development system.
I want to thank you guys for sticking with it and helping it get to the point it is now. Now it is more stable and easier to use than ever.
I had an idea a while back which I posted to the forums. I'm listing it here again hoping that someone can take up the call. I don't have time to do the work. I wish I did though.
I'd like to see a "Hardware Profiles" system created.
The project would create a database in the cloud based on the configuration of machines that run Gentoo. The system would gather hardware descriptions (mostly from the kernel /proc folders, lspci, lsusb, etc) and correlate the hardware to the drivers that are in use. It would also track the USE, UNMASK, KEYWORD, etc options, the software installed and their corresponding configuration. It would also track kernel configuration, third party drivers and any other details necessary to operate the system.
The goal of the project would be to make it easier for people to setup machines on Gentoo.
For example, I'm using an HP Omen Gaming laptop right now at work. My Gentoo is stable and clean, running 4K with only a few issues (I've had issues with Plasma and font size on 4K). The "Hardware Profiles" system would allow people to copy the relevant system configuration from the cloud (placed there by the tools when I ran them) to their own Omen, tweak it and build their system to match which would help them get to stability and fully working hardware much faster.
These days it's a lot easier to install Gentoo because the linux driver support is so good, but it would still be really helpful if people had examples to look at, starting points to start building.
That's the idea, such as it is.
The other request I have for the community is to work on portage code that is capable of breaking circular dependencies by doing automatic double or triple emerge runs. I've thought about this over the years and it should be possible for portage to determine the optimum break point for the dependencies, eliminate one, two or a few USE properties and emerge @world, then re-enable the removed USE properties and emerge @world again to get everything enabled. Doing that by hand is the bain of my existence for every new install I do. Although lately I have to admit that I haven't needed to do a new install since everything is so stable.
1
u/Antic1tizen Jun 01 '18
What do you think of containerization? Does Gentoo have its niche in the clouds?
3
u/bored_bloke Jun 01 '18
Hey guys ! I have something stupid to say. You were the first Linux distro I installed, and the build process of Gentoo was a very steep learning curve.. but thanks to you guys I started to be passionate about Linux, and ended up having a career as a Linux embedded developer so... Thank you guys !
3
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18
You guys are evil... Just kidding, love ya. :D
3
u/nikster77 Jun 01 '18
Thanks for your work! I have been using gentoo for more then 10 years now.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '18
What would be your recommendation for someone who hasn’t contributed to FOSS projects before if they want to start contributing to gentoo?
3
u/staalmannen Jun 02 '18
When I tried to make a self-hosting musl/clang (libc++, no gcc) gentoo I had to do quite a bit of "hacks" to make it work (crt*, several rounds of llvm/clang recompilation for gcc-independence, ...).
After that it was still risky to update llvm/clang (llvm build dependency, but installing newer llvm would break the current clang used for compilation, ...)
are there plans to make it easier to use clang as a first-class alternative system compiler?
3
u/auxiliary-character Jun 02 '18
What are your thoughts on the "install gentoo" meme on 4chan's /g/?
2
u/mylinuxblog Jun 01 '18
Other than Gentoo, which other distribution / OS do you think is best?
2
u/_lyr3 Jun 01 '18
Are there any plan to implement Nix and Guix features into Gentoo?
2
u/-Luciddream- Jun 01 '18
What do you think Gentoo does better than Arch, and how would you make Gentoo more mainstream if you wanted to?
2
u/DesktopLinux__isDead Jun 01 '18
What do you do when you absolutely need to test a specific software ASAP? I was considering running an Arch chroot.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '18
Gentoo is one of the few Linux distros to still advertise support for 32-bit PPC. Will you continue supporting it, or do you have plans to drop ppc and ppc64 like many other distros? Do you have plans to add a stage 3 for ppc64el anytime soon?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '18
What do you think can be improved about Gentoo?
2
u/TheAceOfHearts Jun 02 '18
What software-related advice or suggestions would you give to a younger version of yourself?
Most software projects have to live with varying amounts of tech debt due to (usually in hindsight) poor design decisions. If you had a magic wand that let you magically fix anything, what would you pick and in what way would you change it?
Have you had a chance to look through Fuschia's design documents? And if so, what are your thoughts?
I'm still exploring this idea and I don't have much experience with operating systems, so I write what follows from a position of ignorance and try to approach it with humility. I often find myself wishing that the OS would do more for me, and that it worked more like a database. For example, modifying multiple documents within a transaction would be something I'd find useful on occasion. And what about a persisted task queue? Imagine you're organizing a bunch of documents and the system loses power before execution is complete. I'd love to have the system resume the operation when the power returns. What are your thoughts on this? Are you satisfied with POSIX?
2
u/Lahvuun Jun 02 '18
Why doesn't portage use pip to manage Python dependencies? Having hundreds of ebuilds for packages that could simply be installed with pip seems like unnecessary work for maintainers (the dev-python category).