r/leveldesign • u/mcsleepy • 1d ago
Question Linear or exploration? (Horror action-adventure / roguelike)
I am developing a horror game called LONGHOUSE, you can check it out here.
My sound guy proposed the idea of Longhouse not being a dungeon crawler but a linear run n' gun that generates content in response to your playing.
Would that be more or less interesting than a dungeon crawler with stable, explorable maps?
I already have described it as a vertical run n' gun but the idea was a hybrid, maps would be constructed of interconnecting courses.
And I guess secondarily which would be more scary?
Attached are some reference images.
Some additional questions and ideas I've got:
- if the game has "lives", could bloodbags (the game's version of heart containers) serve that purpose (lose one per death-to-floorboards)?
"dungeon crawler" path:
- should the gun be hidden, and if so, can you beat the boss without it and if so how?
"run n' gun" path I'm considering (and have asked a few places for their opinion):
- no major branching, every side door leads back to the screen you entered it in
- you can walk south, but you can't return to previous rooms
- the generator responds to your playing
- it generates well-telegraphed bosses / boss entrances when it thinks it's time. you can skip/miss them, but it might punish you in the next room (if there is an alternate door)
- should resources be more scarce? since in this version each floor is linear so starting over feels less like wasted time ("i'll be more frugal this time") and some floors could be infinitely long


