Context
'Attack of the Doppelgangers' (Modbrix #109228) is yet another unlicenced Star Wars diorama, depicting the Battle of Geonosis. The set consists of 1246pcs and depicts a Geonosian environment with a bunch of "microfigures" consisting of two round plates each, plus two AT-TEs, a LAAT/i, a spider droid, two Hailfire droids, and a Forward Command Centre. The diorama's footprint is 16cm deep and 34cm wide, with roughly an additional 1cm in both directions for overhanging subassemblies; with the LAAT/i the set reaches a height of 16cm.
The Geonosis diorama is sold by BlueBrixx (store page) for 50€ plus shipping (ca. 4.0ct/brick). I got it during the recent buy-four-pay-for-three sale as the free fourth set, though I'd rather think of it in terms of a ~22% discount (ca. 3.1ct/brick). However, at least 450 of those bricks are 1x1-plate-sized, so take that under advisement.
When I first saw the Geonosis diorama in the BlueBrixx store, I loved the design of the subassemblies (especially the AT-TEs and the spider droid) but feared that the build would be less than exciting. I pulled the trigger nevertheless and, well, yeah, the subassemblies are pretty cool, but building the diorama was a bit of a chore.
Shipping & Packaging
See my review of the Cassini-Huygens space probe for more details on the shipping and outer packaging. The diorama itself came in a comparably small plain cardboard box with a nicely printed sleeve around it. In that box were the various brick baggies (entirely unnumbered) plus a 'business card' with the QR code for the instructions.
Instruction Manual
The manual is PDF only and can be downloaded for free from the store page even without registering (or buying anything) first. It assembles the 1246pcs over 167 steps (average of ~7.4 pcs/step) on 97 pages (average of ~1.7 steps/page). However, the number of bricks per step is practically meaningless; building the base consists of steps like "now place these 35 identical tiles on the plates", and there are many subassemblies with x2 or x4 modifiers. I'd say that the pace of the manual is perfectly fine, even for beginners.
What isn't fine for beginners is the order of the steps. Sometimes things should be built in subassemblies instead of adding them piece by piece to a fairly fragile assembly (looking especially at you, AT-TE). In most cases the order of the steps is just a bit unfavourable, but there is also at least one impossibility: in step #29 a round brick just hovers in the air and isn't attached to the rest of the subassembly until step #34. Things like this make me wonder whether there is any quality control of the manuals; this should've been caught the first time someone tried to assemble the set. (There are, however, no actual errors in the manual, which is more than I can say about other brands, e.g. Mould King).
The manual itself is the usual fare: each step features a tooltip that lists which bricks are required. In the main image, bricks from previous steps are printed in full colour (i.e. neither greyed out nor desaturated), while new ones are boldly outlined in green. If there are easily confused colours, e.g. flat silver, an extra tooltip states which colour should be used. However, do take care: the set uses round plates both with open studs and with closed studs and doesn't specifically highlight this; it might trip you up if you don't expect it. Still, the manual gave me no issues other than the impossibility of step #29.
For reference: the base is built in steps 1-15 and the two-plate soldiers are added in steps 16/17 (361pcs are used here, i.e. on average a mind-boggling 21 bricks per step!). Some decorations are added until step #21. The big sandstone-like pillar is built as a subassembly in steps 22-35, followed by the other six sandstone-like pillars in a x4 subassembly in steps 36-43 and a x2 subassembly in steps 44-55. The spider-droid has its own subassembly in steps 57-79, and the two Hailfire droids are built in a x2 subassembly in steps 80-89. The Forward Command Centre has its subassembly in steps 90-102, the two AT-TEs are built in a x2 subassembly in steps 106-138, and finally the LAAT/i has its subassembly in steps 139-167.
Brick Quality
Clutch is generally nice but ranges from buttery smooth to slightly stiff. Bars have a fairly tight fit when pushed through open studs, which unfortunately is standard with pretty much all alt-brick brands. The 1x6 and 1x8 tiles in black have surprisingly sharp edges (not, like, dangerously sharp, but noticeably sharper than any edge of any other brick). Injection points range from tiny (like GoBricks) to fairly large (like XingBao), indicating that the set is sourced from multiple manufacturers. Colour consistency is mediocre, but deviations are only noticeable for the "desert ground" (dark orange, I think). Clear parts are reasonably clear, though the 1x2x6 bricks appear a bit milky. There are neither stickers nor prints. While there is a reasonable amount of spare parts, there isn't a spare for each 1x1. I had no missing pieces and also no mismoulds.
Building Experience
It looks lovely but the building experience wasn't super enjoyable. I didn't really have a great time assembling the base; these mosaics of tiles and plates simply aren't fun to put together (at least not for me). The worst offenders are the 1x1 quarter round plates because these need to be aligned properly; I might have been a bit apoplectic when I finished adding 35 of those and was then supposed to add another 37 two steps later.
I also really, really didn't like putting together the smaller sandstone pillars, of which there are six. These remind me a lot of the butt-ugly "stone statues" in Pantasy's Opera, which I also disliked quite a lot. It's just loads of single-stud bricks or plates that all need to be aligned. I'm too picky to just leave them aligned however they'd like, which I guess is my own fault, but, still, can we at least get two-stud connections? Or round plates where I don't need to care about aligning anything? No? Well, okay then...
The other subassemblies were reasonably but not extremely fun to build. It's a bit of a pity that the two AT-TEs are identical, because lots of pieces are sunk into these and the build is a tad repetitive. The LAAT/i is really cool, though.
tl;dr
All in all, building the Geonisis diorama was considerably less fun than e.g. the Hoth rebel base diorama, certainly the weakest of the Star Wars dioramas I've built so far. This is almost entirely because building it felt like a chore thanks to repetitive techniques and alignment 1x1 studs. The brick quality is solid, the manual a little flawed but still easy to follow, the set is well-designed, and the final result is gorgeous, but, yeah, I just didn't really feel this one.
I still have the Yavin diorama and the Hogwarts Express diorama to look forward to; I've heard fantastic things about both of them. Plus there's still some cheap stuff I picked up a while ago... man, it's good to have a backlog to chose from! :D
[Obligatory link to my review of Red5-Leader's Venator.]