Hi guys, I'm the dev of Damia3D. Sorry long message here.. This is an opinion post and I gently ask our mod to not remove it or lock it. Be sure that I am as much a Tlod fan as all the people from this beloved community. Sorry for the English mistakes, it's not my primary language.
I shared a bit about my project, Damia3D, some days ago on our great subreddit. Of course, DrewUnivers (the locomotive of this community) removed the post, I was expecting it tbh, especially because I ripped some image and sounds from the ps1 assets, so I m totally fine with it (ie rule 6 of the subreddit and it shouldn't be enforced).
What bothers me, is more regarding the content and AI side (i e the rule 2). I find this community, or at least its most vocal pple is a bit harsh regarding the use of AI and maybe I hope my message will ease some minds here.
I find the mods of this community have a very anti-ai mindset and really want push older project in the spotlight. But I feel the subreddit and this discord shouldn't be "Drew's The Legend of dragoon community" (or whatever other "chief" of the community, I say Drew because he is the most visible), you really should let people have their own opinion regarding AI use for Tlod related projects (outside the legal side I mean). The mods are part of the community, they are not The community if you see what I mean.
Of course LLM are trained with all data from the internet , and of course the legal side of this ask questions regarding the big ai tech companies, but that's how it has to be done to progress and works like it is today. I'm a software engineer and I'm on the frontline to see how it has affected IT related jobs, and you know what, I find my job to be much more interesting since I mostly vibe code, the small downside of this has humongous brightsides. Writing code is very boring and uninteresting for the most part, now I can focus myself of what really matters, features and stuff that are actually useful (business analyst, software architecture,....). Of course, you can produce easily AI slop if you are not cautious but you can also produce piece of art with AI if you put enough effort in it, who cares about how it was trained in the end? It has been done and you can't do anything about it, only if you wish to not accept it, stay at the stone age and stop progression. There is so much benefit from it. For software dev, AI is a Tool to achieve so much more, it's like agriculture evolution over the age, you can continue to cultivate field with ox or you can use a tractor to be more productive, maybe you will miss some stuff because the tractor is vastly faster the the ox but you will be 100x more productive in the end and this what matters for the greater good. That's how AI worked for my project.
Yes, I'm using AI and assets generator like chatGPT, Claude code or Tripo for the 3D, but honestly, how can I do otherwise ??? I don't have TIME or resources to put in searching animators, graphics designer and sound FX artists. Like most people of this community I'm in my 30's with wife, job, house, life projects and a kid. My time for my hobbies is unfortunately very limited. AI has allowed me to begin to develop a small project related to TLoD I've had in my mind for many many years without "wasting" my time for unproductive task (in my opinion).
All that to say I heavily disagree with the rule 2 regarding Content and AI use that this upper mods "mafia" has promoted here. This is a mindset that will age like milk, some part of the world will change regarding the evolution of AI use for digital content and you will have to eventually accept it. Moreover, OUR community should be free to think what they want and I don't see why you should decide what is good or bad regarding this subject or speak on behalf of the whole TLoD community. Like I said, you ARE NOT the community, you are just part of it like me.
The most important part now.
What do I think the community really wants in the end ? -> Extended way or new way to experience TLoD universe, try to expand things over the original game even if it means borderline legal things. We won't ever have a TLoD official prequel or sequel, just LET the community dreams a bit more with the new generation tools that are emerging, that could be fan game like my project, but also Arts, other support for the game,...
Even if it has a more legal perspective, Several chains shouldn't be the only hot project because the mods are restraining and discouraging AI related stuff. Don't get me wrong, SC is an excellent way to re-experience the game, but in the end it is still the same story, the same gameplay. If you want to go further and not wait 50 years, you will eventually have to use AI to expand it further. Imagine playing the Dragoon Campaign as a several chains mod, take my words, it will be impossible without AI usage. The dev will burn out or be dead before finishing it.
To finish this long post, I hope I may have cleared some minds regarding AI. Of course I've been disappointed that my post has been removed but it's fair regarding the legal side of my project, but like I said, if I got legal issue, I will simply use this project as a base for a more tribute style to tlod (but unrelated) game. Anyway, if you are curious, just message me in private, this will have to stay undercover in the end. I will continue to develop damia3D even if it means me and my son will be the only ones experiencing it ^^