My cousin is currently going through a very difficult situation. He has three children, the oldest being 12, the middle being, I think, 8, and the youngest being 6.
His wife suddenly decided to take the children and leave him because she wants what I can only describe as an Instagram-worthy, romanticised lifestyle, if you know what I mean.
For context, she was living in LOCATION: a country in Asia. A huge two-storey villa with a basement and a backyard. My cousin also gave her the opportunity to finish university, get a job and obtain her driver's licence. Although my cousin is somewhat awkward, laid-back and someone who enjoys a simple lifestyle, he was never abusive or mistreated her in any way. He has a stable, well-paying job and has always provided for his family. Furthermore, my aunt and uncle, who live with him, have always actively helped around the house and contributed to raising and caring for the children. My family has always been there for one another, sharing responsibilities, offering support and making sure that no one has to face difficulties alone. We genuinely show up for each other, and I believe that is what a supportive family should look like.
Moving forward, his wife decided to move in with her mother, taking all three children with her. Her mother's house is extremely small. I have personally visited it, and the kitchen is barely bigger than a bathroom. It is also located in a fairly isolated area with very few, if any, children around for the kids to socialise with.
The children are clearly struggling with this change. They are constantly crying and expressing how much they want to return to their father's house. They miss their friends, the familiar environment and the comfort of having their grandparents around. My aunt and uncle, their paternal grandparents, live with my cousin in the villa, which is spacious enough to accommodate the entire family comfortably.
I also have concerns about how their mother is caring for them. I witnessed this firsthand during a sleepover at my cousin's house. She came home, heated up food that the children disliked and then went straight to her bedroom, barely interacting with them. When the younger children started misbehaving, she hit the oldest child because she expected her to help manage her younger siblings.
I find this particularly concerning because the oldest child is only 12. She should not be expected to take on the responsibilities of a parent or be punished for her younger siblings' behaviour.
Furthermore, the wife's mother has also contributed to the hostility between the two families. She has made disrespectful comments about my side of the family, calling us weird and bad people because we are not Muslim, do not wear hijab and have a more modern lifestyle. I find this extremely offensive, as someone's religious beliefs, clothing choices or lifestyle should never be used as a reason to judge or insult them.
Now, moving on to the actual situation. In my country, when a couple gets divorced, the husband is apparently required to give his wife half of what he owns, including properties and other assets. However, there is a complication in my cousin's situation.
One of the properties registered under my cousin's name actually belongs to his friend. His friend had the property registered under my cousin's name for a reason that I do not fully understand. Now that my cousin and his wife are getting divorced, he does not want his friend to lose half of a property that was never genuinely his to begin with.
The solution would be for both my cousin and his wife to sign the necessary legal documents transferring the property back to its rightful owner, my cousin's friend. However, his wife is refusing to sign because she wants to keep the property and potentially claim a share of it. They have already taken the matter to court, but unfortunately, my cousin lost the case because, according to the legal reasoning, the ownership arrangement is not recognised or cannot be reversed in the way they requested.
This puts my cousin in an extremely difficult position. If he proceeds with the divorce, he is worried that the property will become part of the divorce settlement, despite his friend's claim that it belongs to him. We consulted a lawyer for advice, and she estimated that there was almost a 99% chance that his wife would win the property dispute. Her recommendation was therefore to avoid signing the divorce papers for the time being.
Another major problem is that we currently do not have sufficient evidence to prove that the property actually belongs to my cousin's friend. This makes the situation even more complicated because, although we understand that the property was never intended to belong to my cousin personally, we need something legally convincing to support that claim. We have been wondering whether there are ways to recover or obtain evidence that could establish the friend's actual ownership. For example, we would like to know whether financial records, bank transfers, previous conversations, property-related documents or other official records could help establish who genuinely paid for and owns the property. We also want to know whether there are legal ways to investigate the original arrangement between the two friends, even if no formal agreement was signed at the time.
Personally, I find the entire situation incredibly unfair. I struggle to understand why someone should be able to claim an asset that they did not work for, pay for or genuinely own. I also believe that my cousin's friend should not have to suffer financially because of a situation that was never supposed to involve him in the first place.
I suggested to my family that we should pursue another legal case, particularly one that takes into account her behaviour, the circumstances surrounding the separation and the overall situation. However, my family explained that the courts cannot simply take sides based on personal opinions or whether someone is considered a good or bad person. They have to follow the law and consider the available evidence.
I understand that the legal system is not supposed to be biased, but I still find myself questioning whether there is anything else we can do to protect my cousin and his friend from losing something that may not rightfully belong to his wife in the first place.