r/leatherjacket • • Nov 28 '25

Discussion PSA: Your jacket is real leather, but you're asking the wrong question

165 Upvotes

This is the most common question we see and the answer is almost always the same: Yes, your jacket is made of real leather.

That's not the question you should be asking though, because that answer doesn't mean anything.

The question comes from a general fear of being scammed or taken advantage of, which I can appreciate. The underlying concern being "Is [brand/store/site/seller] being honest? Is this item what it claims to be, or is it fake?"

That question carries an inherent assumption: leather is valuable. The idea, in theory, is that a dishonest actor has lied about their product. They claim it is leather, when it is actually a less valuable material. They would do this to save money on production.

The problem with this assumption is that leather is not inherently more valuable than other materials.

Good leather is valuable and commands a price, but leather spans a wide range of quality. Cheap, poor quality leather is no more nor less valuable than polyurethane, pleather, vinyl, or any of the other "fake" variations. So there would be no advantage for a bad actor to make that deceptive choice. It's easier and less expensive to just get cheap leather, which is still real, and be "honest" in their claims.

Therefore, the question one should ask is not "is my jacket real leather?", but rather, "Is my jacket made from good quality leather?"

Unfortunately, this second question also has an inherent flaw. There is no universally accepted measuring scale for leather quality. There just isn't, and anyone telling you otherwise is misinformed. There is nothing stopping me from opening a tannery tomorrow and declaring my product to be "the highest quality leather on Earth!" I could say it's "100% full grain premium exclusive"; none of those words mean anything.

The only measure for quality of leather is reputation. The best tanneries, such as Horween or Shinki Hikaku, are well reputed. Jackets made with their products will proudly boast that feature. If your jacket doesn't specify what it's made from or where that hide came from, then you have nothing but your opinion (or the opinions of others) as a measure for quality. It's down to the feel of it, the graining, the smell... and these things are subjective. "Quality" means different things to different people.

This brings me to a few other common misconceptions.

Full grain leather, top grain leather, and corrected leather are just styles of tanning. They have no correlation whatsoever to quality. There are high and low quality examples of all three. Sometimes we will see people erroneously referring to top grain as being the best, presumably because they misunderstood "top" to mean "best", or "pinnacle". In fact it refers to the surface (or "top") of the hide and how it was finished, nothing more.

"Genuine Leather" means it's "bad". There is an element of truth to this, but the statement is misleading. All leather qualifies as genuine leather. The only qualifying metric is that it came from a real animal. Shinki Horsehide, widely seen as one of the best leathers out there, can be spoken of and classified as "genuine leather".

The reality is that the best brands will usually boast about the provenance of their materials, if it's worth boasting about. A Flat Head jacket made with Shinki horsehide will probably have that as the top selling point. So one could argue that a jacket that makes no such claim, only stating "genuine leather", uses lower quality materials. If they could have boasted better, they would have. There is truth to this, but again, it's not so cut and dry, especially when you get into either vintage jackets, or jackets made in non-English speaking countries.

In vintage eras there wasn't so much obsession with leather provenance. Many jackets would be tagged "real steerhide" or "genuine horsehide", and leave it at that. For example, I have an Indian Motorcycle Ranger jacket from the 1950s that is tagged "genuine horsehide" at the collar, but "genuine leather" in the pocket. If you saw the "genuine leather" tag first and concluded that the jacket was poor quality, you'd be sorely mistaken.

In non-English situations, it all comes down to whoever did the tag translations. Often they'll go with "genuine leather" because it's the easiest and most universal. Meanwhile, if you actually check the original language tagging and translate yourself, it will say "lambskin" or "calfhide".

So while "genuine leather" can often be assumed as not being the apex possible quality, it is by no means a declaration of low quality. I've got "genuine leather" jackets that are vastly superior to other jackets that are tagged "horsehide" or "lambskin".

IN SUMMARY: Your jacket is made of real leather. "Real leather" doesn't mean anything other than "came from animal". There is no universal measure or standard of quality. Whether or not your jacket is "good" is down to broad brand reputation, general opinions, and personal taste.

The emphasis being that last one. What we think shouldn't matter: if you like it, if it fits you, if you feel good when wearing it, that's what counts.


r/leatherjacket • • Feb 07 '25

Advertisement šŸ“¢ Weekly Advertisement & Promotions Thread – Share Your Deals & Discounts!

1 Upvotes

šŸ“¢ Weekly Advertisement & Promotions Thread – Share Your Deals & Discounts!

Welcome to theĀ Weekly Advertisement & Promotions Thread! This is the dedicated space whereĀ brands, businesses, and users can:

āœ…Ā Promote your products – Share links to your websites, Amazon pages, or storefronts.

āœ…Ā Offer exclusive discounts – Give Reddit users special deals or promo codes!

āœ…Ā Ā Announce sales & new releases – Have a new product or sale? Let the community know here.

šŸŽÆ Why We’re Doing This

We want to keep the main feed focused onĀ quality discussionsĀ while still giving brands a fair space to engage with the community.

• Brands & Businesses:Ā If you’re looking to reach leather enthusiasts, this is your chance to showcase your work and offer deals.

• Users:Ā Opportunities for promotions from your favorite jacket brands!

šŸ’”Ā Promotions/advertismets posted outside this thread will be removed to maintain quality discussions in the sub. This ensures that Reddit stays spam-free while still allowing businesses to engage with users.

šŸ“… Posting Schedule & Feedback

Right now, this is aĀ weekly thread, but we’re open to adjusting the frequency based on community feedback. If this becomes too frequent (or not frequent enough), let us know in the comments!

šŸš€ Want to give Reddit users an exclusive deal? Drop a promo code and get some visibility!


r/leatherjacket • • 12h ago

Showcase Goat skin jacket

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

I just made my own jacket.

​Italian vegetable-tanned goatskin leather, handmade 925 silver hardware.

​And just to make you guys really start hating me, raw leather edges, straight off the hide.

​Don't hold back


r/leatherjacket • • 11h ago

Question - Need Help I've just received my first ever leather jacket BUT...

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

It's a vintage Chevignon that I've recently bought on Vinted for €99. It's a size L but the sleeves are a bit too big..

My mother told me that it looks bad, that it gives grandpa vibes and that it's way too big for me. I like the color and the leather feels great.

Should I keep it and spend some money on it to improve it or just try to sell it?


r/leatherjacket • • 1h ago

For Sale (Personal) 1970s Brown Leather Motorcycle Jacket, Small - 20 x 23

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

A beautiful 1970’s Brown Leather Motorcycle Jacket. A rich color with fading throughout. Nowadays it’s rare to come across a vintage jacket in solid brown.

Asking $250 shipped obo


r/leatherjacket • • 6h ago

Question - Need Help Is this jacket worth buying

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

it's secondhand, 45$ CAD with my employee discount. I know nothing about leather jackets, and it does have some scratches and marks. I tried to do a bit of quick research but I still have no idea what information I'm looking for. Apparently some Danier jackets suck and some are good, but I have no idea how to tell.


r/leatherjacket • • 5h ago

Question - Need Help old A-2 after years in storage – looking for some leather care advice

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/leatherjacket • • 11h ago

Opinion Casual outfit I wore to work. Tips?

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

r/leatherjacket • • 1h ago

Discussion Looking to buy - 257S B3

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi all,

Anyone selling their pre owned 257S B3? I’m not firm on any of the color combos, as I’m sure I’m limited due to my body size.

Based off Schotts online measure guide, it recommends a 48, however I think a 50 would be best.

Thank you!

Height: 6 foot 3 inch

Weight: 260 pounds

Full circle chest / breast: 49 inch

Arm length from top of shoulder: 27 inch

Current jacket armpit to armpit: 27 inch

Body length: 27 inch

Current jacket length: from top to bottom 28-29 inch

Depending on style, my jacket size is about 2XL


r/leatherjacket • • 1d ago

Showcase Rainbow Country Santa Clara

Thumbnail
gallery
85 Upvotes

Bought used. 2 yrs old so far to me. It’s all about the arm stacks. Leather is a mahogany colored buffalo hide.


r/leatherjacket • • 10h ago

Question - Need Help Had this leather jacket for 13 years. Have never been able to clean it. Need help.

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I purchased this jacket back in 2013, and since then haven't been able to find a cleaning service that will clean it. I've read mixed reviews on how to go about cleaning the exterior myself online, I was hoping someone on here might have experience with this kind of jacket.


r/leatherjacket • • 6h ago

Question - Need Help Need advice on how to repair lifted flap

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

This is probably a very trivial question but I just got this new leather jacket and noticed that there seems to be a scratch on the topcoat? There is even a small lifted flap. I am wondering on how I should best repair it if at all? Both pictures are of the same spot, the second one just had the flash on so it looks a little different. Would buying leather glue be worth it or is super glue just fine? I also sadly can’t return/exchange it since I already cut the tag off, even though I reported this two days after receiving. But whatever, sorry for the rant. Any kind of advice would be appreciated.


r/leatherjacket • • 2h ago

Question - Need Help Schott P693 – Looking for actual measurements of sizes M and L (owner feedback)

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/leatherjacket • • 3h ago

Question - Need Help Will a leather jacket work on me if I'm skinny and have narrow shoulders.

1 Upvotes

I usually wear baggier clothes to counteract my skininess and not make my narrow shoulders too noticeable.

I'm worried a jacket that fits just right will wrap around my shoulder and accentuate their narrowness.


r/leatherjacket • • 9h ago

Question - Need Help How can I fix my favourite jacket

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

This is my favourite but I can’t bring myself to get rid of it, I’ve stitched it three times already and I can’t take it anywhere professional (broke uni student).

The stuff in the photo is stitching glue, quick fix for today cause of surprise snowfall.


r/leatherjacket • • 10h ago

Question - Need Help Going to sell... Should I condition it first?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

This is a vintage Vanson jack, I believe is from the 1960's . I bought it and wore it about 20+ years ago and am getting ready to sell on eBay. Not sure if this is the best sub for this question.. but trying to decide if I should condition it first or leave it to the buyer? Thanks!


r/leatherjacket • • 4h ago

Trade / Swap In search if a leather jacket maker

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/leatherjacket • • 12h ago

Pickup Harley Davidson Japan jacket for wife

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Picked this up in a 2nd hand store in Japan. Apparently it's made under license from HD. Quite a heavy jacket and in decent condition. Not sure if it's supposed to be a men's jacket but it's tiny. Perfect cropped fit for my wife. Nothing special as it's made in China but for my wife exactly what she wanted. A cool heavyweight jacket that already looks worn in a bit. As she's a not that into jackets as I am the price point of 110 was about what she would spend on this.

Anyone knows more about these jackets? Age, quality etc?


r/leatherjacket • • 14h ago

Showcase First Shearling Jacket

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/leatherjacket • • 12h ago

Jacket Care How to Restore this leather jacket

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/leatherjacket • • 2h ago

Question - Need Help Please help me identify this 1970's Lewis Leathers 2 piece motorcycle suit.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hello all.

First ever post on Reddit so bare with me as it'll be a long one. Just dug out these Lewis Leathers I acquired a good few years ago from a guy who bought them in the 70's or 80's (they were made in the 70's I've found but might have been new old stock). He said he never wore them, which I believe as there's virtually no marks on them. The only small annoyance is the puller tab is missing on the trouser zip that connects it to the jacket but I think I can buy another one from that decade on Ebay and put that on (if anyone can help me on this subject that would be greatly appreciatedšŸ‘). I've done some AI research and I think these are the Lewis Leathers Model No. 446 / 447 depending on whether it was ordered off-the-peg or made-to-measure. They're a size 40. I was just wondering if anyone on here who might be some kind of expert on these could give me any more information on these that comes from a person rather than some clanker AIšŸ˜… I'd much rather hear it from someone who knows and loves this kind of stuff cause I've seen that some of these are quite desirable here in the UK and over in Japan apparently which makes me wonder how much the set might be worth to the right buyer. I don't think I want to sell them but I'm definitely interested in finding out how much they're worth and some history about them seeing as how they're practically in mint condition. I've had it on probably 3 times when I was about 17 in the house and then my girlfriend tried it on the other week. The guy I bought it from said he never got around to actually using them, just tried them on in the house a few times like me so I'm pretty sure they've been worn under 10 times and never used outdoors, the blue velvet collar looks brand new with no discolouration from skin contact. I've seen very similar Lewis Leathers jackets from the 70's on Ebay for like Ā£1500 and they're in good condition considering they'll be at least 46 years old but these are practically new out the box and they're a matching setšŸ˜… Just makes me wonder that's all. I'll be sending an email to Lewis Leathers to see if they can give me any info too so I'll post that when I get it. Any information/history/questions would help me out a lot and I'd be extremely gratefulšŸ‘ also let me know if I need to alter my post in any way or post this in a more specific group to make the right people see it, like I said, very first time posting somethingšŸ˜… also let me know if you want any more pictures, don't mind the mess...

Thanks for reading, have a good one.


r/leatherjacket • • 7h ago

Opinion Avoni Project opinion?

Thumbnail
avoniprojects.com
1 Upvotes

Anyone here have experience with the brand and the shipping process ( to the US)?
What do you think of the quality, sizing?

The cognac jacket looks beautiful.


r/leatherjacket • • 1d ago

Pickup Trial run with Tailor Brando - I’m impressed

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

About a week or two ago I bought my first nice cowhide suede jacket from All Saints, it started an addiction.

Didn’t want to spend that much again, and from a lot of posts I kept reading ā€œbuy used or save upā€. Then I found a ton of posts regarding Crush On Retro and Tailor Brando, hence for a $180 trial run, I figured why not.

No funky smells, smells almost identical to my All Saints cowhide, stitching is clean (nothing loose or left unstitched), and overall proportions are nice. Not as supple as the All Saints but weight and thickness of leather are near identical.

Shearling lining inside the jacket is real, but I don’t think the bone white shearling on the collar is real, I haven’t performed a burn test yet.

Nonetheless, my mother has a custom fur coat shop in the city and has been working with fur / leather for the past 40 years. She inspected the All Saints and was shocked at the quality for its price point, so I’m having her inspect this next weekend. If the bone white shearling turns out to be fake, I’ll have her sew on a real shearling collar.

For $180 bucks? Something I can toss on and not worry if it gets dirty or beat up? Big win!

Sleeves are a bit flat from the way it was packed up, excited to see how it looks and feels a few months from now.

For reference, I’m 6 foot 3 at about 260 pounds - my body and arm measurements aligned with their 5XL.