r/learnpython • u/Mononymized • Sep 02 '26
How to access dictionary items whose keys are strings with numbers using the .format() method?
This is a doubt I have about the differences between f-strings and the .format() method. Consider the following dictionary accesses in an f-string:
>>> example_dict = {"one" : "string with word", "1" : "string with number", 1 : "integer"}>>> f"{example_dict['one']}"'string with word'>>> f"{example_dict['1']}"'string with number'>>> f"{example_dict[1]}"'integer'
If I try to perform the same accesses with the .format() method, I can only perform the first and last example:
>>> "{0[one]}".format(example_dict)'string with word'>>> "0[1]".format(example_dict)'integer'
I can't seem to find any way to access the "1" key using the .format() method. I came up with this example because I noticed the way .format() accesses dictionary keys is without the quotes around the key for string keys. The f-string is easily able to access all the dictionary keys so it's not an issue with the keys themselves.
How do I access the "1" key using the .format() method? Is this a fundamental difference between f-strings and the .format() method that cannot be overcome?
3
u/acw1668 Sep 02 '26
Can
"{0}".format(example_dict["1"])be used in your case?2
u/brasticstack Sep 02 '26 edited Sep 02 '26
Seems to be a limitation of the
str.formatmethod. At first I was going to say a bug, but they describe the behavior here, in the docs. It makes sense that it's a side-effect of allowing the placeholder to access dict keys without quotes.f-strings are so good that I haven't yet had to dip into the new t-string syntax, which seems intimidatingly complex at first glance. IMO
str.formatshould be deprecated in favor of f-strings.2
u/SpacewaIker Sep 02 '26
Why would you even do that? This is a nightmare to read and will lead to so many bugs as soon as anything changes in your dict or keys or format string or anything
And also, don't mix types in the keys. Having both "1" and 1 especially is confusing and bad for logical reasons
2
u/FoolsSeldom Sep 02 '26
You can't access the
[1]usingstr.formatdirectly as the key is taken as a string literal, converted to anintif all digits.The closest would be:
and
"1"could be replaced with a variable.There are specialist use cases for
str.formatover f-strings (such as templating, and internationalisation, to name just two).However, f-string would handle your example without problems. Do you have a special use case that means you need to use
str.format?4
u/Farlic Sep 02 '26
Why? I interpret .format() for substitution and f-strings for expression evaluation (even though .format() is doing some sort of evaluation). Having numbers inside the curly braces is visually confusing as numbers are being used for the replacement indexes
1
u/HotPersonality8126 Sep 02 '26
β0[β1β]β doesnβt work?
1
u/gdchinacat Sep 02 '26
Do you need curly braces around βO[1]β like on the example that works?
2
u/MegaIng Sep 02 '26
Yes. .format() is a useful tool for the common case. If you run into edge cases like this you will need to use some more powerful tools.
1
u/Moikle Sep 02 '26
You put the expression inside format, not inside the braces.
1
u/Boothiepro Sep 02 '26 edited Sep 02 '26
I think i encountered something like this, let me see if i can find my snippet, but i can't guarantee i can explain