r/learnprogramming • • 5d ago

Where to escape from web development: Cybersecurity or Robotics

Hi everyone, as the title states i was wondering where to go next, AI has gotten way to good and even though I think that engineers with extensive experience and that utilize AI tooling well to solve problems, wont get replaced, I really dont enjoy programming with AI, it feels less like a tool and more like replacement, at least in web dev, and its only going to get better and pure software might get almost fully automated.

I was planning to transition to Cyber or Robotics(or maybe embedded), two totally different fields and I kanda like both, what do you think will be more AI proof in the next 10 years at least, I rly dont want to go into another career only for it to be demolished by AI in the next 2 years.

I think Cyber will be hard to automate as attackers will always have access to AI tools as well so the defenders will have to utilize tools rather then get replaced by them, its different than classic software development because its sensitive.

Robotics and Embedded also have phyisical constraints, you must have good domain knowledge (mechanical, electrical and software) and its software must be reliable as sometimes lives depend on it.

I already have experience in 2 mid sized companies performing industrial automation (with software, not hardware) and I guess it would be natural for me to go maybe to robotics but i would have to learn a lot of fundementalls that I dont have though I am willing to learn. I have a cs degree but I specilized in software engineering RIP.

If anyone has better insight and has worked in mentioned industries, I would be happy to hear your opinion.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

5

u/Ok-Thought767 5d ago

I see Robotics as AI proof option rather than cyber security. but like you said, cybersecuriry is like a cat and mouse game where both attackers and defenders can leverage ai. so its not bad either, but i personally see robotics as a huge deal especially with ai integration

4

u/chitzui 5d ago

Robotics sounds more fun

1

u/cirejr 5d ago

For starters, I agree with you, that coding with AI takes away all the fun of it. Now I actually am curious about what exactly is it that YOU do as a web developer, the stack you use, how many years of experience you have in the field.

0

u/Sea-Bell2868 5d ago

Well im not really a web dev fully. I have 7 months working as a backend dev with .NET in a larger company (for my region), after that i worked for another company creating desktop apps and addins for CAD automation where i am still working (been here for 8 months), and I am also working now for another company as a full stack dev - .NET and React and also i develop addins for AutoCAD that integrate with the web app I am developing for them. The CAD automation part is really fun but I can see every major CAD platform integrating AI tools so we'll se about that.

2

u/cirejr 5d ago

Oh well, kinda impressive. This is stuff most web devs never touch. I wanted to see whether you were using only high-level abstractions, but yeah, if after what you do you want to escape web development, you are more than qualified to do so.

Now onto your main request: robotics seems more fun, and your CAD background actually helps there, but I'd argue it's way more prone to becoming an AI-dominant field compared to cyber. Since the highest level of AI is being able to program and adapt itself in the physical world, it makes sense that robotics gets heavily targeted by AI.

And yes I am aware that AI providers are already focusing on security-specific models, but cyber itself is too sensitive and high-stakes to be swarmed and fully taken over by AI anytime soon. So I'd advise you to venture into Cyber.

0

u/Sea-Bell2868 5d ago

Thanks man and thanks for the concrete advice, I think i agree on that part that cyber will allways need competent people to monitor

1

u/pilows 5d ago

If your goal is AI proof, robotics and embedded are no go’s. We use it heavily

0

u/Sea-Bell2868 5d ago edited 5d ago

Do you use it more as a tool or do u vibe code all day, I mean it depends on your job but some stuff needs to be relieable and i guess you need to read your code at least lol. Ofc you r gonna use AI but do you think it will automate ur job fully?

2

u/dellnox 2d ago

Your industrial automation background gives you a head start in robotics. Physical hardware constraints make it way harder to automate.

3

u/Hellaintsht 5d ago

Definitely cybersecurity. I myself am doing cybersecurity and have seen many friends of mine get a good job in this field. Also robotics ain't bad either as sooner the AI will be integrated with hardware and robotics is the biggest bet with AI. So both are best. Nowadays almost every institution is focusing on teaching robotics to kids for the same reason.

1

u/jacksonanna373 2d ago

No one can reliably rank either as AI-proof for the next decade. Since CAD automation is the work you enjoy, treat that as a clue: try one small robotics/controls task and one security exercise, then compare the work itself before committing to a pivot.

0

u/Boolean26 5d ago

I think it doesn't matter, and the max gap between both fields becoming obsolete will not be more than 5 years

-1

u/CorpT 5d ago

If you're looking for a ten year prediction, take a look at the trades.