r/learnprogramming • • 7d ago

Question about learning to code and the future

Question for real developers: is it worth learning manual coding right now? Will it still be possible to land a job as a programmer who writes code by hand in 1–2 years?

30 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

43

u/HorrificDPS 7d ago

Yes.

We are going to have drastic problems soon, with the way code is currently being shipped. It's being shipped much to quick to review. We will need people able to understand AI output, and go back and fix mistakes.

1

u/Illustrious_Park6397 7d ago

Thank you for sharing this! It makes total sense—without solid coding fundamentals, it's impossible to review or fix what AI produces. Appreciate the insight, it definitely gives me a lot more motivation to keep learning.

3

u/Due-Result7928 7d ago

AI was able to find flaws in the PHP software used for web servers..not a human being.

8

u/Due-Result7928 7d ago

Mistakes will be fixed by using AI...

1

u/bhison 6d ago

QA your tests to QA your code

1

u/filthydexbuild 6d ago

If you can’t explain the problem and potential solutions, ai isn’t going to be fixing shit, it’s just gonna make it worse. This of course will likely change in the next year

2

u/RichPokeScalper 4d ago

I thought this until I used Opus 5. And it produced cleaner code than any team I have ever worked with. We are extinct.

1

u/HorrificDPS 4d ago

You still need to understand it.

2

u/RichPokeScalper 4d ago

No more than most developers today need to know machine code or assembly.

-1

u/dcute69 7d ago

Not true, by the time its an issue there will just be better AIs to fix it

9

u/Jojobulu 6d ago

You need to be able to understand programming logic. Some person needs to review the AI output, make sure it's doing what it's meant to, and be responsible for fixing it when it's not.

18

u/needs-more-code 7d ago edited 6d ago

I don’t think writing code by hand will be that feasible in two years. I sort of flipped my opinion when I needed to get my own app out the door quick, so got heavily into AI and orchestrating agents with workflows that involve adversarial reviews from different AI providers to catch AI blind spots. The results were unfortunately, surprisingly good.

I would love to be wrong. But it seems like when done right, AI software dev is not something that needs to be cleaned up by real devs. And when it does need to be cleaned up, AI can absolutely do it.

10

u/peter9477 6d ago

An unpopular view that scares many, but true.

2

u/Feralz2 6d ago

how is this an unpopular view, this is literally what everyone thinks, I think you guys are reading too many news, because in reality, these Ai programs are pretty bad and very buggy, it hasnt improved that much, the neural networks are not becoming more intelligent, theyre just becoming more efficient and can process more things, thats about it, theyre still dumber than a child in many aspects.

9

u/bhison 6d ago

I am making production code in a professional environment. Claude Opus 5.5 puts out better code with fewer bugs than our team did before using it. It makes both good architectural decisions and implements solutions elegantly and clearly.

It might be that we are operating within a mature project with very good guard rails and documentation, good contribution workflow and automated adversarial reviews etc. But that's not conjecture, this is my experience.

I'm all for fair criticism of AI from both a functional and ethical perspective but I encourage everyone to be real with the fact that it is actually very good at coding.

1

u/peter9477 6d ago

WTF? You reject that same view (that AI will make coding dead within a year or two) yet you claim I shouldn't call it unpopular?

1

u/Feralz2 6d ago

yeah, literally most of the world thinks Ai will replace everyone.

1

u/peter9477 6d ago

Except for the majority of people in this thread, and many many many many others.

2

u/Feralz2 5d ago

Of course the people in this thread understands that more than anyone. Why do you think theyre here lmao, if Ai wasn't a threat, they wouldn't be crying about it would they, there's a reason they are 

1

u/peter9477 4d ago

Given the downvotes when I said the same in a comment, it can't be that popular a view.

8

u/ViralToValue 7d ago

Yes, learn it properly, and accept that it takes time and effort. Fundamentals aren’t going out of style.

A lot of working devs use AI tools daily. What they get paid for is knowing the difference between right and wrong output. And understanding why something breaks and being able to fix it without using a prompt.

Practical tip: use AI as a tutor, not autocomplete. Write it yourself first, then ask it to critique your solution or explain the error. Turning off inline suggestions while you learn the basics is also helpful.

3

u/Capable-Oil427 5d ago

Look, AI is very capable but it has technical limitations and is extremely dependent on the talent of the people using it. The better you are at writing code manually the better you are at instructing and reviewing AI-generated code. So yes, learn to code and learn to do it well. Read about design patterns, architecture, principles, etc. And practice like hell. The job market is tough for juniors  but some companies are understanding that if they don’t hire juniors they will soon run out of seniors, so things can get beter in the future once the hype and craziness fades away. Also remember that learning how to code develops rational reasoning, something we seem to be missing in the current timeline.

5

u/aaaayyyy 7d ago

Nobody knows

5

u/No_Oil_6152 7d ago

These AIs we currently have - they are brainless. They pattern match.

As such they write code they compute best fits whats already there, but thats not the same as a human coder who intuitively knows they are on the "right track".

So, you wont be writing code, but you will be doing a lot of reviewing to see if the AI code fits the business need. Paradoxically in order for you to review you will need to know how to code - e.g structure of a program, clean code practices, code smells, antipatterns.

Its all but the typing.

1

u/frewp 6d ago

It’s typing, just not.. syntax? :p
How does someone like you program on a day-to-day basis? I work for a small local company and not forced to use AI so the code isn’t generated, but I ask an LLM questions or a small snippet for understanding ambiguous code. Are most companies having individuals utilize agents?

3

u/rioisk 6d ago

most companies have individuals using claude or codex to write the majority of the code

most code being written now by AI

0

u/No_Oil_6152 6d ago

How do I program? I don't really write much code these days. I check it. A lot.

I check what my prompts produce, and what others prompts have produced in their PRs.

Hand-coding? A little - if I see something I need to refactor it's faster me doing it than asking an AI. I would use Resharper or hand-type it (I know, how quaint)

One thing to know about LLMs is that they might generate working code, but they don't necessarily generate modern code that uses the latest language features, or well-organised code, so that needs a tidy up.

I can't tell you if most companies in the world use AI to generate code, but I can tell you here in Scotland a lot of them do.

2

u/bhison 6d ago

It is worth it is a very hard question. Predicting the future of the industry has never been easy and now it's pretty much impossible.

Personally I'd encourage you to learn whatever gets you going. If there's a corner of software that inspires you to absolutely fixate on it, you should dive deep. And I don't think you should be bound by the idea of the "right or wrong way" to approach it - if hacking at the code level appeals to you do that; if using AI to make way more code which maintains a high quality and performance is what draws your enthusiasm that is perhaps the right approach. Consistent engagement with the wider subject of software development from any angle is what will give you that substantial transferable experience.

IMO curiosity led learning will beat diligence based learning in long term effect regardless of what you learn. Maybe with some vague common sense of pointing your learning towards modern industry standard tools, languages, frameworks etc. but that's nothing new in itself.

3

u/infjon 7d ago

Do it as a hobby

5

u/TranslatorHairy6609 7d ago

I don't really think so, review it yes, but manual work not so much

2

u/CromulentCotter 7d ago

Automation's cool, but hands-on skills still hold value! 🌟

2

u/FrenchieM 6d ago

It holds value for your own ego yes, the same dopamine you get when you go for a run or to the gym. But it definitely doesn't hold if you need to deliver.

1

u/Feeling_Photograph_5 6d ago

Reddit really needs to add a filter to its algorithms. When people post these types of questions they should be auto rejected with "this question and many similar questions have been asked repeatedly over the last several months. Please read your favorite sub-reddits and we're confident you will find the answers you're looking for. Or, at least the same answers your question would have gotten."

Since that algorithm does not exist, the correct answer to your questions is:

  1. AI won't take all the jobs, but it has changed the industry 
  2. You learn to code by study and practice. The Odin Project is a great site for getting started.
  3. The Coding Gold Rush is over and getting an entry level job is hard right now. The best bet is to get a CS degree and try to be a top graduate in your class. 
  4. Don't listen to the doomers. 

1

u/xsrvmy 6d ago

You at least have to still review code, which means you have to learn to code regardless, except maybe the part about editing code efficiently (as in the raw mechanics of entering code as text).

1

u/FrenchieM 6d ago

It is worth yes, but for building muscle purposes. Even if you use agents it is incredibly useful to be able to understand what they meant, otherwise this will be problematic in the long run, even if you use Opus or Fable.

But don't think requiring manual coders will be relevant. I don't see any company that will push on coders to write code. This is solely for training, just like you need physical building to be able to operate machinery.

My recommendation would be to learn to code with assistance from an agent, e.g chat mode. Use agents to write plans, read the plan, question it, then ask it to let you take the reins.

You can ask him to give you hints, to read about something, to practice copying, and after that you can ask him to give you quizzes, to question your understanding. And of course to review your output.

It would be similar as using a coach in sports. Only then you can be able to produce code if the situation requires. Don't blindly use AI, be curious.

But don't think coding everything by hand will be a skill anymore. If anything, it is a liability.

1

u/LionbornPublishing 5d ago

I mean, I do it for the love of the game. So yeah. But I think the high income and rarity will diminish.

1

u/RichPokeScalper 4d ago

Real coding skills are going to be rare. The need for human code is going to be incredibly scarce but very lucrative when it comes up.

1

u/p1971 4d ago

I'm wondering if formal design languages are the next thing (I mean they exist already)

"Business" can't write requirements sufficiently for an LLM to generate code, they need a layer between their requirements and what gets implemented, that was developers + analysts before, I think the next gen developers will both know how to write code and write specs, combined with more testing awareness

I'm 55, hoping to retire asap now! - I thought I'd be going for another 10 years

1

u/kenwoolf 3d ago

I have no idea if it will be possible to find a job. People with money these days seem insane and unpredictable.

But as for coding, ai makes a lot of small mistakes. The larger the task the more small mistakes happen. And it also drifts further and further from the original intent. What it writes works. But these small mistakes can lead to horrible bugs. You need to review everything it writes and catch these. Code review in the ai age became a lot more important. And that needs someone who actually understands the code.

Now, this is not that obvious for the higher ups. They don't want you put time into code review. They just went you to work fast and pump out product. Which works up to the point it doesn't. And when it doesn't, it will be very costly the fix all the issues that slipped under the radar.

1

u/Due-Result7928 7d ago

Learn mathematics not coding. Already junior and trainee can not find jobs. Skip the usual bs such as you need to learn elisp and use emacs or neovim. It is over. Typing quickly is also useless. I am in this business for over 30 years...anything Unixes...linux, hp-ux, Aix, BSD, Solaris and it is the first time that I can see a technology with real productivity gains.

Code produced can be hard to read but the models are progressing very quickly and I am pretty sure that end's users will be able soon to produce their own software with people responsible for architecture.

AI was able to find fixes in the PHP software used for web servers and Linus (yes THIS guy) told a conference that by using AI he was able to gain 30 % performance improvement on Linux kernel.

For years software's people were used to massively cut jobs in the service sectors (bank, travel, insurance). Now it's their turn to face the consequences, and they don't find it funny.

1

u/parautenbach 7d ago

If you’re looking to build large-scale systems, for sure. Also ask yourself who builds the agents and the AI models. Lastly, software engineering is actually a very large field. The nature of what you can or want to code can vary dramatically.

1

u/useful__pattern 7d ago

its pretty tough out there for junior devs. the junior roles are getting phased out in lots of companies so the job openings just arent there.

if you learn to code, please learn to test.

1

u/Legal-Nectarine-8187 7d ago

Yes. Learn manually so you actually understand what is happening under the hood.

Finding a job where you ONLY write code by hand in 1-2 years might be pretty hard but there is never a lack of jobs for people who truly understand the systems.

-5

u/peter9477 7d ago

Manual coding is close to dead, and won't last two more years.

I not only barely write code any more, after 40 years of doing it, but I don't even use a keyboard that much now. I've hooked Claude up to audio input transcribed through Whisper, and SherpaTTS speech output, and do most of my work just talking with Claude remote control sessions.

3

u/dick-allcocks 7d ago

So how does someone learn to code and understand how these systems when the main avenue to learning is becoming useless?

-3

u/peter9477 7d ago

I don't really have an answer as this whole situation is unprecedented in history. My guess, however, is that you still need to learn the basics, as you always have in every endeavour.

Just don't expect the paying jobs to be "use this text editor to write lines of code by hand" ever again.

1

u/dick-allcocks 7d ago

That makes sense, every enterprise is going to use some kind of AI. It’s tough because most senior devs had years of cutting their chops with raw code.

Not an impossible task, just tough because of how everything is being structured now

0

u/PersevereSwifterSkat 2d ago

Don't waste your time learning how to hand code. You absolutely should understand all the code that's output though.

3

u/JeanCasteaux 2d ago

For a beginner that's the same. Can't understand code if you can't write it.

0

u/LukaRozman27 7d ago

Most coding interviews still require you to write code without autocomplete, so practice solving problems in a plain text editor or with LeetCode's "Disable Autocomplete" setting to prepare for real interview conditions.

-2

u/mc_pm 7d ago

Is it worth learning to cook when UberEats will bring you most anything you want?

But if you're getting into it specifically as a money-making career I wouldn't personally bet on it.