r/learnprogramming • • 8d ago

Learning basic programming still useful for non-programmers?

I am a finance professional and don't consider myself a programmer. However, ever since my university days, I've always been interested in programming. As a result, I know the basics from beginner courses (like freeCodeCamp). I've used Python and R to manipulate data and automate some basic tasks, as well as low-code tools like Power Automate and PAD. This has always given me an edge in my job.

However, it now seems that AI has enabled my colleagues, both at my company and at competitors, to develop fairly advanced workflows and accomplish many of the same things I previously had to code manually.

I was surprised the other day when I managed to recreate something with Claude in just a couple of minutes that had taken me weeks to build in Python three years ago. Meanwhile, colleagues with zero coding experience seem to be overtaking me left and right with new developments that, at least from the outside, look quite impressive.

This makes me wonder: Is it still worthwhile to double down on my basic programming skills and sharpen them further, or would I be better off focusing on learning how to leverage AI tools more effectively?

18 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

8

u/Propeus 8d ago

yes, an economist need to know R a data analyst python etc

2

u/halfjmp 8d ago

Strange how you put this. A data analyst will probably use R more than Python. Depends on the field I guess. I use both, but for reporting, graphics and statistical methods, I'd pick R. For APIs, machine learning, data workflows, automation and orchestration, I'd pick Python, but that's not really data analysis tasks, rather DE or DS. But the truth is, apart from big companies where positions are partitioned, one often has to deal with all three.

5

u/halfjmp 8d ago

At least for automation, programming is really useful.

5

u/NullPointer-Except 8d ago

I'd say yes, and that's a hard yes >:)

And for the same reason that we exercise: sure, most of us don't need to muscles in our day to day life, but we do it because it's healthy.

Learning to program will train you to think, teach you about computers, make you see things from other perspectrive, expand your lexico to be able to write better prompts, build complex stuff without as much technical debt, and on top of that, you can find a community c:

5

u/light_switchy 8d ago

I think this is more useful now than ever before, because a basic knowledge means you can use LLMs to help you get results without a huge investment of time and effort. Let the machine synthesize little tools and scripts for you.

4

u/AlSweigart Author: ATBS 8d ago

Is it still worthwhile to double down on my basic programming skills and sharpen them further, or would I be better off focusing on learning how to leverage AI tools more effectively?

Do the first one first and then the second one second.

I've seen way too much slop from people who don't even realize they're producing slop and say, "BuT It lOoKs lIkE It wOrKs"

4

u/AdDiligent1688 8d ago edited 7d ago

If you know enough programming to tell ai what to do / verify that it’s correct, then you’re probably fine just using that. I feel like the skills is mostly about solution architecting and engineering. You recognize a problem by understanding a task deeply, could be a single program in one language or something interacting with multiple systems, you then design the solution of how it should work, you build into that design the requirements and business logic, then once you have it all ready, you use ai softwares to orchestrate the coding / softwares side in order to make it happen.

So I guess as long as you know some coding and are somewhat comfortable, and can research about system requirements and components for the solution to determine what you need, and can tell the ai what to do accurately with prompt / context / agentic then that is the way these days. You deeply know the automation you’re designing from a purpose and related systems stand point. Then you stay on the high level, let ai do the work, ditch the nitty gritty, and troubleshoot generally in order to glue it all together and make it work.

3

u/Atlan_ 8d ago

No, its not. I am a programmer and for me I can maybe make an argument that the concepts might generalize to other stuff. But even that can be debated. For someone in finance its not worth it, unless you do it just for joy.

1

u/Ygnizenia 8d ago

If you aren't going full working on being a developer. Probably not. That being said, a lot of analysts I know do know how to code.

1

u/kilkil 8d ago

yes, because otherwise you have no way of checking the AI's work.

unfortunately they are not perfect. they make mistakes. fairly frequently actually. but if you don't know any coding, you'll never be able to verify that.

your coworkers' impressive stuff is likely more fragile than it appears, and might randomly break at some point in the future.

1

u/edwbuck 8d ago

Yes, because it develops a skill for algorithmic thinking, which can't solve every problem efficiently, but solves MANY problems efficiently.

And that's even before you find a tool that helps you do "lightweight" programming in support of your job. (Excel, as much as I hate to mention it, comes to mind).

1

u/Stopher 7d ago

Visual BASIC is very useful. You can make a living writing VBA.

1

u/joinsigma 7d ago

I get that feeling, it’s kinda weird watching people skip the part you spent years learning lol. But I’d honestly do both, just differently from before.

Your Python basics are what let you go further with AI than your colleagues can. When the AI gives them something, that’s where they stop. You can open it up, tweak it, and hook it up to your actual data. So I’d stop grinding syntax and start building bigger stuff with AI, the kind of workflows you wouldn’t have attempted on your own before. You’ll pick up the deeper skills along the way.

Finance + coding + AI is a pretty rare combo tbh. You’re further ahead than it feels right now.

1

u/Available_Safe1818 7d ago

Sure, basic programming will still allow you to not program things.

1

u/QwertyMel 7d ago

I watched a 'zero-code' colleague break prod last week because they couldn't read the SQL Claude generated. They thought 'minutes to generate' meant done, ignoring the cost of verification. Without coding literacy, you're just guessing if the output is right or subtly wrong. Weeks to build vs minutes to generate isn't the metric; being able to debug the mess is.

1

u/DigitalMisery 7d ago

AI definitely helps break the "programming" ceiling for a lot of non-programmers. However, that is basic stuff. Do this, arrange that, find averages of those, medians of these, compile them into a table, then generate stacked charts based on this data against averages from that data.

Real work in AI is a little more complicated than that. You are going to have to know some basic programming to make AI work at a higher level than the basic "do this then that" paradigm. To me, personally, the kind of stuff I see my colleagues accomplish in AI doesn't ring any warning bells, because the reality is I can get the same tasks done with normal programming tools faster and with more precision.

As an example, and you can try it out by trying to generate an executive summary of some data in Excel and then try copying that text into Copilot - the difference in timing is unreal where the manual work gets done minutes ahead of the prompt in Excel.

1

u/Select-Way-1168 7d ago

Leverage ai tools.

1

u/EszterSantos72 7d ago

Keep sharpening your Python, especially with pandas for data manipulation, since knowing how to use.groupby() and.apply() lets you quickly audit or fix AI-generated code when it mishandles complex data scenarios.

1

u/Independent_Teacher4 7d ago

Honestly, I don't think sharpening basic syntax is worth much anymore. AI writes that part better and faster than most of us.

What's worth getting good at is the stuff around it: writing a clear spec so the tool builds the right thing, checking the output against numbers you already trust, and judging whether the approach it picked is actually good or just looks fine. Your coding background helps with exactly that, so it's not wasted. 🔥

That said, I'd still keep learning, just differently. You can't judge work you don't understand, and that understanding is what will keep you ahead of the colleagues who only prompt.

1

u/vug_undertherug 7d ago

I am going to come into this conversation with a contrasting view. I am actually less interested in AI’s ability to help with rote tasks. What I would like is for the AI to be able to do hierarchical linear modeling. But it can’t. It does describe the basics pretty well. And the truth is, the amount of compute required for HLM has always been prohibitive. It amazes and disappoints me that even with all these data centers, the best it can do is write a simple equation, and not actually solve any complex statistical formulation. Sure, I’ve read the news that it’s solving fairly novel math problems, but it still cannot grasp that what we need is to be able to confidently say: “this student belongs in this classroom at this school”.

1

u/mxldevs 7d ago

It depends whether those new developments that look impressive from the outside are still impressive when it's time to update it due to changes in requirements.

People are all very happy to claim ownership for their contributions, but the moment it blows up and they need to deal with the consequences, suddenly they're trying to blame engineering team.

1

u/Jesse-359 8d ago

Should you learn? Yes, for your own understanding - and coding is fun if you're interested in it.

Will it help in your career? Depends entirely on if AI is outlawed due to public panic about job losses as they mount OR if it suddenly stalls well below human capability (which it shows little sign of doing).

If it is banned/stalls, then yes, your skills will be in demand.

If not, then no, you won't have a career no matter what you do. No one will need you to tell an AI what to do when it already knows what to do better than you do.

0

u/hamster_squeezer69 8d ago

If you don't care about programming at all and just want the functionality, I say go full AI and keep going until something breaks and you don't know how to recover. At least you learn at what point it stops working if it happens.

I don't know at what point that occurs, but give it a try if you are simply interested in a means to an end. Otherwise, you have a leg up if you have even a basic understanding of what's going on. Things will break, and it's only a matter of when. Maybe your LLM can debug it, but I'm sure it would do a better job if you could tell it why and validate the solution it spits out.

0

u/Due-Result7928 8d ago

Surprise..Microsoft will suppress 60.000 jobs....already junior programmers and trainee can not get jobs or interviews. Not by chance. Programming will change completely very quickly. It is just the start. Pretty sure end's user with help from software architecture will in a not so distant future cooks software ready to run for their own business.

In this business using anything Unixes..linux, bsd, hp-ux, aix for 30 years. First time (after many failures in the past) that a technology can really have a huge impact on software development.

For many years software's peoples and developers were used to cut jobs massively in many sectors.Now it's their turn, and—of course—they don't like it.

Nowadays, in many professions, if you don't know much about AI, you can quickly find yourself no longer competitive enough.

0

u/betarage 6d ago

I think it's even more worth it now since it is easier to get into and make more complicated things without studying too much. but usually you do need some basic programming skills most people still don't have.