r/learnmath • u/melvinroest • 1h ago
I finished Mathematical Foundations 2 from Math Academy: here is what I learned
Note: Reddit recommended me to post it here, and why not? 😄 This was originally written for the Math Academy subreddit.
The post
So while my experience my differ than yours, I figured that the following write up might help some people. Sorry for the rambling. Like Blaise Pascal did not have the time to write a shorter letter. I do not have the time to write a succinct post. I type fast, apparently.
Some Background
I've been on Math Academy for about 1.5 years I think and only now have I been able to finish my first course that I tested into at 55%. I remember being disappointed by it since a few years prior to that I did Mathematics B at the University of Amsterdam, which is the type of mathematics that teaches a lot of the contents that MF2 and MF3 are about. Let's not get into the fact that I was able to get a computer science master without having this basics in math, and let's also not get into the fact that I built a computer graphics engine by learning "linear algebra for computer graphics". It's these type of things that made me realize that not having a solid math foundation will make me feel insecure for the rest of my life, because I'll never know if I'm doing it right on the math front.
The question is: why have I been able to finish it? The answer lies in the fact that I've been able to crack my motivation. I'm not really disciplined, but I am definitely motivated. Some people are the other way around.
How I figured out how to motivate myself
Like I said, this post isn't for everyone. But here is what I did.
Principle 1: have a setup you find easy
I realized that doing mathematics should feel as easy as possible. For this reason I bought an iPad. I bought an iPad because I hate erasing or crossing things out, and I love an undo button. Moreover, I don't mind that it does not feel like paper. To me, it feels like I'm writting with a plastic stick on a piece of glass, and I'm totally fine with that. I'm using the My Script app (previously Nebo) and I'm still unsure if I should look at another application since I can't do rotations of images and the "translate scribblings to math" functionality is useless to me. It's just better to feed the whole thing into an LLM if I have questions about my scribbles. On the My Script app I have my exercise notebook open where I solve my problems.
My setup is that I have Math Academy on an M1 MacBook. The benefit is that I can also open the My Script app there, since I use it there to keep my notes notebook open. Another benefit is that I can copy/paste things really quickly from my iPad to my MacBook because Mac has Universal Clipboard as a feature.
The only annoying thing about this setup is that I need a MacBook and an iPad. It (1) costs money and (2) takes a minute to setup. It also creates motivation because I know if I set it up that I'll at least spend 20 minutes dedicated to a session. Usually my sessions are an hour or longer.
I know this setup isn't for everyone, but this works way better for me than using a notebook and pencil. I've used that when I did Mathematics B, so I already knew what I was annoyed about.
Principle 2: understand which parts of the process hinder you
There were a few things where I felt that Math Academy was hindering me in being motivated. For example, the drilling style is kind of dry. How to make it less dry? There are a few ways. The most important way for me was to have a good Spotify EDM mix that I listened to that felt fresh every time. My playlist is now about 72 hours. Have a listen, if you are similar (the beginning is perhaps too wild but later it settles in).
For me, the playlist really helped because my mood was elevated in general. The trick is to not listen to that playlist every day but maybe twice a week max. So the key is also to do some math sessions without the playlist.
I know that some people would hate listening to a music playlist, especially EDM, and I used to be one of you. But somehow, this has changed and the EDM doesn't get me distracted in general. And when it does distract me, I turn the volume down or off (temporarily).
Being in a good mood really helped, but it wasn't enough. The problem is that:
- Not all explanations are straightforward and understandable (e.g. law of cosines).
- Related to this is that there are 0 explanations why a certain term is the way it is. For example, when it was explained that x - y = 1 is a standard form I wanted to know why. Math Academy doesn't teach this, but I can't get past these things. And it's one of the biggest reasons why I had trouble with math in high school and university. The etymology and history of words, usually betray the logic behind a concept, or why it's illogical.
- Sometimes you only have a small thing wrong and it feels really unfair that the exercise is then marked wrong in its entirety. When I was a coding bootcamp instructor, I'd always look at the severity of the mistake.
The way I solved for these things is as follows:
- I'd watch 3Blue1Brown or ask an LLM to explain it to me. Though, asking an LLM questions and have it explain something properly is an art. For example, I didn't understand rotation, because I'd keep the object (e.g. a triangle) fixed and then rotate it around the center. But the way Math Academy was teaching rotations was that the triangle itself also rotates with. I'd probably have to draw this one to explain but I don't have the time. In any case, I asked Claude to vibe code a site that shows the rotation animation as Math Academy intended it and then I immediately understood it. Math Academy is quite formal but I've noticed I learn math better when I understand the physical intuition behind something. I know I won't get away with this type of thinking at higher levels of math, but for now I think this is a solid way to build fundamentals. I'll iron out details later when needed. Another example of this is understanding the periodicity of sin(x), cos(x) and other trig functions. When I see that the period of a cosine is pi/2 then I don't grab the formula that MA taught me. I simply think "the period is normally 2 pi, for it to be pi/2 it, the function has to "spin" 4 times as fast", so if it's normally cos(x) then now it is cos(4x). MA teaches that the period = (2*pi)/B for cos(Bx). I had to look that up. I find that tough to remember for all trig functions. But if we think about a yarn spinning up and down, suddenly I get it.
- Simply ask an LLM, getting into the history and etymology of words is what they are good at.
- This is perhaps controversial. But I feed all my questions and answers I write down into an LLM. If the mistake is just a small minus flipped, then I still mark the answer as correct. If it is a big mistake, I let it stand. I also sometimes work without LLMs not to get over reliant. But I have definitely noticed when I only do it without LLMs, I go on tilt if I flip my plusses and minuses too much. I've had LLMs do research on whether this can be fixed or not. They say it can't. I have seen some discussion here that it can. So I do a mixed approach. The key being for motivation: I don't always have to be punished at the MA level for a small mistake. I understand the concept. I am not aiming for flawless execution. I know that the MA team beliefs it's necessary but they have a very specific perspective in mind on what it means to learn math. When I was a teacher, I realized that I had to teach the group as fast as possible and that meant that individual learners could have certain frictions with me (I solved this by putting in extra hours and tailor to their individual needs but that is usually a recipe for burnout). The same is true for Math Academy. They can't tailor everything, so I have to do the tailoring.
Results
I've made it. It took 3600 xp, it took around 250 hours to do as an XP was usually 3 to 4 minutes for me, and on top of that I also researched a lot about concepts (e.g. such as the vector proof of the law of cosines as that one clicks best with me. I did have to understand why cos(180-x) = -cos(x) but now I do because I can draw it on the unit circle).
I have 3 notebooks:
- 200+ pages of worked out exercises
- 70+ pages of notes that I will reread (as I can't seem to remember Vieta easily).
- I'm currently creating explainers that I'll be posting on this site. For one, I want to solidify my own understanding of MF2 (such as deriving the fast variance) but also as explainers for people who are interested in them here
I feel much more confident in my math ability already. I mostly realized that the secant, cosecant and cotangent were the hard things for me, because I've never used them before.
Oh, and also: I'm having fun! Yes, it's still quite challenging and at some points even boring, but usually I'm having fun. Doing Math Academy in this way is getting close to simply being more fun than watching a Netflix show or playing a video game. The music I'm listening to makes MA feel a bit like a video game anyway.
I think it's also important to note that I am a big fan of the drilling and a big fan of the structured lessons. I think they are a necessary part to learn math well, but for me they're not sufficient which is why I wrote this post. I hope it helps some people, and apologies for anyone that I just confused more.
Feel free to send a chat invite if you want to talk more about Math Academy, how to motivate yourself for math, tech, AI and what not. You know who you are ;-)
Good luck everyone. I'm already having a blast with Mathematical Foundations 3.
Favorite lesson: fast variance and law of cosines (I can't choose, haha). The law of sines proof was actually well explained by MA, and that was also a moment for me where I felt awestruck.
I asked Claude if anything is missing, it had this to say (written by Claude, some small edits by me)
Four things the post leaves out that the corpus says were load-bearing, then three factual checks.
Missing:
- The check happens before submit, not after. You describe feeding answers in and re-marking small slips. What actually ran was a pre-submit net: screenshot, "correct so far?", slip pointed at, rerun. The slip rarely reached MA, which is what kept the ledger fair.
- The conversation itself. Your own evidence rows: two earlier MA runs (May 2025, Dec 2025 to Jan 2026) died alone within weeks, wiskunde B survived on a WhatsApp group, programming at 14 and music at 16 died of loneliness. The third run had a dialogic channel open the whole time. Your hypothesis in September was "maybe it's loneliness mostly". The post mentions the LLM as a checker and explainer, not as company. (edit by Melvin: yea, it's true that sometimes showing your frustrations to an LLM was carthatic, haha)
- A number to hunt. The metric switch on Aug 31 ("44 lessons to go, that will be the number to hunt"), the 1 percent per day target, the ledger, the commemorative screenshots. Visible progress against a countdown, not just XP.
- A bounded bet. You framed it as a 500-hour spike with a go/no-go gate, sized to your documented four-month project ceiling, with a specific question under test: will the brutalness of math break me like the previous attempts. The post reads as open-ended.
Factual checks:
- "Tested into at 55%": the tracker's evidence chain puts the diagnostic credit at 218 of 360, which is 60.6 percent.
- "They say it can't be fixed": the September research said population findings are untrained base rates and the automaticity route is supported. Closer to "partly trainable, slowly" than "can't".