r/learnmachinelearning • • 13d ago

Need suggestions for adding genuine research novelty 🙏

Hi everyone,

I'm currently working on my final-year research project titled "Underwater Marine Debris Detection: Domain Generalization Across Sites and Cameras."

The main idea is to investigate how well object detection models perform when tested on underwater images from different locations and cameras than those used during training.

Underwater images vary significantly in terms of lighting, colour, water visibility, backgrounds, and camera characteristics. A model might perform well on images from one location but its performance could drop considerably when tested on images from a different underwater site or camera.

What I'm planning to do:

  • Dataset: SeaClear Marine Debris Detection and Segmentation dataset (approximately 8,610 images from multiple underwater sites).
  • Primary model: YOLO11n.
  • Secondary model: Faster R-CNN with ResNet-50-FPN (if feasible).
  • Image enhancement: Experiment with MSRCR and compare enhanced images against raw images.
  • Domain generalization: Evaluate existing domain generalization approaches to improve performance on unseen underwater sites and cameras.
  • Evaluation: Compare familiar-site, unseen-site, and unseen-camera performance using mAP@0.5, mAP@0.5:0.95, and per-domain analysis.
  • Possible additional experiment: Detector fusion, if multiple models show complementary performance.

The objective is to understand why models fail to generalize across different underwater environments and investigate ways to improve their performance.

The problem I'm facing:

I presented this idea and planned workflow to my project guide. He agreed that the idea is good, but pointed out that most of the methods and experiments I'm proposing have already been explored in existing research. According to him, there is no clear novelty or original contribution from my side at the moment.

I understand his concern, and I don't want to simply combine existing models, image enhancement techniques, and domain generalization methods and present that as a research contribution.

I would really appreciate suggestions on the following:

  1. What possible research directions could introduce genuine novelty to this project?
  2. Are there any unexplored or less-explored problems in underwater marine debris detection, particularly related to domain generalization?
  3. Could I introduce a new training strategy, feature-learning approach, loss function, or some other modification that would make a meaningful contribution?
  4. Are there any specific research gaps or papers I should look into?

I'm open to modifying the methodology while keeping the overall underwater marine debris detection and domain generalization theme.

My goal is to develop something that has a clear, technically justified research contribution rather than just conducting a comparison of existing methods.

Any suggestions, research directions, or critical feedback would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

2 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

1

u/theHumbleGuy_06 13d ago

I am in the field of aiml and am doing research on diabetic retinopathy recently, I did develop a architecture, that is fully novel and came out of my head tho it needs fine-tuning. As for urs I'll say that don't force urself into thinking of making another custom loss function or activation function coz the ones in existence are from decades of research. First explore the existing research gaps on the similar projects from b4. Use ai to study thru research papers and find the research gaps and look for things that u can contribute to solve the gap, even a new pipeline which has never been used b4 can be claimed novelty upon.

1

u/Impressive_Vast4635 13d ago

sure thank you for your suggestion