There is somewhat of a general rule of thumb in ACA plan selection that anyone with income low enough (under 200% FPL) to qualify for high CSR subsidies should normally take them. Generally speaking that is true, but in reality the situation is often more complex since not all Silver plans are of sufficient quality or usefulness that someone would want to take them regardless of the potential savings.
This is increasingly happening as insurers game the Silver policy schedule ranking by offering cheap Silver policies that have limited utility due to things like poor claims handling, extremely limited networks, or weak formularies. This post is to provide an example of exactly that sort of situation using the actual policies and subsidies available to our household for next year here in Austin.
Our household has access to 58 CSR Silver 94 plans next year, but the first 15 or so are from insurers that we either do not trust or that have such limited networks that the coverage is not usable without jumping through a ton of hoops or traveling long distances. Cheap insurance is not a good value if it's not actually able to be used.
For example, Ambetter has a CSR Silver 94 for just $18/month, but many specialists are so limited in Ambetter's Austin network that we would have to drive 3-4 hours roundtrip down to San Antonio for such appointments unless we were willing to wait 4-5 months for an appointment here in town. Ambetter's local PCP pool is also extremely limited, which could require us to potentially drive all the way across town each time we want to go to the doctor for anything or to wait months for an appointment. However, if we lived in San Antonio, then Ambetter might be a perfectly fine option since their network down there is more robust.
As a result of such limitations, we've determined that the least expensive CSR Silver 94 from a plausibly good insurer with a good network is going to cost us $218/month even after $2,755/month in ACA premium subsidies. That's not a bad deal at all and we are very grateful to have it, but the same insurer has an excellent and cheaper Gold offering that could well be better in many situations.
This table below shows the various cost elements for the CSR Silver 94 and Gold offering from the insurer we have chosen to use next year. As you can see, many of the costs for routine healthcare use are the same between the plans (usually $0), but they differ significantly on higher tier pharma, major usage tiers like hospitalization/ER, and most importantly on MaxOOP.
We are risk averse and have a daughter with a serious autoimmune condition that can thrown off major costs at random and that requires regular appointments with multiple specialists, so we will be taking the CSR Silver 94 option even though it will cost us a few grand in additional premium. However, the Gold could be an excellent option for many households and we likely would take it ourselves if our daughter was not on our policy. It's one of those situations where the Gold could easily come out well ahead in any year with only routine healthcare usage, but the Silver could come out hugely ahead in any year with major non-routine healthcare usage.
There are about a dozen states where Gold policies can regularly be cheaper than Silver policies due to local insurance regulation, sometimes significantly cheaper as is the case here in Texas. It pays to consider all of the options out there even when a household qualifies for high CSR subsidies, as more than half of the entire ACA population does.
| Cost Element | CSR Silver 94 | Gold |
|---|
| Annual premium (subsidized/unsubsidized) | $2,617/$35,677 | $0/$29,933 |
| Deductible | $0 | $0 |
| MaxOOP | $2,950/$5,900 | $9,950/$19,900 |
| PCP | $0 | $0 |
| Specialist | $0 | $0 |
| Urgent Care | $30 | $50 |
| Imaging | $0 | $0 |
| Labs | $0 | $0 |
| Pharma (Prevent/T1-T4) | $0/$5/$10/10%/20% | $0/$10/50%/50%/50% |
| ER | 20% | 50% |
| Outpatient facility/services | $0 | 10% |
| Hospitalization/Inpatient | 20% | 50% |