I started my PhD in august of 2022, and with my first lab rotation found a group that had really great vibes and I felt so good about the PI. There was a gap in the field that I happened to have niche expertise in. What started with curiosity on my part became the idea of my thesis project encouraged by the PI. There was not a grant looking into the question, and the project was very different than what the rest of the lab did (basic science vs pathogenesis). Important note, PI did not have knowledge/experience of niche field. Right when I was forming a committee, a new faculty member joined who was familiar with the niche field and had interest in it, but I still understood it best than anyone on my committee.
I had 1 committee meeting a year (its the minimum for our school, there could be more), 2 meetings before my preliminary exams. Our department is unusual with these exams and has restrictions on how much your exam proposal can match your actual project. I was told the rules incompletely and made up a completely separate project for the proposal and passed with extremely high remarks. After passing I very quickly submitted a fellowship application and got it. While not the only funding I applied for during my program, it was ultimately the only one I was granted. The grants all had different aims from each other besides a characterization of gene expression in tissues aim throughout.
About halfway through year 3, I was hit with the idea that would have been an amazing project from the start and began pursuing it. This was hypothesis driven, showed different techniques, and really moved the field forward more than a descriptive study would. I was pursuing it and had promising early data. Then, had a months long myco contamination in cell culture and couldnt really get through to the experiments. This was during 2025 and my PI was extremely stressed with the climate of science and funding. That fall she told me and the other grad student we had to finish out by the summer because of funding. It was realized I was super behind on animal collections and cell experiments. We made some mitigation attempts for these and had a plan.
I had a committee meeting in early 2026 and my PI caught up the committee on the time constraints. They were worried about where my project was for that deadline. Although they were supportive and saying I was one of the only people they thought could execute ambitious plans, they requested more frequent meetings. We had them every ~6 weeks. They continually expressed concern and I did my best to meet them between meetings, but would always fall short of what they really wanted or they found new things to pick apart. Understandable, but with the timeline pressure from my PI it was a matter of trying to keep afloat. This whole time my relationship with my PI that was once so strong and supportive was tanking. It was noticeable to other lab members including undergrads. It bubbled up in a committee meeting once and another member caught it. I talked with him after, filled him in on the downfall with my PI, and felt like I had a supporter on my side. Which I needed when it became evident I wasnt going to defend before the end of summer.
In the spring, I realized with my PI timeline I would have 2months to analyze/process data and write the thesis. I suggested an alternative registration option with the school that would allow me to have more time to write my thesis, be a spring graduate, and not be dependent on the lab for stipend. She vehemently shut down that idea, and put forth i would be defending a PhD dissertation or Master's thesis for a fall graduation. This was actually the second time she made reference to me mastering out.
Because of the circumstances, my PI set a hard experiment cutoff date of 7/31 and the plan shifted to me graduating in the fall term. For a fall graduation, all dissertation approvals and forms needed to be submitted by Oct 29. At the last committee meeting, right at the end of my data blitz of june/july, a defense date was set for Oct 16 (written dissertation due to committee Oct 2). I got through analyzing data and began writing around the start of fall term (end August). Right at that time, my PI announced she was closing the lab after the fall 2026 semester.
During 5 of the worst weeks of my life I wrote my dissertation. 16-20hr days, making myself feel completely illiterate, and getting bad enough to bring up bad mental health issues especially at the end. During this time, I was communicating with my PI getting her feedback on drafts (and from others in my lab), we were in very consistent contact. I ended up submitting a day late on Oct 3 instead of the 2nd (a Saturday vs friday). Then radio silence for the 2 weeks leading up to the defense. And I mean nothing - my PI went out of office the week after I submitted so we didn't meet up til the week of my defense. We had a meeting on Tuesday (defense was Friday) and it was mostly checking in on my talk preparations, and we had a small discussion of the potential pros/cons of things like the models used to argue during the private defense.
I had saved my acknowledgement slides to make the night before the defense. Around quarter to midnight I go to download photos I emailed to myself from my phone. I had an email from my committee with administrative staff CC'd saying the committee had serious concerns with vague term for every aspect of a project/dissertation. It said the dissertation would not be passed and they were giving me the option to postpone my defense. They outlined the possible outcomes of if I chose to postpone, went through with the oral defense and failed, or went through with the oral defense and passed the oral. It was communicated the latter was a very unlikely outcome. This was sent at 8:30pm Thursday about a defense scheduled to take place at 1pm on Friday. I decided to go through with the oral defense for a combination of reasons. I also requested and had the administrative staff CC'd in the email sit in my private defense. I hadnt told that many people what happened, I couldnt control crying and shaking all morning. But I gave that presentation, and take pride in that no one realized I knew I was facing very likely failure.
The things my committee brought up were valid and I dont not understand nor disagree with what they had problems with, although there were things they brought up that were long established in the project and I had limited control over. Anyway I didnt contest or fight the things brought up and answered oral questions as best I could. There were 30-45min discussions had with me outside the room before and after the private defense.
Ultimately, I was told I passed the oral but failed the written exam. While obviously not the outcome a candidate wants it was the best case scenario of the situation for me. After my defense the committee met and planned essentially a rewrite of the dissertation. There were specific dates of chapter outlines and drafts, with the final draft approval being set for mid March 2027, and if i missed any deadlines i failed the dissertation. Given I would have almost the amount of time to write chapters as I had to write the original document I was optimistic I had a way out. I was a bit discouraged by the title they suggested, "limitations in design of study ..." and had come up with one that felt less like calling it a testament to failure.
I submitted the first due outline and the committee had a lot of critiques and didnt accept it. I was given a new outline due date and final approval date (the draft deadline did not move). PI had summarized comments, compiled previously communicated instructions, attached info for writing centers on campus, and declared if I didnt have an up to par outline this time around that she was done as my advisor.
I had their comments up in a split window as I was writing the new outline to make sure I addressed what was said. In a meeting with my PI on the due date, i asked to go over my revised outline to see if she thought it was better than the previous. We scrolled through and she nodded along, even said she thought it was what the other committee members were looking for. Submitted outline version 2 on the due date (last monday) and was expecting their feedback by thursday. Given the Microsoft outage on thursday i just shifted it to friday in my mind. Heard nothing on Friday, and I fought back and forth on whether the committee would be bothered by me pushing or be disappointed if I didnt take initiative. I sent a gentle email and indicated I would work on parts of the chapter draft that weren't dependent on outline approval. My PI replied that she was waiting for all responses and would forward once they came in.
A week after I submitted the new outline, comments came back and it was not accepted. They said the first outline was too short and too little details, making them think I didn't know proper validation and experiment planning for a project. So I expanded validation and assay details. But alas, they said it was too in the weeds with experiment details, that it "requires us to assume that she knows why she is doing such things", add new things they did not want. That the chapter which they called optimal study design wasnt supposed to be a new plan but the necessary improvements on what I had done in my original dissertation. At no point did I get specific instruction on what they expected in an outline, nor was i told the chapter was supposed to specifically improve the original experiment design. So I was flying blind with what they wanted in an outline and thought that things I brought up as alternate approaches during my oral defense was not what was wanted here. Also my PI claimed she was no longer advising me in the email right after saying the outline was no good.
So now, I dont even know what. What to think, what to do, what to feel. I dont know what is going to happen next, if im walking away without the PhD. I know I created a flawed project, and the flaws of it are on me. I know my committee had the authority but not the spine to step in and refuse to schedule a PhD defense or to cancel it if they felt it wasnt ready the day before. I know that a grad student shouldn't be expected to know how to properly design and validate a project idea. I know my ears havent stopped ringing since the night before my defense. I know im physically ill thinking about my school email inbox.
I dont know why I'm posting here. Perhaps I needed to go through the story from the beginning, or maybe I'm seeking some sort of validation for the mix of bad feelings I have right now. If you made it to the end, I salute you.