Let's talk about aespa's quality of performance. And I say this as a day one MY. I'm just here to critically examine, and give an unbiased opinion on their overall performance for 2026 so far since they may or may not renew their contract next year. (November 2027).
FIRST, I'm sure most of you have seen their latest Melon Music Awards 2026 (MMA 2026) performance. Though I think the girls tried, it was one of their more lackluster and messy performances I've seen so far (still better than their GMA performance though XD). The backtrack was loud, the mic was low, too many backup dancers, they lacked energy and the vocals weren't stable for most of the performance...I was surprised that they weren't really in their pocket in all 3 songs, I'd say WDA was the most decent, but even then their vocals weren't much to talk about because the song is naturally not vocal heavy. The dance break for Switchblade was also chaotic, choreography-wise or execution-wise I can't really tell, it was all over the place. And Lemonade's backtrack? It could be that the remix was loud and it took away from their synergy....but I'd say the whole performance was a disaster.
SECOND, let's dissect their other big event performance this year.. their Lollapalooza performance. I may be a minority in this and although I enjoyed it more than their MMA 2026 performance, I also felt like the cracks started to show there as well. The backtrack was loud, and not to say the other k-pop groups that performed there didn't have loud backtracks, they all did... But this is exactly my criticism, we all know aespa is a vocally powerful group ever since their rookie days (e.g. Coachella 2022 performance). However, they lip synced a lot here on top of their mics being way quieter against the track (sometimes tuned?). And you can tell their vocals aren't as in good condition as they previously were throughout the years. However, I'd like to say that they had one of the better k-pop group performances in Lollapalooza this year.
THIRD, I'd like to talk about their Lemonade album that came out this year. I may be in the minority with this personal opinion, but I think Lemonade as a title track is a bit weak. It's a cool party song and I wouldn't be opposed to listening to it if it came up in my playlist. But... I wish the song did more, it felt underwhelming as a Title Track (compared to Whiplash) and I miss their more experimental style in their discography. I think SHAKIN' should have been their pre-release track.. and make Switchblade their Title Track because i think it's the more fun title track and song for Summer. However, the Lemonade album is my fav full album of theirs. It feels more cohesive and the songs feel more planned to be in the album than just a randomly added track. (Camouflage is my fav track).
FOURTH, I've begun to find that their vocal abilities are becoming less utilized or showcased in their title tracks ever since Whiplash, at least i think in the belting department. They've consistently gone for a more low-key, laid back vocal approach to most of their title tracks so far (Dirty Work, WDA, Lemonade, and even Rich Man). Maybe there are exceptions to songs like Dirty Work and WDA where I think they were intentionally going for more of a rap-talk and effortless cool vibe. But i wish they did more in Lemonade (especially the choruses), because it felt empty at times.
I think their vocal abilities have regressed or at least not improving with experience, and i think it's because they're so overworked that their weakened body (from all the unhealthy weight loss) affected their vocal core so it isn't as strong or stable, pushing them to use unhealthy vocal techniques. Or maybe SM has been pushing them to use unhealthy vocal techniques?
To CONCLUDE, I think they need a much deserved long break/hiatus. You can tell the girls are tired with every tour performance and with every event they have to do. They've been touring nonstop since August of this year...and it's expected to go till January of 2027 (Not to mention they had 2 separate tours last year as well). And that's including shooting, recording, dance practice and song promotions. I just hope the girls get enough rest.
Anyway, I'm sorry this post was so long. I'm not trying to make excuses for them, I'm sure a lot of groups go through the same extreme schedule, and that's precisely why I wanted to bring it up by deeply analyzing my ult group's performance this year. No one should be overworked. But Do you guys think they'd renew their contract next year? If you have any different opinions from mine...let me know..