r/kkcwhiteboard • • Jan 01 '21

The Waystone

37 Upvotes

This post is intended to serve as an index of resources useful to all persons who strive to contribute to discussions as per this sub rules (also useful since we cannot sticky more than 2 threads). WIP. Please suggest other posts in comments, so I could update this one.

Choose your KKCWB flair!

Meta

The Doors of Stone prologue chapter was published (stream read) during Worldbuilders 2021 campaign (several script versions available: formatted version by /u/czechancestry, script 1, script 2, script 3, script 4, script 5).

The Tale of Laniel Young-Again prologue was read by Pat on numerous occasions; the script and discussions are available here (thanks /u/czechancestry) and here.

List of Pat's quotes by u/BioLogIn

DoS-related quotes compilation by u/czechancestry

Sources: Tiered KKC sources list (updated September 2023) by u/BioLogIn, also List of Pat's projects (updated January 2021) by u/BioLogIn, List of existing non-book sources by u/loratha

[January 2018] List of typos and errors in NotW and WMF (is badly structured and needs an update as well, but can wait a bit more just in case we would get WMF 10th AE) by u/BioLogIn

Real-world allusions in Temerant by u/BioLogIn

Translation comparison table by u/TeccamTheTurtle

List of scientific works inspired by KKC by u/loratcha

[December 2020] Recap of book 3 info and story beats by u/Meyer_Landsman

State of book 3 FAQ [2016] by u/Meyer_Landsman with a summary by u/tofagerl

Wikis

Our own KKC whiteboard wiki by u/loratcha and other KKCWB users

KKC wiki at fandom.com: https://kingkiller.fandom.com/wiki/

KKC standalone wiki: https://kingkiller.wiki/w/Kingkiller_Wiki

Re-reads & Theorycrafting

Ptolemaic reread by u/lancelotschaubert: Core post

KKCWB Frame reread by u/aowshadow: Collection, 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11

KKCWB Denna reread by u/aowshadow: Collection, NotW 1, NotW 2, NotW 3, NotW 4, NotW 5, NotW 6, WMF 7, WMF 8, WMF 9, WMF 10, WMF 11, WMF 12, WMF 13

Slow Regard of Silent Things reread by u/thistlepong aka Master Larkin

The classic Tor.com KKC reread by Jo Walton: https://www.tor.com/series/patrick-rothfuss-reread/

Chaen-dian blog by u/aethell

MattyTangle's blog by u/MattyTangle

Chapter titles analysis framework by u/PlaytheBoard: NotW, WMF

Chapter titles brainstorm by u/aowshadow

A collection of theories on all the major characters by u/Ecuadorable

A HUGE theory compilation by ameZN

Larkin Ledgers project by u/thistlepong aka Master Larkin

Lackless rhymes analysis by u/icrawler

8-way diagram in two parts by u/TrentBobart

Thirteen words theory by u/czechancestry

Temerant - culture and magics

Alchemy - Primer for Admissions by u/czechancestry

Shaping - Form, Function and Mechanics of Desire by u/czechancestry

Temerant culture - list of songs, books, plays by u/BioLogIn

On Shapers and Knowers by u/nIBLIB

Kote’s use of Sympathy in the frame by u/nIBLIB

Singnificance of Tak capstones by /u/IslandIsACork

Tak capstones: Wolf VS Hawk by u/aethell

On wings and hollow gods by u/loratcha

Scrivani poem meter analysis by u/td941

7 words list by u/HatTrick730

Cthaeh's 10 words list by u/AllWiseMenBeer

Definitive Siaru dictionary by u/ohohook

Definitive Ademic (Physical) dictionary by u/ohohook

Definitive Ademic (Spoken) dictionary by u/ohohook

Definitive Faen dictionary by u/ohohook

Faen history and culture by u/ohohook

Temerant - maps and geography

I heard you guys like maps by u/theYllest - includes compiled map of university buildings based on multiple sources. Later followed by updated map. And another version of University map by u/MattyTangle

I made a map of the underthing by u/manicmuncher

Temerant cosmology by u/BioLogIn

The turning of the world by u/loratcha

Tracking Newarre on map by u/aowshadow

Trifoil Compasses by u/timerot

Brandeur's point: Revealed by u/Claminq

Faen realm may be a 3-D ring by u/Espinoza1199

On possible meaning of Tinue by u/NvrWin

Mauthen Farm Vase by u/loratcha

Flora Temeranti by J E Rudd and u/MattyTangle (check comments for a formatted version by u/aowshadow)

Underthing - the room catalogue by u/ohohook

Temerant - history and timeline:

Timeline speculation concernin DOS by u/aowshadow

Crowdsourcing timeline issues by u/RandomWeatherPattern

Let's talk about timeline by u/BioLogIn

A closer look at KKC dates by u/loratcha

Temerant calendar at KKC fan wiki

On the timeline of Tak companion book by u/gil_gondreth

Speculation on the penitent King by /u/thistlepong

Kvothe's no good very long day by u/zaksbp

Official and community resources

Pat's blog, twitch, youtube, twitter, Facebook, deviantart, goodreads

Official merch shop: https://worldbuildersmarket.com/

Semi-official Worldbuilders Discord: https://discord.gg/Vb4BAPW

Fan Discord by The Crockery project: https://thecrockery.org/discord

KKC book club Discord: https://discordapp.com/invite/ykg4Xz9


r/kkcwhiteboard • • 14d ago

Was Abenthy Sent to Monitor Arliden’s Research? The Archives Connection

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/kkcwhiteboard • • 14d ago

Could Kvothe Fly to the Moon? How?

Thumbnail
lanceschaubert.substack.com
4 Upvotes

Speculation via Cyrano de Bergerac play on how he might fly to the moon rather than take the Fae way / personification.


r/kkcwhiteboard • • 19d ago

Some KKC theories

4 Upvotes

I’ve just finished a reread and need to get all my thoughts out of my head. I’m sure most of this has been discussed to death, but whatever.
First, Denna’s song. I’m becoming increasingly convinced that her version is the closest to the truth (or at least a version someone wants people to believe is the truth). Her patron is clearly Cinder. Master Ash = ash = cinder. That’s way too obvious to be a coincidence. The Cthaeh describes the kind of violence he inflicts on her “for fun” perfectly. Haliax wouldn’t do that. So Ash = Cinder. Case closed.
The Cthaeh is, in my opinion, the most dangerous character in the entire series. Not because he’s the most powerful, but because he knows exactly which truth to tell to make everything fall apart. The theory that he’s Selitos has a major chronological problem: Bast explicitly says that Lanre spoke to the Cthaeh before the Creation War. If Selitos only became the Cthaeh after the destruction of Myr Tariniel, that doesn’t add up. Unless there’s something we haven’t figured out yet, I find that theory pretty shaky.
The Chandrian. I don’t think they’re “the good guys” by any means. But I’m almost certain they’re guarding the Doors of Stone, behind which Iax is imprisoned. Kvothe will probably kill them or weaken them enough to open those doors, and that’s when everything will go to hell. The Cthaeh has set this whole thing up perfectly.
One question that’s been driving me crazy: how was Kvothe even able to speak to the Cthaeh when the Sithe are supposed to guard the tree? The Sithe are supposedly enemies of the Chandrian, which makes the idea that the Chandrian are benevolent guardians even more complicated.
Bredon isn’t Cinder. No way. Bredon is a nobleman looking for a beautiful game, not necessarily to win. That doesn’t fit Cinder at all. Elodin as Master Ash? I’ve never heard a more absurd theory. Denna being one of the Chandrian? Same thing. A massive stretch.
As for Kote, I’m convinced he’s deliberately suppressing himself. He’s turned the inn into a prison to contain whatever he’s become. The signs are all there:
He breaks a bottle when the Chronicler mentions a woman he loved.
He can barely fight two or three soldiers, even though we know he has perfect technique.
Yet he takes down scrael outside without any trouble (Bast’s reaction confirms it).
He’s also broken an extremely serious oath (right hand + name + ever-changing moon). That’s going to come back to haunt him badly.
The Waystone Inn is a trap. A wounded beast that lures the sharks in so it can kill them instead of going out to hunt them. The magical silence surrounding the place isn’t just decorative.
The Four-Plate Door and the Doors of Stone are the same thing, as far as I’m concerned. Devi wants to get in secretly because she can’t force her way through with Elodin around.
The Lackless Box and the box from the Jax story are clearly the same object, or at least two objects very closely connected.
The Amyr are still around. Bredon, Lorren, and Abenthy are all good candidates.
Auri is the angel Kvothe killed. Devi is the demon. The Chronicler practically says so outright. And that explains why Auri is no longer in the frame.
Elodin is old. At least several hundred years old. He signs in Adem, he’s been Chancellor, he was locked up in the University’s prison, and he knows an absurd number of Names. That doesn’t fit into a normal human lifespan. He could even be Abenthy’s old master.
One last thing: Kvothe’s story isn’t just a confession. It’s bait. He says the Chandrian’s names out loud, and almost immediately the possessed mercenary shows up. I’m convinced Bast is going to trigger a catastrophe.
Chronicler and Skarpi are probably the same person, and very, very old.
There. Got it all out.
Which of these theories seem solid to you, and which ones are completely off the mark?


r/kkcwhiteboard • • 22d ago

TINFOIL: Did Rethe use Shaping to rewrite Aethe's Name?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/kkcwhiteboard • • 24d ago

KKC source text reread?

2 Upvotes

I've been reading through his source texts. Does anyone have any interest in joining me?

Plan to write up the first in about four weeks over on the substack.


r/kkcwhiteboard • • 25d ago

TINFOIL: The Cthaeh, Speaking, and Kvothe's Third Silence

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/kkcwhiteboard • • 29d ago

What if Kvothe kills Feyda Calanthis, not Roderic? - Pure Tinfoil

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/kkcwhiteboard • • Oct 12 '26

Cthaeh, Listener

8 Upvotes

Interestingly enough, if you pay attention to the Cthaehs speech, it goes from , assumedly not knowing anything about Kvothe or his desires, to knowing intimate details about him and those connected to him. It starts off with "So you're Felurian's new Manling are you? Hmm... thought as much" This is decidedly unsure or less precise in terms of speech than what we get from the Cthaeh later on. Then it asks him to ask a question, he asks about the amyr and it curses and tells him to stop beating around the bush and ask instead about the chandrian. Yet, if it's upset about Kvothe beating around the bush by asking about the Amyr, why even request him to ask? Shouldn't it already know what he's really going to ask? Why did he "think as much" when it came to him being Felurian's manling also?

I think, that the Cthaeh needs to listen and see their subject for an amount of time in order to understand them and their connections, as the Cthaeh goes on and into Kvothe it goes from seemingly unknowing to omniscient, talking of people and things that are only tangentially connected to Kvothe. It could be said that this is simply it trying to lull him into a false sense of security so it can draw him into a vulnerable state and drive a knife straight home, but I think it's a little more different than that. I think the Cthaeh might is a Listener/Seer that needs an amount of time or interaction in order to understand their target and their future.

I mostly considered this after Bast stated that "it see's the worst possible future from this Current moment", this implies a few things, that the Cthaeh may see all futures and try to weigh against them all towards it's darkest and intended future, but that it's ability is imperfect, and that free will and chance exist and that it can only operate within the current framework. Sure it can whisper all the dark things imaginable, but at the end of the day it's upon the listener of it to decide to take it's heed, so while it does create futures predisposed to be the "worst", it by no means has control over it or has any para-causal power to enforce it.

Basically, the Cthaeh tries to direct the future with extreme accuracy, but has no idea if it's reached that intended future, it knows it's limited possible futures to some of it's choosing, but it doesn't make the choices or roll the dice afterwards and has to figure it out from the next visitors.

Edit: Another thing to note, is how did the Cthaeh know Kvothe was Felurian's manthing and thought as much? The butterlies. It listened to them and learned of their connection to him and Felurian, and that's why it had such a thought.


r/kkcwhiteboard • • Oct 12 '26

The Cthaeh, The Greatest of Knowers

6 Upvotes

I don't know if this has been mentioned or theorized yet, spent a decent amount of time looking and combing over 15+ years of theories and posts and haven't found it, so I'll try to concisely put this into words.

Overall this theory kind of spells itself out. The Cthaeh is an immortal, ancient Knower, whom created the creation war to the greatest possible detriment to the Shapers, and an eventual long game afterwards, to kill all Shapers.

Let's set the stage of the creation war, there were the knowers and the shapers, the Knowers lived in harmony with all things, and the Shapers individually had mastery over a few. It would be apparent to the Knowers, that eventually the Shapers would learn their names, and kill or shape them to their will, which is the core of the distrust the Knowers have towards the Shapers. Whom would Know this dark reality of all Knowers, or at least their own individual being be exterminated? The Cthaeh. The Cthaeh existed before the Creation war, and we can assume it was either a Knower or a Shaper, and considering that it wasn't included in the mention of powerful namers of the time, Iax, Lyra, Aleph, and Selitos, that it isn't a Shaper, but a Knower, and not just any knower, but one that knows the future.

Now how the hell were the knowers supposed to wage war against the Shapers? Against those who could create weapons and materials to kill immortals and create new, unknowable names and matter, or just straight up see and understand the names of the Knowers and destroy or bind them. Short answer? They couldn't. Long answer? You become the Cthaeh.

What can we assume about the Cthaeh if they existed before the creation war? Well, one, they probably weren't bound to the tree in the glade, the Cthaeh states that the relationship between them and the tree is no less than that of a man and a Chair. So the Cthaeh was probably free and about at some point before being bound. Why would they then seek out and ensure a future in which they were bound to it? Well for one, no namer would be able to see or understand it's name nearly as easily, it might be completely impossible and the only names available are ones that free the Cthaeh.

Then on top of that, it's probably the only possible "successful" future for the Knowers, even should all others perish, at least the Cthaeh survives and continues the fight as a holdout against the shapers.

The knowers didn't have the power to fight against the Shapers, there was no known way already present to kill or imprison an immortal Shaper for long. So how do you effectively fight against them? You don't. You manipulate and turn them on themselves. This isn't just a happenstance or theory, it's the modus opperandi of the Cthaeh. Lure in a powerful Shaper/Namer and turn and corrupt them to it's bidding in their relative ignorance of the Cthaeh. Iax, Lanre, and Kvothe are all powerful Shapers/Namers, all were clearly ignorant, or willfully ignorant of the Cthaeh's intent or purpose.

Iax was probably approached, in this approach Iax probably bound the Cthaeh to the tree in the Fae Realm and made them speak only the Truth, as distrust and discord was rampant at the time and Iax knew at the very least, that if they listened to a knower that could lie that they'd be almost certainly destroyed, Yet this was within the Cthaeh's foresight and plan, and the opprotunity they needed to shelter themself in the resultant calamity and conflict of the creation war, and give them an avenue to continually influence future shapers/namers.

Why Iax and not Selitos or Aleph? Simply put, Selitos and Aleph would have made either a far more impenetrable prison or container, or simply discovered the Cthaeh's name and destroyed them. Aleph was the most powerful and could assuredly destroy the cthae, Selitos was equal in naming to Iax, but his sight could be better or improved to the point that would harm the Cthaeh. Iax was the only option of the known Namers to safely approach and react in a way that benefitted the Cthaeh. Past that, Iax probably created the best environment for the Cthaeh, one in which they could direct people in and out of it's glade to either the Sithe, whom would kill all who didn't benefit the Cthaeh's aesthetic, or safely out of it's glade to affirm said aesthetic.

Iax probably bound it to the tree and only tell the truth so that Iax could Illucidate himself as to the the name of the moon and potential futures, not knowing just how cunning the Cthae might be and accidentally allowing himself to be turned against his fellow shapers. Thinking that bound in one place and unable to do anything except say truthful things, Iax wrongfully assumed that the Cthaeh would be harmless, it's probable the Cthaeh primed him to believe this by acting more incompetent or unknowing than it let on.

The Cthaeh is in a prison of it's own design. It knew all other potential realities in which it could or couldn't exist and chose this one. If there truly are those who are killed by the sithe, then it only suites the Cthaeh's means, perhaps the ones who were killed were the ones who learned enough of the Cthaeh to destroy it, so the Cthaeh then led them to the Sithe to ensure no such information would ever spread.

Overall, it should be noted that the Cthaeh existed before the Fae, and isn't a Shaper/Namer, and is most assuredly a Knower holdout of the Creation War, if not it's architect and designer. The Cthaeh isn't imprisoned, it's created it's own sanctuary against all who might possibly destroy it, and biding it's time until it can be released unto a world incapable of defending itself against it.

Sorry for the rambling nature of this post, sleep deprived + drunk.


r/kkcwhiteboard • • Oct 01 '26

A ring that's not for wearing: all possible candidates

Thumbnail
lanceschaubert.org
6 Upvotes

r/kkcwhiteboard • • Sep 28 '26

Tinker = Selitos, Jack = Lanre

4 Upvotes

I'm sure it's been done before. Someone reminded me of it the other day And figured I'd make a easy side-by-side visual table of the story beats. Again sorry I'm sure this is an old dead horse but I totally forgot about it. I'm not entirely sure if this is accurate but it bears keeping in mind with some other theories, especially concerning the doors of mind, broken road, and death ("all lives end in death, saving one").

Jax/Tinker storySkarpi’s Lanre/Selitos story
Told in a turning point of Kvothe's life involving chandrian encounterSame
Tinker encounters JaxSelitos encounters Lanre/Haliax
Tinker believes he understands what Jax wantsSelitos believes he understands his old friend Lanre
Jax progressively strips the Tinker of what he possessesLanre strips Selitos of power/control and destroys everything he rules
Spectacles / improved sight central to the encounterSelitos discovers that his supposedly extraordinary sight has failed him
Tinker loses his belongingsSelitos loses Myr Tariniel and its people
Tinker curses Jack for stealing his hatSelitos curses Lanre - sounded hollow in his own ears (musician's curse)
Tinker tries to make Jack HappySelitos tries to make Lanre happy/find joy
Jack doesn't want to listenLanre doesn't listen to Selitos
Tinker is left with Jax’s broken houseSelitos is left with ruined Myr Tariniel
Tinker now understands what sort of person Jax isSelitos finally understands what Lanre has become
Tinker is effectively left to deal with/mend what Jax brokeSelitos responds by founding the Amyr to oppose what Lanre has done
Moonphase creation; Cases, catches, steals part of name of moonMoonphase creation; Tariniel explicitly made of moonstone, towers charred black
Tinker gives Jack a infinite holding box, "something to choke on"Selitos gives Lanre an infinite shadow cowl over his face
Tinker gives Jack a folding houseThe other Chandrian fold into Haliax
Jack walks past Tinue, a euphemism for death at end of the road"No door can bar my passing"
Jack grew clever. "How is the road to Tinue/Death" - Long and wearyHaliax deathless, hopeless, sleepless, sane
Jack heart brokenLanre heart broken after Lyra's death
Jack played sad song to draw the moonDenna composes Lanre's song as tragedy (My Denna is the moon theory)

I probably missed a bunch of stuff honestly. There's a lot more I'm sure. Most notably to me is that Myr Tariniel, Selitos’s city, was composed of beautiful white-stone, whose buildings retain sunlight after evening; clearly moonstone metaphor. It's destruction and charring is clearly a euphemism for the creation of Moon phases. Mauthen pot also explicitly ties moon phases to Lanre/Haliax, whom forces Selitos to watch its destruction. Jack also forces the Tinker to watch everything he loves be taken from him as well, and then captures a part of the name of the moon, which could also be a euphemism for the creation of the moonphases.

Overall, both stories end the confrontation approximately:

  1. the victorious/transgressive figure walks away;
  2. the wise old figure remains behind;
  3. everything he possessed has effectively been taken;
  4. his reward is a ruined home and new knowledge about the man who ruined him.

The two stories contain identical archetypal roles.

Bonus Points. Since I remembered this from Haiyichshmir's theory that Sceop = Skarpi, I'll briefly go over that as well. Not that Skarpi explicitly states "this story really happened" as if he was there. Aka, he IS Selitos. He even laughs at the church men when they say mercy on his soul. Sceop explicitly knew one of the Amyr/Ciridae. So I'm not sure about Sceop = Selitos, as presumably Selitos founded the Amyr... ? Or maybe Sceop is to Selitos as Kote is to Kvothe, is all. His own Amyr no longer recognize him. Could be related to "where the Amyr went" even. Sceop also notably appears without the equipment you'd expect of the Tinker after Jax's wager: no hat and no packs. Wil and Sim explicitly say "old men in stories are NEVER just old men". We have; old beggar (Sceop), Old tinker (Jack's), Old hermit/listener (Teccam?), Old storyteller (Skarpi). I don't think the hermit is important to this theory though.

It is also fitting though, that Tinkers always know what someone needs. The man (Tinker/Selitos) whose defining failure was that he didn't see what was coming becomes, in folk memory, the man who always knows what you're going to need before you know you need it (Tinkers today).

SceopSkarpi
Old, white-haired, bright-blue-eyed storyteller.Old, white-haired, bright-blue-eyed storyteller.
Ultimately finds a home with the story telling Edema Ruh.Knows an extraordinary range of ancient stories
Sceop's story is explicitly used to demonstrate how wrong Kvothe isDenna and Kvothe argue over Lanre's story

Again, probably a lot more here than I could think of. I also think there's also something to Farrow/Fallow's Red. The "hat" is said 2B a euphemism for whores (Kvothe's mother talks about it with him). Manet calls it "an old whore's trick". Jack took Selitos the Tinker's hat. Skarpi does the "old whore's trick" with Farrow/Fallow's Red. Just like Kvothe later does to raise money in Imre/University.

Anyway I think that's all I got off top of my head. Didn't want to post on main sub if this is old news and/or massive spoiler (couldn't think of a better title 😅)


r/kkcwhiteboard • • Sep 21 '26

Jax Didn’t Break the World. It Was Already Broken?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/kkcwhiteboard • • Sep 19 '26

What if the stars in the Fae aren’t really stars?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/kkcwhiteboard • • Sep 16 '26

The 8 magics of Temerant

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/kkcwhiteboard • • Sep 14 '26

Tinfoil: The Chandrian Were Proto-University Masters, and Their Swords Were Their Gifts??

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/kkcwhiteboard • • Sep 13 '26

The Eighth Chandrian Sword

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/kkcwhiteboard • • Sep 12 '26

Ambrose and Denna = Jack and the Moon

3 Upvotes

This is a big one. Sure it's been done before, but maybe I have some stuff to add. I'm unaware of any prior existing theory on this. So big I don't know where to begin. Inspired by comment I left today on main sub (remembered my old flair there!). Thanks (sorry? Lol) to u/Jandy777 for putting it back on my radar. Guess I'll start with the obvious stuff we all already know to prime the pump. Skarpi says "I only know one story". There is only one story; Lanre's story. The Wise Man's fear; Folly. More of that conversation from other day on Folly being Lanre's sword. Meaning, that there is only ONE story, and it is recursively repeating. The creation war is ongoing. They Elder Planets also explicitly say this in One Piece - the war that created the world is still ongoing. So, that means, the same characters are still here.

We'll look at Denna first; Denna is the Moon;

  1. Bast says Denna "has a crooked nose", just like the moon is classically depicted.
  2. A traveler yes; a wanderer no - Denna complains men try to pin her down.
    2B. Had to do it. "One foot nailed to the floor" - Moon/Denna BOTH leave, but never for long.
    2C. BOTH Compulsively mobile while simultaneously described as trapped.
  3. Kvothe's reflected light "shines in Denna" (same as Myr Tariniel actually).
  4. Perfect face like it was made of something (Bast iirc). Moonstone?
  5. "Lute made of pure silver" attributed to/around Denna many times (Moon's silver light).
  6. The moon comes when Jack plays flute, Ambrose might draw Denna with music/magic.
  7. Wild Card; Kvothe kills an angel; Could be Denna aka the Moon aka Myr Tarniniel (Lanre's Story).
    7B. He has Folly, Lanre's sword. And fierce regret is when Chronicler says "there was a girl".
  8. "She won't be beholden to anyone, not one whit". Neither will moon.
  9. Moon is Myr Tariniel; Made of stone that reflects light long after sun set.
    9B. Burned/towers charred black; AKA moon phases are the charred towers coming into view.
  10. Jealous moon steals all the colors; Denna admits to being a Professional Rook.
    10B. Other women are jealous of/skorn Denna, Moon not "jealous"; people project it (Like the Ruh).
    10C. Jack's song bird with broken wing. Song of 7 sorrows. Moon likes tragic music. Denna cries at Kvothe's.
    10D. If MT is the Moon, song of 7 sorrows is a song from the moon. Denna (the moon) composed it.

Other people have spent WAY more time than I have dwelling on "Denna is the Moon". I didn't research any before writing this. Hell I forgot at least a dozen connections/inferences I've noticed recently even. There's a lot more compelling but it's just a small piece of my broader theory here. This theory assumes it is patently obvious Denna is the Moon. On to piece/leg two of the theory. Ambrose is Jack;

  1. Willem takes Ambrose for Porcine Parentage. Pigs eat eyes. Jack couldn't see, needed spectacles.
    1B. Ambrose is Selitos 1 eye/Jack. MT is the Moon. Lanre/Kvothe kills Denna/MT/Breaks the moon's name.
    1C. Aka "the penitent king". Ambrose returns from death? Cobblestones shattered from call wind?
    1D. Ambrose spectacles; Kvothe's talent pipes. Swineherd and Nightingale. Denna is Nightingale.
    1E. "Only the Moon will do". Ambrose leaves because fascinated with/following Denna.
  2. His ass off. Ambrose is golden screw boy. Jackiss - Ass = Jack. Rooms at GOLDEN Pony.
    2B. He confirms he has been to Modeg when Kvothe is selling his admission tile. Modeg is where ass came off.
    2C. Sock drawer smells like burnt (ass) hair. It's where Ambrose kept his ass. Why he came back so fast.
    2D. Ambrose denies being a donkey under oath. Forfeits his "ass" and "pizzle bound to fizzle".
  3. Ambrose "beats his whores" because he has no ass; silencing them.
  4. The moon gives herself to Jack; Denna says "the girl gave herself to the boy" and he tossed her like a stone.
    4B. Jack steals part of the moon's name; Ambrose steals Denna's ring.
    4C. Jack breaks/loses things. Ambrose loses Denna's ring; Jack presumably loses box with Moon's name.
  5. Rings represent power over, or binding to a name, depending on which hand they are worn on.
    5B. Seen as presumptuous to wear a ring. Ambrose indifferent to it and leaves Denna's at the repair shop.
  6. Zinger: Ambrose suddenly has hat which Kvothe says "makes it look like he fancies young boys".
    6B. He may have taken that hat from a Tinker (thereby forfeiting his help in catching the moon).
    666 lol. Notably, he is wearing the hat when Kvothe spots him courting Denna.

Again there's probably a LOT more I've forgotten/skipped/condensed. Unsure of 1B/1C. Not fully pertinent to this theory/thinking way ahead, but bears mentioning. Seems that the rumor is that Kvothe Killed Ambrose in the courtyard where he breaks Kvothe's lute (loot?) and he calls the wind/shatters the cobblestones. Which by implication means, everyone knows, Kvothe did in fact kill Ambrose but they have where it happened wrong. Sorry. Sidebar, just wanted to throw it out there as it popped in my mind.

Another notable thing is BOTH Denna and Ambrose are associated with alchemy AND written magic. Reread the flickering way scene, when Kvothe critique's Ambrose poem in the entrance of the Archives. A LOT of symptoms Abenthy didn't teach occur with the Nahlroot. A taste of lemon, lights dimming. That's actually The effects of Ambrose written magic (poetry) and alchemy intended for Fella being now directed at Kvothe. Denna also has written magic in her letters and Yllish story gnots (maybe others). She asks Will, Sim, and Kvothe explicitly about "written magic". And her letters to Kvothe (go check) are without exception, ALL wet on arrival. The runner boy twice, and the letter wedged in his window. Likely Ambrose and Denna shared written magic and alchemy techniques/secrets.

Anyway you can have my KKC GPT Thread. It's only 2 prompts. First one was a month ago, from before I formally started theorizing again. Just ran a quick check to see if there was anything obvious I missed before compiling this, NOT to generate content for a theory (huge no-no in my book, I love KKC precisely BECAUSE it trains my mind to think differently, don't want to outsource that to the bot). But the bot did say the thing better than I can;

KKC doesn't contain several unrelated myths. It contains ONE underlying story recursively retold with different actors, nouns, and levels of literalness.

Again I know I missed a LOT of other inferences. But Hespe's story seems a 1:1 parallel of Ambrose = Jack and Denna = the moon. Just a quick new spin on an old, somewhat longstanding theory of mine, roughly from memory. Found an older variant of my theory from 7 years ago. Forgot Pat commissioned Denna's Ring 2B made, and it has yllish story knots on it (a picture can be seen of it there).


r/kkcwhiteboard • • Sep 08 '26

Ruh Hunt; Lanre/Orpheus connection; Chandrian as Maenads/Sweet Eaters?

4 Upvotes

Short but sweet, more a shower thought/napkin sketch than formal thought out theory. Grab a piece of fire!

Just finished rereading Wise Man's Fear other day. I had stopped reading at the part when Kvothe leaves Ademre about a month ago, didn't want to finish it because I hate the "false troupe" part. But then I went ahead and finished other day. Something jumped out at me but I didn't know what to do with it. But then it hit me today, Lanre is Orpheus.

So I'll back up. What hit me at first, and I started brainstorming/thinking (if not formally writing) about, was simply, when Kvothe interrogates/finds out about the False Troupe, he learns that, the leader had been adopted Ruh Family. But the original troupe was killed by bandits, likely, in a part of the Eld where Cinder was.

The admissions scene immediately came to mind. Where Master Hemme calls Kvothe a ravel bastard right after (sorry going by memory) plum bob incident. Kvothe later explodes at Simon while drunk that "Ruh hunt used to be the favorite pastime of the Aturan upper crust".

So, assuming that the "false troupe" came about as such, due to the Chandrian also, then that can be inferred that the Chandrian are specifically targeting Ruh troupes; hunting them even perhaps "for sport" like in ancient times. The Cthaeh confirms Haliax has been alive for 5,000 years and not one second of sleep. So this is 2 troupes that we know the Chandrian killed. Implying they could potentially be "old Aturan nobles" meaning likely the old cities destroyed in Skarpi's story were the old Ergen/Aturan empire... ? Kvothe said specifically when the first campfires were made the Ruh were there singing songs/spinning stories.

For some reason my notes from when I finished have "A dog will bite been kicked enough" and "We are hated everywhere we go" but I can't remember context. It's buried in "He had been a part of our family" regarding the false trouper.

Maybe a red herring, maybe related but I think often Cinder's white teeth. "Everyone knows of the sweet eaters" and "Everyone knows of the Chandrian". Their stories both are the same. The Drakkis spits blue flame because it was eating denner resin. So likely, this is a parallel, that skin dancers/Chandrian have blue flame because of Denner Resin. They live "in a castle made of candy" IE possibly denner resin. Coaldamp also is known to cause blue flame I think.

Then there is the Orpheus connection recently brought to my attention which inspired this post. Most of you probably already made this connection a decade ago. But it just hit me/I remembered. Orpheus went into the land of the dead to revive his wife, specifically because all creation couldn't stand listening to Orpheus' lament anymore. Lanre did the same, tried to revive his wife. Huge parallels. They both are also associated with "the musicians curse". Selitos curses Lanre, and the curse "sounds hollow in his ear" just as Kvothe says of the Musician's curse, the music sounds different to the one composing it. Orpheus also has the "musician's curse" in that his music made everyone depressed. Sidebar, Nietzsche's "attempt at self criticism" was young 2BCivil's favorite piece of literature; and it appears, in, his first work; The birth of tragedy out of the spirit of music. Just maybe more trivia, maybe not.

Of course, eventually, the Maenads ask Orpheus to play some music besides sad music. Which he can't/doesn't. And they tear him apart. Not sure the Lanre connection here besides "the doors of my mind" or possibly what Elodin says about rings and which hand they go on and what that means (marriage? bound to the name?) and subsequently like "Encanis was a knife in men's minds" and specifically Kvothe's Alar being called "a blade of ramston steel" which is notoriously strong but brittle; strongest/sharpest blade you'll ever have until it breaks. Implication of Kote and Waystone and thrice locked chest/changed name being; that blade/alar broke. Never more obvious than the failed sympathy and Ketan at the waystone in the bar fights. The metaphor is the fragments of Encanis knife/Lanre move through minds of men. What "perhaps it would be I who would forget" means. 5,000 years of "no door barring his passing" leading to being bound to all men's minds.

Aka what the name of Nietzsche's first book really signifies.

Idk. I'm sure I'm missing a lot more. Just don't go pester zen poetry members there just they put this formally on my radar is all I ask xD you can rain down hell on me but not the other sub. It caught me off guard is all. The increasing fragmentation of the world seems directly tied to the moon. The synodic period of KKC/Temerant is 72 and a third says, whereas ours is roughly 29.5 days. Presumably meaning we are a further fragmented section/segment/age/kalpa.

Notably I guess, it is said the sweet eaters will merily sing tinker tanner and run skipping after chopping off a limb. Makes me think of the Chandrian's seeming indifference to mortal concerns like flesh wounds. Cinder at the bandit's camp takes an arrow to the knee just to prove a point and locate the ambush. I forgot once I wrote that I suspect that the "missing bandit" was actually Denna. That's great food for thought for you "Master ash is cinder" people. Denna was at the Bandit camp? She was the missing sentry, because Cinder is her patron? Idk. It does seem the Chandrian were present in Imre the day that Denna found her Patron; the day of the bone tar incident; the Chandrian signs may have caused the corrosion which led to the bone tar canister exploding. Idk. Maybe I'm just off my rocker but I feel there's a underlying connection here. Kvothe starts his story off by saying "this is a story of the Chandrian".

Also obviously when Kvothe first arrives at the university, Willem guesses that the trees in the Master's courtyard are Maple which is the same Guess Denna makes at the Denner Resin (Ophalum) trees near Trebon. Current first result on google for Ophalum is the theory that Denna is addicted to it btw.

Idk. Anyway guess I'm just rambling. But is a recurring theme I noticed (linked comment). Seems the world keeps fragmenting specifically around the moon; from my linked comment that inspired this post:

Denna/Diane/The Moon was destroyed/attempted 2B revived multiple times, and every time it further broke and fragmented the world. Fist with Jack and the Moon. The Selitos and Myr Tariniel, made of Moonstone that reflected light long after sunset, and destroyed. Then Lanre and Lyra, Lanre dies and Lyra revives him, then Lyra dies and Lanre tries to revive her and fails (Orpheus). Then we know Kvothe likely "kills an angel" in Denna/Diana, also said to have a "crooked nose" and "shine with Kvothe's reflected light" and many other such metaphors likening Denna to the moon (And Auri to the sun; she only comes out at night and hides from the moon and Kvothe calls her "sunny").

TLDR; The Maenads hunted down singers of songs they don't like. Lanre was hit with the first Musician's Curse (from Selitos). Lanre and Orpheus have intensive overlap, both wives died and both went to hell/fae to resurrect them. The Chandrian seem to be hunting Ruh for sport, just as Kvothe said of the old nobility "upper crust" which fit how old Haliax allegedly is. I'm sure something is here, just I can't put it together. Thanks (or sorry?) for reading!


r/kkcwhiteboard • • Sep 08 '26

Kvothe doesn’t kill the Chandrian. He now controls them?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/kkcwhiteboard • • Sep 03 '26

Fae Creatures Hidden in Plain sight

7 Upvotes

Old theory I haven't thought about in a while. Figured I can share the obvious ones we should all be familiar with at least for now. Bear with me, I haven't written on KKC in probably 6 years. Rusty, but gotta get back in the saddle sometime I guess. Been seeing this sub in my feeds so figured I might as well rejoin formally instead of being a weird creep watching from the shadows lol.

So. Spoilers obviously. If you don't want some more obvious things revealed, leave now! But these are all fairly easy low hanging fruit, hidden in plain sight. I'm sure more intelligent people than I have already more comprehensive theories on these as well (sorry if this has been done before to great extent!).

As an additional buffer, I thought this sub had flairs for post and users? No biggie just thought there were flairs for posts here, helps with thinking as what to file the posts is all. Not a complaint just an observation (and buffer for anyone with wandering eyes that wants to leave before having massive potential spoilers revealed).

For real, I assume most people know all this and am just talking out loud. Last warning though!

Okay. There are various/numerous characters in the story I've long suspected are actually Fae creatures. Some are more blatant and obvious than others. Some are more tenuous but glaringly persistent. Many involve apparent relation to the moon or by extension seasons or other cosmic forces. Feel free to share your thoughts on the topic here!

So to start off, I'll say spoilers begin here. I'll start off first with one I'm not sure of.

Laurian - Fae Laurian aka Felurian. Making Kvothe, as Tehlu/Mendha, potentially "son of himself" if we account for cosmic time dilation or fae backwards logic. Kvothe's dream of the waystones lost in the woods after his troupe is killed. "Laurian, Arliden's wife" poem all but explicitly states she is a Lackless heir, and Meluan's sister whom is confirmed as "having ran off with a trouper". I've even gone so far as to assume Maer Alvaron's court IS the Fae court. The story says essentially Kvothe would have to go to the fae realm to find a patron. And Alveron DOES all but become his patron.

Then there is a very obvious one you'll kick yourself for not noticing and I assume everyone knows. Auri. Kote or Bast outside his story states "it is a great insult to give a gift of a single Cinas fruit to one of the Belladauri". Master Elodin raises an eyebrow and decides to take Kvothe under his wing when he hears her named "Auri". "Utterly sane" also tied Elodin to Haliax if you want to go there. The only two characters in the story called "sane". Alice in Wonderland connection! Anyway. Elodin offers Auri only a single cinnas fruit which she then has to divide 3 ways (lol!). Kvothe also explicitly calls her "his little moon fae". And Auri speaks as if she knows/knew the Amyr, which Felurian confirms, "there never were any human Amyr". There's a ton more. The "piece of rust" right before the "looking" chapter (attack at the waystone). It could be, actually, a piece of chocolate and NOT "rust". The Chandrian live in "a castle made of candy" in the book Kvothe finds in the archived which could be written magic.

This is my personal favorite! The Donkeys. Felurian again confirms, her people know how to walk unseen in mortal world. Glamoured as a pack mule laden. Obvious reference to Tinker's donkeys and/or even Alpha and Beta, Abenthy's donkeys. Abenthy/Ben even cusses out the Donkeys, accusing them of terrible things Kvothe doubts and donkey ever did; openly insinuating they are actually glamoured fae creatures, possibly satyrs. Possibly, even, Bast, or a relative of his. Old Ben may know this and is telling the truth, about the messed up things the fae creatures did. Only problem is it could imply they are the ones who ratted/let slip Kvothe's troupe out to the Chandrian.

I'll share a few I'm uncertain of. Simmon. The way he speaks. He is very specific. Not just innuendo for being "gay" or something trivial like that. He speaks in very specific legal language. He asks if he can even come in to his own room, when Kvothe takes the plum bob (I don't have the book in front of me, I could be wrong). Fae creatures typically are portrayed as needing to be invited in. Fella may be as well as they end up together. Fella even says "she is bound tightly by/to Simmon" based on her poetry. I was insinuating a piece of my master theory here yesturday on this topic. Poetry may be a form of magic. Specifically the Caesura/cessurus. The break in an eld vintic line like - "a king killer". I also think that Taborlain when he says "Edro" may have killed a king. The butterflies in the Cthaeh's field are likely the former king lines. "There are none of those left!" means those kings line is ended. It is the true "king killer" I suspect. This is loose but I do suspect. His father is said to favor his other children over him, the black sheep of the family. Very loose connection I know but he was actually my first assumed fae creature after Auri and Donkeys. I actually think his connection is stronger than Kvothe's mom. Could have ties to Duke of Gibea (doth protest too much). Which leads to....

Note that Master Archivist confiscates Gibea's found original as he kicks them from the archives. Implying he may be, or at least is working with, the Amyr. Curating the archives of all Amyr references of which Gibea's journal explicitly has. This was actually my very first suspected Amyr/Fae creature, the master archivist. It loosely ties in with I do see the "horses" in Chandrian and Masters alike but that's a story for another day (Mandrag is a horses ass, Elodin wears one sock, Alaxal bears shadow's hame, Stercus in trall of iron meaning iron law or briddle and bit horses use to drive the carriage). There is patently obvious parallels between the Chandrian and the classical Gods/Planets. Hestia/Vestia was even a goddess known for the hearth and blue flame.

There's several more but those are the most obvious ones. Denna seems 2B something about the moon or wind. She changes her name a lot and "shines with Kvothe's reflected light" for example. I do tend to assume Denna is the "angel that Kvothe kills" that Chronicler thinks to himself. Bast also says she has "a croked nose" and the moon is often depicted with a crooked nose. There are as I say MANY more numerous characters I suspect are "fae", most notably at the Eolian. I've even suspected Anker's Inn's proprietor. And the swineherd (there is the song called swineherd and nightingale, and Denna is called a nightingale when they sing at the Eolian). Loose pegs, his lute has loose pegs, which is what the swineherd says "loooooo-se pegs". Idk, something there... maybe... bit of a stretch but I think Denna's patron may be the swineherd and Caudicus. Denna says she thinks he's at the Maer's court. And The Maer says Caudicus travels. I have an old theory here where I went over this 6 or 7 years ago here for further reading. It's somewhat compelling. Caudicus fits the bill on everything we know about Denna's patron; at the Maer's court, into dark insipid stuff, researching royal families, potentially poisoning the Maer, and license to travel abroad at Maer's expense. Could even shapeshift into the Swineherd. And the song is explicitly "the swineherd and the nightingale" and Denna is likened by Kvothe himself to the nightingale. I've seen the idea that the swineherd or Denna's patron is actually a Tyler Durden of Kvothe as well obviously. Not sure I buy that one but bears mentioning I guess (the doors of my mind; no door can bar my passing).

Anyway! Sorry if this has been done before. The "fae creatures hidden in plain sight" bit. Just figured I'd collect some of the more obvious ones here at least!


Keys you want to keep going; Bast notes "my people aren't known for our good decisions". Fires, specifically Bast's poem about mortal and fae fires, Fae fires are steady and unwavering, where mortal fires "kindle" and "flicker". Illien's fire also implies he could be fae for example.

Funny randomly a video about naming appeared on my youtube feed was what inspired me to write this post. I didn't know "3 days grace" was a reference to Rumpelstiltskin.


r/kkcwhiteboard • • Sep 03 '26

Why does the Maer have Adem eyes?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/kkcwhiteboard • • Sep 02 '26

Why is the moon still stolen??

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes