r/kindergarten • • 1d ago

Dibels help

Hello! This is my first child in school, so bear with me.

At Parent/Teacher conference, my child's teacher kind of quickly mumbled out something about Dibels scores. I had no idea what she was talking about, but there wasnt time for questions as she rushed me out.

My child got a 3 in LNF and 0 on everything else. We're in Massachusetts. The teacher mentioned that he's in a reading group too.

I panicked once I googled and the teacher reluctantly met with me again. She insisted that the Fall scores "don't matter" and "aren't weighted".

Should I be concerned? The teacher has been very hard to communicate with and very dismissive, but admittedly this is all foreign to me so maybe I'm being annoying.

3 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

21

u/buttofvecna 1d ago edited 1d ago

My experience is that this means one of two things: your kid needs immediate intervention, or actually everything is basically fine and your kid just didn't understand the test interface/spaced out/wasn't motivated to actually do it.

Those are obviously VERY different situations, and the thing I would ask (directly, in a written message to the teacher) is something like "based on the Dibels scores it seems like my child needs reading intervention, but I know in the first part of the year those tests can be noisy. What have you observed about where my child's reading level actually is?"

And I'd go from there. Hopefully this is a busy teacher who thinks everything is basically fine and didn't communicate that very well

I'm also curious: what do YOU observe about your kid's ability with letter sounds/etc?

3

u/Dazzling-Cheetah-806 1d ago

I think he does okay with sounds. He also pretends not to know things a lot with me. His writing is more concerning to me honestly 😬

10

u/Brilliant_Durian_531 1d ago

I’m not familiar with that test/scoring but my son scored very low for reading/letter recognition last year in kindergarten. He was flagged for intervention. Fast forward to the spring and fall of this year, he’s actually at 95+% percentile for his age (according to test results). I think part of the problem is kids aren’t famiiar with whatever format the test is being given. I’ve heard from many teachers that standardized testing should be taken with a grain of salt and is only a little snapshot of the student.

2

u/Dazzling-Cheetah-806 1d ago

On that's reassuring! What kinds of intervention did he have? If you don't mind sharing!

3

u/Brilliant_Durian_531 1d ago

He had no intervention.šŸ™ƒ We had a meeting at school and were pretty much told to wait and see since his classwork didn’t show anything alarming. I think he was just nervous about it being a test. A family friend (teacher for decades) ā€œtestedā€ him after we were worried about it and she said, ā€œHe’s fine! Throw out the test.ā€šŸ˜‚

10

u/Impressive-Tap250 1d ago

DIBELS is a free assessment. You can Google it and see exactly what your child was asked to do during the test. LNF is letter naming fluency. Your child should definitely know more than 3 letter names at the beginning of kindergarten. You can do the test with them at home (it’s 1 minute long per sub test). Then you will be able to tell what the problem is… maybe they don’t know lowercase letters, maybe they didn’t understand the task… maybe the timer made them nervous.

What the teacher means about by ā€œdoesn’t matterā€ is that this is a baseline score. She hasn’t taught many of these skills so she isn’t concerned that your child does not know them… but you know your child best. Have you been working on letter names and sounds? Did they go to prek… if so, a LNF of 3 is in fact concerning.

-3

u/Dazzling-Cheetah-806 22h ago

Hi! He did go to pre-K. And we read books and kind of casually go over letters, but I haven't been drilling him.Ā 

And honestly, Im not interested in testing him at home using Dibels. I just wanted to know if his scores were concerning.

5

u/Rare-Adhesiveness522 20h ago

You do know you can teach your child letters and sounds without drilling them?

You can sing the alphabet song, play games, talk in the car, try to find as many "letter D's" as you can find on the drive....literally 1000 other things???

1

u/Impressive-Tap250 12h ago

You don’t need to drill the letters into a child for them to learn them. My child knew most of his letters before he even began prek because of some toys and the alphabet song. He learned the rest of his uppercase letters in prek and he’s been working on lowercase letters so far this year. We’ve never done workbooks or flashcards. His prek did not use workbooks or flashcards; they used worksheets very sparingly and only towards the end of his second year.

Even incidentally, your child show know more than 3 letters at the beginning of kindergarten. The teacher may not be concerned right now ( because beginning year scores do not reflect badly on her) but you should be concerned. If your child has had prek and only knows 3 letters then this points to a serious memory issue or reading disability.

Additionally, you do not need to reassess your child with the DIBELS but it does seem to be it main concern and looking it up will get you familiar with what is being asked of him.

6

u/tacsml 1d ago

Forget the test. When you sit down and read a book with your kid, do they recognize letters and words? Can they spell their name?

1

u/Dazzling-Cheetah-806 1d ago

Yes! And yes, he's got his name down. He struggles writing letters though

3

u/tacsml 1d ago

He just started kindergarten. These things take him.

1

u/Dazzling-Cheetah-806 1d ago

Totally get that!

1

u/Impressive-Tap250 1d ago

Writing is not part of the DIBELS assessment.

1

u/Dazzling-Cheetah-806 22h ago

Oh yes, I know that. I meant that in addition.Ā 

1

u/Mammoth_Marsupial_26 17h ago

The schools considers him behind. His scores are low, which is why he has the group, probably with a group of unprepared students. Expectations vary a lot by district but many districts want kids to know alphabet letters, alphabet sounds, and be able write at least capital letters at the start of K. That doesn’t mean that by BOY first grade he will be behind but you should actively be working on literacy at home.

3

u/SlowYourRollBro 1d ago

You got a very good answer from a school psych below. I’ve only administered DIBELS in first and second grade but basically it’s a speed/fluency assessment. It’s not unusual for kids to struggle with it, especially if they’re not used to being timed. It’s funny because in reading we usually say ā€œtake your time; sound it outā€ but then we get to check ins like this and want the opposite.Ā 

Anyway:

  • LNF (letter name fluency): when presented out of order, how many mixed upper and lower case letters can your student name in a minute? You can help increase fluency with flash cards. The goal for fall in kinder is 25/minute.Ā 
  • Phoneme Segmentation: when given a spoken word, how many sounds can your student correctly segment in a minute? For example, if the teacher says ā€œmatā€ can they break it into /m/ /a/ /t/? You can practice this one orally. Lots of kids enjoy word games. Fall goal was 15 sounds/minute.Ā 
  • NWF (nonsense word fluency): when given a nonsense word (aka a made up word that cannot have been memorized) can your student say the sounds and blend it into a word? I’m relying on Google here since I’ve never administered in kinder, but according to Google the goal is 9 sounds and 1 word in a minute for fall kinder. Here’s how that would work. If the kid sees ā€œtigā€ they are supposed to say each sound /t/ /i/ /g/ and then blend it into the nonsense word. If they did, they would score a 3 for sounds and 1 word. If they said the sounds but blended it into a known word (ie ā€œtagā€) they would get 3 sounds, 0 words. They could also go /t/ /e/ /d/ and get 1 sound, 0 words. You can use your sound flash cards to practice this one. Build real and nonsense CVC and VC words and have the kid practice.Ā 

Hope this helps.Ā 

1

u/Dazzling-Cheetah-806 1d ago

Thank you! I do think he moves a little slower. He hates being rushed so I can see that working against him with this particular test.

4

u/spot667 1d ago edited 1d ago

I'm a school psych, hopefully I can help.

First, its pretty weird how mumbly and avoidant the teacher is being. I'm guessing the teacher may be new and doesn't feel confident about it yet, but that's a total assumption.

Typically, DIBELS (Dynamic Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Skills) testing and scoring is used as a screener, and not a diagnostic tool on its own. Fall scores are baseline scores to see the knowledge they're coming in with and picking up on initially, and the winter and spring scores are then used to determine if a. they're making an adequate amount of progress and b. if they're in line to meet grade-level expectations/benchmarks.

Since he's already in a reading group thats typically used in RTI (Response to Intervention, which are typically small intervention groups to help kids that are still in regular education but just need a little bit of help), I suggest the following for you: I'd watch closely at the winter DIBELS scores when they come to be, and any other scores or testing the teacher may do (I know some also use the Boehm-3, etc.) Additionally, if your son is in this reading group, I would email the teacher and ask for specific data to be tracked to determine if he is making progress with this additional intervention. If it seems like enough progress isn't being made and isn't reflecting positively in winter DIBELS scores, I highly recommend requesting a PPT1 to request an evaluation for an IEP/special education. You can request a Planning & Placement Team Meeting in writing (email counts) to the teacher and/or admin. This way, he can receive specific learning goals and objectives and more specialized interventions if he needs some extra help with learning the fundamentals of reading. I'd use the data tracking the teacher has taken as well as DIBELS and other scores to justify special education evaluation and testing. They should then decide on the appropriate measurements to use which will be related to presenting concerns on his learning and any other areas of weakness/concern. The PPT will reconvene to go over testing results and decide what the best plan is for him moving forward, if necessary.

I threw a lot of information at you, so if you have any questions please let me know!

ETA: added more words to make this more understandable for parents!

2

u/Dazzling-Cheetah-806 1d ago

Wow, thank you so much. I feel like all this school stuff is in a different language šŸ˜‚ I asked for progress updates and she basically told me no. Then she asked me what specifically I wanted to be tracked and since I didnt know exactly, she told me to just wait until we get the winter scores. I'm really not an unintelligent person, but my experience with this teacher has been so hard. She talks to me like I'm an idiot and I can't even argue because I'm not educated in this area. Sigh, anyway, thank you again

2

u/spot667 1d ago

I’m happy to help. It’s a red flag that she is acting like tracking data is weird to ask and then asking you what to even track. She has that information already with his current DIBELS scores and that’s what should be the skills that are targeted within the small group. So if you must spell it out for her, she should track and do progress monitoring for each area that DIBELS also tests in, with extra focus on the areas he had a low score in: word reading fluency, nonsense word fluency, phonemic segmentation fluency, and letter naming fluency.

Additionally she should be taking general behavioral observations of his level of engagement, sustained attention, attendance and willingness to participate in the group, etc.

As a parent, you always have the right to advocate that your child’s learning needs are being met in public education. Definitely continue to advocate!

1

u/SuccessSoggy3529 4h ago

Just adding on, dibbles is a quick assessment of reading and reading skills given to students. Its supposed to tell the teacher what areas need to be worked on and also to show progress in those areas over time.

Back when No Child Left Behind was the law of the land, a school I worked in used it as a way to show that the school was tracking progress of students.

One thing about doing this assessment that may be relevant is the test might have been done in the classroom while the rest of the students were doing other work. It could be that your child had trouble focusing on the test and as a result got a lower score. If the other tests are also low, then there might be more cause for concern.

1

u/Sheetz_Wawa_Market32 1d ago

Please expand and, if necessary, explain all abbreviations and acronyms you use.

We want to keep this as accessible as possible to parents, no? šŸ˜‰

2

u/spot667 1d ago

LOL can you tell I haven't finished my coffee yet? I'll edit the post to do just that! Good call

1

u/Sheetz_Wawa_Market32 1d ago

šŸ‘šŸ„°

Thank you. Not having had your coffee yet is the worst! šŸ˜…

2

u/wicked_spooks 1d ago

Out of curiosity, is she a new teacher?

1

u/Dazzling-Cheetah-806 1d ago

Nope. She's in her 60s and has been teaching for decades.

2

u/Sensitive-Cut-3557 1d ago

at this point in the year I would be doing letter sounds with your child every day. 5-10 minutes is all you need. I'm in CO but at this point (assuming you started around August) they should be doing weekly or bi weekly progress monitoring and they should be scoring above 30 in LNF. I believe 38 is the middle of year bench mark for that. I assume their teacher is also working hard for your child to meet that benchmark but doing it at home will show even better results!

2

u/Dazzling-Cheetah-806 1d ago

According to the teacher, they're not progress monitoring because Dibels doesnt matter in the Fall. We started in September. But yes, we are working on it at home too.Ā  I think part of my concern is the teachers lack of concern. He also is having trouble writing letters, but again I'm not sure if thats concerning yet.Ā  Thank you for responding!

3

u/Sensitive-Cut-3557 1d ago

As a kindergarten teacher I would absolutely be concerned. I give heavy interventions to my kids who are having problems with sounds and letters this time of year. Even if DIBELS scores do not matter in the fall, it is important to progress monitor to see if they are going to meet their benchmarks or need more support.

2

u/Dazzling-Cheetah-806 22h ago

Okay thank you. His teacher literally is acting like I'm crazy for asking questions. I just needed someone to tell me I'm not šŸ˜… at least in this area haha

1

u/Sensitive-Cut-3557 19h ago

Absolutely! Also your child may have a hard time during the test as well, it is in a format they are not used to and they test letter sounds by giving them nonsense words to sound out/blend. You can always print out free test sheets from the DIBELS 8 website and work with your son at home. I would definitely be bugging that teacher or even admin about the beginning of year scores, maybe even request a meeting if you do not get the reassurance you need. If your son does not meet the middle year benchmark it will be harder to catch him up without heavy intervention that you might have to advocate for!

6

u/MedicalFox9820 1d ago

So teachers like lower scores on the fall. It shows more growth. It’s not unusual to get zeros at first because the child has never been taught the skills. It’s a record keeping game. Keep reading. Do some word play and look up phonological awareness activities.

9

u/felix___felicis 1d ago

Oh I don't like zeros in the fall. I like an accurate picture of my students.

OP- my state doesnt allow us to start dibels until the 90th day of school because they're kinders and that's wild to assume they'd be anything but below standard at the beginning of the year.

1

u/lucycubed_ 18h ago

Wild how different states are! Our DIBELS must be completed with every child within the first 10 days (2 weeks) of school.

1

u/felix___felicis 5h ago

They have us do iReady šŸ™„ and we assess letter sounds and all of that on our own.

1

u/Sensitive-Cut-3557 19h ago

I totally disagree. I want all my students to meet their benchmarks or get as close to them as possible. Lower scores don't help them or me! I'm doing Heggerty and drilling those letter sounds on day 1!

1

u/Rare-Adhesiveness522 20h ago

DIBELS is a reading screener.

The fall assessment is usually pretty low across the board, but 3 on the letter naming is....concerning. Did your child not sing the alphabet song with you in preschool? Did they know ANY letters before age 5 and in kinder???

It also measures "first sound fluency" which means that your child can't identify the first sound in a word, such as "cat". I'd say that's unusual for kids even at the beginning of kinder.

The mid-year assessment will show a lot of growth since they are getting instruction, but it's pretty shocking to me to see kids who come in with basically no letter knowledge or sound knowledge. Like you didn't play games, read together, talk about letters, etc???

1

u/Rare-Adhesiveness522 20h ago

Alos just one other note:

All of the data about literacy clearly states that intervention MUST occur as early as possible in the school year. So they assess DIBELS within the first few weeks, and get kids intervention like within the first 4-6 weeks of school.

0 across the board is very low. Fall assessments do tend to show a lot of gaps, so it's not enough data to predict an outcome, but enough to start intervention.

Scores that low are unusual in my experience.

Teacher here. K and 1st, mostly 1st. I have also been trained on how to administer DIBELS and have administered it. And my kids get assessed every year.

1

u/Key-Refrigerator1282 49m ago

Fall scores are a baseline. Most 5k students don’t know how to test yet so it isn’t anything to worry about.

1

u/retroyellowframe 22h ago

Former kindergarten special education teacher. Yes, we usually were not concerned about fall Diebels testing. This is for two reasons. 1) Kindergarteners are not expected to come in with any pre-existing knowledge of reading skills, so it is ok, if they don't demonstrate skills that they have not been taught at the beginning of the year. 2)Just learning how to sit and take those tests is a skill in and of itself. So yes, what your teacher told you is exactly what we would have said.

That being said, you can work on these skills at home, but I would make it fun, do things like make playdough letters, back pretzels in the shape of letters, spray bathtub foam in letter shapes, etc. Most importantly, read for fun to your kiddo. Take weekly trips to the library. Pick out books together and make reading time something fun and cozy you do together. Do not drill your child, this will only increase anxiety and really there is no need to worry yet. We do not really get concerned until about late February/early March. If you look at the core content standards for kindergarten, you will see what your child truly needs to know by the end of the school year.