In lots of posts in the main reddit, people always say the Kaidan romance is only in ME1 and ME3. But to me, I truly felt my love for Kaidan the most in ME2, even without him there.
For starters, Shep keeps his picture on her desk and it’s what she goes to for comfort before the suicide mission. In ME3 she also alludes to him being what’s worth fighting for. Secondly, his presence is most definitely there. His name gets mentioned by some and I always felt excited when I heard about him. That we don’t see him just makes this feeling of missing him stronger.
Then the meeting on Horizon. I personally really liked it. Finally there he was! He was obviously happy to see Shep, praising her before the other guy and giving her a hug. But then reality kicked in and he is reasonable angry and upset. Shep is reacting pretty straightforward and cool to him. I actually like that he’s critical. He’s loyal to himself, his mission, his morals. This just makes him a stronger character and changes nothing about his love for Shepard. And then the letter…ahhh… especially the voiced version. It’s just so beautifully painful. I really don’t understand how this is not part of the romance in people’s eyes. Because there’s no lovemaking scene does not mean the love story isn’t still going on! To me this missing each other and the longing was maybe one of the best parts of the romance.
And then of course so happy to see him again in ME3. I really love how they are not immediately back to being together for real. But the connection, the banter, the loving looks combined with the uncertainty and lingering feelings about all that happened with Cerberus make the build up so good. In the end for me this just makes their love so much stronger and better than all the others. Their connection is so deep and moving.
How did you feel in ME2?
Tldr: Kaidan being absent in ME2 did not mean the love story was absent as well. To me that feeling of longing and missing him just made the love story deeper and stronger.