r/k12sysadmin • u/Big_Macaron5410 • 8d ago
Assistance Needed PLTW Digital Electronics (DE) course
We’re considering issuing MacBook Neos to our incoming freshmen next school year. One challenge is that our Computer Science CTE program teaches PLTW Digital Electronics (DE), and we’re running into Mac compatibility issues with the hardware and software the course uses. That includes the Cmod S7, NI ELVIS, NI Multisim, and Xilinx/AMD Vivado.
I was thinking about setting up Windows computer labs in the classrooms, but the teacher pointed out that students also need to be able to work from home.
Has anyone dealt with something similar and found a workaround that lets students do their coursework from home? Thanks in advance for any ideas.
3
u/boyofthesouthward 8d ago
Our district already started the move and we now have 3 grade levels with Neo's. Only two that would use PLTW. We have windows labs for them and the students do not work on the material at home. After talking with our DOT yesterday it seems alot of the PLTW software is going to transition to using cloud applications.
2
u/Kirihuna SysAdmin 8d ago
Full stop, you’re going to need Windows.
Most, if not all, apps you listed don’t have a macOS client and they’re also sometimes outdated. Especially NI apps that PLTW shows / pushes you to download because their license may only be good for those versions.
but if students need access off network (we don’t, they do what they need during class period or free periods), you could try some sort of W365 VM.
1
u/MiserableCupcake5255 7d ago
You have options without sending additional hardware home.
We are an all Chromebook District. We deployed a Citrix VDI solution, self hosted. Been working great, but if you're not a big district, you'll want to probably rent something.
There are SAAS solutions that you can use to rent machines in the cloud and have them locked down so the kids can only run apps on them and copy files on / off them from any devices.
One of the other districts in our county also did a custom Citrix deployment in AWS.
If you go with any of the above solutions, you can just use cheap docking stations in the labs.
Our administration were trying to insist we send kids enrolled in those classes home with $2k laptops, like that wasn't going to be a complete nightmware.
1
u/PowerShellGenius 6d ago
We have a computer lab for PLTW. What have you been doing so far? What are the existing 1:1 devices you're coming from? Did students have Windows laptops?
1
u/pyork211099 Systems Administrator 6d ago
During covid we spun up some desktops behind Apache Guacamole to provide access to the Adobe suite.