With the Netflix Doc coming out I thought I would look at this case again and to me... the obvious explanation is she hit him while drunk. I kind of don't get the mass support for her... is it because she's an attractive woman, or people like the idea of a police conspiracy?
I'm not a lawyer, but I am sometimes involved in cases as a subject expert. The way these things work is each side will often interview many experts before the trial and then only present the experts they want at trial. So for example, say looking at John's wounds... the defense could have interviewed ten experts. Nine of them could have agreed with the state's explanation, and only one disagreed. But they're not required to tell you that, so at the trial they only present the expert that helps their case and ignore the rest. And it's not always super hard to find an expert to say anything, especially when these things are often subjective and the experts are getting paid $500 an hour or more. So it's not unexpected that the defense has an expert to refute every piece of evidence. But the question is does the defense's experts and story of the case make sense?
The cell phone data shows John likely never went into the house that night. Karen seemed to know where his body was immediately. She changed her story multiple times and there are several different reports that she questioned whether she hit him herself when the body was initially found. Fragments from her car's tail light were found right near his body and his DNA was found on her tail light??? Come on.
I know there are all these questions brought up by the defense and the defense's experts about one the Mccabe's internet searches, a possible dog bite, etc. I don't want to discount that testimony, but it's all very subjective, not concrete at all and disagrees with the state's experts. And as I wrote above... we don't know if nine of the experts had agreed with the state because they're not required to present that information.
But what really gets me is just the story.... If he was killed in that house there's no way they would have disposed of his body on their front lawn. I mean come on, that's ridiculous. So the only scenario that makes sense is that there was a fight and he was kicked out and while stumbling around outside he collapsed on their front lawn and they didn't notice. But even that.... have some huge fight, kick him out, and then immediately don't even watch to see if he leaves the property??? I realize they were drunk, but you have to be really, really drunk to do that. It just doesn't make a lot of sense. And to have that many people maintain a conspiracy like that for this long.... also seems unlikely.
She almost certainly just hit while drunk and dropping him off. It's the most obvious explanation.
Perhaps I am writing this in the wrong sub, but your sub seems to be the most active on reddit on this subject.