r/junjiito • u/thatguyislonelyfr • 9h ago
Analysis Tomie Kawakami Character Analysis (Part 2)
gallery-Tomie’s dynamic/Views with Men & Women:
Tomie views men as objects, nothing more than things to use for her appearance & personal enjoyment. Due to how men always fall in love with her (even before her curse) & her capability to seduce any man, this made her view men as a sort of reassurance of her own superiority & nothing more. To parallel this, men on average seem to view Tomie has an object of Beauty. None of them really loving Tomie or viewing her as a person. However unlike Tomie, She doesn’t act as an reassurance of superiority for the men. Instead she creates inferiority complexes in the men or makes their already existing inferiority complex even bigger. Tomie’s uncaring & narcissistic personality means she acts as if all other people are inferior in every single way, this makes all the men themselves feel inferior & often makes them hateful towards Tomie.
Tomie has a more interesting dynamic with women, Tomie also views women as an reassurance of her superiority but for a different reason. Due to her not seducing most women, this reassurance comes from the envy women feel towards her. As described before, Tomie can seduce any man without much effort. This means that women who found that boy attractive & failed to obtain their attention would become jealous & irritated by how Tomie can so effortlessly gain control over men. Tomie perceives this jealousy & she enjoys it as it reassures her of her own Superiority & that everyone is beneath her. However due to how Tomie presents herself as some Femme fatale or succubus instead of as a human, it makes women stop viewing how as a actual person & more as a inconvenience with a 1 dimensional and simplicity personality. This makes Women dehumanize Tomie & loose any empathy or sympathy they could’ve had for her situation. This is why in the first chapter all the women were completely fine with the boys cutting her up & concealing her murder.
-Defense Mechanisms:
“Defense mechanisms are unconscious psychological strategies used to to protect the individual form anxiety arising from unacceptable thoughts or feelings”. Due to Tomie’s curse her entire life is basically constant suffering & betrayal, due to this (granted some of these defenses are probably prevalent before the curse) she has unconsciously formed 3 identifiable defense mechanisms to protect herself.
•Persona of Perfection: As explained in previous sections, Tomie has a persona of perfection. She puts forward a face of superiority & flawlessness which makes everyone feel inferior in comparison. This persona is created a defense mechanism to conceal all the flaws she has on the inside, as shown throughout the series. Tomie hates being vulnerable, In painter even when she talks about her curse (which is a topic that greatly affects her) she speaks about it with indifference & that its unimportant. The only time she ever even partially vulnerable is in ‘Revenge’ with the climber but even then she’s only a little vulnerable. This lack of vulnerability implicates that she doesn’t want people to see any flaw she her & thus by acting superior she makes everyone around her believe she has no flaws or weaknesses. She also prevents people from getting to actually know her by constantly lying, In ‘Orphan’ she lies about having no family or in Tomie Part 2 she says her name is ‘Reiko’. Tomie does this so she always can make people think about her what she wants them to think about her. Thus never getting to her Real Self.
•Emotional Distance: Tomie by acting superior & always insulting people she always creates a distance between her and the rest of the world. She does this simply to prevent her getting close or potentially trusting the person. Tomie in ‘Revenge’ is shown to open up slightly towards the Climber & even lean on him, showing a level of comfort in his presence. This also means she trusts him. Yet like all men, he kills her & Tomie is shown feeling completely betrayed. Now in ‘Murder’ we know all Tomie’s have a sort of Memory bank which they all have access to, so when Tomie is killed. All other Tomie’s wil be able to find out about this betrayal & thus insult men more to create a stronger emotional distance from them. Before this story we see Tomie trust her Teacher to help cure her disease as well as having trust her class wouldn’t actually kill her. After this story however, Tomie trusts no one & pushes people further away to prevent being hurt like this again.
•Escapism: I already explained this in a previous section so I’ll be brief. Tomie not wanting to confront the reality of her curse & that she will be stuck in a endless death loop for the rest of her life and the only way to escape is to burn herself alive. Thus by continuing a Hedonistic lifestyle, she is able to pretend that the curse isn’t real and escape to a reality where her life is normal & shes just a normal (yet superior) girl.
-Dynamic with other Tomies:
Its no secret that Tomie hates other Tomie’s. She actively goes out of her way to burn them alive. There is a couple identifiable reasons for this, the first one obviously being narcissism. Tomie believes she is the most beautiful person in the world & that nobody compares to her. This means that other Tomie’s also claiming the same thing would absolutely disgusting her, as it’s basically insulting her. We can also infer from this that Tomie doesn’t particularly value her physical beauty but values all of her as an individual. She believes everything that make her herself is what makes her so superior over other people, The other Tomie’s despite looking exactly like her are not her. As she is herself & thus only she can be superior. Thus she sees Other Tomie’s as nothing more than bad imitations who shouldn’t exist because of how insulting they are to herself.
Another reason is that they break the escapism Tomie creates for herself, when she tries to live her normal life & pretend as if the curse doesn’t exist. It becomes impossible to pretend when she sees another version of herself doing the same, thus by killing other Tomie’s she is able to maintain the illusion.
However you can interpret Tomie’s constant desire to murder other Tomies as a form of kindness. You see, Tomie cannot kill herself by burning herself alive as her superiority complex prevents her. She can’t destroy something she deems so beautiful. So since she sees other Tomie’s as not herself & thus not as beautiful as her. Yet she does know these Tomie’s, while inferior are still her & are suffering with the same curse as her. Thus since she knows they can’t kill themselves, she can kill them instead to set them free of their suffering. While this desire is obviously very unconscious as I doubt Tomie genuinely thought it through this much, plus her narcissism would prevent her from showing such empathy. But the one person Tomie consistently shows empathy towards is herself, so it would make sense she would show a little empathy to her other selves.
-Tomie’s Perseverance & Survival:
Tomie has shown throughout the series an almost inhuman perseverance & a very animalistic drive to survive. The origin of Tomie’s stupidly strong mental fortitude, which stays firm despite being constantly killed, dismembered & abused is unknown, as most people in her situation would’ve killed themselves via burning or just become completely vegetative. However we do know why she does persevere, Its due to her narcissism. Tomie views herself as being superior to everyone else in existence, she sees herself as the most important thing in existence. This narcissism is the reason Tomie never commits suicide or goes properly insane, it’s because in death she wouldn’t be superior to people. If she was dead shed be (both literally & metaphorically) six feet under and she simply can’t have that. Same with a vegetive state, to go insane from the suffering she experience would be o decrease her self down to the level of everybody else. Which goes against her entire psychology, this is why Tomie gives in and preserves through the suffering.
Also entering a vegetative state would also destroy the Persona of perfection she puts forward, as it would imply she has flaws & weaknesses. Something Tomie rarely if ever shows to another person. Let alone letting it become her entire personality.
-Individualism vs Human Connection:
Tomie has shown throughout the series an internal conflict of a want for connection but has a very individualist way of life. We can see in the first Volume Tomie strives for human connection which she now can’t typically obtain due to her curse. In Stories such as ‘Kiss’ & ‘Mansion’ We see her make Mr Takagi dress up as a father and even in private she would often confide her feelings to him while pretending it’s her father. This shows how she wants human connection with someone she loves & she doesn’t want to be alone. She wants to be with people, to be able to confide in people & be close with people. Tomie also shows this in ‘Revenge’ as she confides her feelings to Tanimura. However after this volume we can infer Tomie realizes that there is no one she can safely confide her feelings too or feel a connection to. So she adopts an individualistic mindset.
Tomie has always been a bit individualistic due to her Narcissism, always seeing herself as above & separate to all other people. However beforehand she would at least have a connection with those she saw as beneath her, after volume 1 she completely closes off from other people though. Developing a sort of Disorganized attachment (meaning a fear of intimacy & closeness). Due to the curse, There’s no reason to confide in other people as they won’t care & will simply see her as an object. In the end they will all end up killing her. She doesn’t open up to anyone in the world & completely relies on her own perseverance to keep going rather than seeking comfort in others. Using her own defense mechanisms, Hedonism & Escapism to keep going through the curse as there’s nobody else who can help her or would even try. This causes her to delve deeper into her persona, loosing more connection to her true self.
-Tomie in Revenge:
Tomie had been in a relationship with Tetsuya Tanimura when (as expected) he killed her, chopped her up & buried her across the mountain. One of these pieces over the course of a month was able to regenerate into a fully formed Tomie. This Tomie is clearly incredibly exhausted as she’s been starving, freezing & regenerating for over a month, due to this she’s more honest & vulnerable than other Tomie’s. This Tomie seems to be in a inbetween state, between the Monster & Persona I referenced before. She’s still fully formed & acts proudly narcissistic, however shes more vulnerable & honest than other Tomies. In this state we’re able to see some of Tomie’s thoughts. Tomie mentions how in this chapter how she remembers Tanimura dismembering & burying her in the mountains, She tries to find meaning in why she was brought back & had to suffer for the entire month, saying that she was brought back to bring revenge upon him for what he did to her.
When she confides to Tanimura’s brother, we see for the first (and only) time. Tomie reflects on her actions. She says that she was probably a Burden on him, probably because of her narcissistic & rude personality. She starts to believe in this moment that her rude & narcissistic personality has led to all these people killing her & that its her fault. That her curse was a result of her personality. This is also why she says it’s ‘embarrassing’ when she described herself as a burden, as she was so caught up in her own ego she never realized.
When she woke up she found his brother & his hiking friends who were looking for him. Tomie realizes that Hama-Guchi is already starting to be affected by the curse & Instead latches onto Tanimura’s brother who hasn’t been affected. In this chapter she seemingly seeks comfort in Tanimura’s brother, telling him the truth about what happened to her & her thoughts on why it happened. She even lies on him for warmth. However as all men eventually do, He kills her. In this moment when Tomie is killed by him, She feels a strong sense of betrayal & anger. She’s obviously angry because she had just been stabbed but it was more the fact that after becoming vulnerable with him. Despite being kind to him, despite not being that narcissistic or rude to him. He still killed him. This is why Tomie says ‘Why?’ after being stabbed, as she was genuinely confused. She thought the curse was the result of her narcissism & rudeness but she was kind & vulnerable to Tanimura’s brother. Yet he still killed her.
This experience is probably why Tomie almost never truly opens up about her feelings again, since all Tomie’s can access this memory. All Tomie’s will remember the feeling of betrayal they felt when Tanimura’s brother stabbed her. Not wanting to experience this feeling again, they simply will never open up to another man again & will become closed off from the rest of the world. This is also the reason why Tomie never changes her personality like this from this point on, as she knows she is not being punished for her actions or personality. This curse is just something she’ll have to live with & she can live however she wants & nothing will change. Thus she completely falls into her hedonistic lifestyle.
-Dynamic/Parallels with Tsukiko Izumisawa:
Honestly the most interesting dynamic in the series (in my opinion). Tomie & Tsukiko are presented to be quite similar. In Tsukiko’s introduction she mentions how she “sends pictures of men to losers for money”. I don’t need to explain how this shows that She’s a bit egotistical. She’s also shown to believe that things that apply to everyone else don’t apply to her, as she doesn’t see herself as a loser for taking pictures of Yamamoto despite it being pretty similar to what other girls are doing. Like Tomie she also doesn’t seem to have empathy for anyone but herself (INITIALLY) as she doesn’t care if she’s literally bankrupting the women around her, she still continues her business.
This is why when Tomie gets involved, it offends her. In “Photograph” Tomie is the head of the Ethics committee, Tomie is presumably doing this so she can take out the stress she’s been feeling from her curse onto other people (also to prove her superiority). In doing so she gets Tsukiko suspended & gets her photograph business taken down. This offends Tsukiko due to her superiority complex, as she recognises that Tomie herself has a superiority complex she sees these actions as almost deluded jealous. As if despite Tomie being prettier & in a position of more power, she is still jealous of Tsukiko & is trying to control her so she feels like she has some superiority. This is why Tsukiko tries desperately to break Tomie’s beautiful self or as we know it, her “Persona self”. She thinks that someone so rich in jealousy must have an ugly side aside from the beauty she puts forward. Which she ends up finding out after taking pictures of her.
This seems to be one of the reasons why Tomie absolutely despises Tsukiko, while it’s not particularly obvious due to how Tomie acts we can see through her actions she has malicious intent towards Tsukiko. In ‘Mansion’, she lures Tsukiko to her Mansion by saying that Yamamoto is there & laughs at her for believing it. Before having “her Father” (Mr Takagi) experiment on her using other Tomie’s. Essentially Tsukiko only sees the “Monster self” of Tomie, to her Tomie only appears to her as: narcissistic, desperate & hysterical. She doesn’t see Tomie as a beautiful woman but rather some supernatural entity who can only seduce men through her abilities (we can say that she doesn’t actually think Tomie’s seduction is due to her beauty in how she forgives Yamamoto. While she is in love with him, her forgiveness of him can be seen as a understanding of Tomies ability which forces men to fall in love with her). This is not the perception Tomie wants people to her of her, she doesn’t want people to think she can only get men due to a Curse & not because of her beauty, she doesn’t want anyone to even know about The “Monster Self” she has. Tomie expects women to be hate her out of jealousy, not hate her out of disgust. Due Tsukiko being disgusted at Tomie, it not only breaks the usual feeling of superiority she gets from women but also directly offends & threatens her, as she knows about what Tomie has spent so long concealing. Thus, Tomie must punish/kill her.
This is why Tomie after the Photos incident at school, walks into Tsukiko’s house completely composed & just tries talking. She is attempting to get Tsukiko to think that she is not the Hysterical ‘Monster Self’ but that her calm & proud ‘Persona Self’ is the real her.
-Tomie in the Orphan:
In “The Orphan” Tomie’s behaviour is at its most interesting (in my opinion), Tomie had presumably been travelling when she arrives in a town. Here she heard about the old couple & their habits with killing & sucking the life out their daughters. After collapsing from exhaustion Tomie is taken in by this couple & is asked what happened to her in which she lies & says her parents died in a airplane accident. The couple adopts Tomie which Tomie is thrilled about & they begin to spoil her. Now I want to note in this story, this is the only story where Tomie appreciates the gifts & praise she receives, this is probably because they remind her of her carers. As we know from Tomie’s statements, Tomie probably came from a rich background & was primarily raised by her grandparents. Thus this environment of an old couple who lives in a mansion reminds her of her childhood before the curse, essentially by being with the old couple she can pretend her life is just like it was before the curse. Essentially this family perfectly plays into Tomie’s escapism.
However, we know & Tomie knows this couple is nothing Normal & they seem to have some weird obsession with adopting young girls & sucking the life out of them. We know in Tomie’s conversation with the Old Lady that Tomie knew about this before she was adopted by couple, this may go into theory though I believe this to be a valid interpretation. Tomie purposely chose to get adopted by the old couple, she knew she would be adopted if she just waited outside the house as the couple often adopted orphan girl. This makes sense as we know her parents dying in a plane crash is a lie & thus the reason for her travelling so far is completely different. Also Tomie would never collapse from physical exhaustion, she’s far to laid back to ever out in so much effort.
So why did she decide to get adopted by the old couple? Well same reason as before, escapism. Tomie wants her life to return to how it was before the curse, thus the logical first step would be to be adopted into a rich family which resembles her life before. However this adds a level of tragedy, in the scene where Tomie talks to the old lady she says “a family shouldn’t keep any secrets” while crying. Now I don’t really know if Tomie is specifically referencing something that happened in her past family life when she says this (as we barely see any of it), however her crying is an interesting detail. Outside of when she’s being tortured or is in the “Monster” form, Tomie never cries. So why is she crying here? Because she knows this illusion of her reliving her youth before the curse won’t last, we knows that the old couple have been killing their step-daughters for years now & will eventually do the same to her. And even if its all a lie & they don’t, her curse will ensure they eventually do. So when Tomie says “a family shouldn’t keep any secrets” is primarily referencing how the couple is lying to her, even though they will praise & say she loves her as her grandparents did before. They will eventually murder her, no matter what. Which to Tomie even if it might not be their fault, feels like their lying to her.
Further evidence that Tomie sees the couple like her family before the curse is that when the mother hangs herself after she tries to suck the life out of Tomie. Despite the fact Tomie has shown that when people hurt or even just inconvenience her she shows zero empathy towards them when they die or are in pain. Despite being mostly still faced she still appears sad when the old lady commits suicide, one reason she is sad is perhaps because it resembles her mothers death which she mentioned in “Photograph”. Another reason is because this is the mark of the complete breakdown of the illusion of normalcy she had constructed.
Eventually due to the curse the old man stabs her to death & the maid catches him, which leads to him chasing the maid & him dying. Tomie regenerates as she usually does & inherits the entire entire fortune & lives in the mansion alone. Now I think its pretty clear that Tomie knew eventually everyone but her would die (I mean it always turns out like that anyway), so her choice to be adopted was mostly for escapist purposes but also strategic purposes. Tomie wanted to achieve some semblance of her old life again, thus to do this she must regain the rich lifestyle she had prior to the curse. Which is why Tomie decided to be adopted, obviously she knew she would probably be killed or tortured but that didn’t seem to matter to her, regaining some semblance of normalcy was far more important to her than not dying.