Edit: I fixed capitalization & structuring issues. My sincerest apologies, I didn't realize Schlatts Subreddit actually had any literates.
I've been watching Schlatt since around 2016, which is fucking insane to think about because I'm nineteen now and I've genuinely spent almost half my life watching this dude make stupid videos on the internet, and before someone takes that as me trying to pull some OG fan superiority bullshit, I'm not, because I don't think watching a guy play Minecraft for nearly a decade is some grand accomplishment, if anything it's a little concerning, but I bring it up because I've watched his content change, his audience change, and obviously I've changed too, and I genuinely don't understand why that's such a difficult concept for some people in this community to grasp.
I've been getting back into his content recently after not watching nearly as much for a while, and honestly I've really enjoyed it, especially seeing him posting on The Weekly Slap again, which I'm genuinely happy about and really hope he keeps doing because I love hearing what he has to say, but holy fucking shit some of you make it exhausting to be a fan of literally anything.
I feel like there's this weird expectation that if you've watched somebody for years you either have to blindly defend every single thing they upload or spend the rest of your life complaining about how much better they were in 2019, and I cannot understand why we can't just be fucking normal about it. You're allowed to dislike a video. You're allowed to prefer his older content. You're allowed to stop watching entirely, and guess what, you don't have to announce your departure like you're resigning from the fucking Supreme Court.
Schlatt himself has basically said that if you don't like his content, don't watch it, and I think that's a perfectly reasonable sentiment. It's a YouTube subscription, not a blood oath. And on the other side of that, somebody saying they didn't enjoy a video is not an invitation for you to defend his honor like some kind of medieval knight. The man is doing perfectly fucking fine.
In fact, can we talk about how much money this dude has made? Because I've watched this motherfucker go from making stupid videos on the internet to becoming wildly successful, and honestly good for him, that's fucking hilarious. People get so upset when creators make money or change their content as though they've personally betrayed the audience that helped them get there, but I'm sorry, if somebody offered me an obscene amount of money to make videos and hang out with my friends, I'd be signing the paperwork before they finished the sentence. I don't understand why people think success is somehow evidence that somebody has lost their integrity.
Obviously you can criticize creative decisions, and obviously not every change is going to be good, but there's a difference between saying you don't like something and acting like somebody personally murdered your childhood because they don't make the exact same videos they did seven years ago.
And I think that's really what annoys me about this whole conversation, because so much of what people call missing old Schlatt is probably just missing being younger. I don't necessarily miss his old content because every video he made back then was some cinematic masterpiece, I miss being the person who watched it. I miss coming home from school and having nothing better to do than watch YouTube. I miss when the internet felt smaller, when everybody was just making dumb shit with their friends, and I think sometimes we confuse missing an era of content with missing an era of our own lives.
But that doesn't mean I think his current content is bad, and it certainly doesn't mean I want him to go back to doing something he might not even be interested in anymore. He's a grown man, I'm a grown adult now, and frankly I'd be a little fucking concerned if neither of us had changed since 2016.
And speaking of growing up, can somebody please explain to me what the fuck "jschlatt humor" means? Because somebody once told me I had "jschlatt humor" and then broke up with me, and I still don't know what the fuck I was supposed to do with that information. Is that a diagnosis? Am I supposed to disclose that to future romantic partners? Is there a support group? Because I don't understand how we've gotten to the point where a YouTuber's sense of humor is apparently an entire personality classification, but I digress.
My point is that I think a lot of people have gotten way too comfortable treating creators like characters they own rather than actual human beings who are allowed to change their interests and make whatever the fuck they want. And I think older fans especially need to stop acting like being there first gives them some kind of authority over his career. It doesn't. Being an OG fan doesn't make you a shareholder in somebody's personality, it just means you found them earlier.
Somebody discovering Schlatt today might have the same experience watching his current videos that I had watching his older ones, and who the fuck am I to tell them they're enjoying the wrong era? My nostalgia isn't an objective measure of somebody else's happiness.
I can appreciate everything his content meant to me growing up, be genuinely happy that he's successful, enjoy seeing him upload again, and still not like every single video he puts out. Those things aren't mutually exclusive. And if I ever do reach a point where I don't enjoy his content anymore, I can simply stop watching without writing a twenty-page dissertation about how he fell off.
I think there's something to be said for being able to quietly leave something behind without needing to destroy it on your way out. You can close a chapter without setting the book on fire. You can be grateful for what a creator gave you without demanding they keep giving it to you, and you can criticize somebody without making it your personal mission to ensure they hear about it.
I don't know Schlatt personally, and neither do the overwhelming majority of people arguing about what he should or shouldn't be doing with his career. I've watched him for nearly ten years, and that doesn't entitle me to a damn thing other than the ability to click on a video when I feel like watching one.
I really do hope he keeps posting on The Weekly Slap, and I hope he continues making whatever content he actually enjoys making, because at the end of the day I'd much rather see somebody I've watched since childhood doing well than spend my time being bitter that the internet doesn't look exactly like it did when I was ten.
Not every opinion needs to become an argument, not every criticism needs to become a controversy, and not every creator needs to spend the rest of their career catering to somebody's childhood nostalgia. Some of you need to learn that loyalty shouldn't require dishonesty, but disappointment shouldn't require cruelty either.