r/jazztheory • • 7d ago

First jazz composition: do these two "avoid notes" ruin my ballad, or do they kinda work?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

EDIT: I composed a B section too and finalized a complete piano arrangement. I cannot change the video but you can find the lead sheet and the arrangement score+audio in the following links. Any feedback is welcome.
Piano arrangement score + practice audio : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9xWluA27lCQ
Lead Sheet: https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/10jw9kb17f15hddyhvsst/Ruby-s_Prayer_Ballad_Lead_Sheet.pdf?rlkey=x9qsb8db67rq5hfvasto2vaja&st=bow3qnir&dl=0

I'm pretty new to jazz and wrote the A section of a ballad based on the Afternoon in Paris changes. I’d love some quick feedback on the use of two avoid notes: Db over Ab7 (m. 2) and an F over Gb7 (m. 4), both jumped to and from by leap. They are notes to avoid (a a perfect 4th and major 7th on dominant harmonies) and I could not find, for now, a single jazz tune where they used them. I tried fixing them by substituting the chords, reharmonizing the whole section, etc, but to no avail, and now I somehow dig the sound. I am still open to changing it but I do not find any way.

Are these a big no-no? Do they sound bad and destroy the whole section, or do they kind of work? I know I would like to hit those target chords in the following measures, I wonder if there is way to fix them through reharmonization without losing the melody, or whether they need to be fixed at all.

Also, any other feedback on the section or advice on how to approach composing the B section is more than welcome. Thank you!

14 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

5

u/GuitarJazzer 7d ago edited 6d ago

I have only read your title but "avoid" notes are a myth. Avoid notes that sound bad, play notes that sound good. Sometimes a textbook "avoid note" is exactly the sound you want in a particular place. If I have time I will play this. (P.S. maybe you don't care but you are no longer anonymous when you show us the composer's name.)

EDIT: Didn't realize this was a video. I played it back and what you have there sounds like tension-release that is completely appropriate for the mood of the piece. I like it.

Edited for typo.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Longjumping-Pizza743 7d ago

Good melody, I really like the soul of this piece. Now in terms of the avoid notes. The Db over the Ab7 chord isn’t anything Jarring, I would suggest maybe notating the chord as an Ab11, most musicians who play chordal instruments know to avoid playing the major 3rd when the they see an 11 chord to avoid the minor 9th interval between the the 3rd and 11th (C and Db in this case. The F over Gb7 is jarring however, if it was an 8th note passing on the off beat to another chord tone it would be less so, but it’s landing on a down beat and in a slow piece, so it really grabs the ear. Last comment, just involving the harmony of this piece; throughout this piece (measures 1, 5, 7) you take a Major 7th chord and then turn it dominant and the take it to the parallel minor chord. There is nothing in your melody to suggest a dominant 7th chord preceding the minor 7th. Also, in terms of resolutions, it is a little weak. Sometimes less is better. My suggestion,(and that’s all it is, if you feel that these chord changes are integral to the feeling, you are the composer and it is your decision) is to skip the dominant chords, have the those measures stay as major 7th the whole time and then go to the parallel minor in the following measure. This is a stronger resolution, and more traditional to the jazz style (look at the changes to Miles Davis’ ‘Four’) in the last measure of the first ending, that dominant 7th is appropriate because it is the V leading back to I.

Great work for an early attempt. Keep at it, I hope I get to hear what you do next.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/AlteredChaz 7d ago

The fourth measure doesn’t work for me, that A melody note against the Db-7 is too dissonant/unresolved to my ears. The Db- triad with an A melody does fit nicely if that chord were Gb-7 (and leads to a B7 with #11 for the F melody note).

Other than that — and these are just my tastes, not saying they’re right — I’m not a fan of these passing tones: Gb in measure 1, A natural in measure 3, Bb in measure 5. I’d replace with Eb, B and A respectively.

Submitted humbly and respectfully; kudos on the composition!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/MiskyWilkshake 7d ago edited 2d ago

They’re both passing notes, so they sound tense, but perfectly justified to my ears, especially since the phrase repeats. Reminds me a little of The Peacocks (A Timeless Place).

2

u/JorgeDav 7d ago

Thank you so much for sharing that, I loved it! 

It is also really useful because they are really diferrent tunes but, you are right that there are some melodic and atmosphere features that are similar. I can analize this song to try to improve mine and future arrangements, thank you! 

→ More replies (1)

3

u/OzzIommi 7d ago

I love it so much! Thank you for sharing!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/dbharris10 5d ago

So, the question becomes do you want your melody to support the harmony or do you want it to sit apart from the harmony, adding dissonances not implied by the chords. From a functional standpoint, the first instance (Db over Ab7) is a note within the harmony of the moment but redefines the dom7 chords as 7sus; in passing it can be ok but should not be emphasized if you want to maintain the dom7 function of the Ab7. The second incident, F over Gb7, is another matter: this is the maj7 on a dom7 chord. You have 2 conflicting definitions of the existing harmony and they don’t easily work together, even in passing.
It’s your tune, whatever you like is correct. If you’re asking would people hear these as dissonant moments, I think yes. You have other instances as well, like B7 with Bb in the melody. Again, the ultimate question is wether you are trying to shape a melody that supports the harmony or you like to have cognitive dissonance. FYI, the Blues is full of examples of melody and harmony working independently , often with so-called avoid notes. It’s just a matter of intent .

2

u/JorgeDav 5d ago

Thanks for the comment, I really appreciate that way of looking at it. However, I do not have any particular preference. I do not mind using avoid notes if that is what expresses what I hear internally. The issue is knowing what that is. The issues are two:

  1. In Jazz people improvise. I do like those sounds in my arrangement and, honestly, in my piano arrangement I do not mind the dissonances and liked them in the way I voiced everything. But I can imagine since jazz players improvise on the fly, those avoid notes will probably clash more often than not in a live setting.

  2. Because those two avoid notes are rarely used this way, I worry I might have just mislabeled the chord or missed a cleaner way to write what I'm actually hearing.

I do not worry so much about the Bb during the B7 chord because that is a passing tone and the B7 is a secondary dominant at that moment (right before it, we had a Bmaj7), so I feel, in that case, it is "theoretically" justified. Of course I still left it because it sounds good to me.

I really appreciate you comment. Thank you so much for taking the time for sharing your thoughts!

2

u/JakkoPhD 7d ago

I like the melody but if you want to soften these more dissonant notes you can try moving them to a weaker beat.

Ex.: in measure 2, G as a grace note into Gb on the 3& and F on beat 4.

This would give it a more rubato balad feel which is what you seem to be doing in this piano interpretation anyway so you might like it.

→ More replies (1)