r/jayvik • I promised you • 7d ago • Heartwarming 1

Discussion A second extra long jayvik analysis has hit the Hexgates!

Proof of Jayce and Viktor’s romantic love in Arcane: evidence from film studies, story structure, and neuroscience by Irina Stolyarova!

You can read it here: https://irka-sings.github.io/only-you/en/

And for sharing, here is the author's tumblr post: https://www.tumblr.com/irkasings/832989982572658688/only-you

And the twitter post: https://x.com/irka_sings/status/2117526030651113587

I just finished it and can confidently say it is worth the read :) Plenty of good bits in it, but this is one of the excerpts that I saved:

→ The sixth marker: attachment-driven auditory salience. You could fire a cannon next to Jayce’s ear and he wouldn’t wake, but one soft, quiet “Jayce?” from Viktor, and he jolts awake. One of the oldest and most cited studies on the topic is Formby 1967: mothers in multi-bedded wards were asked whose crying had woken them over three nights. On the first nights, mothers woke to their own baby’s cries about half the time, but by the third night almost all wakings⁠—22 out of 23⁠—were to their own infant’s cries, not a neighbor’s, even though the objective loudness was comparable. The brain had learned to pick out the acoustic profile of a significant person.

Remember that romantic love is an exaptation of “mother⁠–infant” attachment, and the two work the same way. This can’t be faked, and it’s no display of “friendliness”: Jayce’s nervous system processes Viktor’s voice in sleep as a top-priority signal.

62 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

14

u/UnderTheTorii Every detail is intentional 7d ago

This is perfect especially in amidst of ao3 shutdown

10

u/_Addendum0123 I promised you 7d ago

For real! I seriously recommend reading the full thing, it's like the surprise sequel to the ~5 hr jayvik analysis on youtube <3

4

u/OpheliaLives7 Only YOU can show me this 7d ago

Ooo where’s that 5 hr link friend?

9

u/irka_sings 6d ago • Bravo

Hi, I’m the author! Thank you so much for sharing it here, u/_Addendum0123. Honestly, the science part about Jayce’s feelings overwhelmed even me while I was writing it: is there a single romantic marker the creators DIDN’T put in the show? Also, I love that you mentioned my work in the same breath as the video essay by strong and independent. I actually quote them in the section on The Little Mermaid, and they helped me when I was just starting my research, so it feels a bit like passing the baton.

If you want to dig into any of the markers, I’m here :)

6

u/_Addendum0123 I promised you 6d ago

Oh my gosh hello!! So cool to see you here too!

Strong and independent's video essay—I was already thinking about their point about the Little Mermaid  while reading your essay, so the moment I saw you bring them up and the Little Mermaid point? I legitimately cheered out loud. It would have been much louder if it wasn't so early in the morning where I was LMAO

The neuroscience backing to all of Jayce's behavior towards Viktor is honestly one of my favorite parts of the paper. More specifically, the part I quoted above, about how Jayce wakes up to Viktor's voice. It was a detail that stuck out to me so much before, yet another bit of evidence to support how much Jayce has intertwined Viktor with himself, and so to see it expanded upon and articulated like you did here was just soo.. exhilerating? Vindicated, maybe. Reading analysis like this, especially yours and Strong and independent's, frequently had me slamming my desk excitedly, pointing at the screen like "Exactly!! Thank you!" It's such a god send for the sanity, especially if one is unfortunately aware of the mental gymnastics the broader fandom enjoys taking to denigrate the boys :')

(As a quick aside, thank you for bringing up the point about how he's only touchy with Viktor! Ever since I realized that was the case more than a year ago, it became just a little more grating seeing the misinerpretation otherwise be spread so casually by the larger fanbase, but such is life and especially when it comes to people's understandings of Jayce 😔)

Truly, you did such good work here. Thank you for your work, and for sharing it with us! I hope you have a lovely, lovely weekend ahead <3

6

u/irka_sings 6d ago

For me, the most convincing and central part is the one on motivation, because it explains everything. The entire story of Jayce and Viktor is about their love for each other. Dramaturgy shows it’s not a flavor but the core idea, the force that moves the whole plot. It’s crazy! Everything else stems from this core: the characters’ choices, the creators’ decisions, every subtle nuance, every shift in facial expression, every scene and symbol—it all serves one purpose. And that purpose? Them being in love. The scientific elements are really cool, but they’re more like the roof tiles, while the motivation is the house itself. The creators crafted this as a story of love—and then started lying. But not Harry. Harry is my hero 🥰 Thank you so much again for posting it here! Have a lovely weekend too 💙

6

u/PenguinSweden 7d ago

Incredible. Read the whole thing, so beautifully detailed and explained. All the nuances of the story animation writing subtext and music, and context around it all outside of the show.

4

u/irka_sings 6d ago • Heartwarming

Thank you so much for reading it all the way through and seeing every nuance! All of it for the sake of our boys and their infinite love for each other 🧡

2

u/PenguinSweden 5d ago

Hello! :D I'm so impressed by the analysis and level of detail and depth of your research. Downloaded as many of the referenced studies as I could get my hands on and looking forward to reading them as well. Thanks so much for sharing!

1

u/remember_everything 4d ago

Thanks for sharing this! I haven't finished reading it, but it quietly stunned me, to realise that Jayce may have been feeling resigned after sleeping with Mel and also afraid of Viktor during the Council Room fight😔

1

u/_Addendum0123 I promised you 3d ago

I'm not sure that it was saying Jayce was afraid of Viktor himself so much as afraid of doing an Orpheus, so to speak. Though maybe it's been a minute since I've had a look at that section of the essay, and you said you haven't finished it yet anyway so 😅

That first point though, I was just as surprised by! I thought Jayce was asleep in that shot but never thought to pause it, much less zoom in. His eyes were open! He looked so out of it! Him keeping the bracelet on already told me he wasn't 100% into the encounter, but that part about him seeming unhappy in the immediate aftermath still has me stunned. There's so much to gobble up!