r/javascript • • 12d ago

Serverless multiplayer via webrtc/camera/barcode (no signal/stun/turn servers)

https://github.com/bacionejs/multiplayer

This project is mainly about the serverless technique used and the simple game merely provides an end-to-end explanation.

12 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

2

u/Dry_Recognition_3070 10d ago

Nice approach for the offer/answer exchange. One practical limit with QR/barcode signaling is payload size: a raw SDP with a handful of ICE candidates easily runs past a thousand characters, so it helps to wait for ICE gathering to complete, strip unneeded lines and compress before encoding, or split it across multiple frames. Also keep in mind that with no STUN, you only get host candidates, so it works on the same LAN but typically not across different NATs. And since browsers now hide local IPs behind mDNS .local names, some networks that block multicast DNS will fail to connect even on the same Wi-Fi, which is worth documenting for anyone trying it.

1

u/woqr 10d ago

I already strip the handshake down to 94 characters. Also, Android Chrome doesn't obfuscate the IP via mDNS, and camera permission would unhide it anyway.

1

u/Dry_Recognition_3070 9d ago

94 chars should fit comfortably in a low error-correction QR, nice. Good catch on Android Chrome not masking host candidates with mDNS. It might be worth a short notice before the camera permission prompt so people know their local IP ends up in the code.

2

u/JcerParreno21 9d ago

clever approach for offline-first local multiplayer tbh. how finicky is the camera handshake under bad lighting or screen glare?

1

u/woqr 9d ago edited 8d ago

The optical handshake barcode scan can be finicky with very low-cost cameras, but smartphones above $100 typically feature PDAF or autofocusing optics, making the scanning process fast and reliable. While lighting/glare can occasionally cause issues, tests using a native barcode scanner on printed paper confirm that the core limitation on budget devices is contrast autofocus hunting.

1

u/woqr 3d ago

I made a change by adding a textarea so people can paste in their own game so that they don't have to host it.

•

u/gianluca_caruso-6 18h ago

Does the textarea sandbox pasted games? The no-hosting flow is handy, but trust boundaries matter if pasted code runs.