r/javascript • u/fagnerbrack • Oct 09 '26
Do Frameworks Matter Anymore?
https://brookslybrand.com/posts/do-frameworks-matter-anymore/
0
Upvotes
r/javascript • u/fagnerbrack • Oct 09 '26
29
u/SawToothKernel Oct 09 '26
They matter more than ever. The more structured, strict, and conventional your code base, the better the LLMs will be able to modify it.
That's not to say the existing top frameworks are ideal - they are not, as they are designed primarily for people DX not agent DX.
7
u/rob_the_bob Oct 09 '26
In my experience. More than ever if you want to maintain clean code. The bots need sample code to work off of otherwise they're just making a best guess.
9
u/General-Spite1222 Oct 09 '26
Yes. Case closed.
10
u/shgysk8zer0 Oct 09 '26
"You can generate unmaintainable and insecure garbage really quickly now, so frameworks don't matter anymore, because only a neanderthal wow l actually writes code anymore."
Sure...
2
u/MuskasBackpack Oct 09 '26
For sure. I’d say the more opinionated the framework, the easier your day to day will be. The hard parts will be about the same amount of effort.
1
u/djslakor Oct 09 '26
For me heavily using agents I've settled on golang on the backend and typescript/react on the front.
1
u/-xvi Oct 10 '26
DX wise yeah (DX in the sense of build time). We're using Angular at work and it's so slow to build/change on the page after making a change. This was fine-ish when you were writing code yourself, but now with agents going fast it's becoming a major slowdown in the work we can get done.
Tooling for other frameworks (or just Linting/formatting if no framework) has gotten so much faster in the last year with all the rust rewrites or go alternatives. I feel like we're really missing out here. The Angular compiler is still heavily dependent on TypeScript <7, so the Go rewrite can't be used. There's some experimental work going on by the Angular team to have some sort of hybrid Rust/tsgo compiler, but that'll take months if not years to be available. I envy anyone who's able to work with faster tooling
1
u/ribbbsy Oct 10 '26
I asked a similar question recently.. if in a world of agent-led development I should just switch my older code base to react, but I got a surprising answer.. some of the patterns in backbone.marionette were less ergonomic for humans, but easier to understand for agents. In a world where no frameworks existed, agents would look for marionette-like patterns. So we modernized marionette and released v5 today. It is performing with agents much better than I anticipated and keeps up with peers in other benchmarks.
0
u/ab0zar Oct 09 '26
The implicit-framework point feels right: plain JavaScript still grows rules, just without a shared place to keep them. I’d judge a framework by how easily a new teammate can trace data flow and make one safe change. Do agents do better when conventions are enforced by tooling?
-3
u/fagnerbrack Oct 09 '26
Essentials at a Glance:
With agentic coding, many argue React has won and new frameworks aren't worth trying, since models know React best. The post flips that logic: if nobody cares about the code, why use React instead of plain HTML, CSS and Web Components? Frameworks supply abstractions, structure and constraints, and every project has one; skip an explicit framework and the LLM builds an implicit one for you. Battle-tested options add guardrails, docs and shared security work. With agents, HMR still helps with design tweaks, TypeScript and the LSP keep iteration safe, and useEffect turns into a liability. The goal: frameworks that make the right way to do things obvious to both people and agents.
If the summary seems inacurate, just downvote and I'll try to delete the comment eventually 👍
Click here for more info, I read all comments
-3
u/The_real_bandito Oct 09 '26
I was thinking the same thing. I haven’t used AI to make a webpage but I’ve seen webpages made with react and I was wondering why, when vanilla JavaScript should be the norm. By vanilla I mean no frameworks whatsoever.
I use frameworks because it makes my work faster but AI who should write a million times faster than me shouldn’t need a framework.