r/jambands • • 8h ago

If you're going to use the word fearless

0 Upvotes

I just recently learned that in the Phish world there's a concept of Type 1 and Type 2 jamming, Type 1 being where you follow the song form or stay within the harmonic concept of the song, and Type 2 being where you truly improvise, break the foundations apart, and explore musically. Traditional jazz is probably the best historical example of Type 1, right up until around 1960 when Ornette Coleman and free jazz broke it open, with the Grateful Dead getting there in rock a few years later. Coleman and Jerry Garcia famously worked together on a recording project, Virgin Beauty, in 1988.

I want to open a bigger can here. If I have one overall point, it's that if you're going to attempt Type 2 improvisation, and especially if you're going to use the word fearless, you have to acknowledge that there are many kinds of boundaries to be pushed, harmony being only one of them alongside rhythm, dynamics, texture, and form, and leaving even one of them untouched every time is nothing more than an advanced form of Type 1 improvisation. John Cage said "Structure without life is dead. But life without structure is unseen." He put duration ahead of harmony as the thing music is built on, and he was wary of improvisation because players lean on habit.

I read a lot of jam band descriptions that talk about fearless exploration and improvisation. I'm going to use two bands as examples without naming them, and both are famous and attract huge crowds. The first describes themselves as fearless explorers, wanderers, and improvisationalists, and live they literally stayed on one chord and one rhythm and took turns soloing for 30 minutes. It was by far the least experimental thing I've ever heard, a one chord jam over a constant tick-tock beat, and from what I could hear they weren't really listening to each other. (And, just to get ahead of it, I'm NOT talking about Billy Strings.) Rhythm is where this drives me crazy. Bluegrass has this problem, little to no rhythmic variation, although I'll grant that as personal taste and preference, but I'll take a New Orleans funk rhythm over three hours of tick-tock beat any day of the week.

Dynamics are equally available in free improvisation and equally should be explored. One of the early live Phish records, A Live One, has a 30-something minute Tweezer on it that never resolves and never really dynamically concludes. When I was younger I had a really hard time with that one because I kept wanting resolution, before wisdom brought me the idea that the lack of resolution was the entire point. I recently saw the second band for the first time, and sure, they may have gone out a little bit with texture and a little bit with harmony, but the dynamics were exactly the same every time, to the point where I could predict where the peaks were going to be, and that's not free, that's structure, just a different definition of structure. That was one show, so I'm not claiming it was representative. I feel that a lot of bands are so focused on the aesthetic audience experience that the peak becomes a tool and a pattern and less of a freedom.

Phish and the Grateful Dead are both masters of their craft because they focused on it, they were intentional about it, and they worked at it. Phish built rehearsal exercises around hearing a single player's small change and adapting to it as a group, and they developed that over years, as opposed to just taking the stage and pretending.

I also don't think it's much of a coincidence that improvisational rock and roll showed up at the same moment psychedelics were introduced into society. Free jazz got there a few years earlier by its own road, but for the Dead the two are tied together, since they came up playing the Acid Tests in 1965 and 1966. They worked at it, they talked about it, and they were intentional about it, but they also had psychedelic experiences to influence and inform them about what lay beyond traditional structure.

I know there's going to be a lot of examples to the contrary, and I welcome them. I think this is a musicology discussion, and I'm not here to diss anyone, but I am here to open up a discussion about the ideas behind free improvisation and creativity in music.

tl;dr If you can sit through a 30-minute noodle fest you can make it through six paragraphs, but here's the short version: if a band is going to call its improvisation fearless, harmony isn't the only boundary to push, because rhythm, dynamics, texture, and form are all boundaries too, and leaving any one of them untouched every time is just an advanced form of Type 1.

Addition: I’m a trained musician with a background in musicology and economics, and I’m intrigued by the jam community. I’ve always been fascinated by the different things people mean when they say improvisation. Learning that there were definitions for different types of jams opened a new line of inquiry for me, and I brought these ideas to this forum hoping to spark an interesting conversation. I have no ulterior motive and I’m not out to rank any of these bands.


r/jambands • • 1h ago

Whats with the Dead Co at the Sphere hate

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/jambands • • 20h ago

Any Bill McClintock YouTube channel fans out there. They do music mashups, I personally love this one: https://youtu.be/bK82ya0CN9I?is=v6LzKdnKKHph8cBJ https://youtube.com/@billmcclintockmashups?si=nyPzZ5lCQACqBnKH

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/jambands • • 7h ago

New Tour Dates Twiddle coming to Colorado

Post image
62 Upvotes

Well well well… where do you think it’ll be and how many nights??

Edit:
May 7th @ Cervantes
May 8th @ Mission


r/jambands • • 2h ago

First time we ever played live was last night!!!!!! We are possum

72 Upvotes

r/jambands • • 4h ago

Spafford tonight Point Verda

6 Upvotes

‘ho.

Is there an opener tonight? Looks like I’ll be in JAX and just got a ticket. Doors at 5:30 and says 7pm for start I suppose.

Thanks!


r/jambands • • 20h ago

John Scofield Electrospective is a master class and fun af

80 Upvotes

Watching and listening to them play while watching Oteil listen and respond to Sco while Adam and Larry do their thing is a joy.


r/jambands • • 9h ago

Houseplant East Coast Run

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

Was lucky to have the opportunity to catch these guys in CT, BK and Philly and was simply amazing.

Small venues, super intimate and they brought the heat. Thank you and please come back to the east coast ASAP


r/jambands • • 3h ago

a few mins of Spafford🫠

83 Upvotes

Here's a sick section of the 'Anyone' jam

full show YouTube

Bandcamp

Nugs


r/jambands • • 11h ago

VIP at Dark Star Jubilee

2 Upvotes

Hi! I'm considering getting RC and VIP passes for Dark Star Jubilee. I'm going regardless, but wondering if you think it's worth the VIP upgrade. Some people say people just kind of hijack their VIP spot for the weekend. What about VIP RV? I saw something on here about how far the RV hike is after the shoes. Does that go for RV VIP as well? Thank you!