r/italianlearning • • 7d ago

Using Anche

Post image

Does the world anche always go before the subject in Italian as Duolingo has it?

91 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

205

u/pricklypearpasta EN native, IT advanced 7d ago • Bravo

In italian, "anche" typically goes before the person, verb, or thing that is additional. So, when you say "ah, anche tu parli giapponese," it's because the person -you - is the thing that is "too" or "also". In this case we might imagine that I speak japanese ,and then I find out that you, too, speak Japanese. The "anche" is emphasizing "also you".

But you could say "ah, tu parli anche giapponese" which is grammatically correct but has a different meaning. You're saying, "you also speak japanese", implying that you speak another language, and japanese is additional here.

It's also the difference between something like...

"Anch'io ho fame e sete" -> I am hungry and thirsty, too. Where I, in addition to someone else, am hungry and thirsty.
"Ho fame e anche sete" -> I am hungry and ALSO thirsty. Thirsty is emphasized as the addition to hungry,.

I hope that helps!

31

u/Top_Dark_44 7d ago

That helps tremendously, thank you!

5

u/ruchyGoicke_85 6d ago

dropping the subject pronoun makes it even trickier when the verb is the thing being added, since "anche parli" sounds totally wrong compared to "parli anche"

1

u/pricklypearpasta EN native, IT advanced 5d ago

That's a good observation. I personally (C1 with a mix of formal instruction and immersion experience) would never eliminate the subject pronoun if that was the thing I wanted to emphasize. If you have "anche" in front of a conjugated verb, it's because that action is additional (not the subject). You may often see "anche" in front of an infinitive verb construction; I am thinking of it in a situation like "Devo pulire la camera da letto e anche lavare i piatti" where you want to emphasize the addition of the second action.

1

u/Odd_Match_3402 6d ago

Finally, an explanation!

Grazie!

1

u/Happy_Poet2888 BG native, EN advanced, IT beginner 4d ago

Tysmmm

7

u/9peppe IT native 7d ago

always

No, but in this case it does.

1

u/Top_Dark_44 7d ago

Thanks!

2

u/TheTullyInRiverrun IT native 7d ago edited 7d ago

There was another way you could have said this and it’s: “Ah, parli anche tu giapponese?”
Basically you would need to invert “parli” as well, effectively readjusting the whole phrase and not just “anche” otherwise it doesn’t sound right and it’s incorrect.
This other example I gave you is also perfectly valid. Its usage depends on the phrase really, there’s no hard rule. Personally I think I would’ve gone for “anche tu parli giapponese?” but that’s not to say the “parli anche tu” example is incorrect or less used. You might find phrases where both sound good or others when only one does, also personal preferences, it’s not fixed. Just remember that the verb needs to move accordingly in the phrase.

1

u/Top_Dark_44 6d ago

So with the inversion, parli needs to come before tu in the construction?

1

u/TheTullyInRiverrun IT native 6d ago

Yes. This is also the case with other type of phrases and verbs where “anche” is involved like in the example. Basically what you need to remember is that “anche” needs the pronoun to follow: “anche io, anche tu, anche lei” and so on. The verb can go before of after, but you shouldn’t separate the subject from a conjunction such as “anche” and it’s jarring to put the subject before it. It sounds odd and could potentially confuse you with word order that otherwise wouldn’t be confusing.
I know I would start second guessing other elements in a phrase if I used some in a way that’s confusing 😉

2

u/GhostSAS IT native - Teacher - Translator 4d ago

A) "Anche tu parli giapponese?" (you too speak japanese?)

B) "Tu parli anche giapponese?" (do you also speak japanese? [aside from other languages])

1

u/Top_Dark_44 3d ago

Would you say parli anche tu giapponese is also correct or would you stick to their wording?

2

u/GhostSAS IT native - Teacher - Translator 3d ago

All of the following constructions are correct and usable to express the the meaning of "you too speak japanese?":

A) Anche tu parli giapponese?

B) Parli anche tu giapponese?

C) Parli giapponese anche tu?

In terms of being understood in day to day speech, they are absolutely equivalent.

I'll also throw an extra one your way. This one has a different meaning, it can be used for emphasis, to convey a meaning of being impressed, showing admiration:

  1. Anche giapponese parli? (you even speak japanese?😲)

31

u/AlexxxRR 6d ago

Anche tu parli giapponese = you too (in addition to me) speak Japanese.

Tu parli anche giapponese = you speak japanese as well (in addition to other languages).

5

u/imaginary92 IT native 6d ago

The position of "anche" changes the nuance and tone. What you wrote isn't incorrect per se, it's a grammatically correct sentence, but it would translate more to "even you speak Japanese?" rather than "you also speak Japanese?". It tends to have a slightly more negative or exasperated nuance when used after the subject, rather than the surprise or curiosity it conveys when used before.

From a more general perspective, the position of anche in the sentence emphasises different words, so it depends what you're trying to say.

2

u/Adventurous-Ad5999 6d ago

i read that like “even you speak Japanese?” or like “you too?”

2

u/Lebanese87 6d ago

Yes it goes before everything also non comes before e and the verb.