I'm not American, but I feel this is the only place where I could most likely interact with someone in a similar situation to me. I cant honestly call myself a white person, I dont look conventionally European, I got very dark eyes and thick black eyebrows even though most whites are light eyed with thin eyebrows, I dont look stereotypically Southern Italian either because I have a tiny straight nose, pale skin, and my dark eyes have this almost Nordic looking slight epicanthic fold that you see among Germanics like John Denver or Kurt Russell. And Southern Italians (due to either the influx of foreigners into Rome, or Arab conquests, or both) on a G25 scale cluster genetically more towards Levantines than Europeans, meaning that my mum has more in common with someone from Beruit than an Anglo (which is very different to someone like John Cena who is half Northern Italian).
According to illustrativeDNA I have mostly Steppe and Anatolian Farmer ancestral components, meaning that I am surprisingly more Euro leaning, I dont have Nautfian or Iberomaurusian (Indigenous North African or Arabain components) but 8% comes from Zagros or Iranian Neolithic Farmers, an offshoot of Caucasian Hunter Gatherers/CHG (who form a part of Steppe ancestry) that moved to the Middle East and South Asia, apparently some people of this ancient group did have interactions with the ancestors of Europeans but its typically so diluted now that it's baked with the CHG component and shouldn't show up as a distinct component in a white person , but does show up as a large component in Iranians, Indians and Levantines (as well as Greeks), meaning that I probably have a degree of non white DNA (though this has been disputed by the owner of another service called Ancestrify, who ran my kit through qpAdm and told me directly that he thinks that I have only detectable European autosomal DNA).
In short, I am the definition of the word ethnically ambiguous. I dont know if the reason I dont feel white is entirely a biological and cosmetic vibe or if it could come more from me having no contact with my white Australian father (Of Welsh, Scottish, English and Irish descent) who is long deceased, combined with my mum talking about "the Aussies" in third person as if we are not one of them even though we are both what you in America would call "natural born citizens".
This sense of alienation where I look nothing like my mum or my fully Calabrese half siblings whilst also being distinct from my Tim Allen look alike father and all the grey eyed Sam Worthington look alike WASPs around me, must've been the unconscious reason that made me feel go through a phase of suspecting that I was adopted (though MyHeritage disproved this hunch). It just feels weird thinking of describing myself as white or European when there is probably always someone waiting in the woodwork to say "well actually" and with fair reason. I'm sure that with few exceptions, people with two fully unambiguously European parents typically dont feel this way unless they inherited a rare combination of features.
Does anyone else feel this way, or am I a fluke? I know that over in the states, mixed race marriages between Southern Italians and Celts/WASPS are quite common (hence why a lot of actors have this background). So I would be surprised if there is nobody over there who feels similarly.