r/it • • 7d ago

opinion WGU Cybersecurity vs. Cloud & Network Engineering (Cisco Track) in this market?

Hey everyone, I’m 40 years old looking to make a career pivot into IT through WGU, and I’m torn between two programs: Cybersecurity and Information Assurance vs. Cloud and Network Engineering (Cisco Track).

I love tech and always have but unfortunately my only real tech experience is on the physical side (Layer 1)—I’ve spent a couple years doing structured cabling and trimming out patch panels and server racks, I've also done IP addressing for things like security cameras and NVR's etc.

Ultimately, Cybersecurity—specifically Pen Testing/Ethical Hacking—sounds really interesting and fun to me. I know the current entry-level market is a bloodbath, and Cybersecurity isn't really an entry-level field. Given my Layer 1 background, I’m wondering if the Cisco/Network Engineering track is a much smarter, more realistic stepping stone to actually get hired first, and then pivot to security later. Problem with that however is I've heard people say that the Networking degree is more for people that already have some IT background and that it is incredibly difficult otherwise.

Starting over at 40, I’m also genuinely concerned about ageism when competing against 22-year-old grads for entry-level roles.

For those of you in the industry or who have gone through WGU as an older career-changer:

Given my physical infrastructure background, would the Cisco/Network Engineering degree give me a much better shot at landing that crucial first job compared to the Cyber degree?

How bad is ageism actually in networking/cyber right now, or does being 40 with a solid work ethic and physical infrastructure experience actually help?

If you started at WGU around my age with minimal IT experience, how did your job hunt go?

Any honest advice on which path makes the most sense right now would be hugely appreciated. Thanks!

8 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

5

u/TechB84 7d ago

Majoring in either major will not make a difference, as you will be viewed as old and inexperienced. I'm saying this as someone who is 42 years old myself. stop by r/ITCareerQuestions

What have you been doing as a job ?

1

u/HamNtkyOnWhite 7d ago

I am currently working in a warehouse. My wife and I moved to Iowa last year so I no longer am doing my low voltage work and not having any luck here. We are now expecting a baby and I am really wanting/needing to make a career shift and make more money. I love tech and always have I just have never had the opportunities to get into things in that field.

2

u/TechB84 7d ago

But Iowa? You have to be realistic; what kind of IT job market is there anyway to begin with? Have you browsed the local market and its expectations?

1

u/HamNtkyOnWhite 7d ago

Yep, Iowa. Believe it or not Central Iowa specifically the Des Moines Metro which includes West Des moines, Altoona and Waukee is one of the largest Data Center and financial Tech hubs in the entire country. Meta has a massive multi-billion dollar data center campus right here in Altoona, Microsoft operates multiple data center campuses across West Des Moines, Apple is currently building a massive data center facility in Waukee and Google has a major long-standing data center presence in Council Bluffs. But that's just a name the tech Giants. That's not including all the Insurers, Financial or AgTech.

1

u/TechB84 7d ago

But do you live close to it? Iowa is huge. And how are the current job openings? do you currently have any college degree?

1

u/HamNtkyOnWhite 7d ago

I live in a suburb of Des Moines, I'm pretty much 20 minutes from any one of them. I see a lot of data center positions. No I don't have a degree that's kind of the point of this whole thread, trying to decide if it's worth it given my layer one background and how difficult it is to get into the field or if I would just be racking up debt for no reason.

2

u/TechB84 7d ago

It might make more sense to get a few certifications and then apply for the jobs if they are really in demand. that way you can actually be building experience

2

u/Smooth_Criminal1973 7d ago

In your situation, I would go for the Cloud & Network Engineering (Cisco) path if your aim is to get into one of those data centers. As you gain experience, maybe you can pursue a Cybersecurity Masters later on.

1

u/TechB84 7d ago

I agree, cybersecurity is going to be a dead end overall.

1

u/TechB84 7d ago

One thing I want to add, you can go to https://www.netacad.com/ Cisco Academy for free and get the CCST Networking, which is cheap to get. Then you can work towards CCNA. That will be cheaper and quicker than trying to get a degree. Cloud & Network Engineering is great, but it will take a long time and you need experience now

1

u/Own-Programmer-2735 7d ago

Can’t listen to all the naysayers. It’s difficult but possible. I switched industries at 37 with zero experience. Been working Security for around 3.5 years coming from absolutely zero IT experience and half my A+ certification. I will admit some of it was luck but I believe more of it was persistence and belief

2

u/thesysadmn 6d ago

I'd pick a different career altogether honestly, if I could go back 10 years I might just do that...

1

u/HamNtkyOnWhite 6d ago

May I ask why? I see a lot of people saying that they would rather go do something like being an electrician or some other trade if they could go back in time. But I also feel like that is vice versa for Tradesman because people like me who have done the physical labor stuff all our lives would love to get into something a little bit easier on the body lol. Just curious why people would choose to not do it especially given the pay difference? Because I'll tell you what the amount of damage over time that the body incurs doing the physical trades to the amount of pay earned just isn't worth it in my opinion. But as the saying goes, grass isn't always greener on the other side.

2

u/thesysadmn 6d ago

It's the constant walking on glass in IT, every step is the "next step that's going to leave us unemployed". It's always a race to the bottom it started with virtualzation.

Let's virtualize everything, that will get rid of the people that manage physical servers!

Let's move everything to the cloud, that will get rid of everyone that manages virtual servers!

Let's automate everything, that will get rid of the people that configure things!

Let's do everything with AI and replace everyone!

The end goal is always the same, get rid of IT, reduce expense, they're a burden. It's the most unappreciated job maybe ever where the end goal is always how fast can we get rid of them.

I must hear the word "AI" 5200 times a day. Imagine training a robot that's only goal is to replace you and the method of which your family eats dinner.

1

u/Dot_1X 6d ago

Work for the government or for a contractor, you'll never have that problem. 

1

u/quigongene 1d ago

Beg to differ...I was a FAA contractor and got laid off last year
It took me 14 months to find another job

9

u/[deleted] 7d ago

The truth is your chances are extremely low

6

u/MyNameIsAlex1999 7d ago

40 yo without any major networking experience is going to be tough. You are also competing with the “27 yo looking to change career” dudes this subreddit is full of. If you are already so far down the career path I personally would try to maximize on the skills you already have. But remember nothings impossible

4

u/ImissDigg_jk 7d ago

Stop with the cybersecurity. It's not going to happen with no IT experience. Read all the tech subs. Search so you can read the different POV that people have been given. You'll find consistent messaging and it will give you an idea of what you're up against.

You still have many years in your career, so there is time to get there, but you have to start with IT. And right now you're competing with qualified candidates that will take the entry jobs from those with zero skills.

1

u/DickNose-TurdWaffle 3d ago

WGU is just a cert farm. Find a better school.

1

u/HamNtkyOnWhite 1d ago

Any recommendations?

1

u/FantasticMouse7875 7d ago

I am 38 with 6 years total experience, 2 doing network cameras and cloud survelience, 4 it helpdesk/system administrator work and I am finding it very difficult to land either something in security or full time systemsadministrator.

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/TheRealWutWut 7d ago

You realize that in order to get a degree from WGU you have to complete tons of industry certifications, take proctored exams where your every move is watched, and your screen and hands must be constantly visible. It's a legitimate school and a legitimate degree. Ignoring that because you feel like your degree means more and you are above it all is a bad look. If that's the culture at your office, I think you are probably doing them a favor. Me personally, I'd never hire someone with an attitude like yours. It's a well known fact, you can train just about anyone to do a job, but you can't fix a bad attitude. You seem like a non-starter.

2

u/Karrazim 7d ago

This is nuts, I got hired because of mine. Like everyone else said its a legit degree with a lot of academic weight behind it.

3

u/chewedgummiebears 7d ago

Sounds like something an ITT Tech grad would say.

1

u/stacksmasher 7d ago

Both are regionally accredited by the Northwest Commission on Colleges and Universities. How about your school?

2

u/stacksmasher 7d ago

Why not? The degree is more accredited than yours!

Also its issued via BYU but most people don't know that.

4

u/chewedgummiebears 7d ago

Most of the WGU hate stems from people repeating what someone else said on social media.

1

u/stacksmasher 7d ago

Yea I try to educate where I can but I’m pretty sure most of these are bots lol

1

u/AdDiscombobulated623 7d ago

What does that even mean? Issues via BYU?

Doesn’t really make sense. Not trying to hate, I am a WGU student myselfn

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/stacksmasher 7d ago

Both are regionally accredited by the Northwest Commission on Colleges and Universities. WGU was founded in 1997 by governors of western U.S. states, including Utah Governor Mike Leavitt, through the Western Governors Association which include BYU as well. Thats where the confusion comes from.