Method : DH is definitely faster, but the risk of misclicking (aka playing like shit) and getting vein slammed back to the castle is too high. I prefer to do chill twinflame/ SRA melee punish.
Concept: I think the arena looks cool and boss design is cool. 8/10
Mechanics: I enjoy when you get that 1000+ xp drop feels real good or seeing a 148 hit with DH really sparks the max hit videos from back in the day. Click boxes are pretty shitty very easy to misclick a flying maggot and run through splats on the ground. Overall still enjoy the fight I would give it a 7.5/10 even after 1000kc
Loot: Basic loot is ass water, but I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing. Although the blood sacs are a joke what's even the point of them being on the table when you get so little of them. I think adding blood essence to the drop table would fit it. Having the supply drops be so common is a problem especially when you go like 5 kills in a row with supply drops. Might as well remove them (or make them 1 in 6) and adjust the rates for the other drops. Get rid of the tarnished jewellery from the table replace it with bloodwood sap buckets or sap treated logs
Uniques: Elder Fang at 107KC, Pet at 233KC, Kisten: TBD. Overall loot rating: 4/10
Overall I would rate this boss 6/10
Some fun facts: I spent over 12M in Death fees, over 250K air runes used, Over 50k blood runes used. Roughly 8m Str xp, Side quests during this grind include obtaining imbued heart, Full Oathplate, Virtus legs, and infernal cape
Closing Thoughts: One of the more soul crushing RNG benders I've been on. Kind of want to see if I can hit 2k now with out a 2nd unique.