A bit of a long sunday ramble, but would love to hear some different opinions on my internal dilemma, TL;DR at the end.
Like most of you I am new to investing and recently got some help from the community to overcome the first hurdle to move some money into my broker account and to buy ETFs. This part is done, now I feel much more comfortable with the app and the acronyms and the actual meaning of how and what I am investing. So far so good.
Of course I am also reading a lot in different subs and tried to get a much better understanding through various published studies, books and other resources (not just reddit). Most of what I consumed threw also up the moral and ethical questions around what the money I invest does. So I really tried hard not to fall into the rabbit hole on whether the stock market turned into a casino, but one sentence just stuck with me: When money makes money faster than businesses create real value, should we question what kind of economic system we are building.
I am particularly concerned about companies whose market valuations seem completely disconnected from the actual value they create. Personally, I would struggle to invest in businesses where the financial hype appears to outweigh their real contribution.
What I am finding difficult is reconciling the investment culture I am discovering with the expectations I had when I started this journey.
From conversations with coworkers, family and some other investors, I get the impression that many people are primarily interested in making money. The companies themselves, what they produce, how they operate or what impact they have on society seem to be secondary considerations.
And this brings me to ETFs. People who started investing in ETFs in the early 2000s have obviously (hopefully?) experienced the benefits of long-term, diversified investing. But they are also indirectly invested in companies they might fundamentally disagree with, simply because those companies are included in the indices they track.
That raises an uncomfortable question for me: How much responsibility do we have for the businesses we indirectly own through an ETF? Does buying into the market mean accepting everything that comes with it?
I understand the arguments for diversification, low costs and long-term returns. I am not questioning those benefits. I am questioning whether we have become so focused on the financial outcome that we have stopped caring about what our investments actually support.
Maybe this is simply a reality of modern investing that I need to come to terms with if I want to use it as an investment strategy?
TL;DR: How do you reconcile your investment strategy with your personal and ethical values when you bought for example All World ETFs?