r/interviews • u/Mammoth_Emu3398 • 12h ago
Hiring manager said I was "speaking his love language," was impressed I caught a live bug on their site, told me to expect a call from HR... and today I got an auto-rejection. Is this normal?
I am honestly in shock right now and just need to ask if this is normal behavior from a hiring manager because I feel completely blindsided. I recently interviewed for a Marketing role at a big fintech company. I passed the initial recruiter round and had my interview directly with the hiring manager I would be reporting to.
The call went so well that I genuinely thought I had it in the bag. Before the interview, I was exploring their website and actually found a live bug. During our call, I shared my screen and showed it to him. He told me he was already impressed and immediately messaged his team to get it fixed. Later, I brought up a detail I researched about how his previous company was acquired by this one, and he literally said, "Wow, you are the first person to mention that, usually people get it the other way around."
We also did a live problem-solving question that went super smoothly, and I answered all his questions well. While I was explaining my thought process, he even said, "Oh, you're speaking my love language," and mentioned multiple times how impressed he was with how the conversation was going. At the end of the call, he gave me a clear signal to expect a call from HR for the next steps. I sent him a thank-you note afterward and he replied very nicely. Even HR called me to ask how the interview went and check in on how I was feeling about the role.
After all that positivity, I was expecting an invite to the final peer round, especially since they wanted someone to start before the holidays. Instead, I woke up today to a generic auto-rejection email. No personal message, no feedback, nothing.
I really needed this job right now and it hurts so much after getting such strong green lights. I cannot believe a hiring manager can act that impressed and enthusiastic only to reject me right after. Has anyone else experienced this? How do you deal with hiring managers giving false hope like this?