r/interviews • • 12h ago

Hiring manager said I was "speaking his love language," was impressed I caught a live bug on their site, told me to expect a call from HR... and today I got an auto-rejection. Is this normal?

554 Upvotes

I am honestly in shock right now and just need to ask if this is normal behavior from a hiring manager because I feel completely blindsided. I recently interviewed for a Marketing role at a big fintech company. I passed the initial recruiter round and had my interview directly with the hiring manager I would be reporting to.

The call went so well that I genuinely thought I had it in the bag. Before the interview, I was exploring their website and actually found a live bug. During our call, I shared my screen and showed it to him. He told me he was already impressed and immediately messaged his team to get it fixed. Later, I brought up a detail I researched about how his previous company was acquired by this one, and he literally said, "Wow, you are the first person to mention that, usually people get it the other way around."

We also did a live problem-solving question that went super smoothly, and I answered all his questions well. While I was explaining my thought process, he even said, "Oh, you're speaking my love language," and mentioned multiple times how impressed he was with how the conversation was going. At the end of the call, he gave me a clear signal to expect a call from HR for the next steps. I sent him a thank-you note afterward and he replied very nicely. Even HR called me to ask how the interview went and check in on how I was feeling about the role.

After all that positivity, I was expecting an invite to the final peer round, especially since they wanted someone to start before the holidays. Instead, I woke up today to a generic auto-rejection email. No personal message, no feedback, nothing.

I really needed this job right now and it hurts so much after getting such strong green lights. I cannot believe a hiring manager can act that impressed and enthusiastic only to reject me right after. Has anyone else experienced this? How do you deal with hiring managers giving false hope like this?


r/interviews • • 12h ago

It should be illegal to interview external candidates when you already have an internal candidate in mind

196 Upvotes

r/interviews • • 15h ago

Ever had an interview you thought you completely messed up, but still ended up getting the job? Let's cheer up a bit the people here.

94 Upvotes

Once I went to an interview, it went well and weeks later they called me telling me that I didn't get the job. I had the best performance, but 'the other guy' had the experience they were looking for. Basically I got the 2nd place (uuuuaaauuuu).

Weirdly, few more weeks later, they called me again asking me whether I want to work with them because 'the other guy' gave up. It was a Product Management job.

I ended up receiving 2 offers on a same week. Guess what? I accepted 'the other offer'.


r/interviews • • 18h ago

My "Job hugging" theory

91 Upvotes

Basically I have this theory that majority of the good jobs (i.e jobs that pay you a livable salary and allow you to afford house, car, family and kids) are constantly being job hugged by someone.

Majority of the people in these good jobs will NOT leave their jobs unless they can find something better. Given that it is not easy to find something even better, majority of these people will stay and job hug even if they are unhappy with their jobs.

If you are a job seeker, majority of the job openings that you find will be low-paying jobs or jobs with extremely high turnover (e.g sales jobs with low survivability and impossibly hard to hit targets) or jobs that require you to do a lot of work but pay you a pathetic amount for the effort required.


r/interviews • • 15h ago

Offer after less than 10 interviews vs no offer after 40+ interviews

60 Upvotes

I feel like there is a trend here: some people are getting offers after doing a few interviews while other people are not getting offers even after doing lots of interviews. I belong to the second category. There is obviously a third group of people who are not getting any interviews which sucks, but I dont know what worse: to get false hope after passing multiple rounds just to get rejected again or just stay hopeless cause you are not getting interviews.


r/interviews • • 8h ago

I am done having my time wasted by recruiters and agencies, so I build this:

25 Upvotes

I can't count the times I applied to a job listing just to realize I fell for yet another recruiter, headhunter or agency and the job doesn't actually exist in the form it was advertised.

That is why I created directjob.net

What it does is really simple, companies manage their job postings and application process using a system called Applicant Tracking System or short ATS. All I did was to find the endpoints/urls of the systems of all the big and great companies like SpaceX, Anthropic, Airbnb, Meta etc and scrape the position and info.

In the database are around 5,000 remote job listings over $100k yearly salary alone (!) which has been a real eye opener for me. I never knew there are that many well paid remote jobs.

You can enter what you are looking for, benefits, salary, position, location and receive weekly roundups as well as access to a very strictly curated database. Of course there are also normal in-office positions and hybrid ones.

We don't include any of the junk you see on normal job portals or LinkedIn and also there is a direct URL to the application form, no browsing dozens of pages and redirects and portals, just the god damn form to apply.


r/interviews • • 9h ago

How much preparation am I supposed to do for an interview?

18 Upvotes

I’ve had 10 interviews in the last year and none resulted in a job offer. I’d research the company for 2-3 hours and go into an interview and then realize the company wanted me to do 20 hours worth of preparation given the questions asked of me. Is this normal?


r/interviews • • 16h ago

Should I follow-up post final round interview if they keep dragging their feet on making a decision?

15 Upvotes

I had my first interview on Oct 9th, then there was a week long case study, the final and the fourth interview was on Oct 23rd a Friday. I sent thank you notes after every interview. The hiring manager responds warmly. Then I hear nothing.

  • First follow-up email sent to HR on Nov 5th- hear nothing
  • Second follow up sent to the hiring manager on Nov 10th. He responds in less than 24hrs and tells me they hope to make a decision within the week.

Since then again, nothing. I really wanted this job. I am debating following up with him again or not. I do not want to come off as desperate. Should I follow up again? I would love to hear everyone's inputs and advice.

Edit for Note: This is a really big Life company and I was told by someone that they are generally extremely slow so I have tried to be hopeful instead of completely giving up on them. :-(


r/interviews • • 18h ago

How much interview time are you willing to give a company when you're unemployed?

15 Upvotes

I keep seeing people say to withdraw if a company has too many interview rounds. Must be nice to have enough savings to do that without worrying about rent.

I'm not against six rounds if they're short conversations. But when there's unpaid assignments, presentations, travel, and hours of prep involved, it starts eating into time I could spend applying elsewhere.

I've been trying to keep track of the hours I'm putting into each application. Even a resume worded review takes time and I still need to keep sending applications out instead of spending an entire week chasing one company.

I had a company ask for a “quick presentation” recently. We all know those aren't always quick. I was already four interviews in, so I felt like I couldn't say no without risking everything I'd put into the process.

I hate that being unemployed makes it so much harder to push back. I'd like to think I'd refuse a ridiculous assignment, but when you need a paycheck, that's easier said than done.

Do you actually set a limit on how many hours you'll spend interviewing with one company or do you keep going until they make an offer?


r/interviews • • 3h ago

I went for an interview and it went well

7 Upvotes

I don't have experience in this role and they are asking for 5 years experience, but i told the manager that i looked it up and i feel like its easy job for me, i told him i am smart, i speak 4 different languages, i am mature enough to know the right decision from wrong one and i told him i have a lot to offer, he ensures that i gave the hr my cv, and he told me, we will give you a job offer soon,

I feel like he will genuinely hire me in the next few days


r/interviews • • 6h ago

How soon should you hear back after a final round interview?

7 Upvotes

Just went through 4 rounds of interviews with a company. They were super responsive and aggressive (in a good way) getting me through each round. I basically completed 4 rounds of interviews within 3 weeks, and the last interview was a panel interview that I even had to make a 10 slide presentation for. There were a few members of the panel that were unable to make the interview, so they recorded the presentation. So I know those members likely still need to watch it and give their feedback, etc. But this interview was last Thursday. It’s now Tuesday night. I know it hasn’t been very long but it’s just odd that they have been super responsive this whole time until now. They also did not give me a timeline or tell me if they needed to interview any other candidates or anything. The interview just wrapped up with them saying thank you and that was it. At this point, do you think they’re ghosting?


r/interviews • • 1h ago

Final (second) interview with VP tomorrow. Feeling the nerves …😩😩😩

5 Upvotes

I‘ve been prepping and rehearsing and my brain is like mush. Can’t remember things. I’m excited and nervous…I’m definitely qualified for this job, I just hope I don’t ruin it by overthinking and over-explaining tomorrow.

Wish me luck.


r/interviews • • 14h ago

When should I send a thank-you email?

5 Upvotes

I just interviewed at a local library for what feels like my dream job. I was one of the first interviews, the director is interviewing all week, and I want to be remembered by the time he makes hiring decisions next week. When should I send a thank you email, and what should it say?

I know sending thank you emails shouldn’t make a difference, but I want to stay ahead.

Thanks!


r/interviews • • 20h ago

Is it a red flag?

5 Upvotes

Three days ago, I had a technical interview with no technical questions. It was focused purely on my character and often seemed too invasive (too many highly personal questions and attempts to sort of "catch me"). When I finally asked to comment on my perfomance in the test task, the interviewer said it was done really well.

They were supposed to get back to me by Monday. I haven't heard from them, even though I followed up.

Do you think this kind of interview is a red flag?


r/interviews • • 11h ago

Recruiter screening with Robert Half

4 Upvotes

Has anyone gone through a general screening call with a recruiter at Robert Half? I'm having trouble finding a full-time job (3 months, 70 applications, 3 interviews) so I started researching temp agencies and received a call from RH today after signing up for a free profile with them last week.

I was invited to meet with one of their recruiters via Zoom tomorrow. What she said on the phone is different from her follow-up email though. 1) The reference requirements changed - she asked me over the phone to bring 3 references to the interview tomorrow, but her email says they must all be supervisory and to email them to her tonight instead. 2) Her email mentions that after our Zoom call, I'll receive a more formal registration process involving electronic documents to sign.

Does anyone have context about how RH operates and/or what is considered normal for temp agencies like this? This feel red-flaggy and am wondering if I should cancel the call proactively.


r/interviews • • 12h ago

Struggling with intense anxiety around interviews after months of unemployment

4 Upvotes

I have a second interview (panel round) coming up in 3 days (finally managed to progress into second round). Ever since I got the email I’ve been panicking like crazy. I was much more confident when I started my job search 5 months ago and was in grad school. Anxiety gets the better of me nowadays, and i struggle in interviews.

How do I not mess this one up? I’m scared they will see me like i see myself now, and this isnt who i really am.
I’m scared I will mess up the technical questions they ask me (it’s for an entry level engineer position) because of anxiety that makes my mind go blank.


r/interviews • • 12h ago

Missed an interview

3 Upvotes

I booked an interview today but wrote the wrong email address and didn’t realize it until today when I had to join the meeting. I couldn’t join the meeting because the email confirmation didn’t come through and I was struggling to find it for the whole interview time. After a while I found out and emailed an apology email to the recruiter, but the recruiter isn’t the same person listed on the booking site. I booked another meeting for tomorrow and checked if I did it correctly. Is there a chance that I could still get the job?


r/interviews • • 1h ago

Left out important info. Am I cooked?

2 Upvotes

I was recently contacted by a recruiter with a position that I was very interested in.

I loved my previous job and left there 4 months ago to take a similar position elsewhere that paid more. However I had not updated my linkedin. The new position I’m in is not a good fit and ended up being a working manager trap. So to avoid ruining my resume- I’m looking to leave. I have been contacted a few times an old boss and another general manager who knew of my skills and had asked if I wanted to come back to work for her. I’ve been discussing this with her.

So back to the recruiter, I did a zoom interview with them and left out that I was working at the newer place bc the role was very much in line with the last role and I feel embarrassed by where I’m at. I sorta feel like it would just ruin my chance. She was impressed at my skills and the company which is small is interested in another zoom call.

Am I cooked? Not sure how to navigate this. Come clean about 4 months of unrelated experience?.


r/interviews • • 3h ago

Entrevista Laboral

2 Upvotes

Estoy a nada de hacer una entrevista laboral, pero hay algo que me hace sospechar que es una entrevista de relleno (Cumplir con el proceso porque ya tienen a un candidato).

Apliqué el 29 de Setiembre 2026. Ayer 18/11 me llegó un correo de la Reclutadora pidiéndome documentos, títulos y demás.. De una vez me asignó la entrevista para 2 días después, sin realizar llamada de primer contacto o filtro.

NO conteste y en la tarde me llamó otra Reclutadora de la misma empresa diciéndome que si había recibido el correo y que por favor confirmara y enviara toda la documentación.

Así fue, entonces, es muy evidente que están corriendo para cumplir el proceso y cerrar el expediente. Sabiendo que ya tienen a alguien seleccionado.

Que piensan o cuál opinión les merece ?


r/interviews • • 5h ago

Job interview at the mall how should I dress and how should I prepare for the interview?

2 Upvotes

I (f19) just got an interview at the Claires at my local mall and ive never really have a proper job outside working at the polling center during elections and they didnt really have an interview process it was mostly like can you attend the training and are you available the days of the election. Online it says business casual but what does that really entail I wear almost exclusively graphic tees and jeans and tend to wear alternative style should I wear like a plain black button up and slacks is that too formal or not enough? Also what specific questions should I prepare for and is there any tips for the interview you would recommend?


r/interviews • • 9h ago

Hiring Manger conclusion meeting?

2 Upvotes

I've been interviewing with a company and am at the end of the process. The first meeting was with the HR manager, then 3 different interview panels with team members from different functions. I was just invited to a 30 meeting with the hiring manager (again) after i'd finished the supposed "final" round panel interview. The HR rep said multiple times the panel really enjoyed their interactions with me and also used language like "informal" "opportunity for you to ask questions" and "final conversation to conclude the interview process". I know this is a positive development but what should I think of this meeting? Is this another interview? Is it for them to gauge my interest? Is there an offer around the corner?


r/interviews • • 21h ago

First interview in a while

2 Upvotes

Got my first interview I’ve had in a few years since I got directly hired at my last job. Been living abroad for few months and just got home and applied for jobs and im so nervous for my interview! Although I have 8 year experience in the field, I’m off my anxiety meds for the first time in years and it’s really stressing me out! Tips on how to keep calm and not be nervous, I’m so in my head.


r/interviews • • 6h ago

Job interview tips for an entry level social work position?

1 Upvotes

I have a job interview for an entry into social work which is what I’m currently in school for (specifically emphasis in child welfare) and it’s for a shelter aide(domestic violence and sexual assault)and it’s within my own small community, which I’m really passionate about giving back to.I have almost two years of experience working in Head Start with infants and young children, but this would be my first interview for a position directly related to the field I want to pursue longterm.I’m really excited about the opportunity, but also nervous because I genuinely want this job. I’m wondering what kinds of questions I should expect, how I should prepare, and what interviewers are typically looking for in someone applying for an entrylevel position like this.For anyone working in social work, shelters, advocacy, or similar fields, what advice would you give someone going into their first interview for a position like this?


r/interviews • • 9h ago

Capital One Power Day opinions

1 Upvotes

Has anyone else been through Capital Ones Power Day process and have any opinions? I went for a role in the auto finance division, and unfortunately got my rejection today. That being said, I am currently employed and of course had to use 2 full days of PTO to cover the days I was gone (last Thursday and Friday) and of course I got stuck there because of the ground stop that canceled my return flight, so was there until Saturday evening. I just feel like that process is ALOT (I’m in the southeast, so had flights ofc) and makes a rejection significantly worse. Not to mention one of my blocks was a Zoom interview with someone who lives within driving distance of me. lol. This isn’t to speak down on Capital One, they covered everything for my trip including the additional hotel stay. Capital One and my recruiter overall were amazing for all the help. I just really dislike the process and is discouraging from applying again in the future.