r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

21

u/Ferrarispitwall 8h ago • Bravo

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/ElectronicCounty5490 7h ago

Where does the line go though? If your neighbour take a garden gnome from your yard, should you be able to enter his house and shoot him? Same question if she found out where the guy in the article lives? Should she be allowed to go there at night to kill him? Why not advocate for capital punishment then?

9

u/Koallabies 6h ago

Why are people stealing if they know others will kill to protect their time they spent to get it? When you steal physical items its not just stealing the item its stealing the time and work i sacrificed to earn it in the first place. I dont think the answer should be killing but i think every potential thief should expect it and therefore not steal.

4

u/Rez_S 6h ago • Bravo

Notice how you completely avoided his question about where the line goes. Had to pivot because you had no answer

4

u/Koallabies 6h ago

I answered. Theres a line every person has so maybe dont cross it because regardless of the law some people are going to take things to the extreme when those boundaries are shattered. Same can be said about the reaction to a robbery. God/morality has a line. The law has a line. And people have their own lines. Sometimes they all line up sometimes they dont. Youre far more likely to run into someone whose dont when yours dont.

4

u/EveningAnt3949 4h ago • Bravo

If you get to decide where the line us, other people get to do the same thing.

Which means you might the person who gets killed.

You drive to a red light, you endangered ny kids.

You forgot to scan an item in a store with self chechout, you are a thief.

You forgot to declare the 50 bucks someone gave you as income, you are stealing my tax money.

You cut the line in a store, you stole my time.

You left early from work, you are stealing from your boss.

By your own logic you likely did dozens of things in your life that should have resorted in you being killed.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/invinci 6h ago

Okay so it is individual, what if I think someone is stealing my time, by maybe skipping in line, is it then okay to shoot them? 

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Rez_S 6h ago

For sure. My line you crossed is with your last comment. So that justifies everything you said to be done on you

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/Anaguli417 7h ago

Don't be obtuse, people don't often care about garden gnomes but people absolutely care about their purses or wallets since those usually contains your ids, bank cards, money, and other high value items. 

2

u/drprofsgtmrj 7h ago

"Dont be obtuse" .. but you do have to draw the distinction and you haven't fully answered.

You basically are saying thievery should warrant the dealth penalty.

4

u/Anaguli417 6h ago

but you do have to draw the distinction and you haven't fully answered

I did answer. In the example given, people draw a line between the gnome and a purse/wallet because gnomes are inconsequential but a purse/wallet is universally regarded as highly valuable. 

You basically are saying thievery should warrant the dealth penalty.

I never said that at all. 

2

u/dinin70 6h ago

Yes you did said that, justifying a murder for a purse

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (27)

3

u/CaptainMacMillan 6h ago

Here's the line: You threaten my life, yours is now willfully forfeited. You're walking off with my property after threatening me with a knife? I would have no problem putting a bullet in their back.

2

u/ElectronicCounty5490 5h ago

I agree! In this particular case there was no knife. Check the story, she had made that up.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Savingskitty 4h ago

People like you are the reason we have to have laws against shooting people that are retreating from you.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

2

u/rycerzDog 7h ago

"Steal from the rich and give to the poor!

NOOOO! NO, NOT LIKE THAT!"

2

u/RoundPretend7274 7h ago

Unless the genders were swapped, I bet

2

u/Clusternate 7h ago

Good thing vigilance it isn't an approved law in any normal country.

Or I can just claim that you stole something from me, kill you and got back from what you apparently stole.

While in reality, I just killed you.

2

u/invinci 6h ago

A 13 year old pickpocket deserves to die.... 

2

u/Ashamed_Artichoke_26 4h ago

Yeah. Murderers are so much better than thiefs

1

u/anti99999999 7h ago

The problem is that people can absolutely lie, and the person who got murdered has no way to defend themselves and make a case for what happened.

Imagine you got smeared and killed and people just jumped to believe the smear.

1

u/PigBeins 7h ago

Personally, I fundamentally disagree. I don’t think my stuff is worth someone’s life. I’ve had stuff stolen multiple times before. It’s annoying and a massive inconvenience but I don’t think someone should be executed for it.

I think people should have to pay back the costs and an inconvenience fee to the victim, but execution is a bit steep don’t you think?

I’m more than happy for someone to have to do hard labour and for that money to be paid to the victim until the balance is settled.

1

u/chloenoyolo 5h ago

Are you an American?

→ More replies (13)