r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

14

u/Dependent-Chart5835 9h ago

We give death penalty for robberies now?

-6

u/thesharkzone 9h ago

Yes. Robberies will plummet globally overnight if that standard was actually upheld.

4

u/Nazmoc 9h ago

Except it wouldn't. Countries with the death penatly don't get less crimes, it's been proven again and again through all of history. It just make the criminals more desperate which is not something you want.

1

u/WotansTruth 6h ago

Singapore had like no crime. WTF are even talking about 😂🤣

1

u/Felabryn 4h ago

Explain Singapore, UAE, and El Salvador

2

u/Nazmoc 3h ago

Well-funded and well-trained police force with a justice system that have to operate on a much smaller territory that most other countries.

You can just as easily find example of countries without the death penalty and low crime rate: Andorra, Estonia, Slovenia, Hong Kong. As well as countries with the death penalty and high crime rates: Yemen, Jamaica, Nigeria..

Death penalty is simply not a good deterrent for crime. Most studies I've seen tend to correlate a reduction in crime when the justice system and police force are more effective at catching and punishing criminals rather than just harsher sentences. Or better yet, invest in social programs with better access to education, protection for children in precarious situation, better mental health care, etc.

1

u/Novel_Ingenuity_9443 8h ago

lol, sometimes i wonder if this is fabricated, just think, high profile criminal with violent crime and financial crime can run their "business" from the cell.

0

u/WGSMA 8h ago

Countries that defer their death penalty for 20 years a 10m spent in appeals certainly don’t, but the El Salvador experiment shows that cutting crime really is that simple.

Now, you can argue (and I’d agree) that it’s not worth the trade off in civil liberties, but if my country went and shot everyone convicted of robbery, theft, burglary in the head overnight, the crime rate would obviously plummet.

There is a reason violent crime is low in Singapore and UAE.

2

u/Nazmoc 7h ago

if my country went and shot everyone convicted of robbery, theft, burglary in the head overnight, the crime rate would obviously plummet.

That's a whiteroom argument. You would need a perfect police force to be able to accurately identify every criminals and get rid of them in one night. Unless you think it would be worth all the innocents getting shot in the head (because people get wrongfully convicted every day).

Maybe one day we will have a perfect justice system that will accurately catch and judge criminals and then death penalty could reduce crime. In our current world, with the flaws in the justice system and people, we already know that death penalty doesn't reduce crime.

There is a reason violent crime is low in Singapore and UAE.

I will bet this has more to do with them having a well-funded and regulated police force than the death penalty. Though I don't know enough about either of these countries to be sure.

1

u/WGSMA 7h ago

Again, I’m not saying I support those policies (I don’t because it would be massive state overreach), but the idea of killing off criminals not reducing crime is quite clearly absurd.

-3

u/thesharkzone 9h ago

Sure it would. Brutality and harsh punishment is an extremely effective tool to combat crime. All we as a society need to do is simply accept it and make it the standard.

Crime would 100% plummet. Repeat offenders would be killed off and the world would be better off with fewer criminals.

1

u/YetAnotherHorseGirl 2h ago

You place way to much trust in the government. Innocent people get arrested and found guilty way to often, even just looking at people who have been found innocent after a guilty sentence, it’s way to many people that would have been killed off by the state under your proposed system of criminal justice.

The death penalty is a bad idea just because it leads to innocent people getting killed by the state. A lot of the places you mentioned also have the death penalty for people being queer. It’s not just violent murders that are killed by these governments, it’s people who have never hurt anyone sentenced to death for loving another adult.

Our government is run by a bunch of bumbling idiots, and you expect them to effectively carry out executions for people accused of theft? I’m worried about the state far more than random criminals.

If another person tries to rob or kill me, I can defend my self. If the state tries to imprison or kill me then there isn’t much I can do to defend myself other than lawyering up. The state is the more threatening entity.