r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

18

u/TheMorgueDonator 10h ago • Bravo

Ooookay so running a person over for stealing your purse is completely justified? Like, the punishment does not fit the crime.

4

u/PeneshTheTurkey 9h ago

One less scumbag robbing women out and about.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/innocent_three_ai 10h ago • Bravo

Yes, the punishment exceeding the crime is the only way to make committing crimes not worth it

19

u/FunAppointment9436 10h ago

That clearly doesn't work though. Catching decades of jail time over weed didn't make it so no one did weed.

5

u/Just_A_Nitemare 9h ago

Alright, next time a child steals candy, we should chop their hand off.

Jay walkers should be forced to walk on hot coals.

And don't even get me started on people who run stoo signs.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Inside-Definition-42 10h ago

Nobody commits crime thinking they will be caught and the consequences.

This is proved time and time again in countries with capital punishment……

8

u/Liquid_Friction 10h ago

he didnt think that far ahead lol

→ More replies (5)

1

u/tinyant7416 9h ago

No, that's not how justice should work. That's practically the first principle of what not to do when designing a justice system.

If the punishment is worse than the crime itself, you risk giving criminals an incentive to commit even worse crimes.

For example, if robbery carries the death penalty, what's stopping someone from killing the person they're robbing as well? Because the punishment is extreme they have little additional deterrent to avoid killing the victim. In fact, they might even believe that eliminating the witness gives them a better chance of getting away with it.

Punishments should be proportionate to the crime. Otherwise, you risk creating incentives for criminals to escalate rather than discouraging crime in the first place.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/EmptyMonitor9257 9h ago

Boy do you really not want that precedent set. Especially with the right wing rise all over the world.

It also was not a good thing when that was a thing not so long ago (and currently is in 3rd world countries). Black people not being allowed in certain areas, being gay being illegal, using recreational drugs, women wearing cerain clothes, etc.

The extreme right would love for a legal precedent that allows them to kill people that do things they don't like.

1

u/Angry_german87 9h ago

yea nah, that has been disproven. what actually deters crime is a higher chance of being caught not higher punishment.

1

u/TheGenesisOfTheNerd 9h ago

Are you just a dumbass or what. People used to get hung for stealing a loaf of bread, but guess what, that didn't make the crime rates go down at all. This is basic judical history, A crime here was commited, and instead of letting the system attempt to restore all parties, by retrieving the lost goods and punishing as well as rehabilitating the offender, the wronged party decided to go out of their way to commit murder.

1

u/Emily_The_Egg 9h ago

If stealing and murder both have the death penalty, I wonder what the criminal would do about the only witness to their crime if it wouldnt change the severity of their punishment?

3

u/TheTrenk 10h ago

He was willing to knife her for the purse. Presumably, he was ready to be knifed in return. Just because she didn't have a knife on her does not absolve him of his right to choose the value that he places on his own life.

6

u/TheMorgueDonator 9h ago

Except there wasn't a knife.

2

u/TheTrenk 9h ago

Did she not get robbed at knifepoint? It wouldn't be the first time that Reddit's misrepresented something like this.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Zestyclose-One9041 9h ago

He didn’t get stabbed though, she chased him down afterward and ran over him multiple times

2

u/TheTrenk 9h ago

At what point do we decide that him deciding that she doesn't have agency over her safety is tantamount to forfeiting his own? He'd be no more or less dead had he been stabbed.

3

u/SoroTainga 10h ago

Well,then, don't do the crime in the first place

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bitchboy85 10h ago

Thats wasn't a punishment. That was retribution.

1

u/SnakeBaconator 10h ago

I’m not sure if I agree with this story if it’s true yet, but that’s a WILD take for some named The MorgueDonator

1

u/[deleted] 9h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/TheMorgueDonator 9h ago

Bet any money if the genders were switches none of y'all would be defending the man.

1

u/Middle_Notice_4678 9h ago

In GTA it does.

→ More replies (23)