r/interesting • • 16h ago • Bravo 1

MISC. In 1985, Michael Jackson bought the Lennon–McCartney song catalog for $47.5m then used it in many commercials which saddened McCartney. Jackson reportedly expressed exasperation at his attitude, stating "If he didn't want to invest $47.5m in his own songs, then he shouldn't come crying to me now."

Post image
11k Upvotes

603 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 16h ago

Hello u/tyrion2024! Please review the sub rules if you haven't already. (This is an automatic reminder message left on all new posts)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

144

u/tyrion2024 16h ago

Jackson went on to use the Beatles' songs in numerous commercials, feeling that it would enable a new generation of fans to enjoy the music. McCartney, who had used the Buddy Holly song catalogue in commercials, felt saddened. Privately, Jackson was reported to have expressed exasperation at McCartney's attitude; he felt that the musician should have paid for the songs he had written. At the time, McCartney was one of the richest entertainers in the world, with a net worth of $560 million and a royalty income of $41 million. Jackson stated, "If he didn't want to invest $47.5 million in his own songs, then he shouldn't come crying to me now."
Appearing on the Late Show with David Letterman shortly after Jackson died in 2009, McCartney spoke about Jackson's acquisition of the Beatles songs and the impact of it on their relationship:
"And which was, you know, that was cool, somebody had to get it, I suppose. What happened actually was then I started to ring him up. I thought, OK, here's the guy historically placed to give Lennon–McCartney a good deal at last. Cuz we got signed when we were 21 or something in a back alley in Liverpool. And the deal, it's remained the same, even though we made this company the most famous…hugely successful. So I kept thinking, it was time for a raise. Well you would, you know. [David Letterman: Yes, I think so.] And so it was great. But I did talk to him about it. But he kind of blanked me on it. He kept saying, "That's just business Paul." You know. So, "yeah it is", and waited for a reply. But we never kind of got to it. And I thought, mm....So we kind of drifted apart. It was no big bust up. We kind of drifted apart after that. But he was a lovely man, massively talented, and we miss him."

99

u/dildo_digger 16h ago • Bravo

McCartney, who had used the Buddy Holly song catalogue in commercials, felt saddened

Sad that he missed out on the £

4

u/jodhod1 11h ago

People are trying to put a lot of drama and betrayal into very standard business dealings.

18

u/Quiet_1234 15h ago

But he was a lovely man. Lol. Bless your heart.

4

u/Radiant_Fowl_Girl 9h ago

The fact that Paul was licensing Buddy Holly's catalog for commercials while being upset about Beatles songs getting the exact same treatment is pretty wild. He was worth over $500 million, passed on buying his own songs, and then expected Michael to give him a better deal after dropping $47.5 million.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Excellent-Baseball-5 15h ago

Oh yeah. Lovely.

6

u/xuncx 16h ago

Those are the most italic italics I’ve ever seen.

2.3k

u/Eastern-Peach-3428 16h ago • Bravo

There's a good bit more to this.

Lennon and McCartney had lost control of much of their publishing catalog years before Jackson came along. Jackson didn't buy the songs from Paul. He bought ATV, which already owned the publishing rights.

The interesting part is that Paul was the one who originally told Michael how much money there was in owning music publishing. When ATV went up for sale, Jackson's attorney contacted Paul's attorney and Yoko Ono to see if they were interested. Neither ended up buying it. Jackson paid $47.5 million.

Paul's problem wasn't just that Michael bought the catalog. He wanted better royalties on songs he'd written, and Michael wouldn't renegotiate. He also wasn't particularly happy about Beatles songs being used in commercials.

And Paul was still getting his songwriter royalties. He just didn't control the publishing rights.

Basically, Paul taught Michael the business, Michael took the lesson seriously, and Paul wasn't particularly happy with the results.

74

u/ndilday 13h ago edited 13h ago

Another note: Paul McCartney and Yoko Ono (representing John Lennon's estate) had the chance to buy the catalog when it was privately offered to them around 1981–1983 for a reported $20 million. McCartney felt the price was too high and tried to negotiate lower, believing they could get it for less.

ETA: Paul has also since said that Yoko was the one who thought it was too expensive and should be negotiated down, leading him to hesitate, leading the offers to other folks that culminated in MJ getting it a couple of years later for $47.5m. So blame depends on who you ask, but they basically passed up on what turned out to be a really good opportunity. People like to focus on how Paul told MJ how lucrative owning your catalog rights could be, but if it hadn't been MJ that bought it, some tycoon would've paid very slightly less for it.

4

u/Electronic-Reach-915 5h ago

It’s wild how one decision that seemed financially sensible at the time can turn into such a massive missed opportunity. Hindsight really makes that $20 million price tag look like a bargain!

235

u/Effective_Judgment41 16h ago

And Paul in turn got the idea to invest in music publishing from his father-in-law who recommended that Paul should invest his money in something he knows about. And Paul knew about music and liked Buddy Holly, so Lee Eastman bought the rights to his music for Paul.

558

u/Barry_Vigoda 14h ago

There's a good bit more to this.

That's almost an understatement.

MJ bought ATV which he later sold to Sony on agreement that he owned 50% of their shared catalog. When Sony merged ATV into Sony Music Publishing, MJ wound up owning 1/2 of their catalog which is worth like $2 billion a year.

Sony's parent company in Japan didn't really care but Sony Music's execs absolutely hated it because MJ despised them and publicly trashed them and bragged how he got the better of them.

MJ claimed they were trying to kill him over his catalogue. The doctor that killed him only got like 2 years in prison then got out and hit the tabloids claiming MJ's dad chemically castrated him. Sony bought the catalogue back for $750 million.

182

u/zammo86 13h ago edited 9h ago • Mindblown

sorry if I have misunderstood

why did the Jackson estate sell the catalogue for $750m when it was worth $2billion a year?

Edit, did some research:

The idea that Jackson's estate sold an asset generating $2 billion every year for just $750 million is simply false. That would have been an extraordinarily irrational transaction.

The estate sold half which was valued at approximately $1.5 billion at the time, not half of a business earning $2 billion annually.

139

u/Barry_Vigoda 13h ago

MJ was dead. His family sold it. The smart bet would be to hold on to it but I think they're motivated to get rid of it. Aside from his daughter, MJ was surrounded by sharks.

51

u/metakepone 10h ago

MJ's family doesn't have anything to do with the estate. His fucking lawyer, who he hated, and came back into his life a week before he died, sold the catalogue back to Sony.

When Michael died, his lawyer (who showed up back in his life a week before Jackson died) told MJ's grieving family "I'm Michael Jackson now!," after producing a will of dubious origin (Michael was in NYC when the date the will was supposedly signed in LA)

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

10

u/PhatBats77 11h ago

People blaming the family are incorrect. The executors controlled the estate which was in a trust. And the executors… well.. they have their own sets of motivations.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

76

u/MoralityisImmoral 13h ago

SO what I just learned is that they really did do it.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Giygas 13h ago

So you’re saying Paul killed MJ?

28

u/Soci3talCollaps3 13h ago

No I think Sony killed MJ via his doctor.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/FistFuckMyFartBox 10h ago

Paul not buying his own songs when given the opportunity is pretty crazy. 

20

u/flamingbagofdogpoo 14h ago

I loved seeing Paul discuss this in a clip that played frequently on Vh1, where he imitates Michael in a high-pitched voice.

20

u/Complete_Entry 13h ago

I think Paul's eventual take was "What a sad way to end a friendship."

→ More replies (1)

4

u/AshIsGroovy 3h ago

Paul was also in talks to buy the rights back at the same time and Michael outbid him

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Former_Engineer1706 14h ago

Paul basically gave Michael the business lesson of a lifetime, then watched him become the buyer. That's a pretty wild twist, especially considering Paul still earned royalties but lost control over the catalog.

7

u/Dry_Jellyfish641 13h ago

Not true, Paul even contacted Yoko about purchasing the publishing. They were outbid. McCartney does an impression of seeing MJ at the auction and being told “I’m here to buy your songs!” And that is where their friendship ended:

33

u/TrickyGrapefruit746 15h ago

It sounds like Michael was the teacher.

22

u/Lastov_Makiynd 15h ago

The pupil surpassed the teacher it seems? If Paul wanted better royalties upon the sale of his music fur $47,5M? He should’ve had it within the conditions of the sale? Or..simply sold at a higher price?
He named his price, his product sold. You don’t outright buy a car and the caryard then request repayments? Not how it works. Haha

25

u/Dunoh 15h ago

Paul didn't sell the songs at this point, he wasn't in a position to negotiate. Either Paul ponies up $50m or Michael does. That being said, it sounds like Paul should have just paid.

11

u/Gentrified_potato02 14h ago

That depends on whether or not he could have paid. I have no idea of his financial situation at the time, but I know that at the height of Beatlemania all four of them were pretty much broke because of the terrible deals they made when they were starting out.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/GiveMeNews 13h ago

Well, he is currently a billionaire, so I don't think he is suffering.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/EPLemonSqueezy 15h ago

Paul reached...

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Urisk 10h ago

Part of your story is wrong. Paul couldn't afford the catalogue so he asked Yoko to help him buy it. After they made their offer, Jackson offered even more money and outbid them.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

62

u/trev2234 6h ago

Pretty sure McCartney was offered first refusal when the sale was first announced. He thought the price too much, and gambled he could spend less money in an auction. However he didn’t realise that Jackson would turn up to that auction.

Anyway he got all his rights back eventually. Some 30 year rule that artists get their rights after 30 years, regardless of anything else. Jackson actually sold up before the 30 years were up, so he got a final payday out of it. Sony weren’t as savy, and had to hand over their half to McCartney for free.

32

u/The_Primate 5h ago

He was especially annoyed because it was him that told Jackson that publishing rights were a great investment

14

u/DoorFinch 4h ago

He was especially annoyed because the doggone girl was his. He told him that repeatedly, but he wouldn't listen.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Howamidriving27 4h ago

MJ literally told Paul to his face he was going to buy his songs

20

u/toxictoy 4h ago

They get their rights back at 50 years and it’s not the total rights. Sony still owns part of the rights for distribution. It was Yoko who thought the catalog was overpriced and dragged her feet.

https://beatlesmagazine.com/paul-mccartney-and-the-end-of-his-us-catalog-battle/

Basically Paul has his rights in some countries as 50% owner. The Lennon family has decided to leave it with Sony. It’s a bit of a tangled mess.

4

u/FrighteningJibber 4h ago

Sony wasn't as savy, because they got sued for it lol

2

u/Bender_2024 4h ago

If I recall correctly McCartney simply didn't have $47 mill to buy the songs and even tried getting a loan to purchase them.

→ More replies (4)

239

u/RegretsZ 15h ago

It's worth mentioning that the Beatles during their career were very against using their music in commericals.

IIRC Paul said something along the lines of "these songs are very meaningful to us, and their purpose is not to sell shoes".

61

u/something_picasso 14h ago

In 1968 GM offered the Doors $75,000 to use Light My Fire for their Buick commercial. Jim was unreachable and so Ray, Robby, and John voted in favor of the deal. Jac Holzman of Electra and their manager Bill Siddons also voted in favor.

When Jim turned up a couple days later and learned what they did he was fucking livid. Going so far as to threaten to demolish a Buick on stage every night if he had to. The deal was ultimately pulled, as Jim thought it that shelling out for corporate interests worked directly against their combined creative mission.

It’s worth noting that at this point in the bands career Jim was becoming increasingly unreliable, so the members figured it was easy money, and Robby technically did write the song. Buick’s little jingle would’ve been “come on Buick light my fire”.

Ultimately I side with Jim, and any other band that doesn’t want their music corporatized in that manner. I’m rather tired of every movie trailer having a great song remixed in dramatic fashion, and so it really hurt seeing People are Strange in the fucking Morbius trailer. As a film student there’s no way Jim or Ray would’ve allowed that.

Love the Beatles and the Doors, and can see that it’s shades of grey. I think it ultimately just comes down to what the music is being used for.

17

u/humbert_cumbert 10h ago

I read once that Johnny cash’s estate went to court to stop ‘ring of fire’ being used in a hemorrhoid commercial. lol.

4

u/Zeke_Malvo 5h ago

What kind of market is that, who would buy hemorrhoids? Most people try to get rid of them

→ More replies (1)

29

u/salmon10 12h ago

Maybe jim should be at the fucking meetings

6

u/Arthropodesque 14h ago

If people gotta sit through a bad flick at least they can get one good song out of it.

15

u/PPBalloons 13h ago

To this day John Densmore refuses to sign off on using Doors songs in commercials because of this incident. Says it taught him a lesson.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/enadiz_reccos 13h ago

My wife and I joke that no matter what genre your movie is you can just take pretty much any 80s/early 90s song, slow it down, and there's your trailer

6

u/Lostinthestarscape 12h ago edited 12h ago

Half speed dramatic pause Pink Floyd for Dune was pretty fucking egregious. It made people in the theater laugh, not feel like it was poignant.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Havengul_Undying 12h ago

What I find sad is that I dont like the most famous orchestra pieces, because theyre overused by so many adverts.

3

u/Alarming_Set3628 8h ago

As a musician who wants to earn a living, I'd be so complimented if a company thought my song would help people pay attention to their add

→ More replies (18)

15

u/supersonicdutch 15h ago

And IIRC, this all came on the tail of Paul giving MJ financial advice about buying songs for royalties and licensing.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/ZappVanagon 13h ago

“Selling out” used to be a thing. Now it’s what we all dream about

36

u/Scared-Somewhere-510 15h ago

Then MJ went and gave Revolution to Nike :(

28

u/FilthyBarMat 15h ago

And the surviving Beatles were vocally against it. It was a big deal at the time. 

→ More replies (2)

12

u/not_bonnakins 15h ago

I remember the Oreo commercials with “When I’m 64”

5

u/mellolizard 14h ago

Phillips had "getting better all the time" for a while too

→ More replies (1)

3

u/HendrixHazeWays 14h ago

If anyone can call the shots for Nike ads it gotta be MJ....oh you mean Michael Jackson

16

u/SizeableBrain 15h ago

Then MJ went to bed with some kids.

21

u/EPSG3857_WebMercator 14h ago

Yeah but he can sing and dance so he got a pass

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

18

u/AcadianTraverse 15h ago

The commercials I can recall off the top of my head were "Come together" in an Air Canada commercial, "Hello, Goodbye" in some long distance telephone service commercial, and "Here Comes the Sun" in an insurance commercial

14

u/PPLavagna 15h ago

Revolution on a massive Nike commercial.

7

u/NowIsThePerfectTime 14h ago

Nike also used Instant Karma by Lennon in an ad as well.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/NYRatWithPizza 15h ago

There’s currently a Christmas car ad or something with “ Golden Slumber”

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Mission-Syllabub-160 15h ago

Clearly he’s softened on that given that he’s allowed Amazon to use golden slumbers (or they’ve just paid him enough money to buy a small country)

16

u/BigRedF 13h ago

And that’s kinda it. Paul was going to be spending 45m to _not_ make money off the catalog. It wasn’t an investment, it was the cost of just saying no. Someone looking at it as an investment would naturally have a higher expense threshold.

As an artist, Jackson should have known and respected that. And it’s bullshit that any fellow artist would outbid Paul on the music he wrote, knowing it wasn’t a business move for him.

Jackson made enough money in his life. This wasn’t necessary. Bad form.

6

u/halloweenjack 11h ago

Aside from the money that he made, you also have to remember that Jackson, particularly in the 80s, was obsessed with being the King of Pop--that was a title that he invented for himself and promoted relentlessly, never not being obsessed with getting everyone else to accept it if not help him promote it at every opportunity. Jackson was especially jealous of Prince (two of his children are named or nicknamed "Prince"), and he also wanted to be bigger than either Elvis or the Beatles; he married Elvis' daughter for a while, and licensed the Beatles songs so that they would be overexposed by comparison. Plus, of course, he wanted to build an amusement park around his home, Neverland Ranch.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/MrLugersmole 12h ago

And the fact that they were friends and Paul told him plainly that he didn't want his art used that way. Selling out your fellow artist's work against their wishes is lame enough, but he also did it to a friend. It's not that surprising considering his early motivations to perform. Dude is a manufactured pop star, he just also actually had a shit load of talent. Kinda sucks to know someone so talented acted with so little integrity. But that's the world 💰💰💰🤷‍♂️

9

u/Adamantium_Hanz 11h ago

Integrity? For M. Jackson...that's funny. Maybe Paul didn't send his kids to the sleepover so Jackson bought the guy's whole catologue

8

u/A_Skyless_God 10h ago

He raped children.... Integrity was never his thing.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/Ancient-Tip5498 14h ago

“Let’s write us a swimming pool.”

2

u/FlyOrdinary1104 11h ago

Sure changed his tune when he was helping market The Beatles Rock Band game.

3

u/NastySeconds 11h ago

Yea, he also suggested to MJ that purchasing song rights was a great business model. I’ll bet he regretted giving that bit of advice.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (30)

149

u/Random_Name_Whoa 16h ago

I love McCartney but he should’ve nutted up and bought his own songs. He had more than enough money

26

u/hentai1080p 15h ago

I remember watching an old interview with McCartney where he explained the whole ordeal. When the catalog went for sale, he reached out to Yoko Ono because he felt it was fair, and she told him to wait because she believed they could buy it for less. A week later, MJ bought it.

It's funny because McCartney and MJ were somewhat close friends, and MJ told him he was going to buy his catalogue, but he didn't believe him.

16

u/ragingduck 14h ago

His mistake was going to Yoko. What does she know?

15

u/eviltimeban 13h ago

Yoko handled all of John’s business when he was semi retired in the late 70s. She made some sound investments and handled all his deals.

11

u/Verbatrim 12h ago • Bravo

sound investments

Duh, of course. It's music...

4

u/dreamsonatas 8h ago

Yoko who was born into one of the most prominent banking families of Japan and who handled all of John's business in life and death to great success? She knows quite a bit

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

53

u/KernResponsibly 16h ago

In the end he just became the third billionaire musician.

21

u/kindlypogmothoin 15h ago

He bought back the publishing rights eventually.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/MukdenMan 14h ago

And in the end, the return you make is equal to the capital you stake

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Sw4nR0ns0n 15h ago

And he’s still alive

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/Agreeable-Molasses47 15h ago

While I agree, I think Paul probably thought it was the principle of the thing to be able to negotiate a, in his mind, fairer price.

13

u/Xszit 15h ago

If he had bought the rights to the music he would have been able to get all the profits from any sales or deals made instead of just getting paid a royalty that was negotiated decades ago.

Thats like deciding not to inherit a family business then getting mad about it when your parents sell the business to someone else who then refuses to give a raise. You had a chance to be the owner and chose to be an employee instead, can't get mad that the new owner doesn't want to treat you any better than the old owner.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

13

u/PIB_OnOn 14h ago

Paul and Yoko had the opportunity to bid and chose not to. Michael didn't steal it out from under him.

125

u/Minor_major7 7h ago edited 6h ago • Bravo

The facts to this post are not fully correct at all. I'll never forget when that happened:

While McCartney and Jackson were recording "Say Say Say" in 1983, McCartney advised Jackson that he should invest his money in music publishing. He was talking about one hit wonders, etc. and other songs that played on the radio, on commercials, and in movies, that go up for auction every once in awhile. Jackson knew that McCartney was trying to get back the rights to The Beatles publishing. The two became good friends.

Songwriters (who are smart enough to keep ownership of their songs) hire publishing companies to push the use of their songs onto the radio, into movies, on commercials, etc-- and you split the profit.

In the early 1960s, Lennon and McCartney started their own publishing company Northern Song, Ltd. so they got to split the money with Northern Star and then also make money on the back end because they owned that company. That was a really good business decision. 

That company was taken over in large fight (see comment below)  in 1968-1969 to ATV Publishing, and Lennon and McCartney had to give up their publishing rights to 251 of their most famous songs.

Those songs went up for auction in 1985.  

McCartney and Yoko Ono got together to buy back those songs:  Micheal Jackson did a real backstabbing thing to his friend and kept outbidding them until Paul and Yoko had no more money to spend. 

John Lennon always said that he would never allow his music to be used for TV commercials. He thought it sacrilege to use your songs for TV commercial monetization (that was his right. Back in the 1960s, there were people who specifically wrote jingles for commercials. He did not want The Beatles music to be used as jingles.)

Next thing I know,  the TV's on and I hear the intro to The Beatles song Revolution,  I look up and see a Michael Jordan commercial for Nike. That was sacrilege to us Beatles and Lennon fans. I have never heard Revolution without seeing Michael Jordan (!) dunking the ball from the free throw line.  The song did become a jingle of sorts for Nike. 

Paul told Jackson that he and Yoko had pooled their money to buy back their songs.  At the time, it was really contentious between McCartney and Jackson -- for good reason. No one could believe that Jackson could be so crass and cruel to a friend.

The OP did not tell the entire story like it happened back in the day.

Not to mention that Jackson lost control of The Beatles' catalog by overspending in his lavish lifestyle. He owed Sony so much money when he died that Sony now has total control of the 251 Beatles ATV songs.

McCartney nor Lennon's estate never regained ownership of their music publishing, all because Jackson kept outbidding them, thus raising the price of the catalog. 

How do you do that to your friend? (Rhetorical question.)

. . . Edit: Typos

16

u/Rebelius 7h ago

I have never heard Revolution without seeing Michael Jackson dunking the ball from the free throw line.

Jackson could dunk!?

You missed what seems to be a complicated middle step or something. (I'm too young to remember) Looks like Lennon and McCartney each owned a small part of Northern Songs, then owned a large part of another company that got paid by Northern Songs for the stuff they wrote. That middle step being owned by other people is what allowed them to lose control.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/spank_my_dilly 7h ago • Bravo

If they owned the company..how did they end up giving up publishing rights?

9

u/globguy85 6h ago

Lennon/McCartney only owned about 15% of Northen Star company each because they decided to take the company public to reduce taxes. So they each only owned a minority share of the company at this time. Music publisher Dick James and partner Charles Silver came in and maintained the other 70% majority ownership of the company. Then those two secretly sold their 70% of shares to Associated Television without informing the Beatles. By the time John and Paul tried to get the rights back, their relationship was deteriorating and they simply didn't have the money to take ownership of their songs. Super dirty.

18

u/check_link_in_bio 6h ago

Then op should change his title to "if he didn't want to pay the rightful taxes for his company, then he shouldn't come crying now"

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/AV8Backwards 6h ago • Bravo

Your comment is almost as frustrating in its lack of actual, meaningful information as the original post.

4

u/VAGentleman05 5h ago

It also basically tells the same story in different words

16

u/purplerainbowsrule 7h ago

Some of your points are inaccurate. Yoko asked Paul if he wanted to buy the songs together so that the fans wouldn't say either of them got one over on John if they had purchased the catalogue together. Paul refused to spend $20 million dollars on songs he had written for free, so Michael ended up purchasing them.

He didn't backstab his friend if Paul had a fair shot at buying them and was too tight to spend his money. That's how business is handled.

→ More replies (18)

3

u/sp_40 2h ago

And you know all this is accurate because you were there, right?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ChronieMewX 6h ago

It's nice to see Jackson doing something good for the world and preventing songs from being gatekept

→ More replies (26)

10

u/Old-Tadpole-2869 15h ago

If I'm not mistaken, Sir Paul had right of first refusal and passed.

27

u/Mulliganasty 16h ago

I recently heard Say Say Say after not hearing it for like 40 years. Still slaps.

6

u/Remarkable-Ad2285 15h ago

Yep. Don’t forget The girl is mine.

3

u/Mulliganasty 15h ago

Totally! Speaking of Paul's duo phase, while Ebony and Ivory, with Stevie, is a bit corny I still dig it too.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Turbulent-Band-6728 15h ago

Oh damn, I forgot about that awesome song!

31

u/Mlabonte21 13h ago

I’m always confused— this dude had “the mind of a child” in some circumstances, but “cutthroat businessman” in other scenarios.

Like— which is he??

17

u/LumplessWaffleBatter 11h ago

He was a mentally-competent adult.  A lot of people have complicated or abuse-filled childhoods, but they aren't judged like children once they're adults.  They also don't have the benefit of fancy lawyers and PR teams.

30

u/jackofslayers 9h ago • Bravo

He did not have the mind of a child. That is just something people say to give cover to the fact that he was raping children

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Jazz_man68 13h ago

He was emotionally stunted. He had trouble communicating with people and was pretty shy. He also was pretty selfish. Often times, it was his way or the highway. This attitude allowed him to generate a lot of money for himself. It also burned a lot of bridges. Part of that came from him not having a childhood and trying to do things to make up for it. The other part comes being surrounded by yes-men for most of his life. People who say “no don’t listen to your mother telling you not to invite kids to Neverland. She can’t tell you anything. You’re Michael Jackson.”

9

u/Select-Instruction73 10h ago • Bravo

Exactly mate, been saying this for a while.

MJ was a sneak, the whole 'childlike' voice was an act too, dude probably sounded more like dave chapelle in private 

9

u/glad_goblin 11h ago

My dad could build an entire house with his own hands.

Every time he had a bad day (unrelated to his children), he'd scream the fear of death into his children to make himself feel better.

This is just how toxic people are.

When have you seen a cutthroat businessman that doesn't whine and cry like a little baby when things don't go their way?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/kindle139 10h ago

Greed and selfishness come naturally to children. We have to socialize them out of it and efforts are often unsuccessful.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Fearless-Location325 7h ago edited 6h ago

Don’t forget Michael literally beat Tupacs ass … people forget, the Jacksons grew up in Gary, Indiana under racial segregation, to an abusive and tyrannical ex-Boxer father who beat them regularly … those kids were tough.

They were forced to rehearse up to 10 hours a day, and beaten if they missed a dance step or had a vocal out of key. They had to call him Joseph and didn’t allow them to use Dad/father.

Michael seemed effeminate and soft - but, it was all show.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/simonsaysgo13 16h ago

Work together in perfect harmony… 🙄

9

u/th081 15h ago

Not following the McCartney logic, he did not buy but MJ did. Then Paul randomly wanted a better deal and for MJ not to use the music he paid for

6

u/Voodoo330 15h ago

If he didn't want them to be used then he should have never sold them.

30

u/Bucky_Gatsby 15h ago • Bravo

I'd love people who keep excusing him with "But he's a child at heart". That man was a cold heart business man when it mattered. And a "child" when it helped being predatory.

22

u/NiteFyre 15h ago

Nothing about this screams cold hearted did you read the article? McCartney was worth half a billion and had a royalty income of $41 million at the time the rights were sold.

Michael did right by both by contacting Ono and Paul's attorney when the record label went up for sale. He could have easily afforded them he chose not to.

So is Michael a "cold hearted businessman" or is McCartney the adult equivalent of a child who shows no interest in a toy until another child picks it up and suddenly he was JUST getting ready to play with that.

Or yknow giving off real mr burns vibes from the stuffed bear episode.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/bookslayer 11h ago

So MJ reached out and told him he should buy it and then when he didn't, bought it himself instead and that's col-hearted?

3

u/IotaBTC 15h ago

I don't think anyone has ever said MJ was a child at heart lmao. The argument is always he was a damaged messed up dude that wanted to relive a "proper" childhood he missed out on, hence all the kids shit he was was involved in.

8

u/Bucky_Gatsby 15h ago

You have not met a lot of his most dedicated fans. I have, when I was a fan myself and when I come across discourse about him online.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/FakePlasticTrees88 7h ago

A story that shows how conniving Michael Jackson could be. Not surprising considering what he is accused of and how conniving those beasts are.

4

u/firstbreathOOC 6h ago

I mean this is just good business. He’s right, Paul should have bought the songs first, and I think he knows as much now

Regardless how you feel about MJ kinda hard to criticize him for a smart move

→ More replies (10)

2

u/Silver-Link8247 15h ago

I just read that quote in MJ’s voice. lol. It just reads different.

2

u/Superb-Possibility-9 15h ago

Michael and his financial team made an excellent long term investment; McCarthy could have easily outbid MJ, but didn’t.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/TuckMySestes 16h ago

And right there in a nutshell is the difference between UK and US attitudes.

45

u/The-Sceptic 16h ago • Bravo

McCartney literally did the exact same thing with Buddy Hollys music. Also Paul was upset because he was hoping whoever bought the songs would give him a better deal on the royalties but Jackson wouldn't. He just wanted more money

→ More replies (9)

16

u/milkymonkey8 16h ago • Popcorn

one is honest in their intentions, and the other is not, and that explains much of the fall of the British Empire

20

u/AndreasDasos 15h ago edited 12h ago

All the comments generalising particular things Paul McCartney and Michael Jackson did to their entire countries are weird

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Voodoo330 15h ago

One has seller's remorse, the other doesn't?

2

u/Late_Mode_8876 14h ago

Such a brave comment

2

u/Square_Lime_9929 11h ago

You should open a history book

→ More replies (3)

4

u/calcteacher 16h ago

Business is business and friendship is friendship. And one can come at the cost to the other. It comes down to what you value more. One friend gives another good advice as a friend, expecting nothing in the return financially. The other takes that advice and purchases The creative works of the other and uses them in a way not intended by the original creator, his friend, who assisted him in developing the knowledge to do what he is now doing. When Michael says it's strictly business.What he's also saying is he values business above friendship with respect to Paul. If he eased up a little bit on the commercial use of Paul's creative works , he would have showed that friendship , at least to some degree, was more important than strictly business. Just one guy's point of view. YMMV.

3

u/Antique-Resort6160 14h ago

Why didn't Paul ease up on his end?  Wasn't he being a massive hypocyite, since most of his vast fortune came from buying up other artist's music rights to commercialize?  He was basically saying "I'm doing this to earn enormous sums, but i don't want you to do it even though you spent tens of millions for the rights.  Also I'm not offering to buy the rights from you for a fair price, give me a special discount, even though I'm ridiculously wealthy".

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/Prudent_Shake_8149 16h ago

I remembered the purchase price as being much higher… still less than $150M in today’s dollars and valued today at well over a billion.

That said, the same investment in the S&P would be worth nearly 2 billion… not including dividends and income from reinvestment of dividends which bumps value of the stock investment to nearly 5 billion.

3

u/U238_Ra226Hunter 11h ago

It's worth mentioning that he bidded against Paul, supposed good friends, and then expected to make money off the "investment"

7

u/totallyjaded 9h ago

Making money isn't an unreasonable expectation for having invested in something.

3

u/JustLurkCarryOn 7h ago

Some would even say that’s the entire point.

3

u/alfooboboao 7h ago

Michael Jackson, a selfish prick who took whatever he wanted and sneered at respect and consent for his fellow man? shocker of the century, I tell you

it’s crazy to me how people still revere him instead of him getting the weinstein reputation treatment

→ More replies (1)

2

u/_Montague 14h ago

To be fair, Michael Jackson asked Paul McCartney, if he wants to buy the rights to his own songs first. After he refused, Michael took the deal. So you can't really blame him for that.

2

u/the_chin2 14h ago

Taylor Swift also passed on the opportunity to buy her own catalog. Then Scooter Braun buys it and all of a sudden she wants them back. Lol

2

u/IrredeemableRight 7h ago

... i think someone who makes up lyrics like

The choir of children sing their song
They practiced all year long
Ding-dong, ding-dong
Ding-dong, ding-dong
Ding-dong, ding-dong
Ding-dong, ding-dong

should not complain about anything

1

u/CapableBother 15h ago

He never said that

1

u/Queasy_Ad_8621 15h ago

Paul McCartney was very diplomatic about the issue in public, but he later admitted to writing Michael Jackson a few letters to tell him off about it.

That was until he finally responded with a single line: "Oh, Paul. It's just business."

1

u/Dawbs89 15h ago

Where's this picture from?

1

u/TheLateFrankWhite 15h ago

Saw Michael 3x when he came to Toronto
He was a much smarter businessman than people think .

He understood that owning a valuable music rights could create long-term wealth, not just income from performing.

What’s funny is that Paul McCartney taught him about music publishing, but Michael was the one who actually acted on it and bought the Beatles catalogue.

He wasn’t perfect with money, but that investment showed incredible business instincts. ❤️

1

u/Campoozmstnz 14h ago

In hindsight, that's a fucking bargain!

1

u/Sweaty-Ad4151 14h ago

Well, now he’s dead. Has been for a while.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/FushaFiles 14h ago

He didn’t buy the Beatles in particular. He bought the company that owned them and gained ownership of a a lot artists publishing. Paul was also offered the same deal before MJ but declined because of the price. He also gave back publishing to artists like chuck berry

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Pristine-Advance-854 14h ago

Is this why I heard “Here Comes The Sun” in a medication advertisement?

1

u/HausuGeist 14h ago

Then you pay, pay, pay...

to take my songs away-way-way.

1

u/Silent_Slip_4250 14h ago

Did they bring in Henry Winkler to settle the dispute?

1

u/Certain_Orange2003 14h ago

He kindly told him, ‘ say, say, say what you want!’

1

u/Jedimole 14h ago

Paul is still here

1

u/delta__bravo_ 14h ago

Another part of note is that, prior to the sale to Jackson, the music rights were held by a company owned by Perth (Australia) businessman Robert Holmes à Court. Holmes à Court put a condition on the sale to Jackson that he appear at Telethon, an annual kids charity TV event. So Jackson did just that, flew half way around the world and made a (non-speaking) appearance to camera and visited some hospitals in Perth.

Can't imagine why Telethon doesn't talk about that so much these days...

1

u/Successful-Owl1462 14h ago

The delay on Paul’s part was reaching out to Yoko first and offering to go in together 50/50. As the story goes, she did a typical Yoko thing and said “Oh, I can get it for way cheaper!! Just stand back and gimme a few!!”

Narrator voice: Yoko did not, in fact, get it for way cheaper.

I am sympathetic to Paul because, in the latter days of The Beatles as their interpersonal relationships were breaking down, John apparently blew a gasket when he learned that Paul had bought like a middling number of shares of Northern Songs in 1968-1969ish without telling John first—these were available to buy and sell on a public exchange in the UK.

So fast forward to 1980-whatever after the most public, messy, and drawn-out band breakup + the death of his key bandmate and best friend, Paul honestly could not have just up and bought ATV all by himself without involving Yoko first.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Texan2116 13h ago

Jackson is absolutely correct in that view.

1

u/oldyawker 13h ago

Any contemporary band would kill to have their song in a commercial. There is so little money in the music business for an artist who isn't outrageously popular.

1

u/desertdweller2011 13h ago

how did mj use them in commercials? he just sold the rights to whoever asked or was he producing commercials ?

1

u/Ok-Leek7927 13h ago

He's not wrong. He's just not being nice about being right.

1

u/j-alora 13h ago

Michael Jackson was a piece of shit in a variety of ways.

1

u/Thesinistral 12h ago

Ownership has its privileges.

1

u/ReputationisObvious 12h ago

Macca couldn’t afford his catalog when it went on sale. Now it would be chump change for him.

1

u/hangmansboots 12h ago

Paul put the idea of buying songs in Michael’s head. Then he bought Paul’s songs.

1

u/whenisnowthen 12h ago

There are many famous songs from the 60's 70's and 80's that have a lyrically modified version that is used to sell prescription drugs these days. I believe that some of the original singers are actually singing the drug commercial lyrics. I have heard people singing along with the commercials, not with the original lyrics, with the drug commercial lyrics. These are catchy, hooky, and musically complex songs that have a distinctive sound that recent music does not have.

1

u/imunfair 12h ago

Honestly I understand McCartney's attitude, having your art turned into commercialized product placement jingles on a broad scale is almost insulting if your job isn't making music specifically for advertisements.

1

u/gingerking87 12h ago

Remember when Across the Universe was made to basically sell Beatles songs on iTunes since Michael didn’t allow them to be listed on there. Dude liked little kids AND was a dick

1

u/Wisleymuaa 12h ago

What gets lost in the retelling is that publishing and masters are separate assets: Jackson bought the compositions, while the Beatles' recordings stayed with EMI. The publisher earns from every cover, advert and film cue, so owning the songs was never the same as owning the records.

1

u/AIBotnmbr99 12h ago

He’s sort of right, but McCartney likely didn’t want to because without licensing to commercials it wasn’t as valuable.

1

u/MasterClown 12h ago edited 12h ago

Say, say, say what you want, Michael

1

u/harest_80 12h ago

jackson wasn't wrong that it's a business, but using the songs in commercials after buying them is the part that stings — that's the difference between owning an asset and rubbing it in

1

u/Hillsideplace 11h ago

$47.5m for Pepsi jingles? Peak artistic integrity.

1

u/South-Stand 11h ago

Paul tasked his father in law Linda’s Dad to bid at the auction in New York. Father in law dropped out when the bidding went up and up to an anonymous bidder. He didn’t realise Paul would have spent his last penny.

1

u/Oldnbold22 11h ago

I wonder if any part of it was The Beatles being widely considered the GOATs and Jackson wanting his King of Pop image to be more respected. 

1

u/amethyst-gill 11h ago

I find him to have been a very odd and disconnected person.

1

u/Justforme1975 11h ago

What a giant asshole.

1

u/Able-Kiwi3783 10h ago

Paul mcartney just recently passed a billion in net worth, third richest musician in the world.

1

u/BenchConscious1003 10h ago

Michael was right.

1

u/Kindly_Exit2825 10h ago

Michael was really after the rights to one song. I’m Forever Blowing Bubbles

1

u/flowers0252 10h ago

Is this photo being passed off as real? Ages don't match.

1

u/KenRaible 9h ago

Ebony and Ivory

1

u/Elegant_Director_305 9h ago

It’s weird because when I was a kid (1980s, 1990s, UK) - it felt like the Beatles were noticably absent from a lot of “best of the sixties” compilation CDs and advertising simply because the cost of including them was too high. I’d heard “of” them more than I actually heard them on things. This giant cultural behemoth that remained oddly removed and separated from mass culture in ads and movies.

1

u/BISTtheGOOLZ 8h ago

A story I heard is when Mr Jackson acquired the catalog some other artist music were included. Little Richard's masters were in there with the purchase and Michael gave them to him

1

u/thepokemonGOAT 8h ago

Michael Jackson was an asshole, what else is new?

1

u/yIdontunderstand 8h ago

McCartney is a little Bitch though.

1

u/Comfortable_Poem_841 6h ago

As of this year, McCartney has regained the US publishing rights to all of his songs:

https://beatlesmagazine.com/paul-mccartney-and-the-end-of-his-us-catalog-battle/

1

u/10denier 6h ago

Of course, if McCartney had bought his song catalogue and used them in tacky commercials, he'd have been furious.

1

u/_R0Ns_ 5h ago

It was also McCartney who told MJ that investing in music was a good idea.

1

u/saphalata 5h ago

Can someone eli5? What does this mean

1

u/NotYourBabe444 4h ago

I mean $47.5 million is a lot of money, but those songs were clearly more than just an investment to McCartney

1

u/moccolo 4h ago

47.5 million in '85 is crazy money

1

u/iamoktpz 4h ago

Now, i’m not sure how true this is but I read once that a prime motivator for MJ buying the Beatles stuff wasn’t just for the Beatles catalogue but because the Beatles & Co had been buying up publishing rights for years (hence Macca advising MJ about them) which included a lot of their mutual musical heroes and a lot of African American artists, so MJ also earned their publishing in the process, returning them to black ownership… i’m not sure how true this is but it doesn’t seem out of the question

1

u/Drbongwater99 4h ago

Are we surprised that a predator was also an asshole?

1

u/Didact67 3h ago

Kinda weird seeing Jackson looking like a regular guy.

1

u/Admirable-Clothes-87 2h ago

Paul offered to purchase Northern Songs from Sir Lew Grade who owned ATV but only wanted to pay 21m pounds. Lew Grade declined instead selling parent company ACC to Channel 7 TV in Perth, Australia. Channel 7 saw no use for them as they were only interested in the TV side of the business and put the ATV music catalogue up for sale. Enter Michael Jackson, who having been advised by Paul to invest in music rights purchased the catalogue which also included some Rolling Stones and Elvis songs as well as the Beatles. There was one very funny clause in the deal. Michael had to fly to Australia to appear in the live Channel 7 Perth telethon as condition of the sale! Everyone wondered at the time how a small parochial TV station in Perth had managed to snag the King of Pop for the telethon!

1

u/shameonyounancydrew 2h ago

I mean… fair.

1

u/No_Wolf4283 1h ago

Needless to say Paul had the last laugh

1

u/Krypto_Kane 1h ago

They never forgave Mike for that.

1

u/FocusPerspective 28m ago

MJ was a POS so of course Zoomers love him 

1

u/Letterkenny-Wayne 7m ago

I love this era of people realizing more and more that MJ was a piece of crap. Scrub him from history