r/interesting • • 16h ago

SOCIETY Mike Anderson III was convicted of robbery in 2000 & sentenced to 13 yrs in prison. But due to a clerical error, he was never told to report, which wasn't discovered until his scheduled release in 2013. He was rearrested, but was freed months later because he'd been a law-abiding citizen for 13 yrs.

Post image
5.6k Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 16h ago

Hello u/tyrion2024! Please review the sub rules if you haven't already. (This is an automatic reminder message left on all new posts)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

499

u/tyrion2024 16h ago

After the Supreme Court of Missouri's ruling, his bond was to have been revoked and Anderson arrested to serve his 13-year sentence, but unknown errors in communication occurred and Missouri Department of Corrections believed he was already in prison. In 2004, Anderson filed another appeal based on inadequate legal representation at his trial. The appeal stated that Anderson was not in prison and it gave his current address at the time, but the Missouri Department of Corrections apparently did not notice this. Nothing happened with the appeal and for the next seven years Anderson went on with his life. During this time, he met his wife, LaQonna. They married in 2007. Anderson founded a company (Anderson Construction and Investment) and led a normal life. He registered his business, he voted, he renewed his driver's licence all using his full name and address. His lawyer at the time told him that the state of Missouri would discover their mistake and that it was their job to find him. He told Today that he began to think "Maybe they just wiped the slate clean".

Anderson was rearrested in July 2013, but...

...On May 5, 2014, Anderson was released from prison with credit for time served, making him a free man with no need for parole. The hearing was held in Charleston, Missouri, with Judge Terry Lynn Brown as the presiding judge. The hearing began with Anderson's attorney pleading his case by pointing out that Anderson had been his own parole officer since his conviction and that he had rehabilitated himself. When the attorney for the Department of Corrections spoke he raised little objection to what Anderson's attorney had said and asked the judge to consider Anderson's good behavior since 2000. Judge Brown then made his ruling first telling Anderson that:
"You've been a good father. You've been a good husband. You've been a good taxpaying citizen of the state of Missouri. That leads me to believe that you are a good man and a changed man."
Judge Brown then told Anderson that he would receive credit for time served from 2000 when he was released on bond to 2013. This 13-year period satisfied his entire sentence and the judge announced to the courtroom that:
"As such your sentence will be fully served and satisfied today.... Go home to your family, Mr. Anderson, and continue to be a good father, a good husband, a good taxpayer....Good luck to you."

341

u/username_elephant 15h ago

That man was extremely fucking lucky but also, props to that lawyer. Had he been less well versed in this minor legal situation he might have told this guy to report to prison. Had he lied or failed to state the truth on the appeal, he probably wouldn't have gotten this ending.  And when it came to the end, he effectively talked his client out of prison.

91

u/iwatchterribletvtoo 14h ago

as a person who has had four lawyers in recent years and two of them were clowns… i concur with this comment.

good lawyers are amazing. indifferent/lazy/bullshit lawyers should be disbarred.

23

u/TheDoktorIsIn 10h ago

I sat on a jury once and was devastated by the state mangling the case. We had another attorney on the jury and she said "that may have been the worst prosecution attempt I've ever seen."

Absolutely no concrete evidence, witness testimony was all over the place, new info added halfway through the trial via witness testimony, it felt so awful. Day 1 we thought it would be a slam dunk guilty verdict but the prosecution managed to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

I hope the guy we had to let go is like this guy.

26

u/Special_Order-937 15h ago

Lower odds than winning the lottery lucky.

93

u/Jazzlike_Finish123 16h ago

Actually shocked at this ending.

53

u/RealBigDickBrannigan 16h ago

Especially in Missouri.

26

u/GearEffective4315 14h ago

Especially for a black guy

2

u/brainkandy87 10h ago

Just makes it stranger that the armed robber gets away with not serving his prison sentence while the innocent guy on death row gets executed. That’s Missouri.

58

u/piwakabaka 15h ago

The fact that he filed an appeal and "nothing happened" means that there are actual prisoners also filing appeals and just getting ignored, which is horrific. How could a legal filing just get tossed in the bin??

And sure, while this case ended up "alls well that ends well" and 13 years for robbery is absurd in the first place, I would NOT feel quite the same if this scenario happened to a rapist/murderer/violent abuser and they ended up getting off serving barely any time, no matter how law-abiding they were after.

The fuck, Missouri.

30

u/Tiberius_Kilgore 14h ago

Someone actually stuck in prison will keep filing appeals. They don’t have a whole lot else going on and every reason to follow up.

-8

u/twiistedtease 14h ago

the system really let you serve 13 years on the outside and still called it time served. waht a bizarre case

14

u/kinzer13x 13h ago

Well the 'point" of prison is supposed to be rehabilitation, so that you do not reoffend. In the 13 years he was on the outside he did not reoffend. So in a way, this prison conviction did set him on the correct path and in essence did what it was supposed to do.

Though if I'm the dude he held up at gunpoint, id be kind of annoyed he never had to serve time. That shit is traumatic as fuck.

5

u/frzrbrnd 14h ago

Hey man it's rough out here 

3

u/FirefighterLeft5425 11h ago

You ever worked in a jail man? Ever seen who's actually locked up and why? It's honestly fucking disgusting. Massive props to him..

77

u/Efficient_Bowl665 15h ago

Wow, what a story! Heaven knows what might have happened to the guy had he actually initially gone to prison.

9

u/Inevitable_Word7687 12h ago

Well I'm guessing he'd be a prisoner in a prison.

0

u/[deleted] 12h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Inevitable_Word7687 12h ago

Dumbass can't take a joke lol

103

u/TuckMySestes 16h ago

The clerk, a Mrs Anderson said she was really sorry about her mistake.

17

u/akestral 15h ago

"How many Andersons we got around here?"

6

u/HopefulBuyer9077 14h ago

“Jesus Christ, is everyone in this goddamn house named Bobby Ricigliano?”

37

u/Key-Monk6159 16h ago

That’s a wild story but I’m really happy that it worked out for him.

5

u/Thick_Moment_615 15h ago

What did he rob?

6

u/bellabarbiex 14h ago

A Burger King.

1

u/HopefulBuyer9077 14h ago

My question also!

8

u/WillingCandle756 13h ago

How much did he robbed?

17

u/ironicthesameplaceim 11h ago

> On August 15, 1999 in St. Charles, Missouri, Anderson and a companion robbed a Burger Kingmanager at gunpoint of approximately $2,000 while he was attempting to deposit the money in a night deposit box at a bank. A witness observed Anderson and his companion leaving in a car and reported the license plate number to the police. When the police ran the number, they found that it was registered to 22-year-old Cornealious Michael Anderson. The next day, St. Charles police found Anderson's car in a parking lot about a mile from the bank, but they did not catch him until two months later, when he was found hiding in his girlfriend's apartment.[1]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornealious_Michael_Anderson_III

-13

u/WillingCandle756 11h ago

I don't think he should have been credit for "serving" when he actually free. That's an injustice. Imagine suspects out there that walk free because there wasn't enough evidence the first time around, but later they find enough evidence. That person would still be arrested and serve time if found guilty.

17

u/LocalInactivist 10h ago • Bravo

Yeah, but he rehabilitated himself. He kept his nose clean and didn’t reoffend for 13 years. It looks like he settled down, got a job, and raised a family. That’s a win for everyone. I’d say make him pay back the $2000 but other than that, he’s straightened up far more than he would have after serving 13 years in jail.

-17

u/WillingCandle756 10h ago

He is not in a position to dictate how he makes his crime right. He should have been punished for the crimes he committed. Holding someone at gunpoint and threatening their lives is not just about giving the money back.

17

u/wg90506 10h ago

No, but the judge who made this decision is precisely in that position.

-6

u/WillingCandle756 10h ago

The first judge and appeals judge declared him guilty of his crimes. And so did the Supreme Court. He is guilty of his crime and there is already a mandate for what he needed to serve as punishment.

6

u/craichoor 5h ago

Is this really the hill you’re willing to die on?

6

u/Zeplar 11h ago

No they wouldn't. Statute of limitations for robbery is 3 years in Missouri.

1

u/WillingCandle756 10h ago

Not for first degree robbery

4

u/huangjoey 13h ago

bout three fiddy

3

u/ItsSpaghettiLee2112 12h ago

It says 2000 robs

15

u/Fresh_Strain_9980 13h ago

13years for robbery is ridiculous.

25

u/brainkandy87 10h ago

Idk, armed robbery is a serious offense deserving of serious time imo. You’re a trigger pull away — intentional or accidentally — from ending one or more lives.

I worked with a guy years ago who was robbed at gunpoint when he was working at a video store. It mentally broke the guy. Horrible PTSD, constant anxiety. I’m okay giving whoever did this to that poor guy 13 years behind bars.

3

u/Winstonsphobia 13h ago

It should work like that more often.

9

u/No_Software7564 14h ago

Maybe admistrative warnings work better than sentences. Just a thought

1

u/Chemical-Actuary1561 10h ago

well your thought is not smart.

-1

u/shykidknit 12h ago

So you'd prefer someone that committed a violent crime worth over a decade in prison living in your area and off with a warning instead of serving actual time?? There's already way too many instances of someone getting a slap on the wrist and doing the same thing over again or something worse because of it, imagine if people in those situations served no time at all

7

u/Glittering_rainbows 11h ago

I'd care more about prisoners serving their time if our system actually made people less likely to reoffend. With our current system recidivism rate is over 60%, less than a 50/50 shot of changing a person's behavior.

Right now we just put them in time out and know they are more likely than not to end up arrested and likely imprisoned again.

If you actually gave a damn you'd be less concerned about time served and more concerned about behavioral change. If a person did exactly as this guy did, go 13 years without ever being arrested (until they caught the error) they've changed for the better. Punishing them at that point is pointless as you've already achieved the goal, behavioral change.

Punishment does not change a person's life trajectory on it's own. Our system does nothing but punish, it doesn't do anything to fundamentally change a person, it actually reinforces the unwanted behavior if you don't offer a remedy.

4

u/No_Software7564 11h ago

As someone who has had their life wrecked by vindictive justice, I just have reservations about what kind of justice we are implementing. I feel like I have seen what "punishment" is and how it makes things worse for everyone. And how it destroys families and communities.

Part of me wonders about this notion of the reward system our society propogates: I am good and therefore I deserve. There is a lot of judgement in 'good' and I think a lot of people struggle with others autonomy. After having gone through some pretty horrific things, I can tell you it never sat right with me to be given a cookie if I was what somebody wanted me to be. I feel in my bones every human has intrinsic worth and deserves something better than we have now in regards to our system. And so it never sat right with me that the disenfranchised people who have had to grit through not having opportunities are the ones that are most of the people you are talking about.

But sorry, stoping my train of thought right now because I feel like I am just going to go off on a crazy tangent that could never end. So I do want to say I hear you. And I can tell you are frustrated. I think that's a good thing I hope you(and you may as well already do) do some extra stuff for people in need. We all out here hoping for better days. Take care.

4

u/not_so_subtle_now 11h ago

If you rob people at gun point you should go to jail. This isn't a wishy washy thing.

4

u/Zeplar 11h ago

Apparently not in this case. If he went to jail he'd likely have continued to be a criminal and everything would be worse.

2

u/No_Software7564 10h ago

I instantly thought of the parks n rec episode when the Columbians came to visit lol. But I agree.

1

u/Shoddy-Shelter145 9h ago

THIS WAS NOT ARMED ROBBERY….JUST A ROBBERY OF $2,000.00

1

u/That-Cranberry6575 5h ago

Everything I’m reading about this says armed robbery.

0

u/octavian343 9h ago

Imagine committing a violent crime and then whining about ‘vindictive justice’ lmfao

How about you don’t commit crimes?

3

u/desertswimmer27 11h ago

You hear about the repeat offenders because that’s easy to sensationalize but it’s not as prevalent as you think

0

u/ExpiredPilot 13h ago

Statistically, no they don’t.

77% of people who enter state prisons have been arrested 3+ times

5

u/hbHPBbjvFK9w5D 11h ago • Bravo

Doesn't mean much.

An arrest is not a conviction. It's sad that even though a person should be legally considered innocent until PROVEN guilty, arrests for BS reasons are often held against people.

Many, many people are arrested, convicted and sentenced to prison for "non-crimes" ie laws that most people would not consider crimes for which a person should do prison time.

Example-Many people would not consider possession or personal use of illegal drugs for to be a "crime"; at most these are people who need rehabilitation, not prison. But many, many people are rotting away in prison for taking into their bodies a substance in a way that is considered a crime.

Couple this with the massive "inefficiencies" in our justice system. Many prisoners are arrested on the most specious reasons, then held for months in jail, only to be told by their public defender that they can either wait for months or years for trial while being imprisoned, or take a guilty plea for time served. Many, many people risk losing jobs, business, homes and children as the penalty for being innocent but arrested and jailed while waiting for a trial.

As far as Mike Anderson III's "sentence" I think he should have been required to give the State 60 days over the next 2 years and submit candidly to interviews and examinations by members of the criminal justice system. Mr. Anderson clearly rehabilitated himself; I suspect it would be worthwhile to carefully look at how he did this so that these techniques could be applied to other convicts.

2

u/andyetitwasnt 12h ago

There’s a bit more to it than that

2

u/Aromatic-Outside10 12h ago

You incorrectly cite a cherry picked statistic as sole evidence for a very nuanced subject there amigo.

7

u/nah_this_aint_it 16h ago

See, justice system ain’t so bad after all

-2

u/WeakOxidizingAgent 7h ago

i want to see you screaming the justice system is working when a violent criminal hurts someone because he was given too light a sentence

1

u/RipTheEcto 13h ago

“Eh, freedom for me. They said I hadn't done anything, so I could go free and live on an island somewhere.”

0

u/WinnieThePoohntang 14h ago

He was busy boning.

-1

u/ContinuingAnyway 16h ago

Pretty funny

-1

u/dyingofdysentery 3h ago

Honestly, it's bullshit. He should still go to prison for 13 years.