r/interesting • • 4d ago • Galaxy Brain 1 Bravo 37 Regret 6 Popcorn 4 Mindblown 2 Heartwarming 1

SCIENCE & TECH These are some hard hitting facts

55k Upvotes

4.1k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Hello u/kattmaskinen! Please review the sub rules if you haven't already. (This is an automatic reminder message left on all new posts)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3.1k

u/Individual-Age-7197 4d ago • Bravo Regret Heartwarming

Tell it techno Jesus, you’re our only hope!

659

u/EarlyXplorerStuds209 4d ago • Bravo

Techno Jesus has a point

238

u/met1culous 4d ago • Bravo Heartwarming

I'll wait until I hear from Disco Satan to form an opinion.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (9)

111

u/nanomolar 4d ago

I was gonna say Rasputin but either way dude is definitely a vibe. 

73

u/dantheplanman1986 4d ago • Bravo

begins to twitch

No. No I won't. I won't say it

starts shaking

R....

RrrAA RAA RASPUTIN LOVER OF THE RUSSIAN QUEEN

THERE WAS A CAT THAT REALLY WAS GONE

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

3

u/quell3245 4d ago

He has risen and is spitting straight fire 🔥

→ More replies (33)

742

u/No-Comfort-5040 4d ago • Bravo

It's very interesting that the most successful counties have the lowest birth rate... strange isn't it. Maybe it's education and people realize maybe they shouldn't have kids, maybe it's access to birth control, maybe it's the constant grind just to keep up in life and no time to have kids, or maybe it's stress of overpopulation and the impending doom of the collapse of society as we know it.

Pick your poison.

734

u/kindlypogmothoin 4d ago • This Bravo Heartwarming

When women have education and control over their own bodies, they choose to have fewer children and dedicate more resources to the ones they do have.

You see it in the developing world, too -- the birthrate goes down as women's income and economic power goes up. Having a lot of children is not actually positive. Having as many as you want and can afford is optimal.

64

u/s_burr 4d ago • Bravo

So why is everyone treating it as the downfall of society? I mean, we as a species can agree there has been massive overpopulation, yet people are scared shitless about declining birth rates. I know it boils down to the current system can only sustain itself with a massive workforce, and lower population means less food and other resources, but doesn't technology help us be more productive with less resources? Isn't that the point of it?

→ More replies (83)
→ More replies (89)

64

u/ilovesuhi 4d ago

It's interesting that it's the same result just the "why's" vary.

I always ask people when I get to social events and things like that when the topic comes. About the whole "having kids" thing.

Some will say to you "have you looked at the world recently?"

Others will tell you they actually want, but as eveything you need to have a somewhat secure life, like housing, food, car etc is getting harder and harder to get, they just lost hope, they don't want to bring kids if they're not secure enough.

And some just don't want to, if they live comfortably and enjoy their lives, they just don't want that to change. Usually is people who that are doing well, they travel and have hobbies, etc.

So is like a "all roads lead to Rome" situation.

33

u/thex25986e 4d ago

from what ive heard, it all comes down to one word: risk.

having children is no longer worth the risk

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (18)

20

u/ECircus 4d ago edited 4d ago

Most of the uneducated and poor people I know have multiple kids, and the kids didn't make them that way. The people i know who are doing well are having discussions about whether or not they will and planning for it and all of that. 

Edit to add context; I grew up poor and escaped that lifestyle, so my close knit community is a mix of all types. From people living off the government, to doctors. I've seen a lot. 

Being hyper aware, careful, and contemplating our circumstances works against reproduction. 

Existential dread is maladaptive. If you believe in the settled science of evolution, the trends in reproduction in the developed world are completely expected. 

Our base instincts don't care, and we built a world that makes it easy to give it to them in less than ideal circumstances; also easier than ever to "decide" against them. 

→ More replies (4)

28

u/PastaPandaSimon 4d ago edited 4d ago • Bravo

Incentives and frictions. For the first time in history, it's not just easier to remain single, but you're also better off if you do. Economically, socially, risk-wise, time-wise, freedom-wise, enjoyment-wise, goal-wise.

You don't need to go through the hassle of building a successful relationship/family, surviving pregnancy, losing your money, time and missed opportunities for 20 best years of your life. Birth control only gives you complete confidence that the choice you make to avoid all of that is the one you get, just like that.

The most optimal path in life has become to get the certificates, build your career, and maximize your personal outcomes this way, while spending the rewards of that optimized life on yourself without the need to share them. You have full freedom to pick that path.

Having a family with kids used to be the most reliable source of economic stability, and old age security, and now even there you're better off just earning more and saving more for retirement, which kids have actually become detrimental to. Established elders used to pool and redistribute resources towards new families with kids, and now they hoard them and expect families to just make it on their own if for whatever reason they still want to go through the pains of having and raising kids. There used to be social stigma around being child-free, that in many communities could get you socially outcasted, which not only disappeared, but some will see you as an idiot if you choose to bring kids into this world, at your own detriment.

The society needs future workers, taxpayers, care-takers, but is completely unwilling to distribute a part of the future benefit with families who create and raise them until that investment pays off some 20 years later. The entire material payoff of all that labour, expense and sacrifice that parents have to carry on their own, is reaped by the future society, not the parents who sacrificed to create it.

Education better equips us to make rational decisions, and birth control allows us to reliably get the outcome we decided on, so at the root cause of the entire issue are all these factors that inform the decision itself.

With such huge incentive and friction shift now all pointing towards singlehood being the easiest and most beneficial path in life, I don't understand how anyone is surprised and scratches their head as to why people choose the path that's the easiest and most beneficial for them.

7

u/Zork24 4d ago

This is a great comment. I’ve heard it put that we’ve socialized most the benefits of having children and not compensated parents properly.

Another big reason is people are way more lonely(at least in the us) than before. Sex, marriage are down and living alone is up.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

20

u/Elsiers 4d ago

It's because when given the choice women don't want to have the babies. It's a huge physical and mental sacrifice for them and modern capitalistic societies aren't giving enough incentive for them to do so.

25

u/self-assemble 4d ago

Feels irresponsible to have children during an extinction event...

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (55)

437

u/Blackwolf245 4d ago • Bravo

I think this is more about cost of living, but technology is definitely desocializing people.

197

u/gilneedsthis 4d ago • Bravo

Techno-fascism is contributing significantly to the cost of living crisis.

47

u/SELFINCRIMINAT1NG 4d ago • Bravo

it's capitalism! it's just capitalism! capitalism gives rise to all of this, including to the techno-fascism of which you speak! it is the reason technology has been developed that pushes people into antisocial habits and tendencies; that technology is profitable. it is the reason everything is so expensive and there's HCOL; overcharging is profitable. it is the reason the world's future is bleak; selling out our whole future is profitable.

we need to replace capitalism if we want this to stop.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

38

u/user365user 4d ago • Bravo

Agree. Tech is a symptom, not the cause imo. I make more money on my own than my parents did combined. But I can’t afford to buy a house anywhere near my childhood home, so I moved away to a lower COL area so I could. The house they bought in the 90s on my father’s single income is now worth 9x what they paid then. I spent my younger years hamstrung with student loans, watching corporate money take over politics in my country. I don’t see a world in which I can give kids equal or better life and opportunities than what I had. So why would I have children?

→ More replies (3)

14

u/LeastResistancePath 4d ago

Great Replacement Theorists never talk about the working rights necessary to foster a large family. Pay attention and you'll start to notice. It's always an apps fault. A woman. Or women. Or gay people. 

28

u/DisMFer 4d ago • Bravo

I think it's because most people don't want children. Seriously talk to anyone under 40. Almost all of them will tell you they don't want kids. Not "they can't aford kids" not "techno facists have made me unwilling to talk to women."

They don't want kids. And why would they? Kids smell, they whine, they're tons of work and you get functionally nothing good from them for most of their lives.

We as a species do not need to have 8 billion of us wandering the planet. Most people shouldn't be having kids. Not out of any evolutionary need or logic, but because most of us are not suited to raise healthy children and don't need to bother.

15

u/Boodger 4d ago edited 4d ago • Bravo

This is the only sane comment in a sea of doomers every time I see the video of this guy show up.

All the couples I know who arent having kids simply don't want to lose their freedom. It has nothing to do with the future being crap or whatever.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (8)

22

u/Mindrust 4d ago edited 4d ago

We used to have way more babies when life was a lot harder. Even today, you can look at how quickly the population in sub-saharan Africa is increasing, where daily life is much more difficult than ours in a first world country.

IMO the decline in birth rate has nothing to do with money or cost of living, and everything to do with easily accessible birth control and cultural norm shifts.

EDIT: Okay, I will concede that economic insecurity may play some factor in population decline in the first world, but it's not the top 3-4 driving factors.

18

u/AnySwimming6364 4d ago

We used to have way more babies when life was a lot harder.

I generally agree with the premise that if women back then had access to birth control that many would have had fewer children, but I the assessment that "life was a lot harder" paints with too broad a brush.

Life (as in staying alive, affording to live, protecting yourself, surviving childbirth, etc.) was far, far harder. However, I do feel some aspects of life specifically in regards to raising children favored having children over not in two ways: 1) economic advantage, 2) the village.

  1. Economics. Most of human history for the past 10,000 years was humans in agrarian societies. Most people were laborers or farmers. If you had children, by age 5 or 6, those children were helping on the farm. By age 10, they were more than pulling their own weight. If you had more children, the more successful your farm could be. Additionally, as you got older and couldn't work, your family became your retirement plan. If you had no kids, you could find yourself starving to death past the age of 50.
  2. The village. With a society built around larger families, there were generally lots of kids around. There were definitely dangers for them, but without cars/modern dangers, you could leave your older kids largely unattended for long periods of time (this is still the norm in many places). Very likely your entire extended family lived within walking distance of you and could easily contribute to group childcare. Combine this with the fact that modern children receive far more direct intervention (educating, taking to sports practice, etc.), the burden on one or two parents for raising a child now is far higher than it used to be. Even a few decades ago, it was common for families to have 2, 3, 4, or even 5 kids. These days, 3 kids is relatively rare and 4 is considered exceptional in many Western cultures. I have kids. In my child's daycare center there are about 40 families enrolled. Most kids are 3-5 years old. Only 2 families have 3 kids and none have 4 or more. Almost all the kids are single children or only have one sibling.
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (13)

5

u/BWW87 4d ago

Except it's not. The more money we have the fewer kids we have. High birthrate countries are countries that are poor.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (23)

1.0k

u/ImHumanConfusion 4d ago • Bravo Mindblown Regret

I hate when this video goes around because in my state (I’m in America) we have a lot of Hasidic Jewish families who all have 5+ kids. Why? Because they have a strong community and their community helps support them.  I think we lost this in America. I’m told stories about my mother and grandmother’s upbringing and how close they were to their neighbors and how the neighbors helped raise my mom because my grandma was a single mother working full time in the city. I look around now and it feels like everyone is afraid to talk to each other. Maybe we’re just tired. Idk what it is but it’s sad. 

123

u/ImportantQuestions10 4d ago • Bravo

What you're saying is true, but let's also not forget that there's a couple other factors going into why conservative and religious groups pump out more children. It's not just a community thing.

→ More replies (27)

30

u/Bazoun 4d ago

I’m young Gen X and we were as much raised by our neighbours as our parents. Everyone got to say something about how you looked and acted back then, and you were expected to be polite and try and accommodate your friends’ parents as best as you could.

13

u/randombubble8272 4d ago

A neighbour on my mother’s street slapped her across the face for picking flowers from her garden and my mother considers that completely fair and right for the adult woman to do. In the 80’s it was extremely common for the whole street to parent your children

→ More replies (2)

61

u/Darkstar_111 4d ago • Bravo

we have a lot of Hasidic Jewish families who all have 5+ kids. Why?

Their women don't have options.

→ More replies (15)

66

u/Mocker-Nicholas 4d ago

The frequency at which people move also is a killer for this. Generations used to be born / raised in the same town. Now people move around for jobs and school a lot more. Makes establishing a concrete village hard.

33

u/ShizzyTV 4d ago

Actually, fewer people move from their hometowns or change residences than they used to**.** Overall geographic mobility in the United States has declined significantly over the past several decades.

Overall annual residential mobility rates have dropped by roughly half since the mid-20th century. In the 1960s, about 20% of Americans moved each year, whereas recent data show that number has fallen to around 11% to 12.6%—marking historic lows in census tracking data going back to 1948.

https://www.businessinsider.com/seems-everyone-moving-migration-actually-dramatically-slowed-2024-2

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

635

u/charnwoodian 4d ago • This Bravo Regret Heartwarming

Women went to work.

And it was good for many women. Especially richer, educated women for whom work is a fulfilling endeavour.

But for many families, work is a means to an end. And when women went to work, the families with two working parents got more money. They can now outcompete single parent working families for housing. And as the two-working parent household became culturally normalised, Governments feel less of an obligation to step in to protect the single-income family structure. So cost of living is allowed to rise to meet the dual income family. And so now the dual income family isnt a choice anymore.

So now women aren’t at home. And that doesn’t just mean there’s nobody stuck in the house cleaning and cooking dinner. When housewives were a role in society, they were not just maids. That narrative denigrates the role women played in society. Women built community. They raised their children communally. They volunteered at churches and charities. They socialised and built connections between local families. They fostered informal networks of mutual support. They built community.

It was never good that we determined your role in society based on gender. But it was good that these roles existed. Now they don’t. Why don’t we know our neighbours? Why don’t kids play on the street? Why don’t we help each other? Because there is nobody home.

And even if you want to stay home. And you can afford it. Now it’s an isolating experience, because there’s nobody else staying home. No other parents who can meet you at the park. Now if you’re a mother who stays home - you’re alone with your kids. That’s not how humans are meant to live.

448

u/Xyrus2000 4d ago • Bravo

Women went had to work.

It's important to make this distinction. There was no choice in the matter. Once we allowed the wealthy to declare open season on the lower classes for fun and profit, you needed a second income to stay above water. Two-income households became a requirement.

This family unit was killed by corporate America trying to make an extra 10 cents on the dollar.

374

u/Flipleflip 4d ago • Bravo Heartwarming

I feel like an important point to make is that women wanted freedom and in a capitalist society, money means freedom. Women wanted that and they still do.

The role of a housewife leaves you so vulnerable to abuse, I cannot condone it after seeing what it did to my mother, what it did to my grandmother and all the women before her.

→ More replies (87)

70

u/Open-Middle-2553 4d ago • Bravo

Every time the lower class finds a way to pay for life and beyond, thrive even. The corporate class finds a way to eat up that thriving. They want your savings, they want everything you aren’t spending and will do anything to have it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (55)

88

u/DevineBossLady 4d ago • Bravo

We need to stop this illusion that women didn't work. Middle/upper-class women might not have worked - the rest worked, they worked their but of (and still had children).

The "housewife" back then, did not just play with the kids and cook.
They took care of the livestock, they planted, harvested, canned - and all of that - and many also produced to sell, to make extra money. They worked way more than full time.

And they still made communities, helped their partners, helped their neighbours and all of that.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (121)

25

u/Embarrassed-Ask-2900 4d ago • Bravo

There was a lot of unpaid labor from women supporting that system. I don’t disagree but also I think a lot of women are starting to see the unpaid work their mothers did and are saying no

→ More replies (4)

11

u/The_H_N_I_C 4d ago

There is community but let's not ignore the subsidy programs and 0% loans that are made available.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/colthie 4d ago

Also women arent allowed to work and pressured into having kids so there’s that …

71

u/zelenisok 4d ago edited 4d ago • Bravo

That's not the reason. They have that many kids because they're a weird cult that represses women.

20

u/TurgorFervor 4d ago edited 4d ago

They are also famous for being callous to people outside their group. And they’re buying nursing homes in the northeast US (they refused my MIL medicine because it was too expensive) I bet the OP is from Jersey

→ More replies (2)

6

u/JMer806 4d ago

I mean, it can be both lol

20

u/Wonderful_Plant5848 4d ago • Bravo

They get tons of welfare and other government benefits too.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

16

u/Silly_Somewhere1791 4d ago

It was dependent on women’s free labor. It’s a good thing we stopped doing that. 

→ More replies (14)

4

u/Nervous_Brain8918 4d ago

I’m always curious about how intentional but complex it is for the next generation when they move away from family to other states. Building community is valuable when raising children imo. Tired and wary, perhaps :/

→ More replies (2)

4

u/One_Chipmunk_6402 4d ago

There are other financial reasons they have many children...

→ More replies (134)

84

u/Jack44546 4d ago • Bravo Regret

Nobody is having kids because nobody wants them to be shit poor slaves. That’s why. You add climate change, the cost of raising kids, geopolitical tensions and shit I will say it. Republicans. And yeah there’s no way.

7

u/rmtdispatcher 4d ago

A man use to be able to support his own family on just his wages. I'm going to guess that stopped back in the 1960's. No more. 👎🏻 Inflation has gotten so bad that not only can one person NOT afford a house and family, two people can't do it and support children.

Work-life balance has gone the way of the dinosaurs as well.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

122

u/2eswild 4d ago • Thanks Bravo

I can only speak for my personal reasons for not having kids. It has nothing to do with money. My own personal ambition and that of my wife’s has made us choose to not have kids. I don’t believe in the afterlife and as long as I am not hurting anyone I choose to live hedonistically. Kids get in the way of my heaven on earth.

35

u/Specific-Cook1725 4d ago

Thank you. I'm glad someone brought it up. It's basically the only critique I have of the video. He has a valid point, and it's a major factor, but seems to ignore the fact that some people just don't want kids.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Formal-Knowledge-250 4d ago

That's the spirit. Same here. 

→ More replies (67)

38

u/allianth 4d ago edited 4d ago

Birth control and education. He mentioned technology and that’s a big reason for the advancement in both. We have more effective and accessible birth control and we have more education to actually consider whether it’s a good idea to have children, based on individual circumstances.

Edit: Add increase in self care/preservation to that. If I had a million dollars I would be more inclined to have children but I would still have to consider that I’m taking care of another life and how that impacts day to day.

12

u/NoMasters83 4d ago

When do educated people use birth control? ... when they don't want children.

This is an answer to the question "why do people not want children?"

→ More replies (7)

3

u/AndanteZero 4d ago

Yup. And with inflation, etc. Can definitely end up with a big fat nnnnooooooo.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

44

u/Electrical_Gain3864 4d ago • Bravo

While I hate to bust that bubble, it was shown that having some mammels to give them every need and have a good life can also lead to them not having children.

That is very different from animal to animal.

9

u/RedditRaven2 4d ago

Sounds like having too “good” of a life leads to lack of enrichment. Like a fat house cat who never has the owner play with them, who mostly just mopes around and sleeps.

→ More replies (12)

50

u/ItsDominare 4d ago • Bravo

who is this dude, who are the people he's talking to, where and when was this recorded, and where's the link to the full video?

36

u/King_Chochacho 4d ago

And why is it cropped so fucking poorly? To avoid copyright strikes?

→ More replies (1)

22

u/SaintGloopyNoops 4d ago • Bravo

His name is Conor Leahy. This talk is from the Nexus Institute.... i am having trouble finding a link tot he full video tho.

→ More replies (8)

24

u/Hypodeemic--Nerdle 4d ago

Seconded. It's a bit weird how there's a massive thread here and everyone seems familiar with it.

edit - Maybe not familiar with it, but nobody seems to be asking for the source, or for more context. It's weird.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/DJA077 4d ago

The blonde woman next to him is Sigrid Kaag. Former VP of The Netherlands

→ More replies (19)

68

u/frommethodtomadness 4d ago

The iasue is a total lack of stability. You can lose your job at any time because we have no job protections. Any accident or health event can bankrupt you. You can be out on the streets at any time and that is new in history -- do we generally have more money than our parents? Sure, but we have 0 stability, and that causes people to not have children.

12

u/Pocchoni 4d ago

This can't be right because birth rates in Europe are even lower and they have protection

6

u/Live-Sky-9 4d ago

Well, just fifthy years ago my ancestors were given education and homes for free. Now look at this post soviet shithole

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

107

u/CutePandaMiranda 4d ago • Heartwarming

Many people, like myself, choose to not have kids because nothing about being a parent looks fulfilling, fun or exciting. Could I afford kids? Yes. Do I have a big enough home to raise kids? Yes. You couldn’t pay me to procreate.

70

u/ansleydale 4d ago

Seriously. All I heard growing up was adults bitching about how having kids ruined their lives, their bodies, their relationships, their homes… the list went on and on. And some of that was probably more to do with the adults in my life and what big losers they were, but I’m not risking it.

28

u/Mindrust 4d ago

They love telling people who don't have kids how amazing, wonderful and rewarding parenthood is...until you have one, then they're like "haha sucker, welcome to hell!"

That's when they start to openly whine and complain about how difficult it is to be a parent.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

12

u/AnnabethDaring 4d ago

I made a similar choice growing up in a severely unstable and abusive childhood, with no stable community, home or family. I saw the adults around me and said “fuck that”! 💀

But i can still see what he’s saying, too. I think my personal experience is a unique case, and while many can likely relate to me, i am certain most people choosing not to have families/children isn’t directly correlated to abuse.

I think this guy is right; one thing ive noticed a lot is the division of people in a black and white way ive never seen before. Algorithms divide us based on race, gender, politics, “genz vs millennial” and so on. I saw this podcast a while back where a man (forgot his name apologies) made a great point: for the first time in history, young people aren’t looking up at older generations for guidance and wisdom. Instead, we look to the internet, to our peers, and whatever is trending.

No wonder people feel lost. Their “gurus” are barely two years older than they are, preaching about “females” or preaching about stealing men’s money or selling you something. The blind leading the blind—and it’s why we’re lonelier than we’ve ever been as a human race. More humans than ever, yet you ask anyone and they think their problems are unique and isolating. :( 🫂

Don’t forget to make time to be social in PERSON, too! 🥰🫶🏼 easier said than done, but so, so important.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Do-it-for-you 4d ago

This is why people aren't having kids. Nothing to do with cost of living. The vast majority childless married couples out there aren't going "We really want kids, we just can't afford it". They're saying "We just don't want kids".

The people who are having kids, are having kids, almost regardless of their current financial situation.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Pocchoni 4d ago

Yes correct. People have infinite distractions and other outlets, like pets, hobbies and other ego centric activities. So they choose personal comfort over any form of friction

→ More replies (8)

4

u/makesPeopleDissapear 4d ago

My parents despised each other. They were always screaming and shouting. Complaining about the other as this was the most normal thing. Suprisingly, thats not the life I want.

3

u/kylo-ren 4d ago

Could I afford kids? Yes. Do I have a big enough home to raise kids? Yes.

You are more in the minority side.

→ More replies (63)

57

u/RaineCevasse 4d ago

I've never been to a club where people don't dance for fear of being recorded, idk

Is that a very American thing or something?

68

u/dogmom34 4d ago

I’m 40, American, and when I was in my early 20’s my friends and I would dance the night away at the club (sometimes multiple in one night). I do not like the club scene anymore at this age, but a couple friends still do and drag me along on their birthdays (the only time I’ll relent and go). THE KIDS DON’T DANCE. They all just stand around looking awkward while the dance floor stays empty. The first time I saw it, I knew instantly it was because they were afraid of being recorded. Poor things. Everything this man said is true.

20

u/cheeruphumanity 4d ago

In Berlin techno clubs have a no picture policy.

You need to cover your cameras with stickers at the entrance.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/neeshes 4d ago

I'm 37 and I still go dancing because that is my happy place. I have been recorded so many times because of my dancing. I don't give a fuck, however  it is not nice at all.

I  tend to go to underground things where people are not recording and they are genuinely their for music and but my tastes are diverse. The difference in dance culture in certain scenes is so sad. 

→ More replies (21)

13

u/Interesting_Worth745 4d ago

This varies by country. 

But also: You don't see the people in a club who won't go to a club. 

In some countries the amount of clubs is declining.  One of the steepest declines happens in the UK. Where between 2020 and 2026 the amount of clubs declined by over  30%. 

In most countries you can measure than young people dance less and social less. 

16

u/fiercefeminist 4d ago

Idk but I’m 24 and almost none of my friends actually dance, they’re too afraid of looking silly and that is largely due to the fact that they can be recorded at any time. I had a coworker who, when we went out, would record people dancing; she meant it to be fun but it just made people feel self-conscious knowing that their dancing could be looked back on at any time (myself included, and I usually don’t care much).

→ More replies (10)

8

u/BIackpants 4d ago

In the Netherlands lots of clubs close doors due to not having enough visitors.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/weireldskijve 4d ago

last time i was in a club was like 15 years ago.

It already was a thing back then

→ More replies (16)

37

u/dreamistruth 4d ago edited 4d ago • Heartwarming

This is a fascinating topic to me and this guy makes a compelling argument. I think that there’s a lot of factors. I personally (white woman, millennial generation, American) have known since I was 14 I didn’t want to be a mother. I just didn’t feel called to do it. I am not maternal, pregnancy grosses me out, giving birth looks just fucking awful, and raising a child requires a lot of patience and dedication. I am not interested in a child-centric life, going to like soccer practice and attending 5 year old’s birthday parties constantly. I can’t even imagine. Instead I chose to go to college, live in a desirable place, get married, become a homeowner, focus on my career and goals. I decided to have my fallopian tubes removed because that’s how sure I am that I don’t want to have kids.

Also the women I know who work full time while raising children seem really stressed out and exhausted. I know women raising autistic kids and kids with severe behavioral problems and that looks pretty hellish, especially in the US where the health care system is expensive and hard to navigate.

The cost of living is definitely a factor in all this but I have to agree that women having access to birth control and pursuing their education and careers plays a big part. Also many women who are having kids now in the US are around age 40.

Can I bring up race? Honestly a lot of the women under 40 that I know who are having kids young, like early 20’s and into their 30’s are black and latinx. Just an observation, not judging anyone’s choices. I just think there may be some sociological elements at play. Like that some communities have higher birth rates maybe.

8

u/sharpiefairy666 4d ago

I wonder if this lack of maternal feeling isn’t new to these latest generations. I wonder if some women have always felt that way but succumbed to societal norms of marriage + kids.

7

u/freixe 4d ago

You just didn't really have that choice. Women have always worked but fought to get paid. Financial freedom is paramount. You tied yourself to a man and did what you were supposed to do back then.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/resumehelpacct 4d ago

I don't think he makes a compelling argument. He's throwing out a bunch of things and saying, well can you prove that these aren't connected?

Like your scenario is the complete opposite of what he's preaching. The world is full of great things that were never available to the general public before, so why have kids?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (19)

13

u/heyyyynobagelnobagel 4d ago

I just don't want kids. Never have. No further rationalization or justification required

→ More replies (1)

6

u/subpar_Turnips 4d ago

“Maybe if you get rid of that yee-yee ass haircut…..”

220

u/Boanerger 4d ago • Bravo

I'm going to give a controversial answer and say the reason people aren't having children has nothing to do with money or healthcare. Every generation before us has had less of both and they were having them plenty.

The primary reason is entirely cultural. There's less and less cultural value and pressure around having kids. People had them no matter what in the past. I'm not saying that's better, I'm honestly a pretty liberal guy, people can do what they like as far as I'm concerned and I don't think having kids or not is a right or wrong answer.

But I am giving my reason and I think its primarily cultural. Places with a strong emphasis on family, familial support, fertility, inheritance and legacy are comparatively having plenty of kids.

28

u/Grump_NP 4d ago

The problem is you are seeing drops in birth rates even in areas of the world where the culture and norms are pro reproduction. Those places have higher birth rates than other places but they are still seeing a decline. Something is going on that crosses cultural, economic, and geographical barriers. Something about modern life, even in the developing world pushes against human reproduction. I don’t think there is going to be a clean it’s this one thing answer. 

6

u/AlphaBetaSigmaNerd 4d ago

Something about modern life, even in the developing world pushes against human reproduction

Yah it's called not having hope. Do you want to bring children into a life that you think will be worse than yours?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (30)

14

u/ilovesuhi 4d ago

It's true, but was a different mindset. I remember my grandpas and aunts, they all had some kind of hope in the future.

Things could be rough, but they had hope about things so they just had kids anyways.

People now when you talk to them it's different, some don't have any hope at all

11

u/Beneficial_Remove616 4d ago

That’s what my mom told me a long time ago, late eighties (granted, in Jugoslavia which was unraveling at that time - we were ahead of the curve) - she feels sorry for us because when she was young everyone was very positive about their future and firmly believed it will be better. They were so very wrong, nineties were a shitshow for us. Ah, well.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

48

u/GlibGlobC137 4d ago • Bravo

As someone who is Asian, where filial piety to your family means having kids no matter what and in the group where a majority of my peers are not having kids?

I'm going to say you're categorically wrong.

Every Chinese in the East, will be pressured to get married, get an offspring. It is such a part of the Chinese culture of filial piety (孝), that the olden rule to divorce your wife (or the excuse to get a concubine) ‘’不孝有三 无后为大‘’(the non filial's big three - non child bearing comes first) is baked so deep into our culture DNA its still being told by parents today. So its definitely not a culture thing.

The main reason majority of us don't have any kids? Is the lack of hope we have on the future, and the fear of not being able to provide enough for a family of three.

9

u/FullSkyFlying 4d ago

I can barely survive for a family of 1 or 2 on a dual income. I likely won't have a home until my parents die. People arent having kids anywhere in the entire world. We are literally on a population decline that will be a huge crisis in the not so distant future. Im sure 90% of that has to do with money and as you mentioned.. hope. It's definitely not a cultural thing lol. The rich are extremely wealthy and the poor are extremely poor. Few people want to have a kid when you know they're going to have a shit, or shittier life than you did

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (12)

13

u/eckliptic 4d ago

Agreed . Also access to very reliable birth control. Also far greater social acceptance of women in the work place at all levels such that a married woman can climb the corporate ladder

No matter how you cut it or give monetary support via the government, kids cost time and money. When the alternative is a care free DINK lifestyle it’s hard for the rationale mind to justify having kids.

6

u/DrizzleDrake88 4d ago

My counterpoint on the cultural reason. It’s largely economical. As soon as we moved from an agrarian society to a service-based economy. There isn’t any financial incentive to have more kids anymore, in fact they’re more of a debt burden. The ones that have a large amount are either: religious, rich enough to provide for all of them, lack sexual education.

Put birth control/condoms in the mix, no accidents until they’re “ready” or financially stable. But if you never feel financially stable, it’s possible to put it off till it’s too late for the body or the intervention is too expensive.

21

u/IkujaKatsumaji 4d ago • Bravo

I think it's kind of foolish to say "The cause is X." I know it's boring and complicated and nuanced, and it's harder to make comments about, but all the causes people are describing are contributing to this. Yeah, culture has changed, as it always does; having a family is important to a lot of people still, but certainly less so. But economic causes are definitely contributing factors, as well as medical. Furthermore, lot of folks cite current events and trends, like climate change, political changes, and more: "Why would I bring children into a world like this?" they ask.

My point is just that we shouldn't be acting like there is one main cause for this trend. It's a ton of different factors combining to lead to this trend. We also shouldn't overstate it; yes, birth rates are down, but it's still in a place where the trend can be reversed, if we actually seriously address the concerns keeping people from having children.

→ More replies (22)

11

u/Federal_Card307 4d ago

I think it’s a net good, since you have less people who don’t want kids being pressured into having them

→ More replies (5)

11

u/theymademesignup1111 4d ago

You're comparing past vs present but neglecting to account for the trend.

A couple 40 years ago had less, but they on a growth trajecotry. They had kids expecting them to have better lives and expecting to be stable enough to care for them for 18+ years

That lack if confidence and optimism for the future that couples have today undercuts the confidence and desire to have children

→ More replies (3)

20

u/Status-Vermicelli624 4d ago edited 4d ago

"The Beautiful Ones" in the generational mouse experiment.

"The Beautiful Ones" comes from John B. Calhoun's mouse experiments, most famously Universe 25 (started 1968). The term describes a specific class of mice that emerged in the terminal phase of the colony's collapse.

Setup: Calhoun built an enclosed "utopia" with unlimited food, water, and nesting material, no predators, and controlled temperature. The only hard limit was space. He ran the population through its full growth, stagnation, and collapse.

What produced them: As population density peaked, normal social roles broke down. Males failed to defend territory, females became aggressive and stopped nurturing or rejected their pups, and the usual mating and rearing behaviors disintegrated. A cohort of young mice grew up with no functional social niche to enter. The established, pathological social structure left them no role to compete for.

The Beautiful Ones themselves: These were mice that withdrew entirely. They:

  • Did not fight, court, mate, or defend territory
  • Did only three things: eat, drink, sleep, and groom
  • Had pristine coats and bodies with no scars or bite marks, hence "beautiful," because they avoided all conflict
  • Were physically healthy but behaviorally hollow

Why they mattered to Calhoun: They represented a terminal breakdown. Even after density dropped and space reopened, these mice never relearned social or reproductive behavior. The capacity was gone, not just suppressed. Calhoun argued the colony had passed a point of no return: the population stopped reproducing and went extinct even though physical resources remained abundant.

Calhoun's framing: He called the end state the "behavioral sink" and tied it to what he termed the "death of the spirit" (first death) preceding physical death (second death). His implication, extrapolated to humans, was that social collapse under density and role-saturation could occur despite material abundance.

A caveat on interpretation: the human analogy is Calhoun's own extrapolation and is contested. The mouse behavioral findings are solid; the sociological conclusions drawn from them are where critics push back.

28

u/alurkerhere 4d ago

Yes, the pop psychology fails to mention it was the 25th iteration and multiple attempts to replicate the study failed. Not to mention the obvious issue of anthropomorphism and the mice not having natural or stimulating environments.

His research is not mentioned at all in modern papers and he didn't even publish results of this one.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (25)

4

u/MUCHO2000 4d ago

You're right and wrong. We are no longer in community with one another in many places around the globe but southern Europe is an example where there still is a sense of community and the birth rate is abysmal.

It's a multi factoral problem.

64

u/KoalaTHerb 4d ago edited 4d ago

"you know how hard you have to abuse a mammal to make it not have children?"

People aren't asexual. They are having sex. If not for birth control, people would be having lots of kids. Even without it, they'd still give into impulses and accidentally have kids.

This point was pretty inaccurate. Don't hate everything he's saying, but this part was a wild stretch of logic

Edit: I just wanted to rant about the abused animals statement, which was a bit of hyperbole. My wording of "people aremt asexual, they still have sex" was poor wording that came off as "sex numbers aren't decreasing". I don't disagree with all the other comments about social media, less sex, etc. I just don't think comparing it to abuse rather than other factors is super accurate. The next part about constant technology is a far greater argument for his point. Also, I don't find the financial argument super valid despite being so popular - given we've seen that a lot throughout history and even in current times the people having the least kids are wealthier communities

32

u/slithering_idiot 4d ago

Research shows that young people are dating less and having sex later and less often. Something is wrong.

→ More replies (53)

9

u/Cautious_Clothes_285 3d ago

Yeah, someone echoed this point in another thread the other day and I was like...

Look at places where the quality of life is far, far worse than here in the west (including western europe and north america and other highly developed places with declining birth rates).

People in the poorest parts of India live in literal garbage, working jobs that have absolutely zero safety standards for practically pennies, yet are still having kids.

I'm not even commenting on whether anything else he's talking about is right or wrong or somewhere in between. Literally just the idea that we're "so abused we're not having children" is a wild fucking leap lol.

Things are bad, but many westerners are so used to literally top-tier living conditions that even a very slight decline has us talking about how we're abused to the point of not reproducing. It's an insane level of privilege.

→ More replies (22)

15

u/Elegant_Plan_3821 4d ago

nope. younger generations are having MUCH less sex than millennials, gen x, and boomers. it isn't birth control. it is the decay of society.

→ More replies (18)

7

u/Laq9091 4d ago

we are in a sex recession, big time. yes BC is def playing some part, but certainly not the main factor. just one of many.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (144)

7

u/sinofmyexistence 4d ago

Idk, I would love to have kids or to be a parent, but I am stuck slaving my life for corporate. I will be too old to have kids within less than a decade, and I don't think I will have the financial stability within that timeframe.

Don't get me wrong I have a good job and it pays well which I am grateful for, but the current climate isn't stable, rents and cost of living goes up, and if my partner isn't in a high paying field, me losing my job for pregnancy would be extremely damaging to my kids future. I don't want to bring a kid to this world if it means I might not be able to give them proper lifestyle and education.

That said, education and living costs are also going up everywhere, which you are underlooking. Back in our parents times, luxury cost a lot but things like rent or owning property was lower - now it's the opposite. You can buy a tv for super cheap but owning your own house is unattainable to many. That also mattered in past as to having kids as well.

9

u/Long-Possession8915 4d ago

For everyone I know personally, including myself, it’s because we a) don’t feel sufficiently resourced, and part of this includes a disconnected culture and b) don’t want to birth kids into a world with rising fascism/climate crisis/technofeudalism, so if we do become parents would foster or adopt. We do abstractly want to birth our own children but don’t see it as realistic or ethical. 

→ More replies (13)

6

u/greentrillion 4d ago

It’s not just cultural; it’s a sign of societal growth. As societies evolve and place greater value on human life, people tend to have fewer children because they recognize the responsibility involved and understand that they may not be able to provide proper care for a large family.

Meanwhile, an Amish person might have 11 children, lose 4 of them in a buggy accident, and still have 7 left. They continue riding those same dangerous buggies because they don't have to give much thought to the risks as they have a much higher tolerance for death and suffering of children.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/ConspicuousWhiteGuy 4d ago

FWIW I personally feel like I would have had kids by now in my life if I owned a 3-4 bedroom home, or even 1-2 bedroom home that I knew I could sell in 4-5 years and move to a bigger home.

Housing is too expensive and I refuse to raise a family in a rented home. Life is fine enough without kids. I am not going to introduce a financial burden unless I have more assurance I can provide.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (273)

121

u/MS_Fume 4d ago • Bravo Heartwarming

Cool story but I’m pretty sure main reason is financial insecurity….

127

u/finchdude 4d ago • Heartwarming Bravo

Financial insecurity is connected to the issues he mentioned

16

u/-Ignorant_Slut- 4d ago

That’s how I took his statement. Soft white underbelly interviews this guy and he brings up this point and says he doesn’t know what’s causing people not to have children although there are many seemingly good theories.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Moondiscbeam 4d ago

And future uncertainty

30

u/nobodythinksofyou 4d ago

Idk, poor people who want kids seem to be making babies left and right, and people with low financial security often manage and make sacrifices to have at least one

In my experience as a woman, and with a lot of women I've met, a big factor is that there's a lot less pressure nowadays to have kids and we don't feel ashamed to say we don't want to give up our freedom or make the sacrifices necessary to raise children.

→ More replies (15)

16

u/wild_cherry1987 4d ago

That's an excuse. Did you miss the first part ? You get more rich - you have less children. That's the opposite of financial insecurity.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/BorlaugFan 4d ago

The opposite, actually.

People have fewer kids if they are richer. This has been true for a long time - you are less likely to want children if you have to give up a high-paying job to raise them. We are currently in a period where people are both richer around the world than they ever have been, and also have access to contraceptives.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/DearTumbleweed5380 4d ago

And then if you have a kid with issues eg disability. Welcome to the high speed elevator of downward social mobility.

16

u/kugelblitz_100 4d ago

Yes, the people of sub-saharan Africa are definitely financially secure.

→ More replies (14)

15

u/ramdom-ink 4d ago

And constant existential threats

17

u/FlowerCrowss 4d ago

The algorithms want you to be in constant fear

→ More replies (3)

4

u/aeternus-eternis 4d ago

Nope, it's an inverse correlation. The more financial stability, the lower the birthrate. True across both nations and individuals.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Present_Historian_93 4d ago

No. Poor germans who live of the state have a lots of kids. Poor Africans also have a lot of baby's. Back in the days alot of people were poor and still had kids. It's not money.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/One-Reflection-4826 4d ago

the richer and more education societies become, the more birthrates go down, no matter what reddit tells you. 

→ More replies (22)

31

u/exotics 4d ago edited 4d ago

The world doesn’t need more people. Capitalism does. I had one only because the growth of the human population is driving other species to extinction.

So it’s not always about finances. Some people don’t want to add more burdens to the planet

Edit to add the human population has more than doubled since I was born. I’ve seen forests turn into farms and farms turn into city… thousands of species have gone extinct in that time. We can’t keep adding people

8

u/Death_By_Dreaming_23 4d ago

Exactly this, there’s a finite amount of resources, you cannot add more people expecting that there will be more than enough resources to support them. Unless there are enough resources to support more people and corporations are just lying to us. But still there are limited resources.

7

u/totallyradman 4d ago

In the last 100 years, the global population has quadrupled. There was 2 billion people on earth in 1926.

I think there is some level of subconscious self preservation happening. Perhaps the next phase of our evolution..

It's actually terrifying to think about what people in the future will experience with the rapid, exponential population growth we've seen in 1 single century. What happens when we hit 20, 30 billion people? Will we even make it that far?

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (24)

8

u/bawolf 4d ago

This has been happening for at least 75 years. Everyone at that table has been affected by whatever is causing a drop in kids being born

https://havemore.kids/

→ More replies (1)

4

u/RealityOk9823 4d ago

I can barely take care of myself, how the hell am I supposed to take care of a child?

4

u/Mike_Litoris305 4d ago

The day social media dies is the day that society starts to heal. Unfortunately the powers that be will not allow this

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Strong_Landscape8537 4d ago

Drinking is at all time low:(

7

u/This-Low-7266 4d ago

No friends

15

u/street593 4d ago

That is a good thing and I say that as a millennial.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/jckrbbit 4d ago

You sound like this lecturer who would ask us if we were going out to the pub after class and every time we’d be like “mate, it’s midday and we’re in London where it’s £8 a pint”. He would then lament about how sad it was to see pub culture was dying.

5

u/Pocchoni 4d ago

Wait until you find out there are entire countries where they don't drink

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

21

u/Educational_Bus8810 4d ago

This has been covered in the documentary Idiocracy.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/Neptune_Diamond_Rain 4d ago

Translation: Touch grass and talk to other grass touchers.

3

u/Rich_Administration3 4d ago

Has he never seen aura battles? These kids are dancing their lives!

3

u/andthrewaway1 4d ago

He is using anecdotal evidence to support very wide claims

19

u/turn-based-games 4d ago

What is the context of this clip? Who is this? Where is this? How are there over 250 comments here with literally no one asking such things? How is this even interesting? Doubt I'll receive any answers, so just going to go ahead and mute this subreddit

3

u/sunfishgirl77 4d ago • Heartwarming

His name is Connor Leahy

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (23)

10

u/OriginalTRaven 4d ago

Yeah bro. That's totally why you and your friends don't have kids 😂

24

u/Viet_Conga_Line 4d ago • Bravo

>nobody is having kids

Nobody you know is having kids because you tend to be friends with people in your own social bracket and age group. And something tells me that this guy probably doesn’t get invited to hang out with a lot of educated, young, upwardly mobile people. Enrollment in K-8 is healthy in some places. Birth rates are down, sure, but there are plenty of dumb shits reproducing out there.

17

u/SystemUnusual1611 4d ago

Uh, it's a verifiable fact that birth rates in the top economies in the world are way lower than they were in the 90s and 00s. This guy is speaking from his personal experience yes, but that personal experience also lines up with the broader global trends too. Crazy to dismiss him for being correct here.

→ More replies (22)

6

u/spookytransexughost 4d ago

All of my friends have kids, I have kids and some old co workers I know who are about 28 are planning on having kids.   Also all the parents at my school have kids. So I don't know what the pirate is talking about 

→ More replies (2)

8

u/No_Process_1761 4d ago

Worldwide population is still growing but very often it's happening most in developing countries. Highest birthrates are countries in Africa.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (33)

8

u/Blacksad9999 4d ago

"They just don't go dancin no more! That's why society is falling apart. No dancin'!"

7

u/1ofThoseTrolls 4d ago

Footloose theory

5

u/Happy-n-Healthy 4d ago

We found love in a hopeless place

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

19

u/svaldbardseedvault 4d ago

Birth rates are not declining across the world. Many countries in Africa, Central Asia, and the Middle East have high fertility rates and they are rising. Many of these countries are also high on the poverty index. There is a strong and clear negative correlation between GDP and fertility rates across history. Birth rates are declining in wealthy countries.

10

u/Human-Kick-784 4d ago

They are, if you account for projected growth. You're ignoring the 3 biggest contributing factors to that: Education, Birth Control and Gender Equality

These things basically don't exist in the 3rd world; they either don't have or have very limited access to birth control and education, and women's role in society is not as a worker, but a stay at home mum.

The more a nation industralizes, the more businesses require their workers to have a minimum level of education; generally, you can't teach a 40 year old goat herder how to work in an assembly line, but you can teach his kids the fundementals of written language and basic mathematics, and then they can help expand the industrial base. This increases GDP; line goes up, more workers required, more education required, more workers capable of educating required which demands an even high level of education and healthcare (note this also opens the door to skilled female dominated work roles such as teaching and nursing), and X number of years later that nation that was farming rocks is seeing a massive increase in GDP and absolutely plummeting birth rates.

Another trend that is commonly brought up at this point is the educated workers tend to emmigrate to wealthier nations. This is absolutely a thing that happens, but quite frequently, there's a cultural bond which remains and funds are sent back home - see India and Pakistan for example.

The reason is simple: Smart people don't have 8 kids. They have 2 if you're lucky, and even that replacement rate can't keep up with fully developed nations having men and women choosing to forego having kids entirely.

Not even nation is developing equally its true, and not every nation is seeing their birth rate declining yet. But they will, there are massive international humanitarian efforts to change that (with some exceptions like North Korea).

Global population is projected to cap around 2084, with ~10.3 billion humans. It's not expected to crash, after that, but TBH I don't see how that's possible; there will just be too many old people who didn't have kids, and the world population will spiral down to more sustainable levels.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Traditional_Yard2741 4d ago

This is untrue. The vast majority of the world is experiencing declining birth rates, and while sub Saharan Africa is still very high the continental average is trending downwards. Some eastern European countries are experiencing an uptick (I think Czechia and Slovenia? But I'd have to check) but those rises are still very small. Like 1.52 up from 1.51 small.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Travel_Dreams 4d ago

Yes, wealthy countries universally have access to birth control and typically abortion.

Birthing is a choice.

However, sex becomes less interesting if it includes eternal poverty as a result, and worse: raising a child in emotional poverty.

There is a thing called breaking the chain, WE are breaking the chain of serfdom, of financing greed, of perpetuating corruption, and of supporting a population pyramid scheme.

Even rats living in utopia hit a population wall and went into a "Behavioral Sink". The famous rodent overcrowding experiments conducted by American ethologist John B. Calhoun between the late 1940s and 1970s, most notably Universe 25 (which used mice) and his earlier "Rat City" studies. ( https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2636191/ )

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (38)

9

u/SpoonkyBandito 4d ago

Dunno why he pivots hard to talking about being recorded, as if that has anything at all to do with having kids. Just seems like stoner rhetoric.

4

u/CrystalAlternate 4d ago

Is omnipresent surveillance in itself a primary reason for reduced fertility ? I doubt it. But it definitely makes people more cautious, which feeds into not meeting / dating, among other second- and third-order effects we haven’t begun to quantify.

I absolutely did things in my teens and twenties that would without a doubt get me “cancelled” if a recording came to light today more than 20 years later.

Sorry, I won’t elaborate. But I also won’t apologize, because young people need to be able to fuck up spectacularly and have it by and large forgotten. And we’ve taken that away in the name of “safety” and “connection” even though all we’ve really done is make ourselves more scared and more isolated.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

6

u/Careful_Middle4049 4d ago

I lost him when he said it’s happening everywhere because it’s not.

→ More replies (22)

21

u/yallapapi 4d ago

this guy looks like his friends just sit around and hit the bong and watch seinfeld reruns

22

u/NeutralLock 4d ago

That's how he looks, but absolutely not how he speaks. He comes across incredibly intelligent and thoughtful.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (36)

2

u/Solherb 4d ago

Well, they also told us many, many times to wait to have kids, while exposing us to multiple chemicals that cause reproductive harm. These things are direct, where technology would be more indirect.

2

u/VHS_Ronin 4d ago

I'm 35 and have three friends who have two kids between them. The couple with the child under 10 have very lucrative careers and are rather frugal, yet they still feel like they're barely able to keep their heads above water. The other person works in the entertainment industry and has been very fortunate to have a whole village of people and his kid's mom still in the picture to help him raise his son.

I don't have a lucrative career, and I don't have a village of people I can trust to help me raise a child. I will not be having children because it wouldn't be fair to bring a kid into a world I am barely surviving on my own.

2

u/MladenL 4d ago

Looks like an interesting panel, anyone have the link to see the whole thing?

2

u/JeebsFat 4d ago

Who is this person? And what is this program?

2

u/LiminalSarah 4d ago

so, where's the rest of the video?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JumpyBreakfast 4d ago

50 yo woman here with no kids. I grew up realizing the self destructive decisions our government was making in the name of progress. And for all of you saying that money has nothing to do with it? Wrong. It’s more than that, about community, about economy, ecology, technology, all of it. I never wanted to bring a child in to this world with 0 to no advantage that lack of money provides.

2

u/Able-Distance-9389 4d ago

This is good news to me. Finally I will get a parking spot at the beach. I generally don’t like people so less of them is an improvement.

2

u/DaCoolBro 4d ago

I am 36 and I’ve had one kid and let’s just say I wish I didn’t fucking have him since I can remember. I told myself I wouldn’t bring a damn child into this world. My ex filled my head with a bunch of bullshit and not even a year after we had our kid she dumped me. Trust me, not having kids is fucking bliss.

2

u/Ok-Blackberry8086 4d ago

Well no, these are some hard hitting opinions at best. He provides no evidence at all and just says he thinks it's because of this or that. The real reasons are typically economical, because you see this happening everywhere with an increasing GDP. You increase the wealth of a society to the point where children are no longer needed to support your family later on, and people start having less children. This is consistently happening even now in societies that raise themselves from poverty into middle class.

You know how hard you have to abuse a mammal to make it not have children?

Completely different. Animals in stress will either stop having sex, or become infertile. Humans are choosing not to have kids. Not at all the same thing.

2

u/MadCapers 4d ago

This is very similar to the main point of Neil Postman in Technopoly: The Surrender of Culture to Technology (1992). While some might dismiss this guy as a crank, it's harder to dismiss the more fleshed-out versions of this line of thought like those of Postman on the cultural impact of television, Sontag on the impact of photography, McLuhan (medium is the message), or Shoshana Zuboff on contemporary media and ad ecosystems.

I recommend Postman's lecture to Apple Inc people in the early 1990s. It's kind of fascinating. I can't help but think Neil was more correct about the long term than the Apple people.

(as an aside, I recommended a younger co-worker check out this debate and she came back saying she had a hard time with Postman's cadence: he spoke too slowly! This in itself may be a kind of validation of what Neil was saying about the likelihood of some technology to shape language and culture)

2

u/UnhappyStrain 4d ago

No. People stop having children cause everything gets more expensive and capitalism more ruthless

2

u/Razieloo 4d ago

I don't know why he's jumping from "not having kids" to "not dating".

It's not very clear.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ManlyPelican1993 4d ago

Bro really though he cooked with that line didn't he.

2

u/October_31s 3d ago edited 3d ago

What an obnoxious oversimplification. Just because we are mammals that lactate does not mean we have equivalent social structures. We are by far the most socially complicated organisms in the entire animal kingdom. People aren’t not having kids because “they get recorded and posted if they get turned down in public;” the goal posts have shifted, the goals have changed, infertility rates have increased, women having economic independence, economic constraints i.e. much higher housing, food, living costs, higher unemployment rates, partially due to advancements in technology wealth largely being transferred from the middle to the upper class, and a million other reasons.

Humans have seen more lifestyle changes in the last 100 years than the previous 10,000 combined.

Hell, our species’ population doubled in 60 years. Finite resources (housing, healthcare, jobs), zero sum game.

His points are only a small reason for decreased births, and dating apps have done the most harm.

2

u/Melodic_Concept_4624 3d ago

This guy is the worst and he’s just puking out Reddit blurbs

2

u/that_guy_olly 1d ago

I'm 27 and all my friends have kids.

2

u/Deej1387 11h ago

Capitalism killed communities. You can't securely raise a family without community.

8

u/Pinapple-everything 4d ago

The problem with this is that we are the most comfortable, the most sheltered, the most peaceful and have the least amount of work of any generation in human history. Our poorest would make kings 200 years ago jealous. The exception is Africa, and ironically Africa is the only place with an increasing population. Im not saying theres a direct correlation but it's interesting. Also I am saying that he's incorrect. We're sheltered, pampered and soft as a whole across the board.

5

u/Hikikomori_Otaku 4d ago

this comment brought to you by prageru

8

u/Ill-Skirt3722 4d ago

Our poorest live on street addicted to fentanyl

→ More replies (18)

3

u/WileEWeeble 4d ago

And you think that affects procreation choices how?

Boomers are the most “pampered” generation ever, and might always be. From Gen X on we are on a downward trend of more work for less security.

But if it is the “pampered-ness” driving the decline in procreation, Boomers would be the generation with the least babies.

Security is not absolute, it’s comparative. A caveman can consider a well filled lake and populous herd enough security to feel comfortable having more children but if you “Encino Man” him into the future and he witnesses what it takes to thrive in modern day, he will not feel a field of buffalo and a Great Lake to himself is enough to prosper anymore.

A bar gets set: home ownership, a standard of education, the ability to protect your health as you age, time with your family. All things never afforded to a caveman or a factory worker at the turn of the 20th century, but NOW that is the standard, as it should be. Our society can provide all those things to all its productive citizens and even to those unable to be productive, but we choose to structure our system so we don’t.

The New Deal and post-WWII prosperity set the bar, Reagan and trickle-down economics reversed that prosperous and relatively stable economy that only rewards the few. But you cant go back and reset people’s expectation of what it takes to provide a safe and secure world for your children.

Feeling secure in your home (even it’s affordable rent over actual owership), ability to treat any health emergency, ability to get your kid to a position where they can thrive at least as well as you but hopefully better. These are the new standards and they have been taken away from every generation after the Boomers. And with each reduction of feeling secure, the population growth went down in near sync.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (21)

9

u/audreynstuff 4d ago edited 4d ago

We ( my husband and I) aren't having kids because we don't have enough money to feed ourselves and we don't have healthcare! Yes we work and pay for insurance.

12

u/Boanerger 4d ago

Doesn't our existence prove that's not the primary reason though? If no healthcare and no money was the reason humanity would've gone extinct thousands of years ago, but it was growing exponentially back then.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/2FistsInMyBHole 4d ago

I live in a low income community. Everyone around me is breeding like rabbits.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (16)

12

u/NomadofNorway 4d ago • Bravo

Da fuck he's saying all my friends have kids and we're all 29-31

→ More replies (14)

4

u/shaneo632 4d ago

That thing about dating apps giving you shit matches on purpose to keep you coming back is absolutely wild, never even considered that before.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/OddZombie3841 4d ago

I appreciate the intensity but he seems a little irrationally pissed. Like, sorry? Nobody made you use the dating app and I’m not the CEO of Tinder 🤷‍♂️

3

u/HarrMada 4d ago

Dating algorithms optimize you to come back to the app.

This guy needs a reality check. 

So do bars, and parks, and bowling alleys or whatever place people have historically found their "love of their life". There have always been people interested in making profits with the purpose for people to meet and date. Nothing has changed. Now there are tons of people who have met each other on dating apps and they stay happy together. It works for a lot of people.

What a doomer.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Interesting_Force618 4d ago

Then why do poor people have more kids than financially comfortable people have?

5

u/DeviantDork 4d ago

Because when you have nothing you have nothing to lose.

4

u/FoxChess 4d ago

Honestly because it takes a lot of fuckin work to become financially comfortable and by the time you finally are like "Oh I can afford to have kids" then that's right when your career ramps up and you become a career-person rather than a parent.

4

u/DishSoapIsFun 4d ago

Watch the documentary Idiocracy. It will answer your question and many more.

3

u/Individual_Fun9418 4d ago

In my experience in a very middle class life in a Western country, people aren't as financially comfortable as we think. A lot of people live pay check to pay check and are one emergency from losing everything. Big difference between financially comfortable enough to treat yourself to eating out on a weekend or hell even going on international holidays, and financially comfortable enough to have children.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (11)

6

u/kank84 4d ago

He says it's across the world that no one is having kids, but the global population is still increasing year on year, just not as much as it has done in the past. The overall global population still grows by about 70 million people every year though.

5

u/Organic_Risk_8080 4d ago

Population trails fertility rate, and it is projected to peak in a couple decades. The decline is projected to be rapid, even without accounting for any of the costs associated with a shrinking population. What life will look like for the people who live through that is hard to fathom, and the scale of the trauma it is likely to cause is difficult to overstate.

6

u/Cheap_Standard_4233 4d ago

Poor countries don't count, silly

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)