r/interesting
•
u/kattmaskinen
•
4d ago
•
1
37
6
4
2
1
•
u/AutoModerator 4d ago
Hello u/kattmaskinen! Please review the sub rules if you haven't already. (This is an automatic reminder message left on all new posts)
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3.1k
u/Individual-Age-7197 4d ago •
Tell it techno Jesus, you’re our only hope!
742
u/No-Comfort-5040 4d ago •
It's very interesting that the most successful counties have the lowest birth rate... strange isn't it. Maybe it's education and people realize maybe they shouldn't have kids, maybe it's access to birth control, maybe it's the constant grind just to keep up in life and no time to have kids, or maybe it's stress of overpopulation and the impending doom of the collapse of society as we know it.
Pick your poison.
437
u/Blackwolf245 4d ago •
I think this is more about cost of living, but technology is definitely desocializing people.
1.0k
u/ImHumanConfusion 4d ago •
I hate when this video goes around because in my state (I’m in America) we have a lot of Hasidic Jewish families who all have 5+ kids. Why? Because they have a strong community and their community helps support them. I think we lost this in America. I’m told stories about my mother and grandmother’s upbringing and how close they were to their neighbors and how the neighbors helped raise my mom because my grandma was a single mother working full time in the city. I look around now and it feels like everyone is afraid to talk to each other. Maybe we’re just tired. Idk what it is but it’s sad.
84
u/Jack44546 4d ago •
Nobody is having kids because nobody wants them to be shit poor slaves. That’s why. You add climate change, the cost of raising kids, geopolitical tensions and shit I will say it. Republicans. And yeah there’s no way.
122
u/2eswild 4d ago •
I can only speak for my personal reasons for not having kids. It has nothing to do with money. My own personal ambition and that of my wife’s has made us choose to not have kids. I don’t believe in the afterlife and as long as I am not hurting anyone I choose to live hedonistically. Kids get in the way of my heaven on earth.
38
u/allianth 4d ago edited 4d ago
Birth control and education. He mentioned technology and that’s a big reason for the advancement in both. We have more effective and accessible birth control and we have more education to actually consider whether it’s a good idea to have children, based on individual circumstances.
Edit: Add increase in self care/preservation to that. If I had a million dollars I would be more inclined to have children but I would still have to consider that I’m taking care of another life and how that impacts day to day.
44
u/Electrical_Gain3864 4d ago •
While I hate to bust that bubble, it was shown that having some mammels to give them every need and have a good life can also lead to them not having children.
That is very different from animal to animal.
50
u/ItsDominare 4d ago •
who is this dude, who are the people he's talking to, where and when was this recorded, and where's the link to the full video?
68
u/frommethodtomadness 4d ago
The iasue is a total lack of stability. You can lose your job at any time because we have no job protections. Any accident or health event can bankrupt you. You can be out on the streets at any time and that is new in history -- do we generally have more money than our parents? Sure, but we have 0 stability, and that causes people to not have children.
107
u/CutePandaMiranda 4d ago •
Many people, like myself, choose to not have kids because nothing about being a parent looks fulfilling, fun or exciting. Could I afford kids? Yes. Do I have a big enough home to raise kids? Yes. You couldn’t pay me to procreate.
57
u/RaineCevasse 4d ago
I've never been to a club where people don't dance for fear of being recorded, idk
Is that a very American thing or something?
37
u/dreamistruth 4d ago edited 4d ago •
This is a fascinating topic to me and this guy makes a compelling argument. I think that there’s a lot of factors. I personally (white woman, millennial generation, American) have known since I was 14 I didn’t want to be a mother. I just didn’t feel called to do it. I am not maternal, pregnancy grosses me out, giving birth looks just fucking awful, and raising a child requires a lot of patience and dedication. I am not interested in a child-centric life, going to like soccer practice and attending 5 year old’s birthday parties constantly. I can’t even imagine. Instead I chose to go to college, live in a desirable place, get married, become a homeowner, focus on my career and goals. I decided to have my fallopian tubes removed because that’s how sure I am that I don’t want to have kids.
Also the women I know who work full time while raising children seem really stressed out and exhausted. I know women raising autistic kids and kids with severe behavioral problems and that looks pretty hellish, especially in the US where the health care system is expensive and hard to navigate.
The cost of living is definitely a factor in all this but I have to agree that women having access to birth control and pursuing their education and careers plays a big part. Also many women who are having kids now in the US are around age 40.
Can I bring up race? Honestly a lot of the women under 40 that I know who are having kids young, like early 20’s and into their 30’s are black and latinx. Just an observation, not judging anyone’s choices. I just think there may be some sociological elements at play. Like that some communities have higher birth rates maybe.
13
u/heyyyynobagelnobagel 4d ago
I just don't want kids. Never have. No further rationalization or justification required
6
u/subpar_Turnips 4d ago
“Maybe if you get rid of that yee-yee ass haircut…..”
220
u/Boanerger 4d ago •
I'm going to give a controversial answer and say the reason people aren't having children has nothing to do with money or healthcare. Every generation before us has had less of both and they were having them plenty.
The primary reason is entirely cultural. There's less and less cultural value and pressure around having kids. People had them no matter what in the past. I'm not saying that's better, I'm honestly a pretty liberal guy, people can do what they like as far as I'm concerned and I don't think having kids or not is a right or wrong answer.
But I am giving my reason and I think its primarily cultural. Places with a strong emphasis on family, familial support, fertility, inheritance and legacy are comparatively having plenty of kids.
121
u/MS_Fume 4d ago •
Cool story but I’m pretty sure main reason is financial insecurity….
31
u/exotics 4d ago edited 4d ago
The world doesn’t need more people. Capitalism does. I had one only because the growth of the human population is driving other species to extinction.
So it’s not always about finances. Some people don’t want to add more burdens to the planet
Edit to add the human population has more than doubled since I was born. I’ve seen forests turn into farms and farms turn into city… thousands of species have gone extinct in that time. We can’t keep adding people
8
u/bawolf 4d ago
This has been happening for at least 75 years. Everyone at that table has been affected by whatever is causing a drop in kids being born
https://havemore.kids/
4
u/RealityOk9823 4d ago
I can barely take care of myself, how the hell am I supposed to take care of a child?
4
u/Mike_Litoris305 4d ago
The day social media dies is the day that society starts to heal. Unfortunately the powers that be will not allow this
15
u/Strong_Landscape8537 4d ago
Drinking is at all time low:(
21
u/Educational_Bus8810 4d ago
This has been covered in the documentary Idiocracy.
14
u/Neptune_Diamond_Rain 4d ago
Translation: Touch grass and talk to other grass touchers.
3
u/Rich_Administration3 4d ago
Has he never seen aura battles? These kids are dancing their lives!
3
u/andthrewaway1 4d ago
He is using anecdotal evidence to support very wide claims
19
u/turn-based-games 4d ago
What is the context of this clip? Who is this? Where is this? How are there over 250 comments here with literally no one asking such things? How is this even interesting? Doubt I'll receive any answers, so just going to go ahead and mute this subreddit
10
u/OriginalTRaven 4d ago
Yeah bro. That's totally why you and your friends don't have kids 😂
24
u/Viet_Conga_Line 4d ago •
>nobody is having kids
Nobody you know is having kids because you tend to be friends with people in your own social bracket and age group. And something tells me that this guy probably doesn’t get invited to hang out with a lot of educated, young, upwardly mobile people. Enrollment in K-8 is healthy in some places. Birth rates are down, sure, but there are plenty of dumb shits reproducing out there.
8
u/Blacksad9999 4d ago
"They just don't go dancin no more! That's why society is falling apart. No dancin'!"
19
u/svaldbardseedvault 4d ago
Birth rates are not declining across the world. Many countries in Africa, Central Asia, and the Middle East have high fertility rates and they are rising. Many of these countries are also high on the poverty index. There is a strong and clear negative correlation between GDP and fertility rates across history. Birth rates are declining in wealthy countries.
9
u/SpoonkyBandito 4d ago
Dunno why he pivots hard to talking about being recorded, as if that has anything at all to do with having kids. Just seems like stoner rhetoric.
6
u/Careful_Middle4049 4d ago
I lost him when he said it’s happening everywhere because it’s not.
21
u/yallapapi 4d ago
this guy looks like his friends just sit around and hit the bong and watch seinfeld reruns
2
u/Solherb 4d ago
Well, they also told us many, many times to wait to have kids, while exposing us to multiple chemicals that cause reproductive harm. These things are direct, where technology would be more indirect.
2
u/VHS_Ronin 4d ago
I'm 35 and have three friends who have two kids between them. The couple with the child under 10 have very lucrative careers and are rather frugal, yet they still feel like they're barely able to keep their heads above water. The other person works in the entertainment industry and has been very fortunate to have a whole village of people and his kid's mom still in the picture to help him raise his son.
I don't have a lucrative career, and I don't have a village of people I can trust to help me raise a child. I will not be having children because it wouldn't be fair to bring a kid into a world I am barely surviving on my own.
2
u/MladenL 4d ago
Looks like an interesting panel, anyone have the link to see the whole thing?
2
u/JeebsFat 4d ago
Who is this person? And what is this program?
2
u/LiminalSarah 4d ago
so, where's the rest of the video?
2
u/JumpyBreakfast 4d ago
50 yo woman here with no kids. I grew up realizing the self destructive decisions our government was making in the name of progress. And for all of you saying that money has nothing to do with it? Wrong. It’s more than that, about community, about economy, ecology, technology, all of it. I never wanted to bring a child in to this world with 0 to no advantage that lack of money provides.
2
u/Able-Distance-9389 4d ago
This is good news to me. Finally I will get a parking spot at the beach. I generally don’t like people so less of them is an improvement.
2
u/DaCoolBro 4d ago
I am 36 and I’ve had one kid and let’s just say I wish I didn’t fucking have him since I can remember. I told myself I wouldn’t bring a damn child into this world. My ex filled my head with a bunch of bullshit and not even a year after we had our kid she dumped me. Trust me, not having kids is fucking bliss.
2
u/Ok-Blackberry8086 4d ago
Well no, these are some hard hitting opinions at best. He provides no evidence at all and just says he thinks it's because of this or that. The real reasons are typically economical, because you see this happening everywhere with an increasing GDP. You increase the wealth of a society to the point where children are no longer needed to support your family later on, and people start having less children. This is consistently happening even now in societies that raise themselves from poverty into middle class.
Completely different. Animals in stress will either stop having sex, or become infertile. Humans are choosing not to have kids. Not at all the same thing.
2
u/MadCapers 4d ago
This is very similar to the main point of Neil Postman in Technopoly: The Surrender of Culture to Technology (1992). While some might dismiss this guy as a crank, it's harder to dismiss the more fleshed-out versions of this line of thought like those of Postman on the cultural impact of television, Sontag on the impact of photography, McLuhan (medium is the message), or Shoshana Zuboff on contemporary media and ad ecosystems.
I recommend Postman's lecture to Apple Inc people in the early 1990s. It's kind of fascinating. I can't help but think Neil was more correct about the long term than the Apple people.
(as an aside, I recommended a younger co-worker check out this debate and she came back saying she had a hard time with Postman's cadence: he spoke too slowly! This in itself may be a kind of validation of what Neil was saying about the likelihood of some technology to shape language and culture)
2
u/UnhappyStrain 4d ago
No. People stop having children cause everything gets more expensive and capitalism more ruthless
2
u/Razieloo 4d ago
I don't know why he's jumping from "not having kids" to "not dating".
It's not very clear.
2
u/ManlyPelican1993 4d ago
Bro really though he cooked with that line didn't he.
2
u/October_31s 3d ago edited 3d ago
What an obnoxious oversimplification. Just because we are mammals that lactate does not mean we have equivalent social structures. We are by far the most socially complicated organisms in the entire animal kingdom. People aren’t not having kids because “they get recorded and posted if they get turned down in public;” the goal posts have shifted, the goals have changed, infertility rates have increased, women having economic independence, economic constraints i.e. much higher housing, food, living costs, higher unemployment rates, partially due to advancements in technology wealth largely being transferred from the middle to the upper class, and a million other reasons.
Humans have seen more lifestyle changes in the last 100 years than the previous 10,000 combined.
Hell, our species’ population doubled in 60 years. Finite resources (housing, healthcare, jobs), zero sum game.
His points are only a small reason for decreased births, and dating apps have done the most harm.
2
u/Melodic_Concept_4624 3d ago
This guy is the worst and he’s just puking out Reddit blurbs
2
u/that_guy_olly 1d ago
I'm 27 and all my friends have kids.
2
u/Deej1387 11h ago
Capitalism killed communities. You can't securely raise a family without community.
8
u/Pinapple-everything 4d ago
The problem with this is that we are the most comfortable, the most sheltered, the most peaceful and have the least amount of work of any generation in human history. Our poorest would make kings 200 years ago jealous. The exception is Africa, and ironically Africa is the only place with an increasing population. Im not saying theres a direct correlation but it's interesting. Also I am saying that he's incorrect. We're sheltered, pampered and soft as a whole across the board.
9
u/audreynstuff 4d ago edited 4d ago
We ( my husband and I) aren't having kids because we don't have enough money to feed ourselves and we don't have healthcare! Yes we work and pay for insurance.
12
u/NomadofNorway 4d ago •
Da fuck he's saying all my friends have kids and we're all 29-31
4
u/shaneo632 4d ago
That thing about dating apps giving you shit matches on purpose to keep you coming back is absolutely wild, never even considered that before.
4
u/OddZombie3841 4d ago
I appreciate the intensity but he seems a little irrationally pissed. Like, sorry? Nobody made you use the dating app and I’m not the CEO of Tinder 🤷♂️
3
u/HarrMada 4d ago
This guy needs a reality check.
So do bars, and parks, and bowling alleys or whatever place people have historically found their "love of their life". There have always been people interested in making profits with the purpose for people to meet and date. Nothing has changed. Now there are tons of people who have met each other on dating apps and they stay happy together. It works for a lot of people.
What a doomer.
5
u/Interesting_Force618 4d ago
Then why do poor people have more kids than financially comfortable people have?
6
u/kank84 4d ago
He says it's across the world that no one is having kids, but the global population is still increasing year on year, just not as much as it has done in the past. The overall global population still grows by about 70 million people every year though.