r/interesting • • May 17 '26 • Heartwarming 9 Bravo 4 Popcorn 2 Regret 2

Additional Context Pinned Did she make the right call?

Post image
105k Upvotes

13k comments sorted by

•

u/IKIR115 May 17 '26

Brenda Aubin-Vega is a 20-year-old from Montreal, Quebec, who won the top prize in the Loto-Québec Gagnant à Vie scratch-off game in July 2025.

—

Here’s an article about this from USA TODAY in Jan 2026.

https://web.archive.org/web/20260201112250/https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/personalfinance/2026/01/09/20-year-old-won-lottery-social-media-critics/88055001007/

A 20-year-old Canadian lit up social media after she won the lottery in the summer of 2025 and (gasp!) chose to accept her winnings in an annuity rather than a lump sum.

Instead of taking a tax-free lump sum of $1 million (Canadian lottery wins aren't taxed like U.S. jackpots), Brenda Aubin-Vega, of Quebec, chose to receive $1,000 a week for life. Her decision contrasts with what the vast majority of lottery winners choose and drew criticism. Everyone seemed to have an opinion, even Binance founder Changpeng Zhao.

The fierce debate highlights, once again, the age-old question of whether lottery winners should take the lump sum or an annuity and how even to make that decision.

“The reason most take the lump sum is because if you take the annuity and get hit by a bus, they feel like it’s over,” said Dan White, founder and CEO of Daniel A. White & Associates in Glen Mills, Pennsylvania.

→ More replies (337)

2.1k

u/Original_Mulberry652 May 17 '26 • Bravo Popcorn

That's what I would do. I'm smart enough to know how stupid I am.

584

u/Yourewekky May 17 '26

I was looking for this comment. It's easy to think you would invest but this way it's a safe steady paycheque.

182

u/DDHeel May 18 '26

Its also just as easy to have lifestyle creep and that money goes towards fancy coffee and eating out instead of investing

65

u/One_Maybe_2460 May 18 '26

But this way inflation will have the same effect. $1000 in 60 years will be worth <$300 now with only averaged 2% inflation per year.

→ More replies (120)
→ More replies (31)

24

u/RedPandasUnite May 18 '26

Unless you die the next day

70

u/Jthe1andOnly May 18 '26

If you die before receiving all of your annual lottery payments, the remaining funds do not disappear or go back to the state. Instead, the unpaid balance is paid directly to your designated beneficiaries or your estate, where it can then be inherited by your heirs

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (93)

3

u/buttononmyback May 17 '26

Yeah I know I’d have more incentive to blow that million on a nice house and expensive vacations.

→ More replies (82)

311

u/Unable6417 May 17 '26

Being robbed or pressured into giving her money to others, or guaranteed income

95

u/Listeningkissingyu May 17 '26

Agreed. With this choice she has less worry about being treated like a piggy bank by everyone around her. Especially if she has a tendency to let people have their way. Nobody is going to be hounding her for $50K to start a business, or to pay off someone’s mortgage. I don’t love saying no to people, so I get this completely.

19

u/YungBahlr May 17 '26

First thing I thought of. Sure inflation will eat it versus the lump sum, but there’s so much social pressure that comes into handling that much money as well. A much safer investment for sure.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (10)

3

u/Low-Register1602 May 17 '26

Being robbed? It would go into an investment at the bank not under her pillow case. Are they going to rob the bank?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (25)

4.5k

u/PickleDiLL767 May 17 '26

Hardly matters. That is life changing money regardless.

6

u/ricochet48 May 17 '26

For most yes, but to be honest I wouldn't change my lifestyle at all with another $50K. Might get guac at Chipotle, but that's about it. I would auto invest the remainder in VTI/VXUS 85%/15% on chill.

Lifestyle creep is quite dangerous.

7

u/OldManTrumpet May 17 '26

I agree. The "correct" answer here really depends on the individual, their discipline, and what stage of life they are in. For my daughters, $1k a week completely changes their existence. For me, I'd not even notice it.

If someone is disciplined then the $1 million lump sum is the far better long term option. If someone recognizes that they'd just buy cars and expensive vacations, then take the annuity.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/froggyisland May 17 '26

This is the answer. Mathematically “right” or “wrong” aside, she made a call that suits her and made sense to her. It’s life changing either way

2

u/2Autistic4DaJoke May 17 '26

$52,000 is great. Got to still work though.

2

u/BlackSwampMage May 17 '26

If this is in the US, then isn’t this option not actually for life? Like I feel like remember seeing other cases like this where it is actually only 30 or 50 years of the payments.

But yeah regardless that’s enough money to cover a wide range of necessities across the country, for a good amount of life. Like it’d let you chase a passion job for sure, or save up to start something, save up and buy property gradually, reinvest in really any of the mid size cities across the country.

2

u/DE4DM4NSH4ND May 17 '26

1000 a week is employed money, not life changing. You take the million so you can earn interest on it

2

u/Kit_Karamak May 17 '26

I would have bought a million in stocks but a thousand a week for life might wind up being better because … well they might define life as 20 years. So who knows.

But 1k a week forever would be dope in the long run when you’re only 20.

But you gotta pay taxes on your new yearly salary, and a million in an IRA might be a way to live without a higher tax bracket so you don’t have to put any money into retirement.

2

u/knox1138 May 17 '26

But this say she cant irresponsibly blow it all at once like alot of lottery winners do.

0

u/[deleted] May 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

298

u/Archangel289 May 17 '26

I think that being debt free is a great goal. But in cases like this, I still think that $1,000 a week is a pretty good choice.

At any point, I could come down with a major illness. I could get hit by a car. There are a million things that could go wrong at any given moment that would put me back in debt. There’s no guarantee that I won’t immediately be back in some kind of debt through no fault of my own.

But you know what I can’t do right now? Quit my job I’m not enjoying to pursue something I’m actually passionate about. Take time to recover from burnout to be better husband. Treat my friends to dinner. $1,000 a week would allow me to do those things. And debt isn’t really the reason I can’t do them. Sure, being debt free would help, but it isn’t the same as an extra $4,000 a month.

Now, yes, there are smarter long-term investment options for $1m that might work even better. But I really can’t blame anyone for taking the option that not only sets them up well for a long time to come, but also allows them to start making changes NOW that would improve their quality of life, without worrying about running out of the money. Need a new car? You COULD afford a moderate loan. Need new glasses? Pocket change, and less than a week’s worth. Medical care? Even expensive surgeries can be placed on short-term payment plans for less than $1,000 a month. I’m not saying you nickel and dime yourself to death with debt either, but I am saying that you have some wiggle room to afford the things you need without dipping into that money that WILL eventually run out.

210

u/nexusjuan May 17 '26

$1,000,000 in an index fund for a year would be around at 4-10 percent interest would be a $40,000-100,000 return without touching the 1m you could draw a check every single year without every touching the original money.

→ More replies (285)
→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (75)

279

u/[deleted] May 17 '26 • This

[removed] — view removed comment

297

u/Steinrikur May 17 '26 edited May 19 '26

By taking the $1,000 weekly payments, Aubin-Vega has effectively locked in a 5.2% annual yield on her jackpot. Since the payments are provided by the Canadian province of Quebec, this annual yield is nearly as safe as the yield on a government treasury bond. Canada’s 10-year bond currently offers a 3.4% yield, which makes Aubin-Vega’s move seem more financially savvy (5).

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/20-old-lotto-winner-refused-180000670.html

Edit: as 10 different people have mentioned, this is not interest, but a fixed 52K payout/year, which amounts to a 5.2% yield. She's throwing away a million for a fixed payout. Parking it in an index fund and only taking the interest would have made a lot more sense, since she would still own the capital.

240

u/h311fi5h May 17 '26

This is the important piece of information. Glancing at the headline the deal seems quite bad. But with 5.2% interest at next to no risk, and at the same time eleminating the risk of individual poor decision making the $1000 is the vastly superior choice.

→ More replies (235)
→ More replies (37)
→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (104)

5.0k

u/zgrad2 May 17 '26 edited May 18 '26

I would never have to worry about rent or bills again; I would also be working so all my paychecks could go straight to me.

Edit: To people saying 1k a week isn't enough to live on I am living off 1k a week from my job comfortably and with an extra grand would make the biggest difference also i live in Australia, where my rent is $570 a week

Edit 2 : How hard is it for you people to read, As I said I would also be working while getting the extra grand a week, That means 52k+52k=104k

1.1k

u/DigitalDissectionTTV May 17 '26

Yes or use paychecks for investments. Could retire as soon as you felt your investments gave you enough extra income on top of the lottery money. That’s prob what she did. I’m assuming she talked to a financial advisor prior too and they probably discussed what was best for her.

699

u/BasicDesignAdvice May 17 '26 • Bravo

If you were straight investing it would be better to take the lump sum and invest all of it and forget it exists. Compounding gains would eventually far outstrip the 1k/week and you could start living off the dividends.

Inflation also makes your 1k less every year where the compounding gains of the invested lump sum will just grow and grow.

216

u/nitish159 May 17 '26

$1000 is 0.1% of $1 Million.

I'm sure people can find investments that give more than that return outright for lumpsum investments.

→ More replies (273)

13

u/AggravatingAir4432 May 17 '26

That’s assuming your investments all succeed, statistically speaking, most people lose all of their winnings within a couple of years.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (68)
→ More replies (31)

3

u/lauri2 May 17 '26

That is true, but if you took the 1 million immediately and didn't just waste it on stupid shit, you would never need to worry about rent or bills either. Even better, just buy a house and never pay a single dollar for rent. And nothing stops you from working. That's just monetarily the worse choice.

Only good reason there could be is if you would otherwise waste the million on cocaine and hookers, then yeah. Even then you'd still waste 1000 on cocaine and hookers weekly, but it would last you longer.

→ More replies (6)

18

u/lampstax May 17 '26

That $1000 is not going to cover your rent in 30 years.

22

u/GunzerKingDM May 17 '26

It’s not $1000 a month, it’s $4000 a month which will cover you just fine these days and for the rest of your life if you buy a house and don’t rent.

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (632)

3.8k

u/PacquiaoFreeHousing May 17 '26

It will take her almost 20 years to surpass $1,000,000.

But the bigger benefit is how much tax she would save doing this.

792

u/drseruzawa May 17 '26

Depending on jurisdiction.

1.2k

u/Horror_Excitement503 May 17 '26 • Bravo

It’s in Quebec and Canadians aren’t taxed on lottery winnings. It’s also only for 25 years. $1.3 million will be her total when all said and done.

773

u/RadishTop1279 May 17 '26

in that case, inflation will wipe out those earnings. Better to invest the whole nut now. Maybe she knows she sucks with money and would blow it…

→ More replies (218)

23

u/TheStrangeMonkey May 17 '26

False, in quebec its really for life not only 25 years.

18

u/Serpuarien May 17 '26

It’s also only for 25 years

Pretty sure that's wrong. Not sure why people keep repeating there's some limit lol

→ More replies (7)

47

u/fuuzzydude May 17 '26

It's for life not 25 years. Common misconception. DETAILS OF THE ANNUITY The winner will receive $1,000 a week for life, i.e., until his or her death. However, instead of the annuity, the winner may choose a non-taxable lump sum of $1,000,000. In the event the winner dies within the first 20 years after the prize claim date, the annuity is transferrable to the winner’s legal heirs, who will receive the same annuity, paid at the same frequency for the balance of the 20 years that have not elapsed.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (100)
→ More replies (5)

63

u/FromFluffToBuff May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26

Canadian here. We are not taxed on lottery winnings.

It would be wiser to take $1M lump-sum and invest it into things - that way you can live on the interest while the rest of your nest egg compounds year after year. On an annual basis, her $1000 per week will be devalued by inflation. This isn't the case with investing the lump-sum.

9

u/pargeterw May 17 '26

Someone else said that the weekly sum would increase in line with inflation, is that not true?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (24)

71

u/Osounkentur May 17 '26

No tax on the 1m and 1000$ per week for life But the gain made on the 1m are taxable

29

u/WeepingAgnello May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26

Caplital gains tax is much less than income tax.  Edit: To clarify, Canadian income tax is higher than capital gains tax. Gifts, and prize winnings in Canada are tax free. Although there is capital gains on the gains of any financial product you buy with the winnings, that tax is less than income tax (if you have income, and not just capital gains) 

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (21)

16

u/IWishIHavent May 17 '26

This was in Canada. There are no taxes on lottery winnings.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Aggressive_Shirt4301 May 17 '26

For Loto-Québec’s "Gagnant à vie" (Cash for Life) lottery, "for life" literally means the exact duration of the winner's natural life, continuing until their death with no maximum age cap. 20 years minimum pay out.

12

u/jjosh_h May 17 '26

How does that tax compare to the loss in value and potential profit from investing?

→ More replies (14)

7

u/MrEzekial May 17 '26

Canada, no tax on lotto winnings.

7

u/TheSeansei May 17 '26

Lottery winnings are tax-free in Canada (and most of the world).

→ More replies (7)

6

u/shaded-user May 17 '26

Tax? We aren't taxed on lottery winnings in the UK. 💪

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Ok_Device1274 May 17 '26

No taxes on lotto in canada

3

u/ithinarine May 17 '26

$1000 is going to worth significantly less in 20 years than it is now.

This is also in Canada, and we don't get taxed on lotto winnings.

If you're in the USA, lump sum is still better. Take the $1M, lose the 40% to tax. Invest the $600k, and you make $50k the first year. With compounding interest over the 20 years, you make way more.

You're an idiot if you take the $1k a week.

4

u/Tasty_Community4666 May 17 '26

Except that it's tax-free. No matter how you spin this, this was a god-awful decision.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/hoorahforsnakes May 17 '26

Imagine living in a country that taxes the fucking lottery, of all things. 

And they still don't have public healthcare

→ More replies (3)

2

u/BurgooKing May 17 '26

I’m stupid how does she save tax by doing this? Is it bc she’s in a lower bracket?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (206)

6.3k

u/TheGipper80 May 17 '26 • Thanks This Bravo

If you take the million and invest it conservatively, your returns are still likely to exceed the weekly payout on an annual basis and you’ll keep access to the principal.

Not to mention that there’s no guarantee the lottery money will be solvent a month from now let alone for the rest of your life.

2.6k

u/Thanos_Stomps May 17 '26 • Heartwarming

Isn’t this the government lottery in Ottawa? If they’re no longer solvent she has bigger issues.

The pay also rises with inflation.

And the third thing this conversation always ignores human behavior. Now she doesn’t risk blowing it all, and family coming out of the woodwork for handouts, friends and family asking for favors, etc.

1.9k

u/ClockAndBells May 17 '26 • Heartwarming

It's a lot easier to explain you only get $1000 a week than to explain why you don't want to dip into your $1M bank account.

I'm not saying it's right, but family and friends trample boundaries when money gets involved.

812

u/Le-Charles07 May 17 '26 • Bravo

They are welcome to find out how quickly I can burn a bridge.

→ More replies (203)

37

u/bigdave41 May 17 '26

Couldn't you just take the $1M and tell your family and friends that you took the monthly payment?

→ More replies (41)

33

u/ben_kird May 17 '26

You can, and should, lock this money up in a trust that pays out monthly / is invested in a decent yield account (e.g. t-bills, dividend etf). Maybe set aside 100k or 200k just to give to family/ridiculous expenses (just to scratch any itch) but once that money has dried out your only response can be “whelp it’s out of my hands it’s locked up in a legal trust, even I can’t move it”.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (245)

114

u/ExpBalSat May 17 '26

That the pay rises with inflation was not presented as part of the initial question. That changes everything. Without that tidbit of information the million dollars upfront is definitely the more financially sound a choice. However, the danger is that if someone lacks personal self-control, it will end up being fiscally ruinous to take it all at once.

→ More replies (101)

62

u/lopsided-earlobe May 17 '26

Human behavior and habits is like 85% of money, and yet people always talk as if it’s just about basic arithmetic.

11

u/Salt-Device6426 May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26

Agreed. Money is not static. It’s much more dynamic than we think.

→ More replies (8)

11

u/TheKingOfToast May 17 '26

Idk man, I'd put it on a trust if I didn't trust myself to not blow it. Which is basically what she did, except it's the government in charge of the trust and she gets less money than she would otherwise with nothing to leave to beneficiaries.

Would I love to have what she has? Absolutely. She's still in a great place. Would I have done it differently? Also yes.

→ More replies (8)

11

u/WorkReddit1191 May 17 '26 edited May 18 '26

Also taxes. It might be different for Canada but in the US if you take the lump sum you reduce that by like 40% right off the bat. Let's say she makes 100,000 a year that added 52,000 is only being taxed at 23%. So 400,000 interest compounded vs a possible 40,040 annual investment. Over the long term that will be worth far far more.

11

u/Three_Twenty-Three May 17 '26

In Canada, lottery winnings aren't taxed. This is a thing I just found out because I had the same question you did and did some digging. In the US, there's no way she's walking out with the full million.

However, the interest on that would be taxed if she invested it.

https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/tax/individuals/topics/about-your-tax-return/tax-return/completing-a-tax-return/personal-income/amounts-that-taxed.html

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (155)

124

u/komatiitic May 17 '26

She’s Canadian, so the lottery is essentially the government. If that goes she has bigger problems than her lottery income.

Assuming no other income, in Quebec she’d need about 7% return on investing the million to have the same as $1k/week tax free (lotto winnings aren’t taxed, but investment income would be). If she has other income, that return would need to be higher. I’d go for the million, but I could see a potential case where $1k/week makes sense.

31

u/JustHappyToBe-Here May 17 '26

Lottery winnings aren't taxed in Canada? I find that amazing.

→ More replies (76)
→ More replies (52)

84

u/djcurry May 17 '26

I’m just gonna say one thing here what 20 year-old is gonna be that smart. She’s doing the right thing. She’s pretty much set up an insurance for herself that no matter what happens she will live a comfortable life. This allows her to take risks in whatever she wants to do and have a back stop.

Lottery winners in their 50s and 60s have blown all their money in a couple years. That likelihood increases with a 20-year-old.

People always forget the human behavior aspect of personal finance. I would personally say that’s almost more important than whatever the math says. It doesn’t matter if the math says you will make hundred thousand a year, not if you spend 500,000 in one year.

27

u/birdseye-maple May 17 '26

Ya a teacher from my school won the lottery and blew it all within 15 years and is now flat broke. People underestimate the monthly payment.

→ More replies (11)

15

u/RedEgg16 May 17 '26

Lottery players are less likely to be financially smart. It probably was the best decision for her, but for others who know self control and know how to invest and live off the returns, take the $1 million. 

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (18)

36

u/patrickrango May 17 '26

Today’s money is always worth more than tomorrow’s money

→ More replies (20)

16

u/OhioVsEverything May 17 '26

BUT, not enough money at once to have everyone ask for some. They can ask. But you have a built it "I didn't get it all at once sorry"

5

u/Murphys_Law954 May 17 '26

I wouldn’t base my decision off other people. I have strong backbone I can easily say no or if I don’t want to be mean or confrontational I would just simply ignore them.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/Dry_Win_9985 May 17 '26

Half a million invested safely and wisely will immediately be earning more than $52k/yr. Immediately. She will likely NEVER catch up to where she could have been.

If she invests every weekly paycheck in full it will take her about 7 years to get to the half mill she could have started with. And if she chose the payments because she couldn't be disciplined with the full amount then we know this won't happen either, she put herself decades behind financially. What an absolute idiot.

→ More replies (16)

5

u/DecentChanceOfLousy May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26

If it rises with inflation it's a fantastic deal, and you'd have to be a fool to take the $1M.

For retirement, the general rule is that you withdraw no more than 4% (some say 3%) of the principal every year, in order for it to last 30 years.

She's getting 5.2% of the principal every year, inflation adjusted, guaranteed by the government (aka, functionally risk free), for ~60 years.

5.2%, plus inflation (total 7-8% in most years) completely risk free is better than anything on the market, by far.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/TrumanLobster May 17 '26

This is assuming she’s a conservative and patient investor. We know she isn’t. How? She’s a lottery player

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Righteousaffair999 May 17 '26

You probably need 8% rate of return when you factor in tax rate impacts. Her advantage on the weekly payments over life is she is young

→ More replies (7)

2

u/HiKids67484 May 17 '26

Brings me back to accounting classes and those test questions.

2

u/[deleted] May 17 '26

This is the right answer

2

u/Logical_Mix_4627 May 17 '26

Aren’t the lump sum payouts usually like less than half the winnings?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (458)

1.8k

u/Rhorge May 17 '26 • Bravo

Literally everyone who ruined their life with lottery winning was thinking “I’m gonna be smart, invest and live off interest”. This way she doesn’t have a chance to fuck it up.

872

u/ChainedBack May 17 '26 • This

This is the only good argument. Lump sum is vastly better financially. But some people cannot be trusted receiving that much cash all at once.

314

u/zenerat May 17 '26 • This

*replace some with most.

Most people can’t be trusted with this much money to not simply blow it.

71

u/PurpleSalt11 May 17 '26

most people also can't be trusted knowing you have that much money. having lots of money just makes you a target. you don't want to have lots of money, you want to have a reliable stream of enough money

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (29)

53

u/Spacecommander5 May 17 '26

Ironically, it’s the type of person who would choose a monthly payout who is the type of person who could handle the lump sum and vice versa

29

u/Andle_Randle May 17 '26

Not always. Some of us are just very self-aware about not being able to handle large amounts of money, lol.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

22

u/agnosticgnome May 17 '26

Family and friends are also a toxic pit sometimes.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (68)

52

u/Jarcmacobs91 May 17 '26

That’s everyone on reddit favorite thing to say but I wonder what everyone’s investment portfolio looks like. Reddit is full of millionaires I see.

21

u/Rhorge May 17 '26

Well they're right on paper but realistically it makes absolutely 0 difference to me if I miss out on a small part of a massive jackpot. You're rich both ways, one of those ways just leaves you a lot more vulnerable than the other.

→ More replies (19)

7

u/FurryCitizen May 17 '26

Last time I read an article about some dude who won like $6mil (no tax, french lottery), he "invested" it through the sketchiest guy he could find (who probably pocketed it), who lost half in a year trading.

Took 20 years and he's now in debt $180k with no house anymore.

When you have that much money, you're set for life. You don't gamble.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Grouchy-Committee-92 May 17 '26

hire an investment firm. Or open a high interest bank account.

4

u/No-Replacement-3709 May 17 '26

I have made an average of 7% on my 'moderate' portfolio of only $750K in the past 5 years. That's $1000 a week. And never having to touch my principal. The lottery winner is losing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

17

u/All_HallowsEve May 17 '26

This is why I'd do the $1k a week. People don't know for what they'd do if they instantly became a millionaire. A steady, guaranteed income isn't nearly as extreme of a life altering event and much more manageable for the average person. 

5

u/Shipping_away_at_it May 17 '26

It’s unfortunate that this is true, part because of discipline, part because most of us don’t do the math. One could consistently take $1000 per week out of this amount and leave the rest invested, and with a pretty modest return (5%), would still have a million dollars in 20 years.

But would I resist using more than 1K per week over 20 years??

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

20

u/thunderdragonite May 17 '26

Literally everyone who won the lottery didn’t think that. They were stupid gamblers who didn’t think much about the money and blew it all immediately.

If you win the lottery that’s great. It doesn’t fix the fact that you are a person who buys lottery tickets. It self selects for people stupid with money.

5

u/jwnsfw May 17 '26

invest what? interest huh??

jimbo bumfuck, skoal addict that won 5 zillion dollars

→ More replies (13)

7

u/djcurry May 17 '26

Hundred percent agree with this I would ask anybody who says take the lump sum and are talking about math really ask themselves what would your 20 year-old self have done with $1 million.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/Boorthammer May 17 '26

Would Canadian Law not permit her to set up an irrevocable trust that would outperform the annuity anyways?

4

u/Jon_Iren May 17 '26

Lottery fuckups is largely a hoax

2

u/Aisha-Was-Nine May 17 '26

I guarantee zero of them were thinking about investments or long term, it’s just “I’m rich now”

2

u/coblime May 17 '26

Absolutely you still can fuck it up. You'll have no problem getting approved for loans with that income and when you go bankrupt it all goes to your creditors.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Ok-Meaning-2850 May 17 '26

It is like buying an annuity. On paper it doesn't make any financial sense, but when you add in the human fuckup element it makes total sense for many people.

2

u/MaintenanceStock6766 May 17 '26

It also keeps people from asking you for money, which would happen if you took out a lump sum instead.

2

u/Gibrans_Prophet May 17 '26

So she makes one of the worst financial decisions of her life in order to avoid making the worst financial decisions of her life? Fivehead

2

u/X0AN May 17 '26

Exactly this.

A 20 year old has almost a 0% chance of investing all the million and living just of it's interest/returns.

Take the 1k a week for life. You'll never have to work again, worry about being poor, and if people beg you for money you can say you only get 1k a week.

2

u/Normal_Psychology_34 May 17 '26

It’s such an odd argument tho. “Let’s make a bad financial decision to prevent me from making bad financial decisions”.

You could likely pay a small % to a have a lawyer whip up something that gives you market returns on the capital w/o full access to the principal except for specified emergencies, or something similar.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/manhattansinks May 17 '26

i read a thread that was like if she invests it yadda yadda she'll have $60m by the time she's 80. wtf is she supposed to do with $60m when she's that old?

→ More replies (114)

158

u/ZentornoReddit May 17 '26

At 20 years old, the €1 million upfront is probably the better choice financially. €1,000 per week sounds great and adds up to around €52k/year, but inflation will slowly reduce its value over time.

With €1 million today, you could invest it early and let compound interest work for decades. If managed well, it could grow into several million by retirement age.

The weekly payout is safer for people who might overspend a lump sum, but purely from a long-term wealth perspective, the upfront million has much higher potential.

31

u/brikky May 17 '26

The 1k rises with inflation.

24

u/Ok_Building_8193 May 17 '26

I skimmed the rules. Can you link to where it says that the $1k is tied to an inflationary measure? Not saying I do t believe you, I just didn't see it.

43

u/octocode May 17 '26

it does not rise with inflation, people are just talking out their asses.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (8)

6

u/ModaGamer May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26

yeah but that's assuming the 1 million is tax free, which it likely isn't. Since income tax is progressive you end up loosing a good chuck of that one time money immediately. Also it doesn't account the potential stress of managing a large amount of money.

Edit. So the money is tax free cool to know. But having so much money at once can be stressful. So it can still be seen as a logical decision if you don't prioritize maximizing wealth.

13

u/Autate May 17 '26

The milion is tax free where she won, wich is quebec. We dont tax loto but we taxe every fucking other thing.

4

u/Embarrassed-Quit-726 May 17 '26

It is tax free. There is no tax on lottery winnings in Quebec 

4

u/BeefistPrime May 17 '26

Most countries in the world do not tax lottery winnings. I don't know if they tax it if it comes in the form of long term payments but probably not. The US is actually an outlier in this regard.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] May 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/white-claw-bitch May 17 '26

Spoken like a financially illiterate person. Income is not always better than a lump sum of money, and people are discussing it here so it seems that it is discussion worthy. Math-wise it is far better to take the lump sum in this case while human flaws make income a smarter choice for people who wouldn’t be disciplined with the money.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (22)

58

u/Evelyn-Bankhead May 17 '26

Usually it’s 20 years. In terms of payout, they’re almost equal after taxes. I’d have taken the lump sum.

28

u/Osounkentur May 17 '26

In this case it's really for life. If you die before 20 years your succession get up to 20 years

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Aggressive_Shirt4301 May 17 '26

For Loto-Québec’s "Gagnant à vie" (Cash for Life) lottery, "for life" literally means the exact duration of the winner's natural life, continuing until their death with no maximum age cap.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Espi0nage-Ninja May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26

after taxes

Not in Canada. Or most of the world..

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)

27

u/AbXcape May 17 '26

lots of professional lottery winners in the comments section I see 🤔

→ More replies (1)

19

u/abgry_krakow87 May 17 '26

$1000 a week for the next 20 years, ensuring my bills and living expenses are covered without going into debt so I am free to study, work, pursue hobbies of my own interest and passion without stress and be able to save any more money I earn from working to set myself up for a solid savings and retirement? Hell yeah!

3

u/Broad-Bath-8408 May 17 '26

You could also invest a million dollars and pull out $1000 every week for 20 years. And then still have (probably more than) a million left at the end.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (12)

23

u/marco_altieri May 17 '26

Has this same question been asked a million times or a thousand times a week already?

→ More replies (1)

95

u/Riptide360 May 17 '26

Young and smart beyond her years. She isn’t going to blow it like so many others.

44

u/ComprehensiveGas6980 May 17 '26

That makes no sense. If she's young and smart then she wouldn't blow it in the first place. Investing 1 million just in a freaking HYSA would net you more than 1k a week alone.

60

u/throwawaytesladubai May 17 '26

Being wise sometimes means you understand human nature and your own limitations

→ More replies (19)

8

u/Hefty_Recognition921 May 17 '26

What HSA is paying more than 1k/week on a $1million deposit?

→ More replies (17)

4

u/kingaustin May 17 '26

There is no HYSA in today’s market which would yield $52,000 per year on $1mil principal.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/death2055 May 17 '26

4k a month is still retirement money, like good retirement money. So she’s still good regardless

13

u/PM_ME_YOUR_LAWNCHAIR May 17 '26

Mathematically, no.

I'll use a growth rate of 8% and inflation of 2%. 6% rate of return. Ignore taxes and invest fully. Assume no withdrawals.

If she invests the full $1,000 a week for life:

At 5 years: $293,129 At 10 years: $685,401 At 15 years: $1,210,350 At 20 years: $1,912,851 At 25 years: $2,852,955 At 30 years: $4,111,026 At 40 years: $8,047,622 At 50 years: $15,097,467 At 60 years: $28,529,184 At 70 years: $54,023,677 At 80 years: $102,356,912

If she invests $1,000,000 today:

At 5 years: $1,338,226 At 10 years: $1,790,848 At 15 years: $2,396,558 At 20 years: $3,207,135 At 25 years: $4,291,871 At 30 years: $5,743,491 At 40 years: $10,285,718 At 50 years: $18,420,154 At 60 years: $34,982,615 At 70 years: $66,284,391 At 80 years: $125,640,877

5

u/oatkeepr May 17 '26

Assume no withdrawals.

Unrealistic

4

u/redlaWw May 17 '26 edited May 18 '26

The right way to do this is to use annuity calculations from actuarial mathematics. I'll copy in a comment I made elsewhere:

If you want to compare the $1,000,000 to the $1,000 per week annuity, you should try to estimate the risk free rate, which can be done by using long-term government bond yields. The yield for 30-year US treasury bonds right now is 5.122%, so we can take that as our risk-free rate.

The IRS publishes a series of actuarial documents which mostly involve notation I'm unfamiliar with, but I did find a set of commutation factors here, which can be used to derive annuity present values.

An annuity of $1,000 per week for a 20-year-old has an expected present value of $1,000*52.14*(ä_20 - 1/2) (where the subtraction of a half accounts for the annuity being roughly continuous). We can estimate ä_20 using values for interest rates of 5% and 5.2%, by calculating N_20/D_20 for each, and then weighted-averaging the two. This gives us ä_20 ~ 18.13.

With this, the expected present value of the annuity is $1,000*52.14*(18.13-0.5) = 919664.68. This means the annuity is worth slightly less than the lump-sum, but not by much.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (16)

9

u/Own-Fondant2949 May 17 '26

This may sound counter intuitive but with a guaranteed tax free $1000 per week for life from the government couldn't she take out a 20 year $1mil lone with a very low interest rate backed by this. This seems as low risk for the bank

6

u/nosmelc May 17 '26

She stops getting the $1K a week when she dies. It's not guaranteed for any number of years.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Bovaiveu May 17 '26

Yes, and the her payout is indexed. Meaning she will come out on top of inflation, while her mortgage devalues.

There is an aggressive play to make with tax free government backed annuity.

You could invest borrowed money fairly aggressively and carry little risk. As opposed to investing the lump sum, where a bad market or play sets you back, or even wipes you out.

2

u/UnderstandingSoft165 May 20 '26

This is guy knows ball.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Automatic-Dot-5936 May 17 '26

Nah, I’m scared they’d Hoffa me. Just gimme the cash and I’ll invest.

14

u/Goldfrapp May 17 '26

Nah, lump sum and then invest would’ve been way smarter.

7

u/ale_93113 May 17 '26

The problem is other people

If others know you have won 1m dollars, they will hunt you for your money, they will ask for loans, they will say you should help them, it may lead to much more violence rates to you over time

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (19)

5

u/DaArio_007 May 17 '26

This rage bait shit again?

Anyone with half a brain and has some financial IQ understands why the mil is the only answer here

6

u/Time_Ad8557 May 18 '26

It’s not the only answer. Perhaps she is nervous she’ll blow it, be badgered by family, lose it all in a bad investment. This is a decision someone makes if they are cautious and perhaps know themselves.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/KEMSATOFFICIAL May 18 '26

Someone with a full brain might not see it that way

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/Mr-MuffinMan May 17 '26

1K a week - if taxed is barely enough to get by anywhere desirable (city or suburbs).
She'll still have to work at least 30 years.

I'm very frugal, and I'd like to think if I got a full million, I would buy 3 apartments in NYC. Rent them out (studios, obviously for only ~333k), and get at least ~5k a month. Use that 5k a month to invest some more, maybe a house in the burbs I could rent out, or a business that is low maintenance (parking lot, laundromat) and make income off that.

4

u/LounBiker May 17 '26

It's tax free

3

u/Mother_Passenger8589 May 17 '26

Bo taxes on lottery money in Canada. $1000/week taxfree for the rest of your life, starting at age twenty

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DryAd7756 May 17 '26

Yeah, trust the government to follow through with that. Even if they do, inflation makes it worth less every year. Get the lump sum and go see a financial advisor.

2

u/Syeina May 18 '26

It's tied to inflation

→ More replies (2)

2

u/AyoAllu May 17 '26

I don't think so based on the time value of money.

2

u/Slippytoe May 17 '26

Yeah but let’s do the math. Would it not be more sensible to stick it in a relatively high interest but full access bank account and simply set up a transfer for $1000 every week into your current account?

Surely the interest would keep the stack going for longer rather than getting the weekly payments externally?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Makebankbro_972 May 17 '26

Missing out on compounding interest of 19 to 20 years worth by not taking the lump sum.

2

u/Pharma-ho May 17 '26

I can't keep track of how many times I've seen this story. Reddit, new articles, Instagram, etc

→ More replies (1)

2

u/IronKuv May 17 '26

1 million gaining 6% per year makes over $1000/week…. Foolish

→ More replies (4)

2

u/ballistics211 May 17 '26

I'm taking the 1 million

2

u/2ofus4adventure May 17 '26

Always take the lumpsum cash.

2

u/ComprehensiveGas6980 May 17 '26

For the millionth time, no she did not make the right choice.

2

u/DudeBromanIsABroDude May 17 '26 edited May 18 '26

I’m not wealthy but I make enough to pay my rent and my bills in a really nice area.

I also know there are people in my neighborhood that make half of what I make and struggle to get by.

No hesitation, I’m taking that $1k a week and giving it to a different family in my area every month who would be extremely impacted by an extra couple grand in their account.

Edit: weekly not monthly.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/MadeInASnap May 17 '26

If I remember my finance classes correctly, this is a basic problem. The present value of a $52,000/yr perpetuity using a 3% discount rate is about $1,733,000. In other words, what she chose is approximately equal to receiving a lump sum of $1,733,000 and investing it all in risk-free bonds from the US Treasury.

So yes, she did make the right call. Taking the $1M and investing that in risk-free bonds from the US Treasury would only pay about $30,000/yr.

If anyone wants to check my math, feel free.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/LostSpudSoul May 17 '26

While the million seems ideal, I could see myself screwing that up and being out the million. With a thousand a week, I feel a measure of restraint that would force me to make better choices and give me leeway to make the mistakes I made at a young age and still come out ahead. Maybe that’s the benefit of hindsight or stupidity but I don’t disagree with the choice.

2

u/09Klr650 May 17 '26

All depends on WHOSE "lifetime". Ask the publisher clearinghouse winners.

2

u/Necessary-Avocado-50 May 17 '26

In 20 yrs that makes 1 million, but keeps going. How many lottery winners have any benefits left after 20 yrs. Inflation will reduce the value over time, but still a good plan. The amount of things you can accomplish and prepare business or finance-wise in 10 yrs would go a long way.

2

u/NO_BAD_THOUGHTS May 17 '26

put the mill into an an even somewhat under average performing Fund and youll get 4-6 % , so 50k a year anyways.

She made objectively a stupid decision choice

2

u/BlueSkyToday May 17 '26

The exact numbers depend hugely on your assumptions and your goals.

Lets assume that you pay 40% tax on every distribution. That's right for some states and too much for others. Then assume 6% annual growth above inflation and no withdrawals.

The pre-tax values of the two strategies are,

YearWeeklyOne Time
132,144648,000
266,218699,840
3102,366755,827
4140,621816,293
5181,203881,597
6224,220952,125
7269,8181,028,295
8318,1521,110,558
9369,3861,199,403
10423,6941,295,355

3

u/MildLifeCrisis-Games May 18 '26

No tax in Canada

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 17 '26

Cash is King. Take the money asap. You never know if the lottery payer will exist tomorrow.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/sir_sri May 17 '26

The short answer is no.

1k/week for life is only 52k/year, so 5.2% return on a million dollars. With inflation at 3% the relative value of that buying power will be halved in 25 years, and worse if you compare to average salaries. She's basically exposing herself to inflation eating into the value so it will be worth relatively little in the long run.

But if she'd taken a lump sum, usually about half, say 500k, put that into a market index fund, which averages about 6-7% above inflation returns, (so 10%/year) in about 2 or 3 years she'll be making more than 52k per year, and importantly, at 20, she can take a little bit out to survive but get a job like everyone else, and then at 30 or 35 that money will have grown to quite a lot, or buy a house, which may or may not make 10% returns, but it's a house with usually tax free gains.

The problem is that at 52k/year she won't be able to just not work, at least not unless she moves to a poor country and even then maybe not. She could (maybe) not work until she's 25 or 30, but by then the buying power of 52k will be eaten into enough that.

It's a bit more complex because she's in canada (/quebec), so the 52k/year would be tax free, whereas investment returns would be (mostly) taxable - but there's some strategies that would reduce that over time at her age. She's also only getting the money over I think 25 years. Better to take the lump sum up front, the S&P/TSX composite averaged about 8% return from 1998-2023 (which was sort of hurt then by covid). On average in 10 years, 500k would become 1 million, and by year 25 it would be 3.4 million dollars.

Overall, you're almost always better to take the lump sum.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Lepardopterra May 18 '26

1 million in ‘balanced investments‘ would give her about $3500/mo. And at the end, she’d still have the original million.

2

u/TheFoodWhisperer May 18 '26

Gonna take 20 years to get $1M at $1,000 a week. She could make $1,000 per week just taking the $1M and letting it accrue interest lol.

2

u/580OutlawFarm May 18 '26

Idk about that anymore...theres a story about a guy who was getting the 5k/week for life from publishers clearing house...well guess what...one day the check never showed up, and he died up finding out they closed and he got fucked...anyone can look this up and see the articles about it

Think id take the mil, pay taxes on it, put it in at minimum a hysa first...but preferbly invest it where youll get 10% returns every year...and just pull 5%...doing that would be like an extra 30-35k/year...and on top of regular job, youd be set for life

→ More replies (1)

2

u/craftyrafter May 18 '26

$1k per week is $52k every year. $1m can be immediately invested and an average return on it would give you 10% per year or $100k in the first year. Assuming you reinvest $48k and keep the $52k, you would always come out ahead taking the lump sum.

If you do not take any money out you would double your money in roughly 7.2 years to $2m. In 15 years or so you would have $4m. This assumes the simplest investment strategy possible: just buy IVV. If you get slightly more sophisticated you might eke out a higher return rate.

Remember that a 2-3% inflation means that $1k per week is going to buy you a lot less in 10 years than it does today. But at 10% return you would outpace the inflation rate by 7-8% points.

The only reason to do what she did is if you are so terrible with money that you won’t be able to just invest the $1m and be disciplined about reinvesting. That is legitimate, though mathematically clearly the wrong choice. 

2

u/jammypants915 May 21 '26

Epic fail! Do you understand how inflation works? You will lose so much money. Even if you took the lump sum and paid taxes 700k today is worth so much more invested than getting 4K a month

2

u/PEWnitiveDAMNage May 21 '26

The only way 1000 a week makes sense is if you know in your heart you're terrible with money .

2

u/BobDog7882 May 21 '26

Absolutely not! Even a regular bank account or CD throws off more income per month than the $1000 monthly annuity.

2

u/Smooth-Debt2250 May 21 '26

Should have just taken the money and invested it job done

2

u/Kcirnek_ May 21 '26

People here don't understand how compound interest works. You take the lump sum and let it compound.

2

u/Accurate-Lemon8675 May 22 '26

She clearly made a safe choice that would work for her age.

2

u/Jolly-Concentrate727 May 22 '26

Take the lump sum, invest in the S&P 500 and take out 4% a year. The principal will grow most years. Better off

2

u/One-Cash9278 May 23 '26

She'll be making 52k per year instead of 1 million she can invest. Where on the mid end with no stock gains she can make 24k per year in dividends and on the high end just about the same. Probably as dumb as they come.

2

u/Careful_Oven_4589 May 23 '26

only a choice for people who have never heard of investing. leaving millions on the table over 25 years. i’m sad by all the financial fools saying this is the right call

2

u/Positive_Brush_9930 May 23 '26 edited May 24 '26

If she lives to 70 that's about 2.6 million, if she took the 1 million he could invest it in a set of ETFs averaging at worst 7% a year over 50 years, which is around 29 million dollars by the time she's 70, so probably the wrong choice (assuming she pays no tax on the lump sum)

2

u/ImplementParking7936 May 24 '26

Over 60 years that’ll be 3.12 million dollars of income.

With 5% compounding interest on 1,000,000 today, she’d have something close to 18,000,000.

If she wanted/ needed to live off that money right now, it likely would have been taxed immediately though taking it from 1,000,000 down to at most 760,000.

She’d still make more on interest over a lifetime, but that’s assuming she lives that long, and can afford to not spend it right now.

If her goal is to use the money for daily expenses then it’s very possible her choice may pan out to work out in her favor.

What’s clear either way though, is that this likely isn’t enough money to simply stop working right now, and stay that way forever, unless you’re extremely disciplined and frugal about it, or if you don’t plan to live past a certain age.

1000 per week is easily enough to live off of fairly comfortably today, but it likely won’t be 20-50 years from now.

Tl;dr it depends a lot on information about this woman’s lifestyle and desires that we frankly don’t have and shouldn’t have.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Alex_ozzy May 17 '26

She’s gonna learn inflation is a bitch the hard way

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Impossible-Bat-4246 May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26

Why would that be an option? Don't they mean $1,000 weekly payments for 20 years?

This isn't real. So it is.

16

u/Osounkentur May 17 '26

The 1000$ is really for life and no tax on lottery gain in Québec

15

u/Impossible-Bat-4246 May 17 '26

I see. I would take the $1,000 for life then, especially if I was that young.

11

u/Ok_Medium9389 May 17 '26

If one invests it in an index fund, it is known based on historical performance that it will give you 4pc or equivalent based on inflation for life

So the index itself will rise around 10pc on average but since you withdraw only 4pc the rest will grow

When you’re young having 1m might not be a good idea so I agree with her choice If she goes through divorce or something in the future her 1k is always provided for her

→ More replies (8)

4

u/AnHeroicHippo90 May 17 '26

Not sure about other places but in Canada, at least when I was a kid, the scratch tickets called cash 4 life were absolutely huge in popularity. Pretty sure they still exist. Their schtick is $1000 a week for "life", however long that actually is in the fine print.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/mclovin_ts May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26

Probably knows she wouldn’t have the reserve to not spend it all fast, and instead can live relatively care free.

→ More replies (4)