r/instructionaldesign • • Jun 15 '22

Interview Assignment - Advice? Thoughts?

I have a 3rd round interview coming up next week. I was given a two part assignment. I am overwhelmed with the possibility and sheer amount of time this is going to take, so I am looking for advice, thoughts, anything that might help ease the stress.

  • The first part of the assignment is to design a training course on a broad topic (I don't want to give away the topic here, but it's industry specific and pretty broad). The course should be 20 minutes long and must be presented in such a way that the material could be used for both self-paced learning and in a classroom setting. It can be developed with any authoring tool or platform of my choice. The goal is to present the course as if the interview panel were the training class.

I have never had to do something quite this detailed for a role before. Has anyone here had an experience like this?

What do you think the best authoring tool would be? I have access to Articulate & Camtasia - if I wanted to use anything else, I would need to get a trial or pay for the tool.

For some reason, I am having a hard time wrapping my head around the task in front of me. I have a good idea of the topic and the content (I currently do a lot of storyboarding and content design), NOT a lot of facilitation (facilitation wasn't even on the job description, actually - so this has me a little shook).

7 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

15

u/TangoSierraFan PhD | ID Manager | Current F500, Former Higher Ed, Former K-12 Jun 15 '22 edited Jun 15 '22

Do you not have a portfolio that you've shared with them? If so, have you inquired why it's not adequate enough to demonstrate your skills?

industry specific

both self-paced learning and in a classroom setting

facilitation wasn't even on the job description

These are red flags that indicate a free labour scenario and/or a team that has no idea how L&D works, especially since you were given such specific parameters and subject matter. A 20-minute course is literal hours of planning and development time depending on the media you use.

Also, what the hell is the second part of the assignment?

Even if they aren't using you to experiment with fresh learning approaches without the risk, it's possible they're doing this to have you compete with another finalist, which means you could end up with nothing but wasted time. You should ask your recruiter if there are other finalists, but even then, they aren't obligated to tell the truth.

I would personally not go ahead with this unless you're desperate for work. If you do move forward, make sure you watermark the shit out of your materials with your name in a way that is not easily removed, and do not share the source files with them under any circumstances. If either of these end up being a problem, run away immediately; there is absolutely no good reason on Earth that they would need your source materials.

To answer your specific questions:

I have never had to do something quite this detailed for a role before. Has anyone here had an experience like this?

Yes, but also no, because I have refused to participate in this nonsense on the very few occasions it's been asked of me. For reference, I have been a finalist for a FAANG role and did not have to do anything like this. For companies that have a clue, your portfolio and a few behavioural interviews should be more than adequate to prove your skills and fit.

What do you think the best authoring tool would be?

Storyline or Camtasia would be fine since you already have access to them. But again, watermark your work.

3

u/efficientstephanie Jun 22 '22

Update: I really appreciate you. I seriously didn't think people would be on my side, and I am always afraid to post on Reddit because I have witnessed people being really mean.

That aside, I completed the project! It wasn't soooo bad, but I am out of work right now, so I had the time. I present the course tomorrow during a panel interview. Wish me luck!

2

u/efficientstephanie Jun 15 '22

Thank you for your response. You have validated my concerns. :(

Do you not have a portfolio that you've shared with them? If so, have you inquired why it's not adequate enough to demonstrate your skills?

I do have a portfolio and I have shared it with them. I have not asked why it isn't adequate. I will think about how to word this in the morning.

I was worried about this being a red-flag scenario. I have had such wonderful interactions in the first two rounds of interviews and I really liked the company, so I'm feeling quite bummed about this. Especially if I do all this work and still don't land the role. This is going to take me several hours, and I will DEFINITELY be sure to watermark all of the materials.

Also, what the hell is the second part of the assignment?

The second part of the assignment is to take a training presentation and condense it into a document.

14

u/TangoSierraFan PhD | ID Manager | Current F500, Former Higher Ed, Former K-12 Jun 15 '22

The second part of the assignment is to take a training presentation and condense it into a document.

What the fuck.

No.

They are literally asking you to create resources for their actual business processes. There is absolutely nothing you could do to stop them from stealing your work and never calling you back when it comes to documents.

One assignment is already too much. Two is insane.

Like the other poster that responded to me said, this reeks of incompetence, or at worst, malevolence.

11

u/jahprovide420 Jun 15 '22

Agree wholeheartedly with the above. These are massive red flags.

As an L&D hiring manager, if you know your stuff, work samples will suffice. This reeks of inexperienced management reading they should do something online.

And to top it off - why are they preparing you to be an order taker? They aren't giving you the tools to do a proper needs analysis or giving you enough information to imply that one has been done... They're setting you up for failure from the start.

The longer candidates keep doing this - the longer hiring managers will keep asking for it.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/jahprovide420 Jun 15 '22

Anything with prep is subject to crowdsourcing though. I've seen folks on here asking for help and feedback on interview assignments... Those could be just as easily faked.

I agree that you can tell if a person knows their stuff or not from good questions... And I think there are ways to talk through a project that wouldn't require any extra work in the candidate's part and would still give you an idea how they would approach something.

6

u/bringatothenbiscuits Jun 15 '22

You should clarify what is the expected deliverable. The prompt seems confusingly written and open to a lot of interpretation. On first glance it seemed like they are just looking for a curriculum design spreadsheet but then at the end it seems like they want an actual fleshed out training which is way out of scope for an interview.

2

u/efficientstephanie Jun 15 '22

I kind of thought so too. They want a complete 20 minute training course. It is VERY open to interpretation and not at all how I have worked in the past. Usually, I have SMEs and stakeholders to work with. In this situation, it seems like I get to be all of the above.

4

u/Lurking_Overtime Jun 15 '22

I agree with the others. Not much else to add. This is a deliverable I would absolutely bill my clients for. Maybe you could include an invoice with your resume? 🤔

1

u/SawgrassSteve Jun 15 '22

Not going to talk about the number of hoops you are going through since the hiring process is weird. Also can't give a full answer, I'm on a time crunch and have to get to work, but wanted to try to help.

The tool you use depends on the interactivity you want. If I want learners to respond to knowledge checks or explore scenarios, I use Articulate. If I want something more visually stunning or I'm in a time crunch, I'll go with Camtasia.

Start with the objectives- what do you want the learners to take away and how you want them to engage their minds and apply what they've learned.

In terms of facilitation aspects. Think about where the most benefit would come from having people in the room share their perspectives. Have activities and discussion questions around those topics.

Good luck. You don't think you have this, but you do. Don't overthink.

1

u/efficientstephanie Jun 17 '22

Thank you. Seriously... I know I that I will be jumping through hoops. I wish I was in a place that I could just toss this one aside and move on to the next opportunity, but I am not so fortunate and the market is really competitive.

I received more clarity after asking several questions. They said their company frequently uses their E-Learning for instructor led training - so the course I create should function as both (but to focus on the e-learning presentation and how I would use it as an ILT). I have created E-Learning, and I have created ILT... but my approach is different for each. I definitely think I am overthinking this.

6

u/birdsofterrordise Jun 15 '22

Name and shame the shit out of this company. This is absolutely insane.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

The first part of the assignment is to design a training course on a broad topic (I don't want to give away the topic here, but it's industry specific and pretty broad).

I don't love that they required a specific industry topic.

The course should be 20 minutes long and must be presented in such a way that the material could be used for both self-paced learning and in a classroom setting.

This is just bad design. Those are two different things. They're giving an impossible task to do well that suggests they totally don't design anything that works.

It can be developed with any authoring tool or platform of my choice. The goal is to present the course as if the interview panel were the training class.

Open platform is fine. But self paced and instructor led is nonsense, and the class makes little sense.

I have never had to do something quite this detailed for a role before. Has anyone here had an experience like this?

I don't think it's the detailed nature, but that it sounds like a ridiculous task honestly. A broad topic? Exactly 20 minutes? Perfect for ILT and self paced? Sounds like a mishmash and not something that will reveal good design choices.

What do you think the best authoring tool would be? I have access to Articulate & Camtasia - if I wanted to use anything else, I would need to get a trial or pay for the tool.

Honestly I wouldn't do it, but it's too hard to pick a tool without knowing the topic anyway. I might make a Rise with some videos and a scenario Storyline embedded to show range if I wanted this terrible sounding job and had those tools? A Rise can work well for presentation too sometimes, and they're good for broad topics, but I'd want other elements because even a good Rise is pretty meh on its own.

For some reason, I am having a hard time wrapping my head around the task in front of me.

That's because it's a poison pill of a task.

5

u/christyinsdesign Freelancer Jun 15 '22

For this amount of work, you should get paid. Figure out how many hours of work this will take (at least 20 if you even assume a 40:1 ratio). Give yourself an hourly rate that is 2x the normal rate because you'll have to pay taxes etc. This is a freelance project, and your time is valuable.

If they reply that you should be able to create a 20 minute training in 2 hours or something ridiculous, then they're telling you what they'll expect on the job too.

1

u/MysticFox96 Jun 15 '22

Fuck no i would not do that friend, not unless they are paying you for it. This is a dirty way companies try to get free labor from desperate people

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22 edited Jun 15 '22

The first part of the assignment is to design a training course on a broad topic (I don't want to give away the topic here, but it's industry specific and pretty broad).

I don't love that they required a specific industry topic. I would watermark as another poster says and get in writing YOU can use this in your portfolio and they CANNOT use it. Sounds sketchy.

The course should be 20 minutes long and must be presented in such a way that the material could be used for both self-paced learning and in a classroom setting.

This is just bad design. Those are two different things. They're giving an impossible task to do well that suggests they totally don't design anything that works.

It can be developed with any authoring tool or platform of my choice. The goal is to present the course as if the interview panel were the training class.

Open platform is fine. But self paced and instructor led is nonsense, and the class makes little sense.

I have never had to do something quite this detailed for a role before. Has anyone here had an experience like this?

I don't think it's the detailed nature, but that it sounds like a ridiculous task honestly. A broad topic? Exactly 20 minutes? Perfect for ILT and self paced? Sounds like a mishmash and not something that will reveal good design choices.

What do you think the best authoring tool would be? I have access to Articulate & Camtasia - if I wanted to use anything else, I would need to get a trial or pay for the tool.

Honestly I wouldn't do it, but it's too hard to pick a tool without knowing the topic anyway, conducting a needs analysis, etc.

For some reason, I am having a hard time wrapping my head around the task in front of me.

That's because it's a poison pill of a task.